10 Great Wrestling Feuds That Produced Disappointing Matches

Sometimes the best isn't saved for last...

AJ Styles Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Over the years, professional wrestling has given us countless memorable feuds. From former friends to sworn enemies, there are infinite possibilities when it comes to creating an intriguing rivalry, and we have seen just about all of them come to life. While engaging storylines are a must for a good feud, one thing that is equally as important is the exclamation point — the match itself.

There is nothing quite as fulfilling for wrestling fans than to see a bitter rivalry come to a head in a match that delivers every bit of intensity that it promised. It's even better when the match is so good that it transcends the feud and is forever remembered for the spectacle that it was.

However, sometimes things end up working out a little differently. Sometimes the creative team, and the talent involved, put their absolute all into making a feud work and, as a result, produce a story that is so marvellous that we can't help but watch in awe as the superstars head towards their ultimate collision — only for everything to fall apart in the match itself. With that in mind, let's take a look back through the archives and remind ourselves of some of the all-time great rivalries that failed to deliver a match worthy of its epic feud.

10. Triple H Vs. Seth Rollins

triple h seth rollins wrestlemania 33
WWE.com

When Triple H turned on this chosen successor, Seth Rollins, in the summer of 2016, we all knew that a collision between the former allies was inevitable. Thus, WWE's writers were tasked with keeping this major rivalry relevant until WrestleMania. For the most part, they succeeded, hiding behind Triple H's sneakiness in an attempt to drag it out for eight months.

After overcoming Triple H's part-time schedule and even Seth Rollins' unexpected injury, the match that had been three years in the making finally took place at WrestleMania 33. With plenty of great spots and an added No Holds Barred stipulation that benefited Triple H's brutal approach, it was ultimately an entertaining match, yet for some reason, we came away from it slightly underwhelmed.

Triple H once again did the noble job and put the young upstart over, so you can't fault his commitment to the cause. However, given his strong history with young competitors and Rollins' success in high-profile matches, this one just fell slightly short of our expectations. That doesn't mean that it was bad, because it wasn't. It just failed to stand out like we hoped it would.


9. Dean Ambrose Vs. Chris Jericho

Ambrose Asylum
WWE.com

Chris Jericho is an absolute revelation on the microphone, and has spent the past few years giving us some of his finest mic work yet. So when he was paired with Dean Ambrose in a feud, it was understandable that our expectations were high. Not only were both men great talkers, they were also incredibly entertaining to watch in the ring.

As expected, the rivalry proved to be highly entertaining with many humorous moments throughout, including the destruction of Jericho's light up jacket at the hands of Ambrose. However, no amount of hilarity or "stupid idiots!" could save their final showdown in the Ambrose Asylum from being a trainwreck. Though the crowd's disinterest certainly didn't help matters, the match went on far too long and the stipulation ended up coming off as corny instead of the intimidating structure it should have been. Aside from the thumbtack spot, there was nothing memorable about this one.

This was really unfortunate because the Ambrose Asylum seemed like such a rich concept for a match, but the execution let it down completely. As a result, the match proved to be a bloated, flat and all-round terrible conclusion to this great feud.


8. Triple H Vs. Randy Orton

Triple H Randy Orton WrestleMania XXV
WWE.com

In early 2009, Randy Orton completely snapped, taking out Vince, Shane and Stephanie McMahon. The sudden character change breathed new life into Orton as he quickly ascended to the top of WWE once more, winning the Royal Rumble. His actions drew the ire of Triple H, who got involved in the feud to defend his extended family's honour. The story was personal and the hatred ran deep. As a result, it was violent, vicious and brutal — undoubtedly earning a spot among the greatest feuds of the decade.

Naturally, it all led to a battle between the two men at WrestleMania and, let's just say that the rivalry's appeal stopped here. Despite having so much history behind them, Hunter and Orton didn't really work well together here and produced a rather mediocre match — which was a disappointing main event for WrestleMania's 25th show. It certainly didn't help that this had to go on after The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels brought the house down with their five-star classic, but we could have forgiven that dreadful idea if the match had been particularly memorable.

