10 Great AEW Wrestlers Who'd Be Better Off In WWE
Time to jump ship.
When AEW first launched, there was debate over which stars from other promotions (namely WWE) would be best served jumping ship to Tony Khan's house of fun.
In 2022, so many actually have jumped ship that the polar opposite topic has arrived: who would be best served leaving AEW?
In a time where former ROH and WWE talent are invading like there's no tomorrow (and also Jeff Jarrett for... reasons), many more long-running acts, some of whom were from WWE themselves, are beginning to get pressed for adequate pushes and TV time. In other cases, stars net a fair bit of telly time but are currently trapped in ill-fitting personas or dead-end angles that are frustratingly hindering their true potential.
The newer stars AEW have really put the machine behind in 2022, such as Daniel Garcia and Wheeler Yuta, have struggled to really remain hugely over or anywhere near the top of the card. Many fans have dismissed them as both being a bit green still for top spots. Others have been critical of the stop-start nature of their pushes and, worse still, the frequent heel/face teases and turns Garcia's had.
For those two, even with those issues, it's fair to say they're where they belong and will get the time to keep growing into their bigger roles. The following 10, however, might be better served reconsidering their employer come contract expiration time. As Cody Rhodes proved earlier this year, a change of location can completely reboot one's image and career.
10. Miro
When it comes to TNT Champions, there's a rock-solid argument that Miro's heated run as 'God's Favourite Champion' was the pinnacle. Ditching his bizarre gamer persona and friendship with Kip Sabian, Miro found his voice as a brawling religious zealot.
In 2022, despite solid crowd reactions when he does occasionally show up, Miro is almost a non-entity in AEW a lot of the time. Scattered mini-feuds and odd promos in the dark haven't showcased 'The Bulgarian Brute' at his best. While a hamstring injury kept him out earlier this year, he has by all accounts been cleared to work for most of his time off at this point.
Despite his dismal closing stretch in WWE, Miro's first year on the main roster did successfully present him as a superstar in waiting. While the Russian patriot gimmick was completely different (and certainly not one that would fly in 2022) to his more interesting character work in recent years, the booking was exactly what he should be; a colourful but dangerous badass.
With new management in town in WWE, Miro could very well reach the heights many tipped him for in 2014 if he were to defect down the road. A return to the old Rusev name with more assured, sensible booking, rather than the start-stop pushes that became a custom of Vince McMahon's closing years, could see Rusev Day be celebrated once more.
At the very least, he might actually make it onto one of WWE's televised shows every week.
9. Jamie Hayter
In recent months, positive fan reactions seem to have forced AEW's hand when it comes to Southampton's main wrestling rep.
After a year of mostly playing henchwoman and second fiddle to Britt Baker, Jamie Hayter's finally getting to actually talk and perform as an individual. It's not quite the solo breakout and Baker feud many are hoping for but it is a start. Frustratingly, a feud with the best wrestling dentist since Isaac Yankem seemed to be on the cards until the arrival of Saraya.
While Baker butted heads with the former Paige at Full Gear, Hayter bagged the Interim AEW Women's Title. It's amazing how one little word like interim can totally undermine the value of the prize at hand. Hayter's win was tainted by Baker shenanigans, leaving many wondering how much longer this partnership might go on. A slow-burn angle has merits, but the decision to have Hayter essentially fob off the crowd support she's received seems counter-productive.
Based on former tag partner Blair Davenport's success in NXT, the arguably more talented Hayter could likely turn some heads with a move to WWE. Considering her size, strength and general intensity between the ropes, it's easy to picture WWE presenting Jamie as a vicious bully heel or, if the fan support's still there, a mighty, if slightly antiheroic, babyface.
After more than a year on major TV, it's safe to say Hayter could likely leapfrog NXT altogether as well. As a completely standalone singles star, her mettle could finally be tested properly.
8. Josh Woods
At a glance, 'The Technical Beast' appears to have a lot going for him. There's the distinctive, menacing look, the heavyweight build and, best of all, the technical wrestling skill and emphasis on mat work.
A high-level collegiate wrestler in his day, Woods, is still active in the grappling and combat sports worlds, often working camps for MMA fighters. His work in sparring and competitive wrestling shines in the ring where he plies a gritty, hard-grafting style. Woods' selling's also consistent and he's shown a quiet flair for being a heelish jerk when given the chance.
