10 Great WWE PPV Matches That Ended In Disqualification
These matches failed to give us a winner, but they certainly didn't fail to entertain.
Okay, I should probably begin with some sort of disclaimer.
At the time, I hated the finish of each and every one of these matches. Pay-per-views are where the biggest bouts take place, and those biggest bouts should almost always have a definitive winner. Even today, a disqualification finish on a show that people have paid to see strikes me as cheap and lazy.
Even so, it is an important plot point in wrestling and as such it is a necessary means to get from A to B. Or from J to K, as stories may be. Just because a match ends with a referee motioning to the timekeeper and thousands of people in attendance simultaneously rolling their eyes and booing doesn't make the action that precedes it bad.
Sometimes, that action is absolutely fantastic. There have been a number of wonderful matches on pay-per-view that have ended in disqualification over the years, and my job here is to bring your attention to them, to those you remember and those you may have forgotten about.
So there might not always be a winner, but this shouldn't cloud over the work two men put on inside the ring before we get to the end. This is about work not spoilers, and the means and effort that two individuals put in before the end of their match.
Here are 10 great WWE PPV matches that ended in disqualification.
10. Randy Orton Vs. John Cena - No Way Out 2008
Believe it or not, but there was a time when John Cena vs. Randy Orton was actually a fresh match! Despite winning his first World Championship a whole eight months before Cena, it took longer for Orton to truly solidify himself as a main event performer, but by 2008 this was certainly the case.
Cena had returned shockingly at the Royal Rumble a month earlier, and after winning it did something that still makes absolutely zero sense today: he decided to have his World Championship shot at No Way Out as opposed to WrestleMania.
Why John, why?
And so the match was made, Randy Orton vs. John Cena at No Way Out for the WWE Championship. The match was still fresh as previously mentioned, and the crowd was absolutely molten for the whole thing.
Now I'm not going to try and tell you that Randy Orton vs. John Cena was a five star classic or anything, because it wasn't, but this was as good as those two were ever going to give us. The finish was different too, as Orton became frustrated that he couldn't put Cena away and struck the referee to get himself disqualified.
It was cheap, but it made sense in a roundabout way.
9. Brock Lesnar Vs. The Undertaker - Unforgiven 2002
The Undertaker features twice on this list, and both times a messy disqualification was necessary in order to continue the feud towards a Hell in a Cell climax. The later of these was accentuated by a need to keep Brock Lesnar strong, to make the Next Big Thing seem on the level of Big Evil when it came to brawling and all-out violence.
This match gets a fair amount of shade thrown at it, and whilst a certain amount of that is vindicated I feel the match isn't anywhere near as bad as many like to think it is. In fact, it is actually quite clever. Lesnar hadn't met anyone who could match him as of then, so this presented a new challenge for the hottest thing in professional wrestling.
The match was thrown out when things got out of hand, but as unpopular it seems that is the sort of finish that really should happen more often. It gives that impression of realism that we so want in our wrestling, and also makes the referee look like an actual official as opposed to a prop in a striped shirt.
It also created the road to a match with no rules, the Hell in a Cell classic that would come a month later.
8. Big Show Vs. Sheamus - Survivor Series 2012
It is still somewhat difficult to accept, but Sheamus and Big Show had a genuinely fantastic series of matches over the World Heavyweight Championship in 2012. Even typing that sentence feels weird. Big Show was as interesting as he had been in years, and Sheamus excels in the 'fighting babyface' role. Together, the two of them had a chemistry that no one had foreseen.
Their Survivor Series bout wasn't on the level of their Hell in a Cell match a month prior, but it was still a damn good three star match. Sure, it was a whole lot of brawling, but the few big spots they planned were pulled off without a hitch and, besides, two men of this size should be brawling, right?
Sheamus' comeback was impressive and the crowd were behind him, something that makes his current plight even more confusing. Sheamus won by disqualification after Show pulled referee Scott Armstrong in front of a Brogue Kick.
7. Alberto Del Rio Vs. Dolph Ziggler - Money In The Bank 2013
The double turn is one of the most difficult things for a wrestling promotion to pull off, let alone to pull off well. You can count the number of effective double turns on your fingers, but one of the most memorable of recent years was the switcheroo by Dolph Ziggler and Alberto Del Rio over the WWE World Heavyweight Championship in 2013.
Del Rio beat the previously-concussed Ziggler at Payback for the title, and the two went at it once again at Money in the Bank a month later. Ziggler and Del Rio had a hot programme at the time, and the two were as good as anyone in the company when motivated.
Their bout at Money in the Bank was immensely intense, full of near falls and a hot crowd. The end came when AJ Lee interfered on behalf of her then-beau Ziggler, and the story of Ziggles moved in the break-up direction as opposed to more matches with Del Rio.
Still, this was a cracker.
6. Eddie Guerrero Vs. John 'Bradshaw' Layfield - Judgment Day 2004
There is some sadness to this match looking back. Judgment Day 2004 delivered such a terrible buy-rate that it pretty much ended Eddie Guerrero's run as champion, with Latino Heat opting out before he was taken out. SmackDown had a pretty awful start to the year anyway, as the blue brand struggled with the loss of Brock Lesnar (left to try his luck at the NFL), Kurt Angle (injured) and Chris Benoit (moved to Raw).
