10 Impulse Reactions Following WWE Battleground 2017

The Bland Of Opportunity.

Rusev John Cena Battleground
WWE.com

Dumped in the SmackDown Live! supercard schedule in between Money In The Bank and SummerSlam, WWE Battleground was in the unenviable spot of being considered a filler pay-per-view before a the card was even announced.

The company looked to get around the perception with several key payoffs to lengthy programmes as well as a John Cena return that in hindsight should have been forecast by his listless July 4th return.

His Flag Match with Rusev was something of an outlier in the build-up, with matches featuring Jinder Mahal, Randy Orton, AJ Styles, Kevin Owens, Shinsuke Nakamura, Baron Corbin, The Usos and The New Day all, in theory at least, booked as potential conclusions to conflicts that had kicked off long before the June Network special.

Subsequently, Battleground gained a level of importance few would have expected. The stakes were higher than usual, and not just the ones carved into all the bamboo. Jinder and Randy's WWE Title simply had to be their final battle, whilst hope sprung that Nakamura and Styles would win their respective feuds to set up a monster secondary title clash at the summer's biggest show.

Featuring prisons, patriots and perplexing puzzlers, Battleground offered little to suggest that the upcoming days of summer won't be as lazy and hazy as they're starting to look.

10. Fresh Start

The Usos Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

The match of the night was executed with such staggering simplicity that it beggars belief WWE are incapable of producing a similar level of quality elsewhere on the card.

Unabashed babyfaces that they now are, The New Day were electric in victory over former champions The Usos, the former champions themselves experiencing something of a career renaissance since turning heel shortly after arriving on SmackDown Live!

With Big E patrolling the arena floor and Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods taking care of the heavy lifting, the challengers were able to be high-flying babyfaces cast against the similarly dynamic but altogether more conniving champions.

In the modern era, the 'formula' tag team match is as a rarity and delight. So purely structured and loyally followed because of how sensational it is at working a crowd into a frenzy, the face-in-peril > recovery > chase for the win pathway was expertly followed after Jimmy and Jey flattened Kingston with a powerbomb on the floor.

Woods showed incredible resilience as the bedraggled lone wolf, battling out of a host of seemingly fatal predicaments, including an outstanding false finish in which he ate a brutal superkick off a springboard elbow.

Always better with the belts, The New Day are now at last where they belong again, thus possibly commencing a brand new quest to break their own remarkable longevity record.


9. Low Blow

Baron Corbin Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Discerning fans were right to be optimistic about Shinsuke Nakamura's chances on the main roster after his rampant success on NXT (as well as the fact the company even signed him the first place), but it now simply has to be concluded that the organisation can just not figure out his most efficient utilisation.

The story's becoming worryingly familiar. Fans go ape for his entrance, but are then given no reason to evoke when the bell rings, to the point where his WWE homogenisation looks complete in record time.

Many will lay blame with Baron Corbin as his limited and inexperienced opponent with a worrying habit of giving several top stars their worst matches since he began his own tear through the developmental brand. However, Corbin's elevated his storytelling game exponentially since really tapping into his contemporary d*ckhead persona in recent months. His moves don't wow but his actions generate emotion, and 'The King Of Strong Style' looks to have the exact opposite dilemma.

The company deserves credit for keeping the entrance fairly special (often by just not featuring it on television at all), but Shinsuke desperately requires an opponent that can make his offence look like it matters far more than his marketable histrionics. Especially when he's left for dead by a low blow in the cheapest of get-outs. That key opponent looked to be coming at SummerSlam, but it appears perhaps that things may have changed...


8. New Face Of Disappointment

Kevin Owens AJ Styles
WWE.com

...because the match that looked destined for Nakamura now looks completely off the table.

AJ Styles and Kevin Owens battled yet again in another disappointing clash with another disappointing finish. When WWE put the United States Title on 'The Phenomenal One' at a Madison Square Garden house show, much of the thinking seemed to be that it was a necessary evil interjecting into the television feud in order to flog tickets for flagging live events. It now seems like that New York audience got the only decent effort these two were capable of.

A whole falling way short of the sum of its parts, Styles and Owens (literally) leaned on an unnervingly large number of chinlocks and restholds to fill out a desperately dull 18 minute clash. Foreshadowing the lousy finish, it became apparent extremely early on that the feud was set to dawdle on despite the game of hot potato with the title again making 'KO' look ultra-weak in his refined anti-patriot persona.

