10 Great Wrestling Careers Ruined By Bad Gimmick Changes

Nothing destroys a promising wrestling career like a botched repackaging: just ask these guys.

Ddp Make Me Famous
WWE.com

Every wrestler needs a fresh coat of paint at some point in their career. Even the most popular gimmicks and characters run their course in time, and there's only so long fans can watch the same old wrestler doing the same old routine before they start tiring of the act.

It happened to Hulk Hogan, whose incredible buzz died down long before his WWE departure in 1993, and it's happening with Roman Reigns today. Staleness is a buzz-killer, and something WWE must avoid at all costs.

These moves are usually done with the intent of prolonging the wrestler's shelf-life, and mid-career gimmick changes have salvaged many a career. Unfortunately, wrestling's many creative teams have churned-out more than their fair share of dross over the years, and their decisions have tanked many great performers along the way.

Chavo Guerrero was never the same after becoming Kerwin White, for example, and the same goes for Val Venis and The Godfather's post-Right To Censor careers. It goes much, much deeper than that, however, and none of the wrestlers within were ever the same thinks to these creative disasters.

10. Giant Bernard Becoming Tensai

Lord Tensai
WWE.com

Matt Bloom struggled to elevate himself above WWE’s midcard as (Prince) Albert and A-Train, but he found tremendous success in Japan after leaving Vince McMahon’s company in 2004. A decorated tag wrestler, he became one of Japan’s most popular gaijin wrestlers as Giant Bernard, teaming with the likes of Karl Anderson and Tyson Tomko to score multiple titles and tournament wins in NJPW and Pro Wrestlng Noah.

Lord Tensai was WWE’s attempt at cashing-in on his Japanese success, and boy did it flop. Bloom redebuted in March 2012, promptly destroying Alex Riley, and embarking on a considerable win streak. The fact that he scored big victories over the likes of CM Punk and John Cena showed WWE’s faith in him as a top star, but it wasn’t to be, and the wheels soon fell-off.

Fans taunted Tensai with mocking chants of “Albert” every time he wrestled, and WWE did a poor job of explaining the gimmick. Tensai soon dropped the “Lord” from his name, got rid of his traditional Japanese robe, and exiled his follower Sakamoto.

A losing streak followed, before Tensai eventually became a dancing goofball as one half of Tons of Funk, then faded into obscurity altogether. He was taken-off television and transitioned to a trainer’s role in 2014, and the Tensai debacle effectively killed his in-ring career.


9. Paul Burchill Becoming A Pirate

Paul Burchill Pirate
WWE.com

It’s a huge shame that Paul Burchill’s pirate gimmick will go down as his WWE career’s biggest talking point. An immensely talented wrestler, the Englishman was criminally underutilised throughout his brief run, and never given the chance to showcase the full range of his abilities. Initially paired with William Regal, Burchill struggled to make any real progress up the card, and WWE decided to bury his credibility altogether in 2006.

Burchill announced to Palmer Canon, SmackDown’s network representative, that he had family ties to the pirate Blackbeard that he wanted to tap into. Unfortunately, he followed through the following week, and appeared looking just like Captain Jack Sparrow himself. Regal tried talking him out of it, but it was no use: Burchill went full-on pirate, swinging down to the entrance ramp on a rope, and renaming his finisher to “Walking the Plank.”

The gimmick fortunately came to an end several months later, but it was an unwanted flashback to the outlandish, cartoony gimmicks of WWE’s dark period in the early ‘90s. Chants of “Pirate Paul” unfortunately dogged Burchill for the rest of his career, and he was eventually released from the company in 2010. Unsurprisingly, a disenfranchised Burchill walked away from the business a few years later, and now works as a fireman.


8. Smash Becoming Repo Man

The Repo Man
WWE.com

Demolition are one of the most celebrated tag teams in WWE history. Ax and Smash were the longest reigning WWE Tag Team Champions of all-time until the New Day took their record in December, and while they originally started life as a Road Warriors knock-off act, they took on a life of their own. Unfortunately, the Legion of Doom’s eventual WWE arrival saw Demolition’s popularity go down the drain, and neither man fared particularly well in the aftermath.

Smash’s career took the weirdest turn following the group’s split in 1991, however. For whatever reason, the former no-nonsense brute became a corny, low-level thief in a long grey coat and what looked like a Zorro mask. Repo Man was born, and Smash’s career as a high-level professional wrestler was slowly ground to dust.