A slow-burning push in ROH has diminished in the wake of the promotion's remains hijacking much of AEW's shows. Right off the bat, Woods lost the Pure Championship, a title perfectly suited to his realistic style, to Blackpool Combat Club project Wheeler Yuta. Bar a solid Rampage bout with Samoa Joe, Woods has done very little of note in the Jacksonville-based promotion in the time since.
In WWE, Woods' distinctive style and aggressive demeanour would likely net him a decent role as a grounding, midcard heel foil for well-liked, high-flying babyfaces such as Ricochet and Mustafa Ali. His technical work's explosive enough to avoid being considered dull, an issue many technical wrestlers faced during Vince McMahon's reign, and would help set him apart as something of a niche act. At the very least, he'd probably be on TV a bit more.
7. Malakai Black
A favourite of both Triple H and Paul Heyman, it's safe to say a return to the Aleister name could be very fruitful for 'The Striking Man from Amsterdam'.
After a hot start in AEW last year, Malakai Black cooled off considerably before beginning his hiatus earlier this year. His dark vs. light feud with then-AEW staple Cody Rhodes (doesn't that seem like an aeon ago?) made him a surprise babyface hit with fans despite his villainous persona and behaviour.
A cool, edgy tweener seemed like the logical route forward for Black after the Rhodes feud came to an end. Instead, Black and the AEW booking team got way too wrapped up in horror movie-style hijinks, turning his once fascinating, occult persona into something verging on Bray Wyatt levels of wrestling silliness.
The success of his impending return will hinge on whether or not Black can course correct his increasingly shark-jumping character work. In Triple H's NXT, his shoot-style, Dutch kickboxing work was emphasised over everything else. It made him an almost strong style-like badass that was easy to root for and, while he did have some occult overtones in his persona, it was subtle enough to be intriguing rather than absurd.
Given he was briefly considered for a main event push against the likes of Brock Lesnar and Drew McIntyre in 2020, Black in WWE under Triple H's eye could very well become WWE Champion eventually.
6. Nick Comoroto
This big, scary beast was actually with WWE for a brief spell starting in 2019. Let go due to WWE's controversial budgets in 2020, he's since found a rather lowkey home in QT Marshall's much-maligned Factory faction.
At a glance, Comoroto looks like a potential star. The whole jacked, mountain man look is rare these days and provides an easily intimidating aesthetic for Marshall's henchman. Beyond that though, Comoroto rarely does much of note and hasn't enjoyed a major TV singles match since his one-and-done Dynamite main event against Dustin Rhodes last year.
The Rhodes bout came during Dustin's brother Cody's infamous beef with The Factory and didn't exactly set the world on fire. That being said, from what we have seen of Comoroto on TV, he does have a penchant for mean-mugging facial expressions and isn't afraid of a little stiff brawling. Agile for his size, Comoroto appears to boast most of the tools needed for a successful, heavyweight beast. He just needs the time, attention and space needed to flesh out his talents.
A return to the now-more-conventionally-run NXT could do wonders for The Factory's main heavy. Always more appreciative of big men and freakish looks, WWE these days would likely find a decent slot for him as a menacing brute eventually.
5. Skye Blue
Beyond some recent, semi-competitive singles bouts with Jamie Hayter, Skye Blue really hasn't done much of any real note since joining AEW. Predominantly booked as a jobber to the stars, Blue's still managed to impressively forge an audible connection with the AEW faithful. Curiously, she often garners considerably louder reactions than better-known vets like Madison Rayne and better-established acts like Red Velvet.
With this surprise audience connection in mind, the still rather green Blue should be on the cards as a longterm project for AEW's women's division. Considering the often spotty booking of the women's scene this year though, it's hard to say such attention to detail for the undercard workers will really be implemented.
In NXT, Skye Blue would be given the breathing room and trainee-friendly environment necessary to keep developing her work rate at a sensible pace. Similarly styled young stars such as Cora Jade have already made leaps and bounds in finding their voice and style under HBK and co.'s watch. As a likeable underdog, Blue would be an obvious, heat-building foe for extroverted heel acts such as Tiffany Stratton and the Toxic Attraction crew.
As Liv Morgan's explosion in popularity over the last year has shown, WWE still do have a knack for building up likeable, if rather outmatched, babyface stars from time to time. A move over to developmental before an eventual main roster run could be just the ticket in Skye Blue's case.
4. Powerhouse Hobbs
P-p-p-p-p-Powerhouse Hobbs has simply jobbed way too much since joining AEW for a man of his intimidation factor and, well, power.
