10 Impact Vs. New Japan Matches We Need To See
Wrestle Kingdom in the Impact Zone!
The Forbidden Door has been blown open.
For the first time in years, Impact Wrestling have a working relationship with New Japan Pro Wrestling, as evidenced by the arrival to Impact of FinJuice at the culmination of No Surrender this past February. The former IWGP Tag Team Champions are now set to challenge for The Good Brothers' World Tag Team Championships at Sacrifice on 13 March.
The previous relationship between Impact and New Japan saw matches like Jeff Hardy vs. Tetsuya Naito and Rob Van Dam vs. Toru Yano. Yes, Naito wasn't the star he is today, and yes, Yano was still the drizzling sh*ts, but these matches happened because they could.
Of course, it's not just New Japan working with Impact, as All Elite Wrestling have also secured a relationship with the Anthem-helmed promotion that will see Kenny Omega defend the AEW World Championship on Impact programming at the Rebellion pay-per-view next month. The implications this has for Impact's reputation are huge.
That relationship sparked an article surrounding ten potential matches between Impact and AEW talent. Why wouldn't we do the same thing for Impact and NJPW talent?
Spoiler alert: Toru Yano isn't in here. Sorry, Yano.
10. Ace Austin Vs. Yujiro Takahashi
There's no bigger trope when it comes to fantasy booking than pairing two guys whose gimmicks are at least the tiniest bit similar.
Will it stop us, though? Haha, lol, of course not.
Ace Austin vs. Yujiro Takahashi seems like a match that's too good to pass up when you first think of Impact and New Japan inter-promotional clashes. On one hand, you've got a genuinely outstanding in-ring talent with a cracking character to back it up. Against him, you have Takahashi.
While the primary aspect of Ace's character has forever been that he's one step ahead of the game, having an ace up his sleeve if you'll pardon the pun, his Impact run has seen him stoop to some low levels. From attempting to have an affair with Eddie Edwards' wife Alisha to involving Trey Miguel's mother in their rivalry, there was nothing he wasn't willing to do.
As for Yujiro, he's literally nicknamed 'The Tokyo Pimp'. Often accompanied to ringside by scantily-clad women, Takahashi has taken the ladies' man schtick, and ran with it, making him a perfect fit to face someone like 'The One True Ace'.
Yujiro is nowhere near as good as he once was, but he's still decent. You'd get an alright match so long as Ace does most of the heavy lifting.
9. Chris Bey Vs. El Phantasmo
Sticking with the X Division vs. junior heavyweight division theme; Chris Bey vs. El Phantasmo. Need we say more?
The pair narrowly missed out on colliding recently as part of New Japan's Super J Cup this past December, with Bey ousted in the semifinals by eventual runner-up, ACH. You didn't even need to see the match to know how much of a banger it would be.
Both men have risen to prominence in their respective promotions since being brought in, with 'The Ultimate Finesser' becoming X Division Champion in his first pay-per-view appearance, whereas the Bullet Club man Phantasmo has become one of the backbones of the current crop of junior heavyweight lads.
The comparisons between the two go further, of course; they both have the look, the charisma, and the required agility needed to succeed in these major promotions. We know Bey can hang in a New Japan setting, and we can only assume Phantasmo would be the same in an Impact ring. It's merely a matter of seeing it first-hand.
Of all the matches on this list, this is one that genuinely feels like it could happen. Phantasmo feels on the same level as your David Finlays and Juice Robinsons in a way - bring him to the Impact Zone.
8. The Motor City Machine Guns Vs. Roppongi 3K
We're three for three as it pertains to the X Division vs. the junior heavyweight division, but there's a fine reason for it. Within these divisions are some of the legitimately greatest athletes wrestling has ever seen.
Chris Sabin, Alex Shelley, SHO, and YOH more than fit that billing.
If you recall, Sabin and Shelley had run-ins with No Limit, the pairing of Yujiro Takahashi and Tetsuya Naito, during Impact's initial working agreement with New Japan. To an extent, Roppongi 3K sort of give off No Limit vibes.
They've been through the Young Lions system, and are now one of the company's premier junior heavyweight tandems. As multi-time Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Champions, the former Sho Tanaka and Yohei Komatsu are laying down the gold standard for what it means to be a flashy, high-flying tag team in Japan; the exact same thing the Machine Guns have been doing for years in North America.
