10 Gimmick Ideas WWE Were Right To Turn Down
Sometimes, Vince McMahon is absolutely right.
Vincent Kennedy McMahon can't sit on some creative ivory tower and distance himself from those who green-light horrible ideas. He's the guy who gave a big ol' thumbs up to monstrosities like Mantaur, The Gobbledy Gooker, Giant Gonzales and countless other horrors that keep wrestling fans awake at night.
He's also the dude who occasionally says something to the effect of, 'Right, no, your idea is sh*ttier than Natalya's drawers after all the farting she did when playing that gimmick'. The WWE boss might not know everything, but even he has rejected pitches for new characters when he thinks they're going too far.
Think about that: Vince viewed all of the ideas detailed on this list as over the score or downright rotten, and he didn't think they deserved to grace his prized programming. This is the same bloke who gave Chavo Guerrero permission to play 'Kerwin White', a pretty much racist golfer who was President Trump before the Donald had a chance.
McMahon was absolutely correct with every single one of them. Lord knows what would have happened to some careers had he thrown up his hands, agreed to these gimmicks and watched them bomb in front of his cameras...
10. 'Double-D-Dust' (Goldust)
Goldust wanted t*ts.
That's it - that's the post. Dustin Rhodes of current AEW fame legitimately pitched to Vince McMahon that he go under the knife and get some tig ol' bitties to help shock the late-90s wrestling world even further. Bruce Prichard has confirmed it on his podcast, and so has Jim Ross. Neither man has any reason to lie.
What's even the point in continuing? It's nigh-on impossible to top male wrestlers who fancy a cracking pair of double Ds so they don't have to stuff that hot new lingerie they've got planned for the next Raw, isn't it? Just you wait though. There's a lot more where this came from.
For now, just imagine Vinnie Mac's horrified face when he learned that Goldust was dead serious and really wanted to take his 'Artist Formerly Known As' madness to the next level by getting breast implants. This is probably one Dustin thanks Vince for talking him out of today.
9. 'Adam Hole' (Mr. Kennedy)
When Ken Anderson was searching for the right name that'd help shoot him to WWE fame, he wanted something that'd be memorable and keep him close to the boss man's heart. So, naturally John Laurinaitis pitched that he become 'Adam Hole'. As in 'A-Hole'. As in...well, you get it.
Neither Ken nor Vince McMahon liked it.
In fairness to ol' 'People Power' over there, his idea was based on something Anderson had already said; Vince had asked him to spew out a catchphrase that he liked saying in every day life. That's when Kenny boy said he enjoyed, "Nice guys finish last - thank God I'm an a*s-hole". Big Johnny's wheels started turning.
Another last-minute suggestion for the soon-to-be Mr. Kennedy came from Paul Heyman. He suggested that Anderson call himself 'Kenny Rumpus', largely because Rumpus was the name of Vince's favourite pet dog. The poor guy must've thought everyone was out to rib him.
8. 'White Trash' (Alexa Bliss)
The defining characteristic of Alexa Bliss 2K20 is that she really enjoys coffee. Somehow, things could've been worse for the Starbucks-supping Women's Tag-Team Champ had WWE liked her proposed "southern" gimmick in NXT. Back then, Alexa very nearly turned into a modern retelling of Nidia hanging off Jamie Noble.
That's Jamie Noble boy to you.
There are some pics and footage of Bliss teaming up with future Revival man Scott Dawson as a pair of no good hillbilly trucker types who were like extras from yet another 'Dukes Of Hazzard' remake. Ultimately, the company decided against turning Alexa into their very own Jessica Simpson and went a different route instead.
It'd take a few years before Bliss really found her calling in WWE as a tiny Harley Quinn cosplaying mega-bitch. Then, eventually, she became less of a cow and found friendship with former psychopath Nikki Cross. Wrestling is weird.
7. 'Spacecore Holly' (Bob Holly)
It's not uncommon for pro wrestlers to take some time off to heal injuries, "learn a new hold" (as Jim Ross would say) or start a family. It's totally uncommon for anyone to book a holiday and spend their free time climbing the corporate ladder over at NASA. That's what one WWE writer had planned for Bob Holly in ECW.
As crazy as it sounds, said writer liked the thought of marrying ECW's home on the then Sci-Fi channel with a gimmick that'd feel right at home. That's why Hardcore Holly almost turned into 'Spacecore Holly', an astronaut who might've been able to make use of Max Moon's old rocket boosters.
They even pitched a monkey sidekick.
If this sounds like the kind of movie Tom Hanks would've starred in during the early-90s, then you're absolutely correct, but it was an honest-to-goodness pitch for Bob. Thankfully, somebody saw sense, probs upon realising that nobody was clamouring for a wrestling version of Buzz Aldrin.
6. 'Illegitimate Son' (Batista)
Prepare to get dark real quick.
Batista told Chris Jericho on his 'Talk Is Jericho' podcast in 2014 that one idea for his formative run in WWE crossed the desk of Vince McMahon and ended up in the bin. It's not surprising when you learn what it was writers wanted; they planned to make big Dave an illegitimate child born when his mother was raped.