The finish was equally turgid, with WWE incapable of following their own rules from one week to the next. Owens launched Styles at the referee, but rather than waving for an automatic disqualification (as has been done for much less in the last few years), his bewilderedness led to a screwy finish that is likely to be debated to set up a SummerSlam finale next week.


7. The Contenders

Tamina Charlotte Lana
WWE.com

Truthfully, it wasn't all that exciting to watch play out, but at least the loose thread of intrigue running through the blue brand's Women's Division remains in tact after Natalya picked up a surprising victory to leave Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair free to tackle the uniquely tight bond between Tamina and Lana.

It was the new pairing that robustly stuck together for the bulk of the contest with Tamina repeatedly bailing the 'Ravishing Russian' out as well as enhancing Lana's extremely limited strikes and attacks. WWE should be credited with attempting to shield the former valet's weaknesses as they so often fail to do in the nihilistic modern era, but even bigger blockades may be needed after viewing her brief flirtations with 'offence' in this encounter.

A Natalya/Naomi pairing on paper looks a little pedestrian for a sure-to-be blockbuster card, but working on the assumption that the champion will retain her title, could afford the young titleholder a chance at a match that will give her reign a memorable talking point.

Natalya's form fluctuates, but matches and feuds with Charlotte, Becky Lynch and Nikki Bella did wonders for the younger foes, and the former 'Funkadactyl' may be next to add some shine to her 'Glow'.


6. All Filler, No Killer

Maria Kanellis
WWE.com

Mike Kanellis burst unannounced onto the main roster alongside wife Maria at SmackDown Live!'s last pay-per-view back in June, but his WWE run already has the worrying stink of a tenure doomed to failure.

With Maria as his dynamic mouth piece and a bombastic entrance theme that stood a chance of achieving 'Glorious'-like cult status amongst fans, Kanellis appeared to have the best possible chance of succeeded, but the sickly sweet introduction has so far only left in a vanilla aftertaste.

Complaining about the organisation's mandated 50/50 booking philosophy is becoming futile (more on that later), but the entire roadmap of Kanellis' first programme seems careless even by WWE's disorganised standards.

After missing the first edition of the show after their grand debut, interruptions from Sami Zayn (himself hardly a big money player on the blue brand) couldn't have made the loved up performer look any less important. Maria is sensational as an indignant heel, but she was given little to work with between the vignettes and her husband's (again, unannounced) debut victory over Zayn on the go-home show.

The mantra of the company remains established - nobody wins, nobody loses, stuff just happens. Mike and Maria tried the same plan as the first match but Sami was wise to it and picked up a victory. The pair both have wins, but far more importantly, both have defeats. Fans don't back losers and they won't back these.


5. Flagging

John Cena Rusev
WWE.com

WWE had been intentionally vague on what variation of the stipulation would be rolled out for yet another jingoistic Rusev/John Cena clash at Sunday's show, but the revelation on the go-home edition of SmackDown Live! promised yet another punch/kick footrace the two combatants were only too happy to supply.

The dual podium setup offered at least a different visual, but little creative thought went into crafting a match around the somewhat unique scenario outside of Rusev actually using Cena's own flag holder as a weapon.

Instead, the pair resulted to pathetically transparent slow-climbing, and inconsequential submissions that did little to actually subdue their opponent long enough to trot up an unconvincingly tiny staircase.

In fact, these exchanges infected the saddest sections of an already-dreary encounter. Whilst Cena powered out of repeated Accolade attempts, Rusev was made to tap to an STF in a match where his submission wasn't even required. His defeat was a crushing inevitability after that.

It was a victory for Cena, but more, audiences were told, a crucial strike for America as a nation against the rest of the world. Devoid entirely of irony as they always are, WWE chose the start of this match to show just how bloody multicultural they are by giving all the announce teams their usual pieces to camera.


4. The Power Of 10

Aiden English Tye Dillinger
WWE.com

The latest strike from WWE against their own fanbase, Tye Dillinger's main roster career took another darkly amusing strike as he somehow managed to eat defeat on the pre-show to WWE's worst supercard of 2017.

The Dillinger/Aiden English pairing serves to represent WWE's most glaring inability in a microcosm. When talent are frozen out of meaningful conflicts (as 'The Perfect 10' has been since his debut) they are hung out to dry by creative disinterest in their characters, and gradually become almost entirely unsalvageable.

