10 Incredible Wrestling Storylines That Will NEVER Happen
If you want Omega vs Punk, you're bang out of luck!
If you're a wrestling fan, then the phrase missed opportunity is burned into your head.
The wrestling industry is littered with things that should have been big but fell flat - if they even happened at all. A painful example is when a wrestler shows incredible promise only to be squandered by a promotion. Another is when a highly anticipated match fails to deliver. But things can always get worse, especially when you see something you want and know you'll never get it.
This has happened time and time again, as wrestling fans make perfect dream matches and storylines in their heads, only for circumstances to keep them from happening.
Did you want to see Sting vs. The Undertaker? Well, tough luck! How about Hulk Hogan vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin? Yeah, better luck next time! History is full of once-in-a-lifetime stories that were never told, and sadly, there are plenty in the modern world that will also never happen.
The following ten examples are mouth-watering storylines featuring dream match showdowns and great potential stories. But don't bet on them coming to life unless you want an empty wallet.
10. AJ Lee Vs. Mercedes Moné
Seeing wrestlers retire before their time is a pain fans are all too familiar with. The beloved AJ Lee was one such name who had to step away from in-ring competition due to neck injuries, and some speculated tensions between her and WWE.
Since leaving the company, she has remained a stranger to the industry, barring her involvement as a producer and commentator for Women of Wrestling.
Her retirement was tragically early not just in how young she was, but also in the fact that women's wrestling soon changed completely, with new stars and better matches than ever. As such, a strongly desired wrestling story is the triumphant return of AJ Lee, and if you want a good opponent for it, then you'd be daft not to think of Mercedes Moné.
Some call Moné the hottest free agent on the market, and she certainly fits the bill. Hell, you heard the reaction when the camera picked her up at All In; it was booming! She would undoubtedly mesh well with Lee in her prime, and this would no doubt be a great rivalry.
Unfortunately, Lee has shown no likelihood of pulling an Edge/Saraya/Bryan Danielson and coming out of retirement. Plus, AJ will likely want to steer clear of AEW for the time being, which is where Moné seems to be headed.
9. Gunther And Tomohiro Ishii On A Grand Stage
Gunther and Tomohiro Ishii are two of the toughest and hardest-hitting fellas, not just in wrestling but all of sport. The slaps, the punches, the headbutts, they've got enough to bring down buildings. But you'll be let down if you want to see them go at it on a grand stage.
Now, this is a fine example of a dream match you probably didn't know has already happened. Gunther (then known as Walter) and Ishii put on an epic display for Revolution Pro Wrestling in 2018, and it was just as brutal as you would expect.
While a great match in an indie promotion is lovely, there's no doubt that the two could work up something very special if given a grander stage. With the right build, arena, and crowd, this could be utter magic. That is if your idea of magic is two grown men smacking the life out of each other.
Unfortunately, once again, that forbidden door is likely never going to open.
Gunther is thriving in WWE, having recently broken the record as the longest-reigning Intercontinental Champion of all time, and the company will not want to share him. Additionally, Ishii's grounded style wouldn't appeal to WWE execs, so it's unlikely they'd pick him even if they were willing to bring an NJPW talent over.
8. Andrade Dominates Lucha Underground
Andrade El Idolo, formerly known as Andrade Cien Almas and La Sombra before that, is a phenomenal professional wrestler. That said, things just don't seem to click for him in American wrestling, as he has now suffered from lukewarm runs in both WWE and AEW.
What makes this all the more tragic is that there was a promotion, a brilliant promotion, that he undoubtedly would have thrived in. Unfortunately, Lucha Underground closed its doors in 2018 while Andrade was still contracted to WWE.
This unique company was full of great talent and wowed audiences with its cinematic presentation, which said goodbye to kayfabe and played into pure film-based storytelling. Hell, Andrade already looks like a movie star, so he would have fit like a glove.
Even names like Ezekiel Jackson and Jake Hager managed to find success there, so imagine what El Idolo could have done! The company could have built itself around his in-ring skills, star power, and charisma.
This would have been a chance for Andrade to see himself as a promotion's top player.
7. Charlotte Flair Vs. Tessa Blanchard
Charlotte Flair and Tessa Blanchard are two wrestlers who seemed destined to cross paths. The daughter of Ric Flair versus the daughter of Tully Blanchard; it would be a Four Horsemen legacy match that would tear the house down.
Besides their family legacies, the pair are also exceptional performers, with star power, stellar in-ring work, and similar athletic styles.
Now, it's usually not best to point fingers when it comes to missed opportunities in wrestling, but honestly, you'd be right to place the blame for never getting to see this match entirely on Tessa Blanchard's shoulders.
A bad attitude, racist remarks, and being tough to work with were all the hallmarks of Tessa's backstage behaviour, and it cost her everything, including a potential run with WWE. Blanchard's had trouble wherever she's been, with even Impact having to let her go eventually despite the success she found there.
Tessa could have delivered major dream matches in WWE, especially with names like Rhea Ripley, Asuka, Bianca Belair, and more. Still, a program with Flair would have been a WrestleMania-worthy match-up with the potential to be the feud of the year. Too bad it will never happen.
6. The New Day Vs. The Elite
Everyone knows The New Day and The Elite would put on a great program together. Both groups are masters at tag team wrestling, and the built-in excitement of seeing the legendary teams battle would sell out arenas. It's a match-up that would make history.
Unfortunately for us, but probably great for them, both teams are fiercely loyal to their employers. The New Day are unlikely to ever stray away from their place in WWE, not after all the success they've had and the clout they possess.
