10 Greatest WWE WrestleMania Gimmick Matches

Cages, ladders, fire, and plenty more besides.

HHH Taker HIAC
WWE

As the grandest show of them all, WrestleMania is all about settling scores. It acts like the season finale for WWE; we cap off our storylines in exciting fashion, then reset the next night on Raw, ready to go again. And the best way to end any quasi-sporting encounter is with a fair fight, no messing about, a straight down the line battle for supremacy.

Sometimes, though, that’s not enough. When a feud gets too heated, or conversely an angle needs a little something to tip it over the edge, technical chain wrestling and spirited competition isn’t going to cut it. That’s when WWE reaches into its bag of tricks and pulls out a gimmick match.

The company’s stipulation bouts tend to go one of two ways - they’re either utterly daft, up to and including the use of untrained dogs, or brilliant, pushing boundaries and encouraging colleagues to up their own game.

Whether these matches utilised their gimmicks to push a narrative to another level, or if the gimmick was the whole point of the bout in the first place, these encounters added a much needed splash of variety to their respective WrestleManias, and in many cases stole the whole show.

10. Kane vs Raven vs Big Show (WrestleMania X-Seven)

Kane Raven Big Show
WWE.com

This hardcore match is perhaps most famous - or infamous - for something that ultimately didn’t happen. During the apex of this particularly silly fight, Raven commandeered a golf kart to flee his substantially larger foes, and in his cavalier driving almost severed the power to the entire Reliant Astrodome.

This catastrophe was averted, but the fact that the mishap was even a possibility gives you an idea of how crazy this match was. Raven entered as champion, and brought with him to the ring a trolley full of plunder. He needn’t have bothered; within minutes, all three men are backstage and using everything and anything as a weapon.

They crash through doors and walls, wail on each other with all kinds of material, there’s the aforementioned vehicular pursuit, and Kane ultimately wins the janky belt after leaping off the stage.

Despite all the mayhem, it hangs together remarkable well, three quality performers packing the sub-10 minute runtime with non-stop action.


9. Cactus Jack & Chainsaw Charlie vs The New Age Outlaws (WrestleMania XIV)

cactus jack road dogg wrestlemania 14 dumpster match
WWE.com

Whether he’s working five star bouts with Ric Flair or mucking about with Mick Foley, it’s always great to see Terry Funk. Here, in his Chainsaw Charlie guise and some 54 years of age, he puts on a deeply silly dumpster match against tag champs The New Age Outlaws, and while it’s no classic, it’s brilliantly daft fun.

For those somehow unaware, the rules of a dumpster match are: you need to take your opponent, chuck them into a dumpster, and shut the lid. Most of the match comprises members of each team falling into the bin but crawling out before the lid can be slammed closed - it’s cartoonish wrestling but all concerned commit fully to the bit.

There are daft plunges from ladders and weapons shots, laid on thick as the era dictated. Eventually the match makes its way to the back, and Charlie utilises a forklift to dump the Outlaws and win the match.

In a Dusty finish, it would transpire that the dumpster used for the win was not the official dumpster, and the decision was reversed the following night. Why the rules would be upheld so stringently in this of all matches is a mystery, but this is a blast all the same.


8. Hulk Hogan vs Vince McMahon (WrestleMania XIX)

Hulk Hogan Vince McMahon WrestleMania XIX 19
WWE.com

Everyone remembers Vince’s street fight with Shane at X-Seven, but the real heads know his match with Hulk Hogan under similar rules two years hence was better still. Built on the history-warping premise that Hogan attempted to bring down WWE during the infamous steroid trials, this was two old, weird men going above and beyond to entertain a crowd.

This was never going to be conventionally pretty match, but the willingness of the two industry legends to take a beating is somehow genuinely admirable. They exchange chair shots, both get busted open, and the crowd hangs on their every ludicrous move.