'Almost' being the operative word of course, in a year where perennial jobber Jinder Mahal carries the WWE Title and Paige remains on the company's books despite a litany of transgressions in her personal life.

However, neither Tye nor English look set to earn a surprise elevation any time soon, not least until there's finally a payoff to their absorbing war over who can pin each other the most times in matches nobody remembers or cares about (!).

The crowd's enthusiasm will be discussed elsewhere in this piece, but perhaps WWE's worst crime here was including the match altogether.

The company may face fresh new bouts of alienation with their audiences if Tye's shoddy treatment continued. Dillinger earned a solid foothold with the crowd following last November's Toronto scorcher with Bobby Roode, but the platform continues to erode under the company's brightest lights.


3. The Plot Thickens

Tyler Breeze Fandango
WWE.com

Or thins, as this case may be.

A bait and switch of the carniest variety from WWE then, as Breezango's assailants failed to materialise outside of paying off a decent gag about The Ascension actually taking the Eddie Money tickets weeks ago. It topped Shane McMahon blaming Steve Blackman for running over Stone Cold Steve Austin, anyway.

There exists a curious middle ground between comedy and credibility that Tyler Breeze and Fandango gracefully strut across most weeks, but the company's failure to make good on a revelation left a sour taste on what otherwise could have been the highlight of the show.

Their mystery remains unsolved, but Breeze was again decked before Fandango was dragged out of the duo's office by the unknown attackers.

It's tricky to determine if the rivalry will have the legs to make it all the way to SummerSlam, but the continued narrowing down of suspects has led to most to speculate that Luke Harper and Erick Rowan will be unified after their singles feud failed in just about every fashion to reestablish them away from the tortuous Bray Wyatt.

A match between the pairs doesn't exactly electrify, but the fashionistas have at least forged a formidable bond with the fanbase, and could be used to reintegrate the former Wyatt followers.


2. Imprisoned

Randy Orton Singh Brother fall
WWE.com

It seems spurious and a little cruel to list out the countless potential problems with a Jinder Mahal/Randy Orton match, but when the company served to justify virtually every concern, it made it incredibly difficult not to be critical of what an absolute shambles it became.

'The Apex Predator' noted specifically on the go-home SmackDown Live! how the structure left the Singh Brothers finally out of his way, but the featured in unconvincing fashion yet again, and were required to take countless painful-looking bumps to mask both champion and challenger's woeful inability to provide something entertaining themselves.

The inherently silly structure was savaged online in the weeks leading up to the battle, but it's worth noting that Dave Batista and The Great Khali had a very acceptable big man war in it over a decade ago.

Ah yes, The Great Khali. The former World Heavyweight Champion thankfully has more bizarre charisma bottled up in his (massive) little finger than either performer does in their chiselled frame. Trotting out to grasp Randy by the throat in order to allow his brother-in-law to escape, he almost saved the show, and did do if you happened to watch the show with the excellent Hindi commentary instead of the usual gang of idiots on the English-speaking.

A saviour to all fans, Khali ensured at long last an ending to an interminable rivalry, and proffered something brand spanking new for the struggling WWE Champion heading into one of the biggest shows of the year.


1. Killing The Town

Randy Orton Singh Brothers
WWE.com

Extreme Championship Wrestling was the revolutionary force in professional wrestling WWE claimed to be in the 1990s, delivering an overall product that was (for the time at least), something completely brand new for a medium that suffered brutal stagnation.

Its home base in Philadelphia was key to the presentation, with the rabid fanbase creating an entirely new atmosphere for pro wrestling shows that eventually bled into other products whenever they visited 'The City of Brotherly Love'.

Philadelphia earned a reputation as one of the country's wrestling hotbeds, but WWE look determined to neutralise sentiment nearly two decades later with some offensively bad shows that will live long beyond their original airdate for all the wrong reasons.

Amongst other transgressions, WWE delivered the unforgettably bad 2015 Royal Rumble, in which The Big Show and Kane threw out every favourite one by one in a flawed attempt to galvanise support behind Roman Reigns. Added to the list will now be Battleground 2017, which saw fan favourites Tye Dillinger, AJ Styles and Rusev all lose, whilst fellow local heroes Kevin Owens and Shinsuke Nakamura got to look like complete nonentities in victory.

It's an aggressive retraining programme by WWE to rebrand the once-hardcore section of their 'Universe', but with next year's Royal Rumble returning, expect regular favourites to yet again get the short end of the deal.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.