Obviously, you'd be receiving a high-quality contest between the two here, but most importantly, it would feel almost like a passing of the torch. Both Sabin and Shelley are nearing their forties and may not have too much left in the tank, whereas SHO and YOH are newly into their thirties.
Sure, it's not a huge age gap, but the point remains the same.
7. Joe Doering Vs. Jeff Cobb
Moving away from the high-flying offence, and into hoss territory here, something Japanese wrestling does best.
On paper, Joe Doering vs. Jeff Cobb sounds appetising. It's pro wrestling down to a tee; two exceptionally gifted performers just knocking sh*t out of each other. As far as the most technical of wrestling matches goes, you likely wouldn't find it here, but you would find something so incredibly tasty that it leaves you salivating for one more release suplex.
Just take into consideration what these two are capable of in the ring. Doering, a former Ace of All Japan Pro Wrestling remember, has wrecked havoc in Impact since uniting with Eric Young and Deaner, proving to have a reasonably varied moveset that allows him to wipe out an opponent with ease.
As for Cobb, he's fast becoming one of Japanese wrestling's greatest gaijins. His performances in both G1 Climaxes and World Tag Leagues is second to none, just like his current crop of work as part of The United Empire. His amateur wrestling background has helped him naturally become the alpha of independent wrestling's big men.
Literally, just through both men in a ring together, and let them lock horns. Hoss fights are one of wrestling's all-time great dessert, so long as that dessert had a nasty headbutt on top instead of a cherry.
6. Josh Alexander Vs. SANADA
Excelling as part of a group in wrestling is one thing, but when you then manage to become a star on your own two feet, you accomplish something completely different. Just ask Josh Alexander and SANADA.
As members of The North and Los Ingobernables de Japon, respectively, both Alexander and SANADA were great. They did everything right, and made both themselves and their respective partners look solid. It was only after they began wrestling in singles action that fans realised their true potential.
'The Walking Weapon' has fast become a bonafide star in the X Division since splitting from the departing Ethan Page in Impact, having solid performances with the likes of TJP and Brian Myers.
As for SANADA, while still a member of the Tetsuya Naito-led faction, his usual tag partner EVIL leaving the group was a blessing in disguise. The former X Division Champion would go on to have a star-making G1 Climax performance last year, and the longest final in history vs. Kota Ibushi. Even in defeat, fans believed in SANADA.
With Josh seemingly on the cusp of becoming X Division Champion himself, why not have the LIJ member make a surprise return for a second run with the belt? Make it a Submissions Match; a battle of the Ankle Lock and the Skull End sounds ever so tantalising.
5. Trey Miguel Vs. Robbie Eagles
Lo and behold, we couldn't stay away from the X Division and junior heavyweight division for too long, particularly when we still need to discuss Trey Miguel and Robbie Eagles.
Again, both men are superb in-ring talents who have done tremendous work in their respective divisions, yet, neither man has actually won the championship they so desire. They're two guys who don't really need a championship, though. Their work speaks for itself.
Trey became such a focal point of Impact Wrestling - to the extent he was main eventing one of the most important nights in company history for the World Championship - that his farewell from Impact alongside Dezmond Xavier and Zachary Wentz was met with such a heartwarming reaction. Fans and wrestlers alike cared deeply.
Eagles, meanwhile, took a bit of a different approach. If you put it bluntly, he used the Bullet Club name and franchise as a way to break into New Japan. When he longer required the association, he simply left and joined CHAOS instead. You've got to love his hustle, really.
Like with the majority of matches we've spoken about, especially Chris Bey vs. El Phantasmo, you'd be settling in for a true cruiserweight classic here. Critics can call it flippy sh*t all they want, and fair enough, that's exactly what it is.
But damn, is it good.
4. Eric Young Vs. Minoru Suzuki
Eric Young. Minoru Suzuki. No rules. It writes itself.
Again, this wouldn't be a savvy technical classic as the duo are a combined 93-years old (!), but it doesn't need to be. You can very easily just have them chop the ever-living sh*t out of each other, have them get all their signature offence in, and call it a day. Simple as that.
