10 Greatest Superstars In WWE SummerSlam History
The larger-than-life men who have turned an annual brawl into the 'Biggest Party of the Summer'.
As WWE prepares to present the thirtieth SummerSlam in its long and illustrious history, it becomes imperative to honor and pay respect to the Superstars who have shaped the event and helped make it a success for the last three decades.
Icons and Hall of Famers, a Deadman and an Immortal, have all helped make the annual August event the 'Biggest Party of the Summer'.
They have been part of unforgettable moments, five-star classic matches, and even a few shocking conclusions that have created buzz among fans and excitement for the otherwise sluggish autumn months.
Without them, the likelihood the event is as memorable or beloved is incredibly low.
In 2017, two world titles will be up for grabs and superstars from Raw and SmackDown will look to etch their names in the history books, hoping to join their predecessors in being able to claim they made the spectacular better than it was before.
In preparation for Jinder Mahal, AJ Styles, Shinsuke Nakamura, Braun Strowman, Finn Bálor, and the rest of the roster's awe-inspiring performances, journey through WWE history and relive the men who have shaped the foundation of WWE's annual extravaganza.
10. Mick Foley
Mick Foley's body of work at SummerSlam may be relatively small but it is difficult to find another Superstar who was consistently part of a high-profile feud the way the 'Hardcore Legend' was.
He left his mark on SummerSlam history in 1996 when he waged war with The Undertaker in a brutal, violent, incredibly physical Boiler Room Brawl that demonstrated the hatred that existed between them.
The mask-wearing freak would win that match, thanks to a shocking betrayal by Paul Bearer, but it would be his transformation into Dude Love the following year that ranks as one of the most underrated in event history.
His victory in 1999 would be his most significant, though. Fresh off much-needed knee surgery, he found himself inserted into the SummerSlam main event, where he and Triple H would challenge "Stone Cold" Steve Austin for the WWE Championship in a Triple Threat match.
With Minnesota governor Jesse Ventura as the special guest referee, Mankind capitalized on a prone Austin, delivered a big double-arm DDT, and won his third WWE Championship.
He returned to action at the 2006 SummerSlam, where he would demonstrate his innate ability to tell a story during a brutal, violent, bloody I Quit match against Ric Flair.
9. The Undertaker
Riding to the ring on the back of a hearse, The Undertaker made his SummerSlam debut in 1992 in a showdown with Kamala. His win via disqualification that night marked the first of 16 appearances at the event, a show he was a major part of for the first-half of its existence.
From 1992 through 2005, he appeared at every single one of the extravaganzas.
Whether he was battling superstars who had no business sharing the ring with him, such as Kama, Giant Gonázlez, or the notorious Underfaker, or squaring off with future Hall of Famers like Edge, Randy Orton, and Kane, he was instrumental in bringing star power and credibility to the event.
In 2015, he returned to SummerSlam for his first match at the event since 2008, battling Brock Lesnar. Hellbent on avenging his first loss at WrestleMania a year earlier, he unleashed furious vengeance on The Beast Incarnate, blasted him with a low blow and applied Hell's Gate for the tapout win.
It appears unlikely The Phenom will ever compete at the event again. If that is the case he has left a multitude of performances, including a journey down the Highway to Hell, that cements his legacy at the pay-per-view.
8. Triple H
Since his arrival in 1995, Triple H has competed at 14 SummerSlam events. He has entered as champion and challenger, competed in cage and ladder matches, and solidified his legacy as one of the greatest Superstars of his generation.
In 1998, the then-leader of D-Generation X overcame what would later be revealed to be a significant knee injury to defeat The Rock for the Intercontinental Championship in one of the more overlooked and underappreciated ladder matches in WWE history. The victory brought an end to the red-hot D-X vs. The Nation storyline that engulfed the summer months.
By the time 2002 arrived, 'The Game' had spent three years atop WWE and was one of the most powerful Superstars on- and off-screen. That year, he battled longtime best friend Shawn Michaels in an Unsanctioned Street Fight that not only ranks as a legitimate five-star classic but also sparked HBK's previously unfathomable comeback story.
