10 Masked Wrestling Gimmicks That Changed Ownership

Tigers, Scorpions and Tom Brandi.

Sin Cara mask
WWE.com

The legacy of the mask in professional wrestling dates back to France and the World Fair in 1865.

Implanted in the United States following the sport's permanent shift from legitimate competition, it was the mask's introduction to Mexico during the early establishment of lucha libre, that entrenched it firmly in wrestling folklore.

Used primarily in Mexico to conceal a wrestler's real identity for the duration of their career, the mask can serve a number of purposes and is a more lucrative contrivance than a championship belt.

Outside of Mexico, masks have, over the course of history, proved to be a fruitful artifice in facilitating an instant character and aura around a previously unknown wrestler.

Whether allowing workers in the territories to compete under more than one persona in different locations or adding new life to a tired or tepid performer, wrestling masks have historically helped enkindle many a legendary gimmick.

However, the carny nature of pro wresting requires a certain amount of duplicity, and masked gimmicks are no exception to the rule.

Over the years many masked gimmicks have traded ownership, some under the full understanding of the audience, while others have been more contentious, emerging from copyright claims and contract disputes.

Here are ten such instances of masked personas exchanging owners.

10. Doink

doink wrestlemania 9
WWE.com

More a wig and face paint than a mask, granted, Doink the Clown was an original WWE shapeshifter back in 1993.

Originally portrayed by territory stalwart Matt Borne, Borne's portrayal of a technically sound, evil wrestling clown would last less than a year before he was fired for repeated drug offenses.

Borne, who wrestled under his own name at the first WrestleMania, was replaced by the unknown Ray Apollo as Doink turned babyface for the first time against Jerry Lawler.

This wasn't the first time Doink had been played by someone other than Borne, however. During his WrestleMania IX match with Crush, Steve Kiern played an impostor Doink, and would often go on to portray the character at house shows during the period, as would Steve Lombardi.

Ultimately deemed a failure, Doink was fazed out throughout 1995. Borne himself, would go on to make appearances in ECW as both Doink and a bi-polar version of Doink, Borne Again, returning to WWE for a final shot as Doink for RAW 15 in 2007.

Appearing sporadically on WWE TV over the years, having been portrayed by Lombardi, Nick Dinsmore and even Chris Jericho, Doink is currently performed by fat Tony at your local bingo hall.


9. Tiger Mask

Tiger Mask
Pro Wrestling Illustrated

Inspired by the anime character of the same name, New Japan licensed the rights to the Tiger Mask likeness in 1981 as a way to attract a younger audience.

Initially considered a mockery of NJPW's serious spectacle, Satoru Sayama's pioneering performances under the mask revolutionised not only NJPW's product but would prove to be groundbreaking in professional wrestling going forward.

Stealing a march on their competition, All Japan purchased the rights to the character in 1984, enlisting Mitsuhara Misawa with the responsibility of following Sayama.

Graduating from a junior, Tiger Mask II became the first heavyweight portrayal of the character, as Misawa battled for AWA and NWA championships in a 6 year showing that would end spectacularly, when he demanded his partner Toshiaki Kawada to unmask him during a match in 1990.

NJPW re-licensed the rights to the character, as Koji Kanemoto became Tiger Mask III in 1992. Returning Tiger Mask to its junior-heavyweight roots, Kanemoto would fail to replicate the popularity of his predecessors.

Losing his mask to Jushin Liger in 1994, his successor Tiger Mask IV has been unremarkably under the charge of Yoshihiro Yamazaki since 1995.

Most recently, in conjunction with the launch of the new Tiger Mask W anime series, Kota Ibushi brought the new character to life in 2016.


8. Black Tiger

Eddie Guerrero Black Tiger
NJPW World

Tiger Mask's anime arch enemy, Black Tiger was brought to life by Marc Rocco in 1982 to oppose his fictional foe.

Becoming the first WWF Junior-heavyweight champion, Black Tiger's feud with Tiger Mask came to an end in 1983 with Sayama left NJPW. Rocco, however would continue to perform as Black Tiger until his retirement in 1991, to be replaced by fellow gaijin Eddie Guerrero in 1993.

Opposing Tiger Mask III, Guerrero balanced Black Tiger II duties while competing in ECW and later WCW. Guerrero's full time commitments to WCW however, would spell the end of his portrayal as Black Tiger in 1996.

Fellow luchador Sliver King was cast as Black Tiger III in 2003, situating the character in CMLL for the first time, before losing the mask to L.A Park in 2006.

Rocky Romero then continued the Black Tiger tradition as Black Tiger IV sporadically from 2005 to 2009 before losing his mask to Tiger Mask IV, who would subsequently make quick work of Black Tiger V, Tatsuhito Takaiwa later in 2009, unmasking him after a 6-month run.