At the time, Triple H's victory sure felt like the feelgood WrestleMania ending that we deserved, but looking back on it, we can't help but feel like this completely obliterated the momentum of Orton's reinvention.


7. Dean Ambrose Vs. Brock Lesnar

dean ambrose brock lesnar wrestlemania.jpg
WWE.com

Brock Lesnar and Dean Ambrose really had all the tools to pull off an incredibly physical street fight at WrestleMania 32. One was a fighting machine with no regard for the well-being of his opponent while the other was a screwloose maniac who would throw everything (including the kitchen sink) at his monstrous adversary just to prove that he could stand up to him. Despite our initial concerns, WWE managed to make the program between the odd couple work and it didn't take long for us to get invested.

With this compelling story set to conclude in a No Holds Barred Street Fight, we were hoping for a moderately brutal war that pushed the boundaries of the PG Era while never actually breaking them. The end result, however, was nothing like this. Ambrose really tried to make us buy into the story, but he just kept finding himself on the wrong end of German Suplexes, which quickly made the match feel repetitive. Barbed wire bats were teased yet the match didn't deliver what it promised.

This should have been an easy match to get right, but it was a major letdown that was hindered by bad booking and apparent laziness on Lesnar's part. The only thing it really managed to accomplish was reminding us how brutal these stipulations used to be, and that made us hate this dreadfully disappointing match even more.


6. The Undertaker Vs. Kane (2010)

Undertaker Kane
WWE

When The Undertaker and Kane get together, threats are made, fireballs are thrown and lightning strikes anything that moves. As history has taught us, the Brothers of Destruction know exactly how to put on an entertaining program, and their 2010 feud proved to be a surprisingly thrilling tale of Kane's final attempt to step out of The Deadman's shadow. Though not as iconic as their original rivalry from 1998, it was still a highly-entertaining program that brought some much-needed supernaturalism back to WWE at a time when it was obsessed with reality.

Unfortunately, the pair's in-ring work wasn't anywhere near the standard it once was as they went on to produce a trilogy of underwhelming matches. Their No Holds Barred match does deserve some points for just how balls-to-the-walls it was, but it still couldn't hold a candle to their previous clashes. However, it was their Hell In A Cell and Buried Alive matches that were the real disappointments. 'Taker was clearly hurting throughout the whole feud and Kane just wasn't the right person to pair him with at this stage in his career.

When we think of The Undertaker and Kane, this feud's mythical promos may cross our minds, but the matches it produced aren't in the same league as the pair's legendary brawls from the late '90s. Their rivalry stood the test of time, but their match quality did not.


5. Brock Lesnar Vs. Braun Strowman

brock lesnar braun strowman
WWE.com

WWE did a great job of building Braun Strowman up as the one man who could finally slay The Beast and bring the Universal Championship back to TV full-time. The Monster Among Men was unafraid of Brock Lesnar and was seemingly immune to his killer suplexes, highlighted beautifully when he got right back up and hit the Universal Champion with a Chokeslam. This was all building towards an epic title match.

When the two men finally met one-on-one at No Mercy, they actually put on a decent match that told a great story. The only problem was that, despite the fact that they weren't given enough time, the repetitive format somehow managed to slow things down. This ultimately led to an abrupt and overall, flat finish which saw Lesnar take everything Strowman had to offer only to hit a single F-5 and win the match. It was such an anticlimactic ending that deflated the audience (and Strowman's momentum).


4. Randy Orton Vs. Bray Wyatt

WWE WrestleMania 33 Randy Orton Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

Randy Orton's feud with Bray Wyatt proved to be one of the more surprisingly intriguing storylines of 2016. With cryptic promos, turncoat Vipers and even Kane thrown in for good measure, this bonkers rivalry was incredibly enjoyable and gave Orton a chance to cut some engaging promos while allowing Bray Wyatt to do what he does best: talk. The pair would eventually form an unholy alliance before Orton won the Royal Rumble and chose his former partner as his WrestleMania opponent.

