10 Gimmicks WWE Should Bring Back For The PG Era

Because wrestling is supposed to be fun.

Whenever current WWE fans are displeased with the state of the product, the one thing they're quick to point out as the primary reason for their decrease in enjoyment is the PG rating that the company now abides by. In their opinion, PG is the thing that is 'ruining' the WWE. WWE switched to the PG rating in mid-2008. The main reason for doing so was in order to get more money via advertising. WWE had long been turning off specific advertisers with their raunchy material. Now, they wanted their money. So it was out with bleeding, swearing and sexual material and in with poop jokes and more John Cena. While older fans roll their eyes at the sight of the likes of the Bunny, Hornswoggle and El Torito, it can be argued that they do have their place in wrestling. The WWE is a variety show, as much as anything else, and has to appeal to a wide range of demographics. Kids find these gimmicks and storylines entertaining, even if they make the more mature audience hit fast-forward. Wrestling is supposed to be fun and silly gimmicks do have merit. If everyone on the show was a serious a**-kicker it would get really boring, really fast. The PG era is here to stay (at least until WWE's Mattel contract runs out) so why not bring back a couple more fun PG-friendly gimmicks from the past?

10. Doink The Clown

The good thing about the Doink gimmick is that it's timeless and anyone, within reason, can play it. Because of the makeup and generic nature of the gimmick (it's just a guy in a clown costume, really) you could stick it on anyone down in the WWE Performance Centre and call them up to TV tomorrow. The Doink character has been played by many wrestlers in the past, including Steve Keirn, Nick Dinsmore and Steve Lombardi. Chris Jericho even played Doink, during an angle with William Regal. The character was most notably played by Matt Borne, who died of an accidental drug overdose in 2013. It could be argued that WWE should retire the gimmick out of respect for Borne, but it could also bring the gimmick back as a way of paying tribute to his most famous role. Doink could be brought back as either a babyface or a heel, as 'Evil Doink' is an interesting spin on the character. Besides, you have to know that Vince is dying to see custard pies back on WWE TV after a lengthy hiatus.

9. Mantaur

What do you mean the idea of a half-man/half-taur gimmick is ridiculous and awful? Hey, maybe the Mantaur didn't get a fair shake during his 1995 run? In 2015, the charging, grunting, mooing Mantaur could be a big hit. He's a merchandise sensation waiting to happen. Besides, doesn't El Torito need a father? Fans have been asking that question since Los Matadors' mascot arrived on the scene. They need closure. Mantaur could be the missing piece of the puzzle. Then again, maybe not, eh?

8. Max Moon

Vince McMahon reportedly spent $13,000 on Max Moon's suit. That's a big investment for a gimmick that didn't really take off and is remembered more for a 'who played him' debate (Konnan and Paul Diamond both performed under the name) than any classic matches or storylines. Max Moon was a spaceman who shot fireworks out of his fists. When Konnan was doing the gimmick, it didn't really work so well because, coming from Mexico, Konnan didn't know how to wrestle an American style properly. He struggled to adapt and was let go, replaced by Paul Diamond. The gimmick was a bust, but that's not to say that something similar couldn't work in 2015. The idea of someone who may or may not be an alien from space is an intriguing one and WWE could have some fun with it. Besides, an updated Max Moon-esque costume is something that a lot of fans would want to see.

7. Simon Dean

Mike Bucci toiled for years on the independents and in ECW before finally receiving his big break as Simon Dean, the annoying anachronistic fitness instructor, in 2004. As Nova, the 'inNovator of offense', he had a cult following but it was only when he hammed it up as Simon Dean that he finally got proper TV time. The gimmick was a hoot. Bucci threw himself into the role and wasn't afraid to make a fool of himself in order to entertain the crowd. Dean would come to the ring (usually on a ridiculous segway scooter), berate the fans for being out of shape and then try to sell them his patented 'Simon System' weight loss/muscle-building programme. It was wonderfully cheesy, just the kind of thing that would work in the PG era. Bucci is basically retired and living happily as a bank manager, so he's not coming back any time soon. However, it is a gimmick that would suit one of the in-shape trainees down in NXT.

6. Kevin Thorn

Kevin Fertig was a massive flop as Mordecai in 2004. He was brought in with the intention of a major feud with The Undertaker but was shunted back to OVW when WWE lost faith in him (and he got into a bar fight which resulted in a messy lawsuit). Still, WWE gave it another try in 2006. They assigned Fertig to the ECW brand and gave him a new gimmick: he was rebranded as the vampire, Kevin Thorn. It was a lot more successful than Mordecai was, that's for sure. Thorn's act had a bit of a sexual edge to it thanks to his manager Ariel (Shelly Martinez). That incarnation of the character wouldn't fit in the PG era. But WWE could do a kid-friendly vampire character, if they wanted to. It's amazing that WWE didn't do it in the late 2000s in order to capitalise on the Twilight craze. Fertig hasn't been too active in the wrestling business as of late and is 38. His time in WWE has come and gone, but a vampire gimmick could be a winner, if done right.

