10 Glaring Main Event Pushes WWE Missed Out On

These guys could have been top line staples had WWE let them...

The sheer number of wrestlers the WWF/WWE have used since the mid-80's is pretty staggering. So many talented men and women have passed through employment in the company, but only a select group can say they were main event regulars. Wrestling fans can (and often do) say what they want about Vince McMahon's methods, but he has paved the way for a lot of entertaining performers in the main event mix. It's been said that not everybody can be a top star. An organisation the sheer size and scale of WWE demands performers fill different roles on the card. For that very reason, there have been ultra-skilled wrestlers who haven't quite been staples on the marquee. Those performers are the ones focused on here. There's a set criteria for this list, each wrestler needs to have been in at least one televised main event. In addition, they need to have been stars of a certain caliber. Every single entry has been in the upper mid-card at least, for example. For mitigating reasons, they couldn't quite transition their varying levels of success into a sustained run as a main event level star. More often than not, this was something the WWF/WWE themselves are at fault for. The question must be asked, why weren't these guys given the chance to headline more often, or set loose as regular main-eventers?

10. Shelton Benjamin

There's one distinct argument raised whenever Shelton Benjamin comes up amongst pro wrestling fans. As talented as the guy was between the ropes, he was painfully average with a microphone in his hand. Whilst that's undeniable, it really shouldn't have stopped him from becoming a bigger star. After all, the likes of Chris Benoit and even Randy Orton could never be accurately described as excellent talkers. Both of those men managed to win World Titles, and the latter is still a focal point of WWE's product today. Benjamin certainly threatened the top line mix a few times, but could never make permanent residence at the top of the card. WWE could have remedied this by giving him a manager. Someone like Paul Heyman would have been ideal for Shelton, because the positives are plain for all to see with the man. Incredible physical ability should have offset his verbal limitations. That's what managers are there for, to mask deficiencies on the mic. Better yet, the 'Gold Standard' character he was playing from 2007-2010 had potential.

9. Val Venis

There's no doubt that the porn star character played by Sean Morley in WWE wasn't designed to crack the main event scene. Val Venis reeked of the 'Attitude' Era, and whilst the gimmick was entertaining, it didn't have the serious tone to really become anything more than upper mid-card. That said, Morley was a talented worker, and a good talker, so why didn't WWE capitalise and switch up his persona? Admittedly, Venis did become more serious in mid-2000, aligning with Trish Stratus. Suddenly, the adult film nuances were largely ignored, but the promotion didn't really replace them with anything of interest. The man was merely a pro wrestler, a good one, but there was nothing for fans to sink their teeth into. This was the ideal chance to elevate him, but creative never grabbed it. Venis certainly had the ability to have good matches. Fans enjoyed his work throughout 1998 and 1999, and he had an impressive physique. At SummerSlam 1998, for example, he was treated like a genuine star during his match against D'Lo Brown. There was potential there for more, but Val would never main event regularly outside of the smaller shows.

8. Diamond Dallas Page

Coming over from World Championship Wrestling in 2001, Diamond Dallas Page should have been a ready-made star. So eager was Page to work in WWE that he actually waved guaranteed money from AOL/Time Warner, cutting his contract short so he could make a splash. That must be a regret from the man, because the then-WWF treated him really shoddily. By the time DDP signed on to work under Vince McMahon, he was no Spring chicken. That fact can't be denied, the man was well past 40, but he still had a lot more to offer. Instead of quickly being shunted into a poorly-executed squash feud against The Undertaker, he should have been an instant main event star. DDP's run may have been brief at the top, but it would have made for several big marquee matches. WWE didn't choose to take that route with the former WCW World Champion. That's a glaring error, because matches against the likes of The Rock, Undertaker and others - done properly - could have drawn some money. Sadly, Page was instead made to look like a chump, and painfully inferior to his WWF counterparts. Talk about wasted opportunity.

7. Kofi Kingston

Today, Kofi Kingston is a WWE stalwart. He appears on pretty much every TV broadcast, and is a house show regular. as part of 'The New Day', the man seems content in the mid-card tag-team scene, which is fine. However, Kingston once promised so much more than WWE has allowed him to offer. In 2009, Kofi had shed his previous Jamaica characteristics used since his debut the previous year. Transitioning into a feud with Randy Orton, the real-life Ghanaian was given ample time to cut promos and get himself over with the audience. It worked, because Kingston became a hot topic in WWE. Suddenly, it seemed the company had a new star on their hands, but the writing staff the inexplicably pulled out at the last minute. There was rumoured heat between Orton and Kofi over the latter's in-ring abilities. Further to that, WWE noticeably cooled interest in pushing the man pretty quickly. It was confusing, why didn't they pull the trigger and at least try to catapult Kingston into the main event mix for good? He was over with fans, a good worker, and proved he could talk.

6. Bam Bam Bigelow

It's been said since the situation that Bam Bam Bigelow just didn't see eye-to-eye with The Kliq in the then-WWF. In the mid-90's, Shawn Michaels, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall and pals ruled the roost, and they weren't exactly easy to work with. Feeling himself to be on the outside looking in, Bam Bam grew frustrated at his lack of a top line push, and departed the company in late-1995. A remarkably agile big man, Bigelow was exactly what the promotion needed in '95. Covered from head-to-toe in a flame motif, the man was a great presence and fans responded anytime he was on-screen. Instead of pushing the awkward Mabel into the main event of SummerSlam '95, Bam Bam would have been a much better choice. There's no denying that Bigelow was an upper-card star, but he was never an established main event player. That's a shame, because he had all the tools necessary to be one. Bam Bam could have been much more than WWE let him be, just look at his stellar main events against Bret Hart (King Of The Ring 1993) and even non-wrestlers like Lawrence Taylor (WrestleMania XI) for proof of that.