McMahon books himself unusually strongly here, going toe to toe with the Hulkster in the test of strength and successfully lobbing the big man around the ring. We even get a hilarious run in from Roddy Piper, who struggles to decide which man he hates the most, before busting Hogan with a pipe and legging it.

The match ends with the usual Hulk up routine (the crowd’s “you!” on the finger point is one for the ages) and the tried and tested leg drop to finish it off. It’s two rich old men taking 20 minutes out of their day to give you a laugh, and it’s glorious.


7. Money In The Bank (WrestleMania 21)

Shelton Benjamin Edge WrestleMania 21
WWE.com

Most of the Money In The Bank ladder matches could take this spot on the list, as they’re close to a guarantee of a good time, but it’s the inaugural offering that makes the cut.

Firstly, the idea was completely fresh back then, and in general WWE programming was less saturated with ladder matches. 21 also boasts probably the starriest iteration of the stipulation, with everyone involved a possible winner.

Then there are the spots. Kane and Jericho take a gnarly tumble from the ladder to the floor, and in probably the most memorable moment, Shelton Benjamin (who really should have won one of these) sprints up an angled ladder to hit a clothesline on Y2J. Equal parts frightening and amazing is Benoit’s flying headbutt from the top of a ladder - the sight is incredible, the effect it clearly has on him harrowing.

The match also proved its efficacy from the off, with Edge nabbing the briefcase and embarking on a run to the top of the card. It’s the first of many, but still the best.


6. Firefly Funhouse (WrestleMania 36)

John Cena The Fiend
WWE.com

Is it a match per se? No. Is the “firefly funhouse” a discernible stipulation? Not really. But is the Firefly Funhouse match the most creative and bold piece of content to come out of WWE in many a year? Well, that’s a big yes!

The pandemic often brought out the worst in the company, but the immediate impact saw some real invention, peaking with this journey into the life, times, and mind of John Cena. Brought back for a ‘Mania match, Cena was lured to Bray Wyatt’s demented kids’ TV show set.

From there, what unfolded was a longform critique of Cena the wrestler and man. His initial difficulties getting over; his burial of younger stars; his unwillingness to turn heel; his increasing staleness. With commendable commitment, Cena sent himself up to the hilt, with Wyatt the cackling roastmaster.

This might be the peak of Bray’s WWE tenure, showing a mind operating on a different plane to anyone else’s. It’s a miracle that Vince signed off on this, and that Cena agreed to this skewering, but thank goodness they did.


5. Edge vs Mick Foley (WrestleMania 22)

edge mick foley
WWE.com

For a hardcore match this brutal and bloody, Edge vs Foley is surprisingly wholesome in its intent. The former Mankind was an industry legend by this point, but couldn’t rightly claim a WrestleMania classic in his career.

He and Edge set out to change that in the way only they could.

A match that easily steals the show on an otherwise fairly pedestrian ‘Mania, it nails its tone perfectly. There are plenty of gruesome moments, but none of them are excessive or superfluous, all building the story of the wily hardcore legend and the rising star who’d have to pull something special out of the bag to win.

Taking a page from the Bret Hart playbook, Foley allows himself to be speared only to reveal barbed wire wrapped around his stomach. From there, the two trade shots with bats and chairs, before the coup de grace - a table, lit on fire by Lita, through which the pair tumble with Edge getting the win.

It’s a hardcore match with genuine psychology, Edge doing a terrific job of selling the heaviness of the encounter as he retreats to the back bug eyed and shaking, making sure everyone watching was fully aware that they’d just seen two titans go to war.


4. The Undertaker vs Triple H (WrestleMania XXVIII)

The Undertaker Triple H Wrestlemania 28
WWE.com

One can argue about the ranking of The Undertaker’s streak matches endlessly, but for sheer drama, this one’s difficult to top. Building on the legacy of the Deadman’s past three wars, Undertaker had been stretchered out of the arena after a successful effort against Triple H the previous year.

