10 Kayfabe Wrestling Moments That Became Real

When WWE or WCW moments involving Bret Hart, Batista, Triple H and more turned real.

Bret Hart Vince McMahon Cage
WWE.com

Wrestling fans are sick of mainstream media's oh-so-"shocking" revelation that the product they watch isn't 100% real. Outlets have battered people over the head with this for generations, and it's tiresome in 2021. Maybe someone needs to sit these stuffy suits down and enlighten them about all the times this industry they seemingly despise so much predicted real life.

It's happened more than you might think.

Every example featured here began as a fictional story or moment, and a few were forgotten about as soon as they passed. Then, at some point in the future, they actually came true. Yes, pro wrestling fantasy became reality, and few saw it coming.

There's a nice mix of injury claims, feuds, seductions, public disagreements and firings here. Each one began as a simple (or, not so simple - WCW is here, after all) plot device designed to entertain. Days, weeks, months and sometimes years later though, these moments rang true outside the ring.

Some are more light-hearted than others, but all of them are pressing reminders that even wrestling's wildest angles have nothing on the silliness of real life...

10. Shawn Michaels "Loses His Smile"... Before Really Getting A Back Injury

Shawn Michaels
WWE.com/WWE.com

Bret Hart thought Shawn Michaels was a lying git when he strolled onto TV in February 1997 and told the world that he'd "lost his smile". A suspect knee injury would keep HBK from returning the favour to Bret and jobbing for him at WrestleMania 13, and the Hitman wasn't happy about it.

Less than one year later, Shawn lost his grin for real.

A nasty casket bump at Royal Rumble '98 tore up his back, and it forced Michaels to grimace through the agony until he could put Steve Austin over at 'Mania XIV. Between January-March, Shawn's performances had an uncharacteristic dullness to them. It was obvious that he was in a lot of pain.

If he was fibbing the previous Feb, then karma bit Michaels hard. Still, nobody wanted him to go through that torture, or for one of the best workers on the planet to face possible retirement. There's something twisted about the way fate played with Shawn's career here.


9. Booker T And Batista Feud On TV... Then Brawl At Promotional Shoot

Batista Booker T
WWE.com

Put your money on Booker.

One of WWE's money feuds for SummerSlam 2006 was a World Title showdown between Batista and 'King' Booker. On TV, the pair were booked to detest one another, but T was reportedly getting rather sick and tired of big Dave's inflated ego behind the scenes too.

Things came to a head when both men convened to shoot a SummerSlam commercial before the big pay-per-view. There, tensions boiled over and staff were forced to try and separate Batista and Booker to stop them from tearing lumps out of each other for real; that cannot have been fun.

Most eye witnesses later confirmed that Booker got the upper hand, and could easily have battered his soon-to-be challenger. Thankfully, this fiction-turned-fraught situation calmed down enough that Booker put Batista over come SummerSlam and everyone moved on.


8. Triple H Mocks Goldberg... Then Beats Him Years Later

If you're ever stuck when trying to describe to a mate how weird the 'Monday Night War' was, then illustrate your point by mentioning Triple H's win over Gillberg on the 2 September 1999 SmackDown. For reference, that was the new show's third episode, and the WWF chose a Goldberg knock-off as Hunter's World Title foe.

The real deal must've been seething that this send up was getting so much screen time, but Bill didn't need to wait too long until he was doing the honours for Triple H too. Fast forward to SummerSlam 2003 and Goldberg was laying down for Trips inside the Elimination Chamber himself.

WWF parody had become real.

Of course, Goldberg was in WCW when the Gillberg squash was booked. If the WWF couldn't ridicule the genuine article, then they were damn sure going to do it to his comedic caricature as soon as humanly possible. Then, four years later, they finally got their moment.


7. Melina And Batista Flirt On TV... Then Have A Fling In Real Life

Dave Batista Melina Perez
WWE.com/WWE.com

It wasn't uncommon for WWE "Divas" to seduce their male counterparts back in 2005. So, MNM manager Melina waltzed into Batista's locker room, put her hands on 'The Animal' (careful) and basically promised him sex. In storyline, she was trying to take big Dave's eye off the ball (CAREFUL!) before an upcoming Tag Title bout.

When it didn't work, Melina began alleging that Batista had sexually harassed her. That's not the bit that transferred into real life though; Batista later admitted in his book that he and Melina had a very-real intimate relationship that he kept secret from his then-wife and her lover John Morrison.

Their kayfabe fling had happened away from the cameras too.

It's unclear how long their hidden romance went on. Later, Melina and JoMo were definitely an item again, and ladies man Batista moved on to other things. Presumably, their affair was as short-lived as WWE's storyline feud between MNM, Dave and Rey Mysterio.


6. WCW Fans “Will Never See" Hulk Hogan Again... And They Didn't

Vince Russo Hulk Hogan
WWE.com/WWE.com

"You will never see that piece of sh*t again".

Those were the words of one Vince Russo during WCW's Bash At The Beach 2000 pay-per-view. As the brash New Yorker ranted and raved, Hulk Hogan (the man that line was about) and Eric Bischoff were already in a limo and toasting the start of their new 'worked shoot' angle that everyone agreed would help the company.

Hogan was later horrified when he heard the Russo had roasted him with insults like, "big bald son of a bitch". He pursued legal action, and it became clear that Vince's cutting comments were more real than even he knew. Bash At The Beach would end up being Hulk's final appearance for WCW before the group was sold in March 2001.

