10 Gimmicks That WWE Dropped Without Explanation
Being Raw Underground before Raw Underground.

When Bray Wyatt launched his 'Fiend' gimmick in 2019, he wore a tortured expression during 'Firefly Fun House' segments and explained that "he" was a manifestation of his pain. When Triple H changed into 'The Game' in 1999, he described a nagging need to be taken seriously. Hell, even Michael Cole only stopped being a heel nuisance on commentary in 2012 because Jerry Lawler's very-real heart attack had shaken him to his core.
Nobody on this list could/can boast a reason anywhere near as solid as those.
Every single one of them changed gimmicks suddenly and without any concrete explanation from WWE on television. There's a fair chance Vince McMahon looked at each switch during creative meetings, shrugged his shoulders and said something to the effect of, 'Who cares why they've changed? Just change it!' to his writers.
Perhaps he had a point, because some changes were for the better. Most, however, weren't - that's why they're here to begin with. They're head-scratching reminders of times when McMahon and company decided to keep fans in the dark and move on without proper closure...
10. 'Reverend' D-Von

Testify!
WWE's not-so-bright idea to split The Dudley Boyz during the first Draft in 2002 flopped just a few weeks in. On Raw, Bubba-Ray was doing his best Dusty Rhodes common man impression in the midcard. Over on SmackDown, D-Von was swimming against the tide as a corrupt, money-grabbing man of the cloth.
By November, the company decided to rectify their mistake and put both kayfabe bros back together at Survivor Series. Fans packing MSG responded in kind with booming cheers, and everybody promptly forgot all about D-Von's little side gig as a 'Reverend'.
Neither he, Bubba-Ray or WWE's announcers would mention this on-air again. The promotion might have made passing reference to the gimmick in documentaries or interviews, but they generally ignore it and pretend the Dudleyz were always an item.
9. Friar Ferguson

Mike Shaw held a dubious boast D-Von could not - he p*ssed the Catholic Church of New York off so much that they complained to the WWF about his 'Mad Monk' gimmick in 1993. Unwilling to fight against the man upstairs, Vince McMahon elected to drop the Friar Ferguson character.
Not to worry, because Bruce Prichard had something much worse in mind.
Slovenly dirtbag Bastion Booger was born that June, just in time for the big man to squeeze into summery outfits that'd turn heads on the beach. Sort of. If dingy singlets that were deliberately too small for his bulbous frame could be considered "summery" or fitting for the seaside.
McMahon and pals didn't even try to link Booger with Ferguson. That would've been a hassle, so they simply moved on as if the monk had never graced Monday Night Raw with his oddly-chirpy facial expressions or terrible squash matches.
8. Headshrinker Fatu

Above, you can see former 'Wild Samoan' Afa sandwiched in between his "savage" islander duo of Samu and Fatu. Together, they were The Headshrinkers, and they were more likely to head butt your teeth down your throat than visit schools and warn against gang behaviour or drug use.
In 1995 though, that's exactly what previously-illiterate Fatu did. He ditched the traditional Samoan garb, learned to speak fluent English (seemingly overnight), dressed up in garish colours and lectured on the evils of recreational drugs. His 'Make A Difference' gimmick didn't last long.
The switch was hardly handled with any elegance either. Fatu literally went from teaming with Samu replacement Sione in the summer to prancing around yakking on about cocaine. The WWF scrapped this a few months later and turned him into a masked monster with no tongue.
Wrestling.
7. Emmalina

Emmalina has become modern wrestling's go-to head scratcher.
On the 3 October 2016 Raw, WWE ran vignettes hyping plain old Emma's makeover. She'd become Emmalina, a vain, egoist who may have acted like some sort of Diva throwback. Fans would never know, because these hype vids dragged on and on and on and on and on for months.
Then, finally, Raw's entranceway gave birth to Emmalina on 13 February 2017, and... she revealed she'd be going through another makeover. This time, Emmalina would go back to being Emma. Almost everybody who had sat through endless conjecture groaned all at once - they'd been duped into thinking this might be something worthwhile.
WWE never returned to the Emmalina character or even attempted to justify the cancellation. Instead, Emma appeared on the 3 April Raw as her old self and it was like nothing had happened. Maybe that's because it pretty much hadn't.
6. 'Blackbeard' Paul Burchill

Disney's first Pirates Of The Caribbean movie grossed an eye-watering $654m worldwide in 2003. That, naturally, made cheeky-chappy pirates (in-keeping with Johnny Depp's Captain Jack Sparrow) all the rage. WWE introduced their own pirate-y treat in early 2006, and Paul Burchill was the lucky recipient of the character.
Shame Vinnie Mac hadn't seen the film.
Despite debuting his new sea-faring gimmick right before the second movie's release in July '06, Burchill's new guise was canned by June when Mark Henry squashed him and sent the rope-swinger packing. Apparently, McMahon didn't see the funny side of a bumbling pirate, and so WWE dropped it.
When Burchill later returned to the company, he was a standard menacing heel, not a wisecracking privateer who looked great with a bit of guyliner. The less said of his wonky incest follow-up with kayfabe sister Katie Lea, the better.
5. 'Russian' Lana