A menacing big man with a nice, explosive snap to his wrestling moves and strikes, Hobbs' only really major win this year was his surprise squash of Ricky Starks at All Out. In the meantime, he's jobbed to stars half his size, such as Orange Cassidy and Dante Martin, and rarely secures much mic time to expand on his current heel persona bar recent weeks with Samoa Joe and Wardlow.
With all the potential in the world, Hobbs is still surprisingly green between the ropes when it comes to storytelling, unless he's working with a seasoned veteran. A trip to WWE's Performance Centre would likely help him iron out his deficiencies in the ring and on the mic by simply giving him more time and attention to work on them.
From there, a bump up to the main roster as a more polished pro could see the sky be the limit for this underrated big man. Notorious for being the land of the giants over the years, WWE seems like a more naturally fitting habitat for an old school strongman-style worker like Hobbs than the fast-paced, high-flying, often hardcore stylings most synonymous with AEW's ring action.
3. Ethan Page
Until his recent work with The Firm, Ethan Page was seriously struggling to find much footing in AEW beyond being Scorpio Sky and the now-seemingly-missing Dan Lambert's buddy. A funny, energetic promo, the Taekwondo black belt found himself mostly looking up at the lights in the ring despite his obvious charisma.
A shoot promo back in August saw Page be quite understandably miffed with his position in the promotion. The problem was it made no sense in kayfabe where he was still best known as Scorpio Sky's funny friend.
Since then, following a brief absence from TV, Page has returned as one of the more over members of The Firm. It seems his shoot promo and general quality of work this year have made enough of an impact that the AEW faithful are taking note of his talents and giving him solid reactions. However, it's left him in an odd place character-wise, and his sudden winning ways aren't hugely convincing after a year of mostly jobbing.
While he wouldn't be challenging Roman Reigns tomorrow in WWE, Page's comedic timing and generally brash presentation would likely win him some fans backstage where the louder, often more charmingly silly, heel archetypes are still emphasised. With a return to a more clearcut, less shoot-oriented persona, Page could easily be operating at the US/IC Title level as a fun heel act ala The Miz and LA Knight.
2. Ricky Starks
Earlier this year, Ricky Starks' vainglorious promos about the FTW Championship almost made the strap feel legit.
There was a swagger to how he carried himself, a conviction in how he spoke, and a cocky showmanship to his ring work that just made everything Starks did that much more eye-catching. Fans took note, and soon enough, this natural heel was getting some surprise babyface reactions.
In order to cash in on Starks' budding popularity, AEW rather confusingly had Powerhouse Hobbs, already a heel, turn even more heel, by assaulting his also heel tag partner Starks. This setback turned 'Absolute' into a fairly white meat babyface, a role which he's largely struggled with.
Bar a powerful, emotional promo that pretty much had to fill in the Swiss cheese levels of plotholes in his Hobbs feud, Starks' whole character and presentation just feels off as a babyface. His crowd interactions often seem a bit try-hard, as do his more enthusiastic mannerisms and body language. Come bell time, he's still an immensely talented wrestler but his showboating and instincts just don't suit this upstart babyface role.
In WWE, his old heel persona would be an easy fit in the upper midcard almost immediately. The promotion has a long history of enjoying witty, arrogant heel and tweener characters. The snazzily dressed, snarky Starks would be an obvious and effective foil for grizzled babyface stars like Drew McIntyre and Kevin Owens.
1. Wardlow
Over the summer, Wardlow really did feel like the next big thing. His babyface turn and feud with devilish former employer MJF was a smash hit, and chants of "Wardlow" rung heavy everywhere he went. After his long-awaited showdown with 'The Salt of the Earth' got somewhat undermined by MJF's real-life company issues, Wardlow was moved into the TNT Title scene.
This move would've been fine if it weren't for 'Mr Mayhem's bizarre promo explaining that he wouldn't challenge for the AEW Interim World Title because he wanted to wait for then-actual champ CM Punk's return. If Wardlow had ever watched a bit of UFC, he'd know the quickest way to challenge an absentee champion when they come back is to the win the interim belt in the meantime...
The months since haven't been much better as he's meandered through aimless title feuds and angles. His recent TNT Title loss could free him up for a return to feuding with MJF. However, between his disappointing run and recent loss of a midcard belt, he wouldn't be entering such a major program at his most over or credible.
Wardlow's tailor-made for WWE. Between the jacked physique, over-the-top facial expressions and powerhouse wrestling style, it's easy to picture the Connecticut conglomerate pushing him in a similar fashion to his hero Batista if he jumped ship. While beating Roman Reigns is a stretch, challenging for the big gold against 'The Tribal Chief' would be a monumental step-up from what he's been given of late.