Russo had been right during his shoot-ish promo. He maybe hadn't intended to legit p*ss Hogan off the way he did, but the outspoken authority figure and future WCW World Champ was bang on the money when he was fans would never enjoy Hulk's presence again.


5. Vince McMahon Fires Hulk Hogan On TV... Before Firing Him For Real

Mr America Hulk Hogan
WWE.com/WWE.com

Take two. Sort of.

In 2003, Hulk Hogan worked a huge feud with Vince McMahon that included an underrated 'Street Fight' at WrestleMania XIX. Afterwards, WWE blatantly started to run out of ideas. That's why someone suggested putting Hulk under a hood as "Mr. America" and peddling the preposterous notion that nobody could prove his identity.

The storyline was still in full swing when Hogan's friendship with McMahon started breaking down behind the curtain. Reportedly, Hulk was unhappy with recent WWE payoffs, and that raised the ire of his boss. Never one to hesitate, McMahon decreed that Hogan's contract with the company be terminated.

Strangely, he had already started to put a line through the masked man angle right before dismissing his old pal. Hogan being outed on TV as America would've led to a kayfabe firing anyway, meaning that (despite a break already being discussed in creative meetings) real life actually jumped the gun on fiction here.


4. The Mega-Powers Explode... Before Then REALLY Exploding

Randy Savage Be A Man Hulk Hogan
WWE.com/Big3 Records

OK, last one on Hulk.

This is more about Randy Savage anyway. His well-known paranoia severed any chance of a full-time friendship with Hogan in the 90s. Randy, who kept a close eye on Miss. Elizabeth backstage and didn't like anyone talking to her when he wasn't there, was incensed when Liz split from him and started spending time at Hulk's house.

Macho Man's brother Lanny Poffo has said in several shoot interviews before that Elizabeth sought sanctuary at Hogan's mansion, and had become good mates with Hulk and his then-wife Linda. That, to Randy, was a knife in the back, and it oddly echoed sentiments he'd shared in WWF promos years before.

Back then, Savage had claimed that Hulk's intentions towards Liz were less-than-pure, and said he had "lust" in his eyes towards her when they teamed together as The Mega-Powers. It seems Randy traded pretend jealously for real resentment within the span of a few years.

His relationship with Hogan would be on/off from that point on - and Savage would even later release a rap song calling out his friend-turned-foe.


3. Chris Benoit Steals Woman... Then Steals Nancy From Kevin Sullivan

Chris Benoit Nancy Benoit
VICE

Ask most wrestling old-timers and they'll advise that workers never get their lovers involved 'in the business'. Kevin Sullivan found this out the hard way when on screen rival Chris Benoit and his real-life wife Woman (Nancy Sullivan) started falling in love back in the mid-90s.

Incredibly, Kevin was the one who booked their union.

Obviously, he did so to inject some drama into his feud with Benoit. The more and more time Nancy and Chris spent together though (they held hand in public, travelled as a pair etc), the deeper and deeper their fondness for one another grew. Eventually, this Woman was Benoit's, not Sullivan's.

It'd be remiss to speak about all this without mentioning the grim end to both their lives. Everyone knows what happened years later with the Benoit double murder and suicide, for example. For more on this story, check out VICE's 'Dark Side Of The Ring' episode that explores each relationship.


2. Triple H & Stephanie McMahon Get Together... Then Really Marry

Triple H Stephanie McMahon
WWE.com/WWE.com

The relationship between Triple H and Stephanie McMahon has been much happier, but it did start out with some heartache for a third party. Chyna and Trips had been an item for years before he started an angle on WWF TV with Steph. That, over time, would become a shoot.

Bruce Prichard has claimed on his podcast that Stephanie still had a boyfriend outside the company until sometime in 2001. After that, it started becoming rather clear to everyone behind the scenes that she and Hunter were romantically involved. That left Chyna to pick up the pieces of her own shattered romance.

She must've been heartbroken.

A fake courtship between Triple H and the boss's daughter turned into something special for both of them. Now, they're married, have children and are the most high profile power couple in pro wrestling today. Prichard says that few could've predicted how things would turn out back in 1999.


1. Bret Hart Says Vince McMahon Is "Screwing" Him... Before Getting Screwed

Bret Hart Vince McMahon
WWE.com/WWE.com

Bret Hart was never known as much of a promo man, but his scathing tirade on the 17 March 1997 Raw was world class. After working a short Steel Cage bout with Sycho Sid (that included interference from The Undertaker and Steve Austin), Bret called Vince McMahon into the ring for a roasting.

A fired up 'Hitman' said that Vince and the WWF were trying to screw him, and he was sick and tired of dealing with it. Approx eight months later, McMahon's outfit would conspire to screw Bret for real by fixing his match with Shawn Michaels at Survivor Series 1997.

They called that the 'Montreal Screwjob' - not sure if you've heard of it.

Seriously though, it's fascinating to look back on Hart's rant knowing what would happen next. Any post-Montreal promo likely would've mentioned the same sort of scheming from Vince and cohorts. Who could've known that this fictional moment would become so real?

What other kayfabe wrestling moments became real life? For more, check out 10 WCW Tag Teams You Definitely Won’t Remember and 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE SmackDown From 1999!


Watch Next


Bret Hart Quiz: How Well Do You Know 'The Hitman'?

Owen Hart Bret Hart Royal Rumble 1994
WWE.com

1. Who Did Bret Hart Co-Win The 1994 Royal Rumble With?

Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.