The Young Bucks and Kenny Omega are similarly poised, as their freedom in All Elite Wrestling is a gift for them, and they are executives. Sure, Cody unexpectedly jumped ship, but this trio is far more connected to the Elite part of AEW's name than The American Nightmare ever was.
Of course, even if this forbidden door were to, by some miracle, open itself, there's a good chance it wouldn't happen the way fans would want. With Big E's in-ring future in question, he'd be unlikely to take part in any physical action, which would cause something to feel like it was missing no matter what.
5. Bryan Danielson Enters The G1 Climax
Bryan Danielson's career has been a never-ending barrage of unexpected accomplishments.
No one expected him to dominate the indies, rise to the top of WWE, return to the ring after his retirement, or leave WWE for AEW, but boy, howdy, he did it all, and fans loved every minute of it. However, as it stands now, his much desired participation in the G1 Climax is an unexpected accomplishment he won't tick off the list.
Danielson's hard-hitting style and the amount of dream matches he could produce would make for an iconic G1 appearance. But all the signs point to this one being impossible.
Bryan recently made it clear that he is winding down his career and switching to a non-full-time schedule. So, the G1 is hardly a place to do that, as it is tough and incredibly hectic.
Let's also remember that Tony Khan isn't going to want to lose one of his top guys for a whole month while they venture off to Japan, especially when Khan can only use him sporadically as is. So, Danielson wouldn't get the boss' approval even if he wanted to.
Seeing The American Dragon conquer G1 is a dream, but perhaps too much of one.
4. Mick Foley Mentors An AEW Talent
Using a legend of the business to mentor a young talent is a bonafide way to increase the younger's stock, keep the veteran relevant, and have some fun. Mick Foley has been used to such an extent a few times in WWE, but really, his expertise as a hardcore wrestler could be way better suited to a company that, you know, has some hardcore wrestling.
AEW is easily a place that Mrs Foley's Baby Boy could bring that side of himself to, as the promotion features many bloody battles, and Foley could play a great role in the build-up to one.
Just imagine him mentoring a young, hardcore talent before they participate in a gruesome match. He could even act as a special guest referee for Blood & Guts. The thought is mouth-watering.
Of course, anyone who holds their breath waiting for this to happen will end up bluer than the Blue Meanie, as Foley isn't going to jump ship from his Legends contract in WWE.
The company has done well by him, and at this point, he seems perfectly content to live on remembering his legacy and enjoying the benefits McMahon's company allows him in his later life.
3. CM Punk Vs. Kenny Omega
If you've heard nothing about the CM Punk AEW controversy in the last few weeks, then you've probably been living under a Dwayne Johnson - sorry, rock. The much beloved and maligned Phil Brooks has officially departed from the wrestling company that brought him back to the industry, and he has taken this dream match with him.
Whatever your thoughts are on Punk (and at this point, any opinion is valid), there's no denying that seeing him debut for AEW was monumental. It wasn't just great to see him back but inspiring to think of all the unique matches that fans would get to enjoy.
At the tip-top of most people's lists was a tantalising showdown with the Best Bout Machine, Kenny Omega. The already promising match was tempered ever further after the infamous backstage altercation at All Out 2022, which caused the pair (and The Young Bucks) to suffer suspensions.
So, that's a great match, a built-in narrative, tension, and a pure sense of grudge. Sign us up! Well, Punk's tepid relationship with his co-workers has officially rained on that parade.
With the Best in the World now gone from AEW, there's no hope you will ever see these two square off. What, are they going to both go to WWE or NJPW to work with someone they hate? Of course not! This one is dead in the water.
2. A Bullet Club Leaders Battle
Bullet Club for life!
That is the creed of this infamous NJPW stable, so by that logic, every wrestler who has ever brushed paths with the group still has ties to it. As such, would it not be spectacular, awe-inspiring even, to witness an epic clash between every single Bullet Club leader? Well, too bad because it will never happen.
Each official Bullet Club figurehead (including Finn Balor, Karl Anderson, AJ Styles, Kenny Omega, Jay White, EVIL, and David Finlay) is still active in the industry at the time of writing.
That's one hell of a line-up, and so it's not hard to imagine that a big blow-off match between them all - besides being a little crowded - would be one of the most spectacular showdowns ever seen in wrestling.
The scale of such a storyline would set the wrestling world on fire, but that is also this concept's downfall, as dear god, it would be a logistical nightmare.
Bullet Club's most prominent leaders are scattered all about the place now. Even if AEW and NJPW's working relationship managed to gather a few together, Balor, Anderson, and Styles would never be able to come, as WWE would not allow it.
It would be awesome to see but impossible to produce.
1. The Face Of WWE Versus The Ace Of New Japan
There was a time when the undisputed figureheads of the world's biggest wrestling promotions were John Cena (WWE) and Hiroshi Tanahashi (NJPW). Nowadays, that prestige is still present in both wrestlers.
Cena is semi-retired, but his appearances always spark excitement. In contrast, Tanahashi is, while no longer at the top of the card, still an active part of New Japan and one-third of the Never Openweight Six-Man Tag Team Champions.
Both stars have had a litany of dream matches, with Cena battling against the likes of The Rock, Triple H, and Randy Orton, while Tanahashi has battled with folk like Kazuchika Okada, Shinsuke Nakamura, and Kenny Omega.
With them being such big names and the former faces of their respective companies, you know a story between them would be massive. Still, while the idea of these icons clashing is awesome, there's close to no chance that it will ever happen.
Cena only wrestles on rare occasions and always with WWE (naturally). While Tanahashi is still very active, he's never had any attention from the US-based company, and it's unlikely that he will get it anytime soon.