Repo Man has since become one of the most widely-criticised gimmicks in WWE history. With mannerisms similar to The Riddler, Repo would use his rope to tie opponents up and steal victory, then assault them after the bell. He snuck to the ring for a memorable appearance in the 1992 Royal Rumble, where he eliminated Nikolai Volkoff and Greg Valentine, but that was about the extent of his success.

The most bewildering aspect of all this is that Repo Man was actually Smash’s idea himself. Quite why he decided to nuke his career in such a way is anyone’s guess, but he was out of WWE by March 1993.


7. Cody Rhodes Becoming Stardust

Stardust WWE
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes has established himself as independent wrestling’s hottest commodity since leaving WWE in 2016. As one of the most in-demand wrestlers in the world, Rhodes has appeared for almost every non-WWE promotion that matters, from PWG and TNA to WCPW and NJPW. Thus, becoming Stardust hasn’t completely ruined his wrestling career as a whole, but it destroyed his run with the biggest wrestling promotion on the planet.

As fun as it was to see Cody adopt some of his brother Goldust’s character traits at first, Stardust soon became a dead-end gimmick for a multi-talented star. At one point, Cody looked set to following in his father Dusty’s footsteps and become one of American wrestling’s biggest stars. Instead, he became a lower-card novelty act, with only his brief feud with Arrow star Stephen Amell standing-out after splitting with his brother.

Cody’s appearances became fewer and farther between, and his frustration grew behind the scenes. Rhodes had reportedly pitched the idea of ditching the Stardust character to WWE on multiple occasions, but he was turned down or ignored at every juncture.

Finally, on May 21st, 2016, Rhodes decided that he’d had enough. He officially requested his release from the company, and was gone the very next day.


6. Perry Saturn & Moppy

Saturn Moppy
WWE.com

The Radicalz experienced a mixed bag of success in WWE. While Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero eventually became beloved World Champions, Dean Malenko found himself languishing during a lengthy Light Heavyweight Championship run, and Perry Saturn was only with the company for a couple of years.

There was always scope for bigger things in Saturn’s WWE career, but these prospects went out the window in 2001. Unfortunately, Perry legitimately attacked jobber Mike Bell after the latter botched an arm drag during a match between the two, and his career soon went down the pan.

WWE enforced a huge gimmick change on Saturn as punishment for his actions. Suddenly, Saturn became madly infatuated with the imaginatively-named Moppy (who, believed or not, was a mop), and started acting nonsensically. The gimmick went over surprisingly well with the crowd, but it made a mockery of Saturn himself, particularly when he chose Moppy over Terri Runnels.

Moppy’s life met a tragic end when Terri fed her to a woodchipper that summer, and Saturn’s career was all but over. Having spent the last spell of his WWE career playing a brain dead toddler, Saturn was released from his contract in 2002.


5. Mistico Becoming Sin Cara

Sin Cara
WWE.com

Mistico’s WWE signing seemed like easy money at the time. The company had been looking for Rey Mysterio’s long-term successor for a while, and it looked like they’d found the perfect choice in one of Mexico’s biggest stars. The multi-talented luchador was one of Triple H’s first acquisitions as Vice President of Talent Relations, and having spent the last few years selling out arenas and winning titles south of the border, Mistico joined WWE in 2011.

He became Sin Cara, and his career took an immediate downturn. Debuting in April, Cara was incredibly eye-catching and exciting at first, but it soon became apparent that he was struggling to adapt to the slower American style. He developed an unfortunate reputation for botching in big matches, and fell foul of WWE’s Wellness Policy. Sadly, he never looked close to succeeding Mysterio, and was soon relegated to midcard obscurity.

WWE’s patience was running thin by 2013, and after infuriating long-time backstage rival Alberto Del Rio during one of his last matches, Mistico was let go. The former Hunico inherited the gimmick and Mistico has since returned to Mexico as Caristico, but his WWE run was nothing but an unnecessary diversion. It’s unlikely that he’ll ever be given another chance in a major American promotion after flopping in such spectacular fashion.


4. Mike Awesome Becoming The Fat Chick Thrilla

Mike Awesome WCW Debut
WWE Network

WCW had no idea what they had in Mike Awesome. Widely regarded as one of the most athletically impressive big men in wrestling history, Awesome was nicknamed the “300lb Luchador” during his time with ECW, where his spectacular matches with the likes of Masato Tanaka saw him become a wildly popular athlete. He lacked the charisma to succeed as a true main event level wrestler, but with the right manager, Awesome could have been a star.