Still, Eddie Guerrero and John 'Bradshaw' Layfield went out in the main event of that show and put one one of the most violent brawls WWE has ever seen. JBL was visibly nervous to begin with, understandable considering he was in his first PPV main event, but the two soon settled and contested an intense fight.
There are some truly uncomfortable chair shots in this match to both men, and the blade-job that Eddie does has reached practically legendary status, just about breaking the Muta Scale. The match ended in a DQ when Eddie hit JBL with the WWE Championship. The title would change hands at the next Smackdown PPV, the infamously naff Great American Bash.
5. Chris Jericho Vs. Chris Benoit - Backlash 2000
Are these two the two greatest Canadian wrestlers in history named Chris?
Well, yeah, obviously. They had a number of famous matches in World Wrestling Entertainment, and they managed to cover a whole host of ground in these matches to boot. You want high-flying, technical, brawling or even some strong style? Chris Jericho vs. Chris Benoit is your match.
Their bout over the Intercontinental Championship at Backlash 2000 was another great match in their cannon. This was Benoit's first singles pay-per-view match in WWE after making the move from World Championship Wrestling, and he would get the victory after Jericho thrust the IC belt into his grill as the Crippler attempted a Flying Headbutt.
4. Shawn Michaels Vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin - King Of The Ring 1997
One year after winning the King of the Ring and giving the promo that would kickstart his career, Stone Cold Steve Austin returned to the PPV as one half of the WWF Tag Team Champions with his opponent on this show, Shawn Michaels. Both men were feuding with the Hart Foundation at the time, and the whole 'enemies but allies against a bigger foe' angle was still pretty interesting way back in 1997.
Austin was an absolute star in 1997 too, and his run of matches on WWE supershows that year is a conveyor belt of excellence. This match against Michaels was the only thing of worth on a show that featured singles matches such as Crush vs. Goldust and Mankind vs. Jerry Lawler.
The match was even throughout, as Michaels wanted to show that he was every bit as good as this hot new thing and Austin was quite simply in the form of his life. The finish is very Attitude Era-esque, however, as both men take it in turns to deck referees because reasons. We'd have to wait until WrestleMania XIV to get a fair finish out of these two.
3. Rey Mysterio Vs. Eddie Guerrero - Judgment Day 2005
Another year, another Judgment Day, another Eddie Guerrero loss by disqualification.
This time his opponent was far more formidable, as Eddie's recent heel turn had taken his lifetime beef with Rey Mysterio to new emotional heights. After a friendly match at WrestleMania 21, Eddie had gone mad and cost the duo the WWE Tag Team Titles, and the two went at it once again at Judgment Day.
For me, this was their best match in a World Wrestling Entertainment ring. Eddie's heel turn in 2005 should go down in history as one of the best ever, as Eddie managed to turn the crowd against him just one year after being arguably the most beloved performer in the company. He threw himself into the role and was doing the best work of his long career.
The match was fantastic, because of course it was. It was Eddie Guerrero vs. Rey Mysterio. This had plenty of call-backs to previous matches and a little bit of interference from Chavo Guerrero, before Eddie absolutely whomps a mid-air Mysterio with a chair for the DQ finish, leading to more wonderful matches.
2. Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs. Kurt Angle - SummerSlam 2001
There weren't many positives to come out of the Invasion angle, but the work done by Kurt Angle and Stone Cold Steve Austin was definitely one of them. it was the emergence of Angle as a top level babyface that allowed Austin to go forward as the major heel on the Alliance side, and the two faced off at SummerSlam 2001, WWF Title on the line.
They spam finishers a little bit too much throughout, but this is an intense brawl that spends most of the time outside of the ring. The match ends with Austin being disqualified after abusing ref after ref after ref and, whilst the decision was a little frustrating at the time, it made sense in the context of the Invasion story.
The match itself great though, and the two told a great story. Angle was the proud challenger, Austin the desperate crazed champion willing to do whatever it takes to retain his belt. Austin wasn't in control of his temper but that worked to his advantage, and the title stayed with him.
1. Shawn Michaels Vs. Mankind - In Your House: Mind Games 1996
Quite simply, the best WWE match to end in disqualification in history.
In 1996, the World Wrestling Federation so desperately wanted Shawn Michaels to be the biggest babyface in wrestling. The problem was that they had pretty much neutered everything that was great about him during his championship run, and he was coming off as vanilla as the ice cream flavour we all want but don't want to order in case someone accuses us of being boring.
Luckily, Mick Foley is a legitimate wrestling genius, and he turned up here to add some depth and edge to the Heartbreak Kid character. Foley was Mankind, and Mankind was a genuine threat to Michaels' WWF Championship. Shawn was going to have to embrace the hate in order to retain his title.
He did just this, busting out some seriously brutal violence in the hope of putting the deranged one down. The only problem was, the deranged one wouldn't stay down. Still, this match was vital in that Michaels evolved from being an entertainer into a champion.
It was a vital match, and it still stands up some 20 years later today. Sure, Vader comes down to ruin everything, but this doesn't take away from the almost 30 minutes that comes first.