Blurring the boundaries of kayfabe, he wasn’t able to live with that image, and so renewed their rivalry again inside the cell. A rare modern HIAC match with the gravitas to merit the stipulation, this is a grandiose, history-drenched encounter with two veterans going all out to assert their continued place at the top of the card.

It’s not gruesome, but it’s heavyweight and gladiatorial, made starrier still by Shawn Michaels in the guest referee position. The finest spot sees ‘Taker eat a superkick then a Pedigree, beating the three count with precision timing to leave the crowd gasping and HBK indulging in head-clutching histrionics.

Undertaker eventually prevails, of course, but the match ends with the three rivals showing mutual respect on the ramp as an era draws to an end. For what amounts to two big blokes walloping each other for 30 minutes in a cage, it’s remarkably poignant.


3. Razor Ramon vs Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania X)

Razor Ramon WrestleMania X
WWE.com

There have been wilder and crazier ladder matches since, but this - a contender for best ‘Mania match to this point - can boast an influence that few matches can top. It certified Shawn as one of the guys to lead WWE into its next generation, gave the youngsters at home something to aspire to, and told an incredible story en route.

The relative newness of the stipulation plays into the action cleverly, with both competitors a little antsy to invoke the steel at first. They feel each other out before bringing the ladder into play, and when they do, things kick up a notch.

The majority of the action is built around Shawn doing crazy things around and off the ladder. He hits elbows and splashes onto Razor, as well as a baseball slide through the rope that would feature in every subsequent ladder match. The reserved nature of the “hardcore” action is paramount to the match’s success - they always give themselves somewhere else to go.

Eventually Ramon knocks Shawn decisively from the ladder and snatches the Intercontinental belt to bring the bout to an end. This one brings the house down with room to maneauver.


2. TLC 2 (WrestleMania X-Seven)

TLC II WrestleMania X-Seven
WWE.com

With the Attitude Era peaking and WCW talent moving in, 2001 saw a crowded field in WWE. To get noticed, you had to go the extra mile. This goes some way to explaining while these six young men would take such insane risks all in the name of entertainment.

WrestleMania 2000’s Triangle ladder match and SummerSlam’s inaugural Tables, Ladders, and Chairs sewed the seeds, but X-Seven’s TLC 2 was the main event. More than a spot-fest, featuring delightful irony - each team suffers the brunt of their own signature weapons - and the extended universe of the tag division, with the third member of the teams getting involved.

That’s not to say there aren’t some crazy spots, though, because there very much are. Matt and Bubba smashing through four stacked tables; Christian taking a ridiculous spill to the outside; and of course, Edge spearing Jeff in midair as he hangs from the belts.

It’s a match that the most cynical non-fan would enjoy, and a measuring stick for extreme crazy bouts ever since. It’s the kind of behaviour that takes years off careers - only, heartwarmingly, four out of the six guys are still in active competition today.


1. Bret Hart vs Stone Cold Steve Austin (WrestleMania XIII)

Austin bret Hart WrestleMania 13
WWE

“Submissions only” doesn’t immediately sound like too exciting a gimmick, limiting the options for finishes and suggesting a technical, methodical match. Well, that’s not the case here.

Austin and Hart are two of the all-time greats, so it’s no surprise their series was quality, but the intensity of this match is off the charts. The two pile out of the ring straight away and throw wild punches as they spill towards the commentary table. Bret proves his wizardry in all things pro-wrestling as he gives Austin a blade job - then forbidden - right under Vince McMahon’s nose.

The encounter doesn’t lose pace for a moment, with a constant rise in intensity up to that pitch perfect finish. A McMahon suggestion, the match ends with Austin in the sharpshooter, his face awash with blood, ultimately giving Hart the win when he passes - but doesn’t tap - out.

He left the arena a hero (and Bret a newly minted villain), in the knowledge that he’d put on arguable the greatest WrestleMania match of all time.


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)