Remember when Lana was a Ludmilla Drago lift off who praised Vladimir Putin and put her 'Bulgarian Brute' Rusev to work as a tool of Russian hatred towards the United States? Also, remember when she'd speak in a thick accent that earned her rave reviews as the 'Ravishing Russian'?
WWE don't, and neither (sometimes) does she.
These days, Lana is an Americanised sex symbol who's teaming with Natalya for... reasons. She does still have a slight Russian twang during promos, but that's something the manager-come-wrestler drops in and out of now when it's convenient. She's definitely not the prim and proper anti-USA spokeswoman she used to be.
WWE changed that in 2015 when Lana started flirting with Dolph Ziggler and expressed a desire to live free of Rusev. Shortly thereafter, the strict Russian pronunciation was gone, only to be replaced with a mixed accent. It didn't come back when she returned to Rusev's side, and it was never made clear why.
4. 'Stalker' DDP

To be fair, this is the same company who thought DDP could go from stalking someone's wife to playing motivational speaker and nobody would notice.
In 2001, Page was injured during a tag match with Kanyon against The Undertaker and Kane at SummerSlam. When he returned in late-October, the WWF had forgotten all about his criminal activities or sins against one of the biggest names in its history. DDP's smile was just too charming, damn it.
Weirdly (and in true Men In Black-ish bullsh*t fashion), Page went from kidding on to ogle 'Taker's actual wife from afar to speaking about inspiring others. Throughout it all, he flashed his pearly whites and turned frowns upside down wherever possible. Nothing to see here, folks! A stalker? DDP?! Nooooo.
Somehow, this led to a run as European Champion and feud with on/off tag partner Christian. Did nobody in creative stop to suggest that it might be wise to tie up loose ends and have Page express regret for being a creepy git beforehand?
3. Pancake Patterson

If you ever have friends round for a wrasslin' quiz night, ask them about 'Pancake Patterson'. Unless they happen to covet the 18 March 2013 edition of Raw, then they'll look at you like you've picked up the wrong question sheet. If they're lucky, someone will connect the dots and come up with Titus O'Neil.
He's the answer to all of life's problems, after all.
Seriously, ol' 'Pancake' was a Titus creation concocted to build towards a John Cena vs. Darren Young match that nobody wanted in the first place. O'Neil donned a stupid wig, had some other props and did his comedy bit to the delight of few, and then his alter-ego was never heard from again.
As you've probably guessed by now, WWE didn't bother to give a reason for Pancake's drop into forgotten territory. O'Neil ditched it rapid and that was that - he has never (to this writer's knowledge) played or made reference to the gimmick since.
2. 'Jamaican' Kofi Kingston

"EXODUS! I HEAR YA, SHELTON!".
Wait, what? The lyrics to Kofi Kingston's old WWE theme song are actually, "S.O.S, I hear them shoutin'?". Get out of here!
It's true; Kofi's jammin' old entrance tune was painstakingly designed to give him as much stereotypical Jamaican flavour as possible. That's why he rocked a thick Caribbean accent too.
Then, in 2009, he dropped that cold.
Kingston went from doing a decent Bob Marley impersonation to speaking in his natural voice and never looked back. Since then, WWE have made occasional jokes about the change, but they largely try to steer clear of reminding fans about Kofi's "Jamaican me crazy!" days.
Aside from hinting that it was just a character (how's that for honesty?), the company hasn't fully explained why Kingston was happy to kid on he was Jamaican. In 2009, they also changed his designated hometown from Kingston to Ghana.
1. 'Bareknuckle' Wade Barrett

Wade Barrett was Raw Underground years before that was even a thing.
In 2012, vignettes started airing of a topless Barrett slugging fools in some gritty underground fighting ring. They were eye-catching, largely because there was nothing even remotely as violent or abrasive on WWE TV at the time. Hopes were high that Wade would be able to parlay this new character into a proper main event run.
It didn't take long before these videos dried up, and The Wrestling Observer reported why: TV executives at SyFy were concerned by the vicious nature of the beatdowns and were worried a flood of complaints would follow. On screen though, WWE decided not to explain why Barrett was no longer England's answer to Tyler Durden.
He moved back into a more traditional heel role quickly and the vignettes were never spoken of again. WWE's announcers did still talk about Barrett's history as a "bareknuckle boxer" (they'd been doing that before anyway), but the bloodthirsty vids were a no-no.
-
What other gimmicks did WWE drop without explanation? For more like this, check out 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE Raw From 1996 and 10 Things We Learned From Jerry Lawler On Stone Cold's Broken Skull Sessions Podcast!