From his first appearance at the event in '95 to his final in-ring performance at the event in 2012 as an authority figure foil for Brock Lesnar, Triple H's career can be tracked through his activity at the event.
7. Shawn Michaels
Shawn Michaels does not have the sparkling SummerSlam resume that he does at WrestleMania but that does not, by any means, mean he is not one of the best wrestlers to ever lace their boots at the annual summertime spectacular.
'The Heartbreak Kid's career at the event must be examined in two parts. There is the pre-back injury half and the post-back injury half. In both instances, he was a damn fine worker. In the latter, though, he recognized the elements needed to deliver a truly epic encounter and leaned on that even when his opponents may not have been able to keep up.
See the 2005 match with Hulk Hogan.
The 'Hulkster' was in no way Michaels' equal as a worker but the two of them delivered a strong, satisfying match thanks to Michaels' ability to tell a story and willingness to bump around the ring (overselling everything).
For every moment he left etched in the minds of fans, it was his unforgettable showing in 2002, against friend-turned-enemy Triple H, that serves as one of SummerSlam's greatest moments.
After four years away from the squared circle, Michaels summoned one of the most inspirational performances of all-time and beat 'The Cerebral Assassin'.
His 1995 Ladder match for the Intercontinental Championship against Razor Ramon was another all-timer.
6. Hulk Hogan
There would be no SummerSlam without Hulk Hogan.
Love him or hate him, The Hulkster's immense popularity during the late 1980s allowed Vince McMahon to test the pay-per-view market with the inaugural SummerSlam event way back in 1988. On that night, Hogan partnered with 'Macho Man' Randy Savage and defeated 'Million Dollar Man' Ted DiBiase and Andre the Giant in a blockbuster tag team main event.
Hogan would be at the heart of the promotion, publicity, and success of the event's early days.
Whether he was teaming with Brutus Beefcake to battle Savage and evil movie villain Zeus or seeking vengeance against Earthquake for a sneak attack that nearly ended his career, Hogan convinced fans to invest both emotionally and financially in the event's growth and evolution.
In 2005, he returned to the stage he helped construct for a showdown with Shawn Michaels. Riding a wave of momentum, and answering questions about his ability to deliver in the big-match situation, he turned back the clock and delivered a fantastic performance against the best wrestler on the planet.
There will be those who point to the lack of historical significance of Hogan's early SummerSlam matches as reason for his spot on this countdown being suspect but without his influence, the event would not exist.
5. CM Punk
CM Punk appeared at every SummerSlam event between 2007 and 2013 and during his run at the event, established himself as one of the elite performers of his generation. The 'Straight Edge Savior' of WWE almost always had a championship around his waist entering the extravaganza or was embattled in one of the most prominent rivalries on the card.
In 2011, he rolled into Los Angeles' Staples Center the hottest star in professional wrestling, fresh off a WWE Championship victory over John Cena in the main event of Money in the Bank. On that night, he would meet Cena in a hotly anticipated rematch.
Along with that first Cena war, there are two matches that truly define Punk's contributions to SummerSlam.
In 2009, Punk challenged Jeff Hardy for the World Heavyweight Championship in a Tables, Ladders & Chairs match. The most despised heel in the sport at the time, he infuriated the fans in LA as he defeated Hardy and captured the gold.
Perhaps no match better reflected his constant battle against the machine than his 2013 match with Brock Lesnar as only interference from Paul Heyman prevented him from beating The Beast Incarnate.
Ironically enough, his run with WWE came to an end in similar fashion, the fighter undone by influences beyond the squared circle.
4. Randy Orton
Just months after a star-making performance against Cactus Jack at Backlash 2004, Randy Orton rolled into Toronto to challenge the world heavyweight champion, Chris Benoit. All eyes were on the third-generation star as he headlined an event against one of the greatest in-ring technicians to ever lace a pair of boots.