Though the title added more stakes to the pair's match, it could not save the bout from becoming the biggest dud of the night. On the grand stage of WrestleMania, these two men had absolutely no in-ring chemistry and produced a terribly-worked match. It felt like WWE had predicted that it wouldn't be great because they really tried to make it exciting by projecting footage of creepy-crawlies onto the ring, but nothing could get the crowd interested in what has gone down in history as one of the most underwhelming WWE Championship matches in 'Mania history. The abrupt ending which saw Wyatt lose his recently-won title made it all the more baffling.

The disastrous outing destroyed the mystique of the intriguing supernatural story and the only thing more dead than the crowd was Bray Wyatt's push.


3. Shinsuke Nakamura Vs. AJ Styles

shinsuke nakamura aj styles
WWE.com

AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura had one heck of a rivalry earlier this year when the latter won the men's Royal Rumble match and challenged Styles for the WWE Championship at WrestleMania. The pair's history outside of WWE was well-documented, and the thought of seeing them wrestle each other at The Showcase of the Immortals sent us all into meltdown. After their incredible encounter at NJPW's Wrestle Kingdom 10, it's understandable the entire WWE Universe had really high expectations for their in-ring meetings.

The rivalry was everything it should have been, starting out respectful before Nakamura became a vengeful heel, desperate to take the championship from Styles. For their matches, the two exceptional performers really tried to channel their past and give the WWE Universe what we were hoping for but, while the contests were indeed great, unfortunately they fell significantly short of those high expectations.

It's hard to criticise their outings because these two men never once produced a bad match, but their WWE clashes were just a little disappointing compared to what we were expecting from them.


2. Triple H Vs. Chris Jericho

Triple H Chris Jericho WrestleMania X8
WWE.com

Triple H's feud with Chris Jericho produced some of 2002's most entertaining moments. With The Game returning from a career-threatening injury to win the Royal Rumble and challenge Jericho for the WWE Undisputed Championship, there was already a lot of emotion involved in this storyline, but with Stephanie McMahon's allegiance with Jericho thrown into the equation as well, this was a huge mountain for the Cerebral Assassin to climb.

Despite the odds, Trips overcame Jericho in the main event of WrestleMania X8. While we were all happy that The Game had placed the exclamation point on his triumphant return, we just wish that exclamation point was a little more entertaining. The match was fairly decent, but after watching the epic confrontation between Hulk Hogan and The Rock earlier in the night, the crowd just didn't seem to care about this contest. Granted, it would have been helpful if Triple H and Jericho gave them something thrilling, but a mildly enjoyable battle that was slightly better than an average Raw or SmackDown main event was not going to send the audience into a frenzy.

Like previous matches on this list, this contest was by no means bad, it just wasn't exactly worthy of this great feud or of headlining the biggest event of the year.


1. Sting Vs. Hollywood Hulk Hogan

Sting Hogan Starrcade 1997
WWE Network

Never in the history of professional wrestling has a storyline with so much potential been utterly wasted in the way that Starrcade '97 destroyed Sting's return to the ring. The creative team had spent a year on this storyline, taking a risk by repackaging WCW's light-hearted headliner into a dark avenger who wanted to destroy the toxic nWo. This risk ultimately paid off as more wrestling fans tuned into WCW than WWE during this period, all eagerly awaiting Sting's ascension to the top to overthrow the villainous faction.

The world observed as Sting faced off against Hollywood Hogan at the marquee event for the WCW Championship and we all watched in amazement as the company squandered the single biggest opportunity they ever had. The match was incredibly dull with the feeling out process dragging on for minutes before Hogan dominated the majority of the disappointing contest. Things got worse when Sting was pinned cleanly, despite the "fast-count" controversy, and Bret Hart restarted the match for a short flurry from Sting and an ultimate victory.

Unlike previous entries on this list, the crowd did not hurt this one — they were completely invested. Terrible booking decisions let this one down and, this was only a sign of things to come for WCW. Months of careful planning and intricate storytelling were washed away in this complete failure of a match. After such an iconic rebirth, Sting (and the audience) deserved so much better than this.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.