Signing for WCW in 2000 looked like his big break, and he made a promising start as “The Career Killer.” Debuting in an attack on WCW Champion Kevin Nash, Awesome famously threw Chris Kanyon from the top of a cage, and aided Billy Kidman in his feud with Hulk Hogan. His legitimacy was shot to pieces that summer, however: Awesome became obsessed with “heavier” women, and “The Fat Chila Thrilla” was born.

His slide was spectacular, and his star power was eradicated. Where Awesome once looked like a fantastic acquisition, he became a no-good comedy character, and nobody could take him seriously. WCW attempted to repackage him as “That ‘70s Guy,” but the gimmick was only slightly less ridiculous than the one that came before it. Awesome’s career never truly recovered from his drastic character changes, and he lasted just a year with WWE after eventually signing in 2001.


3. Typhoon Becoming The Shockmaster

Typhoon, Shockmaster
WWE.com

You can’t have a discussion about bad wrestling gimmicks without mentioning The Shockmaster’s name. Fred Ottman was a popular tag wrestler when he signed with WCW in 1993, and had a WWE Tag Team Championship reign as The Natural Disasters’ Typhoon. He was never going to be a main eventer, but Typhoon was a valued member of the WWE roster, and well-respected among fans and peers alike.

Until The Shockmaster happened.

The sight of Ottman’s glittery Stormtrooper helmet rolling away after he’d tumbled through a set wall has become one of the most infamous in wrestling history. Nobody could quite believe what they’d seen, and as Davey Boy Smith loudly proclaimed “he fell flat on his arse!” the gimmick became an immediate flop. From the hideous attire to the over-the-top, gravelly voice, everything about The Shockmaster was ridiculous, and Ottman never recovered.

WCW persisted with the gimmick as a putz-like character, but nobody could ever get over the hilarity of his debut. Ottman returned to WWE for a brief run in 1994, but he struggled for regular work at a mainstream level thereafter. The one saving grace is that The Shockmaster still makes Ottman money, and he still carries the helmet around at fan conventions, but we’re sure he’d rather have avoided the situation altogether.


2. Terry Taylor Becoming The Red Rooster

The Red Rooster
WWE.com

Widely regarded as one of wrestling’s hottest prospects in the 1980s, Terry Taylor was an athletic, technically-proficient grappler with an excellent look. His career took an unfortunate downturn with Jim Crockett’s acquisition of the UWF in 1987, but it looked like Taylor was finally set to reach his full potential after transitioning to WWE the following year.

Debuting as Scary Terry Taylor, the former UWF World Television Champion was soon repackaged as The Red Rooster. Paired with the legendary Bobby Heenan, Taylor’s gimmick didn’t quite reach Gobbledy Gooker levels of absurdity, but it wasn’t far off. Donning bright red tights and a matching ring coat, The Rooster styled his hair like a real rooster’s comb, and strutted around the ring Foghorn Leghorn.

It was a predictable disaster, and Taylor never fulfilled his incredible promise as a direct result of his first WWE run. Nobody could take Taylor seriously after his run as the Rooster, and while he had further spells with both WWE and WCW over the years that followed, he never looked like becoming a star again. He retired from the ring in 2006, having become TNA’s Head of Talent Relations three years prior, and joined WWE as an NXT trainer in 2012 - a role he remains in today.


1. DDP Becoming A Stalker

DDP Stalker
WWE

WWE might be the most successful promotion in wrestling history, but signing for Vince McMahon’s company isn’t always what it’s made out to be. Diamond Dallas Page is living, breathing proof of that, and after becoming a star in WCW, his career ran aground in WWE.

Page was one of the few major WCW stars to actually jump ship to WWE following McMahon’s buyout in 2001. While the likes of Goldberg and Scott Steiner sat at home and waited-out their mammoth contracts, DDP was placed at the heart of the Invasion. He was immediately thrown into a huge angle with one of WWE’s biggest stars in The Undertaker, but it soon backfired.

A number of vignettes featuring an unidentified stalker harassing Taker’s wife, Sara, aired in the weeks prior to Page’s debut. His eventual unmasking went over huge, but instead of evolving DDP’s character in a more tasteful direction, WWE doubled down on his creepiness. DDP became a horrific, lecherous criminal, and The Undertaker feud soon fell off a cliff.

WWE decided it’d be a good idea to have Page lose to Sara herself, and that was the end of Page’s mainline wrestling career. He won the relatively meaningless European Championship later in his run, but DDP was let go from WWE in 2002. Page’s DDP Yoga system has been an immense credit to himself and the business since his retirement, but stalking Taker’s wife was the end of his run as a top-level wrestler.


In this post: 
DDP
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.