Orton not only kept up with Benoit but actually reversed 'The Rabid Wolverine's late attempt at a Crippler Crossface into an RKO that netted him his first world title. The image of Orton standing on the ropes, bending over and kissing the title, remains one of the most iconic in event history.
Luckily for fans, it was not the last memory 'The Viper' would create on that stage. In 2011, Orton established himself one of the greatest superstars in SummerSlam history.
On that night, 'The Viper' entered the summertime spectacular as the top contender for the World Heavyweight Championship and defeated Christian in an extraordinary match that served as the culmination of their underrated rivalry.
Orton would go on to cash in Money in the Bank and win the WWE Championship in 2013 and headline the show three years later against Brock Lesnar. While most save their best for WrestleMania, the third-generation star has focused his attention to bringing his best at SummerSlam.
3. John Cena
There may be no other pay-per-view event that serves as the emphasis for the "Big Match John" nickname more than SummerSlam, where John Cena has cemented his legacy as the greatest (and most selfless) superstar of his generation.
In 2011, Cena lost his second consecutive pay-per-view match to CM Punk. Two years later, he fought through a very real torn triceps muscle and put Daniel Bryan over clean in the center of the ring.
A year later, he endured 16 suplexes and jobbed out to Brock Lesnar in the most one-sided main event in SummerSlam history. He has lost to Edge, Batista, and AJ Styles throughout his 13 years of competition at the summertime spectacular, all with the idea of strengthening their stars and elevating them to his level.
Perhaps even more important than his selflessness is Cena's track record of Match of the Year candidates.
His match with Punk was a suitable follow-up to the classic from a month earlier. He gave Bryan a match befitting the pandemonium that surrounded the bearded wonder's rise to the top of the card.
Then there was the classic with Styles that rightfully earned MOTY honors and saw Cena cleanly lose to The Phenomenal One.
2. Brock Lesnar
Five months into his WWE career, Brock Lesnar flattened The Rock with an F-5 and pinned him to capture the Undisputed Championship at SummerSlam 2002. The win was the culmination of the most rapid ascent in company history and an announcement to the wrestling world that Lesnar was no longer 'The Next Big Thing', he was the big thing.
A loss to Kurt Angle the following year would spell the end for Lesnar's initial SummerSlam run. Constant travel and personal appearances made life as a WWE Superstar unbearable for the industry giant so in 2004, he waved goodbye and appeared unlikely to ever return.
After years of establishing himself as the biggest box office attraction and pay-per-view draw thanks to a heavyweight stint in UFC, Lesnar returned to WWE and set his sights on smashing a new crop of superstars.
Triple H was first, enduring a broken arm courtesy of 'The Beast Incarnate's Kimura armbar. The following year, Lesnar fended off a valiant effort from CM Punk in a Match of the Year candidate.
It was in 2014, though, that Lesnar cemented his status as one of the greatest competitors in event history when he obliterated John Cena and took the WWE World Heavyweight Championship away from him in dominant fashion.
1. Bret Hart
Hulk Hogan may be the reason for SummerSlam's existence but Bret Hart took it from its humble beginnings as a WWE cash grab and made it into an elite wrestling show in which Match of the Year candidates became expected.
'The Hitman' delivered two all-time great matches in consecutive years, beginning in 1991 with his Intercontinental Championship victory over Mr. Perfect, and continuing with a defeat at the hands of 'British Bulldog' Davey Boy Smith in front of 80,000-plus fans in London.
Hart would remain a staple of the event, competing at every SummerSlam from 1988 through 1995 and returning to the event in both 1997 and 2010. As he did so many times over the course of his career, he delivered show-stealing performances from the undercard and ensured fans went home happy when competing in the night's show-closing bout.
In 1994, he revolutionized the Steel Cage match with brother Owen, proving that typically barbaric match can be a bloodless exercise in drama if executed correctly and to its fullest potential.
He brought workrate to the show in the 1990s when Vince McMahon's company was in upheaval. Amongst the cartoon characters and underwhelming workers, he steadied the ship and provided fans a superstar they could trust to give them their money's worth.