Yes, nothing screams 'family friendly WWE action' like sitting kids down in front of SmackDown reruns each weekend to hear how one of the roster was mentally scarred by traumatic events. Said rape would be used to explain why Batista was so quiet (thus giving him an excuse to work on promos slowly), distant and moody.
The very words Batista used to explain the pitch? "Rape child". What a lovely idea, eh? Far be it from this writer to generalise, but no WWE creative team member would've been able to handle such a gritty subject sensitively in 2002. In fact, they'd struggle now...not that it'd come up in conversation.
5. 'The Lock' (Christian)
"Can you smell what The Lock is cookin'?".
If you've ever wondered why Christian started wearing darkened sunglasses, got a Hollywood leading man haircut and started dressing like Val Kilmer in 2003, then wonder no more. WWE almost turned him into a cheap knock-off of The Rock, and one writer was very excited about it.
Christian wasn't, and neither was Vince McMahon, The Canadian star noted on his old 'E&C's Pod Of Awesomeness' show with Edge that the same writer called him back a few days later and said, "I guess Vince heard the idea and said, 'That's the stupidest idea I've ever ever heard - we're not doing that', so it's not happening after all". Relief all round. Well, apart from the creative staffer.
The whole thing was born from one backstage promo in which Rocky joked that Christian was his favourite wrestler. McMahon wasn't keen, Christian thought it sucked and the company instantly changed tact towards a tag-team with and eventual feud against Chris Jericho.
4. 'Gay Hairdresser' (Kalisto)
As aforementioned in the Batista entry, WWE don't have a stellar track record when it comes to handling potentially-offensive ideas sensitively. That's why it's for the best that they didn't pull the on screen trigger on turning Kalisto into a quote, unquote "gay hairdresser" back in 2015.
The idea called for Kalisto the shed his lucha mask, tell then-partner Sin Cara to beat it, grab some scissors, adopt an overtly effeminate look and become The Miz's stylist. This sounds familiar - it reeks of Rico (Reek-o?) back with Billy Gunn and Chuck Palumbo in 2002, and it may even have been worse.
Portraying Kalisto as a painful stereotype would surely have netted WWE some backlash online, irked corporate investors and it could have been viewed as obnoxiously distasteful. In the end, someone made the call to scrap Kalisto's literal turn and keep him as a masked member of The Lucha Dragons team.
Phew.
3. 'The Female Shield' (Paige, Summer Rae & Anya)
Think of this spin-off group as WWE's version of The Iron Maidens. Sure, it's a solid alternative, but it doesn't quite have the same oomph as Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose did, just as The Maidens don't hit the same high notes as Bruce Dickinson and company.
Unlike Maidens though, this all-female Shield never really got going.
There is footage of an early promo from Paige, Summer Rae and Anya online. It shows the NXT trio (talking over The Shield's music) blasting Reigns, Rollins and Ambrose by saying their job is "only half done". Then, Rae says men shouldn't do women's work, and that the Divas division is the place that needs saving most.
As hard as everyone tried here, it just wasn't that convincing. Being honest, it would've sucked hard had WWE introduced an all-female version of The Shield to NXT programming and expected fans to take it seriously as anything more than a cheap imitation.
2. 'Mailman' (Big E)
Stop staring at the accompanying image if you can.
New Day member Big E admitted on WWE's 'The FCW Story' that he once pitched to become the promotion's walking, talking mailman. In fact, E wanted to be called 'Mal Mann' and run around chucking letters at everyone like he belonged on WWF Superstars in 1994.
It didn't go over well with anyone, and E is only too happy to agree that this wrestling version of Postman Pat wasn't exactly his best idea. Who knows what he was thinking, but one need only watch his bizarre hip gyrations and fondness for creepy looks on WWE TV now to see that E can make almost anything work. "Almost" anything.
A wrestling postman might've been going too far though. He would've become the first wrestler in history to notify champions that he was coming for their titles via written word, for example. Unfortunately for E, WWE weren't interested in making his dreams a reality.
1. 'Baron Von Bava' (Jon Heidenreich)
This is a classic rejection, and it's one so shocking that WWE chief Vince McMahon lost all confidence in Dan Madigan as a creative team member immediately. What was so shocking, you ask? Well, Madigan pitched in 2004 that Jon Heidenreich be reborn as a Nazi stormtrooper who'd been cryogenically frozen.
Presumably from 1955 when such gimmicks would've been ten-a-penny (without the cryo part).
Paul Heyman, who is Jewish remember, would've been the one to thaw out this 'Baron Von Bava' and lead him to goose-stepping glory on WWE television. Reportedly, Vince was so stunned by what he was hearing that he left the meeting room and didn't return for quite some time. Madigan, just like his Von Bava-led plans, was doomed.
Heyman did end up managing Heiden-Heidenreich, but Nazism obviously wasn't part of the gig and Madigan left WWE later that same year. Who knew that McMahon wouldn't be into the thought of plastering swastikas all over one of his wrestlers and putting it on TV?
What other gimmicks do you think WWE were right to turn down? For more content, check out Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 1+2 Remaster: 10 Things You Need To Know and 18 CRAZIEST Moments From WWE Money In The Bank 2020!