The form 'EY' has been on since returning to Impact programming at Slammiversary has seriously been some of the best work of his career. Several years of pent-up frustration from his mistreatment in WWE allowed him to execute what your writer would class as Impact's greatest act in 2020. 'The World Class Maniac', very simply, redefined himself.
By squaring him up against a guy like Minoru Suzuki, you're essentially creating magic. You know that both men are known for their often over-aggressive nature in-ring, and their facial expressions are always more than enough to convey a captivating story for the viewer. They go together like bread and butter.
There probably isn't much time left to tick this one off the list either; the Suzuki-gun man turns 53 on 17 June. Who knows if he'll ever retire, though. He's Minoru f*cking Suzuki.
3. Jake Something vs. Tomohiro Ishii
To go back to Joe Doering vs. Jeff Cobb for just a moment, two big lads having a straight-up fight with one another is something that Japanese wrestling is the best at. The strong-style persona shown in New Japan is why guys like Tomohiro Ishii succeed. He just hits people really, really hard.
Jake Something slots in here beautifully against 'The Stone Pitbull' for this simple reason.
Since his alliance with the former Cody Deaner came to an end, the newly-rechristened Jake Something has slowly become a genuine star in Impact. His challenge of Moose's TNA World Heavyweight Championship a few weeks back was merely the start of his quest.
He's a guy deserving of such an opportunity against the likes of Ishii. While Big Tom has never won the big one in New Japan (damn you, Gedo), he remains one of the promotion's all-time greatest fighters. He doesn't wrestle like he's a big man; he wrestles with spirit.
Jake is the exact same. If he's against a smaller adversary, he'll manhandle them with ease. If they're a bit tougher, he'll make use of his strength. Hell, he's even known to take to the skies on occasion.
He's varied. That's what you need to be in this modern era of wrestling. It's just sadly never enough to combat a stiff Ishii strike.
2. Sami Callihan Vs. Jay White
To put it simply, Sami Callihan vs. Jay White is a match that absolutely needs to happen when you look at the pair's current personas.
Callihan is a cold-blooded sociopath. Nicknamed 'The Death Machine' for a reason, he made a name for himself by competing in these deathmatches for companies like Combat Zone Wrestling. He's no stranger to glass, thumbtacks, and light tubes.
As for White? You could be told he carried out a callous murder, and believe every word. Like Sami, he carries a deadly moniker; 'Switchblade'. It's the gimmick that got him to the top, a character so devious that he even has to wear the Atsushi Onita-inspired leather jacket to get his point across.
Ideally, this would be in a weapons-based scenario. Perhaps even Barbed Wire Massacre V. It's the only match stipulation befitting of two wrestlers of this ilk. Granted, you could put them in a traditional wrestling match, and you'd still receive something exceptionally brilliant, but where's the fun in that?
We, as wrestling fans, want the absolute best situation at all times. Giving these two full access to a range of barbed wire-covered items, from baseball bats to steel chairs, is that precise dream scenario.
1. The Good Brothers Vs. The Guerrillas Of Destiny
It just feels right, doesn't it?
When news first broke of this apparent Impact and New Japan working relationship, one of the top matches at the forefront of fans' minds was The Good Brothers vs. The Guerrillas of Destiny.
The Impact World Tag Team Champions vs. the IWGP Tag Team Champions. The OG Bullet Club tag team vs. the current Bullet Club tag team. Whatever you want to call it, it has to go down sooner rather than later.
Upon leaving WWE, it seemed all but confirmed for Doc Gallows and Karl Anderson to head back to the place that brought them together. Aside from All Elite Wrestling, it just felt right for them to step up as a legitimate threat to Tama Tonga and Tanga Loa's status as the top tandem in New Japan's heavyweight tag division.
G.O.D are primarily where they're currently at because of Gallows and Anderson's 2016 departure from 'The Land of The Rising Sun'. Had they not left for pastures new, there's no telling if Tonga and Loa's success would have been as grand as it has been.
It'll take a while to get there, given 'The Big LG' and 'The Machine Gun's' current involvement with both FinJuice and (sort of) The Young Bucks over in AEW, but rest assured, this one will happen. One day.