5. Jake Roberts

One of the absolute best talkers of his generation, Jake 'The Snake' Roberts is still remembered to this day. His run in the WWF of the late-80's and early-90's is legendary, Roberts was one truly interesting character. As a babyface, he was beloved, and as a heel he was able to show even more of his verbal chops. It's startling that Jake wasn't used more at the top of the card. Roberts did have featured rivalries against the likes of The Ultimate Warrior and Randy Savage, but they sadly didn't really satisfy in the end. Nobody who witnessed it will ever forget the infamous angle whereby Jake set his snake on Savage, but the wrestler was gone from the promotion shortly afterwards. Jake Roberts could have been a top heel around this time in the WWF. Unfortunately, personal problems were a constant worry with the man, and likely didn't help proceedings. That in mind, he definitely deserved a chance to headline more often. As a heel, he would have been tailor-made to rival Hulk Hogan, just as one example. Roberts could have also had excellent matches against Bret Hart when he became champion.

4. Owen Hart

Throughout his run, Owen Hart flirted briefly with the main event scene. In 1994, he opposed his brother, Bret, and the pair constructed a memorable feud over the WWF Title. It's fair to surmise that Vince McMahon never really viewed Owen as a main event guy however, otherwise he would have presented him as such. Following the 'Montreal Screwjob' at the 1997 Survivor Series, the promotion missed out on one glaring opportunity with Owen. Returning to the WWF, the Canadian appeared furious with McMahon over how he had treated his sibling, and fans responded in kind by taking the situation seriously. Re-dubbed the 'Black Hart', Owen had a meaner exterior to go along with his superb in-ring skills. Confusingly, this was never really followed up on. The chance was there to establish Owen Hart as a main eventer, but he was back in the mid-card by the turn of 1998. Later joining The Nation Of Domination, it became clear that those in charge didn't think Owen had enough about him to become a top liner. Many fans disagree, and it's baffling management didn't at least try.

3. Davey Boy Smith

Bret Hart once remarked that Davey Boy Smith's biggest obstacle was himself. Packing incredible muscle onto his physique, the Englishman struggled to keep pace with Hart at SummerSlam 1992. Literally telling Bret that he was blowing up badly, Smith somehow managed to get through the rest of the match. His Intercontinental Title win and performance during the match should have shown Vince McMahon that The British Bulldog was main event material. Rather than acting as a launching pad for the man, Davey Boy was gone from the WWF by the end of '92. McMahon pointed to shipments received by Smith of Human Growth Hormone as reasoning for his release. The Bulldog would return in 1994, and again he was treated as someone on the cusp of the main event. Smith did main event several Pay-Per-Views (against Kevin Nash, Bret Hart and others) going forward, but he was never in the main event mix full-time. In 1995, when McMahon had less stars to rely on that ever before, that shouldn't have been the case. Davey Boy Smith was someone fans reacted to in a big way when he came through the curtain, and he surely deserved a run with the WWF Title.

2. Razor Ramon

Scott Hall is one of the biggest stars never to be a World Champion in the WWF/WWE. In fact, Hall didn't win a World Title in WCW during his tenure there either. That's surprising, because the man was a talented performer, charismatic, and over with fans. As Razor Ramon, he was often posted in the Intercontinental Title hunt, rather than for the main belt. Razor did feature against Bret Hart in a WWF Title match at the 1993 Royal Rumble. This wasn't too long after his debut, and it'd be the closest the man would come to the championship during his run. There's long been rumours that Vince McMahon was finally ready to make Hall a main event player in 1996. Of course, that would be the year the man infamously jumped to WCW and formed the New World Order. Whether true or not, the WWF should have went further with Razor Ramon long before '96. In many ways, the guy is exactly the kind of performer WWE are crying out for now, and it seems hard to imagine he wouldn't be given at least one World Title run. Coming off his loss to Shawn Michaels at SummerSlam 1995, Razor was ripe for a shunt up the card.

1. Mr. Perfect

As the arrogant 'Mr. Perfect', Curt Hennig was a tremendous heel in the late-80's. Hennig was so strong that he was even booked into a feud opposite none other than Hulk Hogan. The rivalry wasn't really given the time to develop it arguably should have, and Hennig was rarely used in the main event again. Even though he remained a popular star, Mr. Perfect was not a regular headliner. That's unfortunate, because Hennig was virtually flawless as a performer. The 'Mr. Perfect' character was a suitably perfect fit, and Curt excelled at anything the creative team passed his way. Admittedly, the man's back would play havoc with any potential main event career, and he had to put himself through immense pain to wrestle on a regular basis. In 1993, Perfect wrestled an incredible match against Bret Hart at the 1993 King Of The Ring. It seemed like he was on top form once more, but back injuries would force him from the company by the end of the year. Way back in 1990, it seemed like the wrong timing for Hennig to become a main event star. Vince McMahon was still obsessed with huge bodies, which clouded judgement over Mr. Perfect becoming established at the top of the card.

Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.