5. The Hurricane

In an age where superheroes are all the rage, it's amazing that WWE hasn't gone all-out with a proper super hero character. Sure, WWE would probably argue that its wrestlers are true, real-life superheroes, but that doesn't mean that WWE shouldn't take inspiration from the recent comic book craze. WWE did have a superhero gimmick in the form of The Hurricane but that, unfortunately, was too ahead of its time. Had Hurricane came along today, Shane Helms' career might have went a very different way. In an era where merchandise sales are valued above seemingly all else, Hurricane would surely be a major player in today's WWE. Back in 2003, The Hurricane was one of the top merch shifters in the company, right up there with the likes of Steve Austin, The Rock and Rob Van Dam. It would be easy to do a PG superhero and, although Helms is now 40 years old and unlikely to return, the company could easily create a similar gimmick for somebody else.

4. Battle Kat

Dean 'Brady Boone' Peters was an inspiration to a generation of future wrestlers, thanks to his high-flying, Japanese-influenced ring style. Boone worked mainly as a jobber for the WWF between 1986 and 88 before being repackaged as Battle Kat in 1990. What exactly was Battle Kat? Well, it was basically Boone in a cat mask. He had 'cat like' agility, you see. So they made him a cat. It was all a bit silly, but Battle Kat had a decent look and a unique ring style which made sure he stood out during his few televised appearances. Kat was also a hit on house show events, but the gimmick didn't last. He was replaced by Bob Bradley after his release. Why not bring back Battle Kat, or something similar? We've already had a bunny and El Torito in recent times, so why not a dude in a cat mask?

3. Eugene

Like Mike 'Nova' Bucci, Nick Dinsmore was a well-respected, talented wrestler who just couldn't get a promotion from OVW to the main roster. WWE couldn't come up with anything for him to do creatively. So he took matters into his own hands and created a gimmick for himself and pitched it to WWE. Yes, Eugene was Dinsmore's own idea. He came up with the idea of portraying the 'special' nephew of Raw General Manager Eric Bischoff. The Eugene character was a surprise instant hit, although the gimmick was derided in some circles who felt it was making fun of people with mental disabilities (although WWE were quick to point out that Eugene was 'special' or 'overly-excited' and nothing more). Eugene dominated WWE Raw in the summer of 2004 before his momentum was waylaid by Triple H at SummerSlam. WWE could give the gimmick another go at some point. Dinsmore can always return for one-off appearances (he had been working as a trainer in NXT before being released in October 2014), too.

2. Festus

From one dim-witted WWE character, to another - it's Festus! After a disastrous spell as the 'fake Kane' in 2006, Drew Hankinson was sent back to OVW and then formed a tag team with Ray (son of Terry) Gordy. The team, known as Jesse and Festus, debuted on Smackdown in June 2007. Jesse was the mouthpiece of the team, the guy that did all of the talking. Festus just stood there, unresponsive. Jess talked at great length about what an unstoppable monster his mentally challenged partner was. Fans were confused, until the bell rang during their first official match and Festus was transformed into a rampaging madman. Festus was a decent gimmick but it wasn't destined for a long shelf-life: Hankinson was repackaged as CM Punk's straight edge bodyguard Luke Gallows in 2010. He now wrestles for New Japan Pro Wrestling (where he makes very good money as a member of the popular Bullet Club stable) so a WWE return seems unlikely. Still, WWE could revise the gimmick for the PG era. They don't necessarily need Gallows to do it.

1. The Boogeyman

Marty Wright's alter-ego has had remarkable staying power, considering the man himself never really figured out how to wrestle and that while he was in WWE he was not trusted with the responsibility of driving from one town to another (because he had failed to show up in the correct state a couple of times). Wright was cut from the $1,000,000 Tough Enough in 2004 after he lied about his age, but WWE signed him up anyway. They must have been thrilled that he did when he showed a penchant for eating worms and smashing clocks over his head. The Boogeyman terrorised WWE audiences between 2005-2009. Of course a character as memorable as The Boogeyman wasn't going to just disappear, and he has made sporadic appearances (including at the 2015 Royal Rumble). Every time he comes back, he gets a reaction. So why not bring him back for a more substantial role on television? The gimmick is over and, with three hours of time to fill during Raw, the company could do worse than giving a few minutes to Boogey for his freakshow act.

In this post: 
Battle Kat
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...