An official Black Tiger wouldn't return until 2012, when Nosawa assumed the role, only to be fired after being arrested for smuggling cannabis a few weeks later.


7. Lord Humungous

Lord Humongous
wiki

The Mad Max film franchise is famous for inspiring the legendary Road Warriors. Less well remembered however, is wrestling's knock-off of one of the films other central characters, Lord Humongous.

Complete with hockey mask and minimal S&M attire, wrestling's namesake version of Lord Humongous debuted to the sounds of Kiss' War Machine in Memphis' CWA in 1984.

A creation of Jerry Lawler, it was the King's trainee Jeff Van Kamp who would become the first permanent Humongous, after Mike Stark's run came to an early end.

As part of Jimmy Hart's heel Family, Humongous was brought in to take out Lawler, which, of course he failed to do. Moving on to Alabama in 1985, Van Kamp's wrestling career would come to an early demise when he retired to become a police officer in 1985.

While John's, Saxon and Gavin would represent Humongous in periodic appearances, the most recognised portrayal of the character came in 1987, when Lawler introduced a new Humongous to Memphis, the unbelievably unpolished Sid Eudy.

Brought in as Paul E. Dangerously's newest recruit, the future Psycho Sid's would portray Humongous on and off for two years before becoming Sid Vicious and joining WCW in 1989, leaving the future Bull Buchanon to pick up the bondage harness in the 90's.


6. Suicide

Suicide TNA
impactwrestling.com

If there was ever a moniker that could be used to surmise the business practices of TNA, it was Suicide.

An original character creation of Midway Games for the video game TNA Impact!, Suicide was brought to life in 2008.

Originally portrayed by Frankie Kazarian, the mask was shifted to Christoper Daniels after an injury to Kaz. Under Daniels' charge Suicide claimed his first X-Division Championship in an Ultimate X match at Destination X in May 2009. Kazarian would re-assume the mantle of Suicide upon his return from injury later in the year, losing the title to Homicide, before eventually retiring the Suicide character and returning under his real name.

Given no one really cared about the gimmick the first time, Suicide was naturally brought back by TNA in 2010, this time under the command of Kiyoshi. In a move that lasted less than three months...

...only to be brought back in 2011, this time with Daniels under the mask.

It would be two long years before Suicide reemerged on Impact, this time portrayed by TJ Perkins. After having his identity stolen by Austin Aries, Suicide unmasked for the first time, revealing himself to have been TJP all along - and the crowd went mild.


5. Black Scorpion

black scorpion
WWE.com

After a fruitless 10-month reign in the WWF, that saw him mostly trade undercard victories on Prime Time Wrestling, Al Perez jumped to WCW in late 1990 to assume what would be his first, and last, main event role in a major company - The Black Scorpion.

Debuting in August 1990, the hooded Black Scorpion (gaudily voiced by Ole Anderson) attempted to conceal his identity while warning NWA champion Sting, stating that he was a figure from his past. The implication was that the Scorpion was Sting's ex-partner, the Ultimate Warrior. However, it was Perez who debuted against Sting as the Black Scorpion at Clash of the Champions XII, in a losing effort.

Despite being the first major feud of his career, Perez, at least according to Ric Flair, was upset with losing and quit WCW in protest.

Sting would go on to face the Scorpion at house shows, portrayed by either Dave Sheldon or Jeff Ellis, in anticipation of prolonging the storyline with Ole Anderson assuming the role of the Scorpion.

However, when Anderson was injured and forced to retire, the decision was made to blow off the angle with a return match, where the Scorpion was revealed to be none other than, the Nature Boy himself.


4. La Parka

After Adolfo Tapia took his talents as La Parka to WCW, AAA owner Antonio Pena decided it prudent to create a junior version of his skeletal creation.

While there was no dispute between the parties over the name when La Parka left WCW in 2000 and went to work for independent promotions, his jump to AAA embittered rivals CMLL in 2003 prompted Pena to take legal action.

Dropping the Jr from his La Parka's moniker and legally forcing Tapia to change his name and attire, Pena's copyright claim resulted in the original La Parka rechristening himself as L.A. Park. Both parties would stake further claims, further souring their relationship, before Tapia returned to AAA in 2010 to feud with the now established La Parka.

Triumphing in their feud, Tapia's victory for his name was later rescinded and the monikers remained in place. To add further La Parkas to the confusion, AAA then created La Parka Negra to oppose La Parka II.

The fact that all previous La Parkas were black too, seemed to be of little relevance. Later, La Parka Negra was replaced by La Parka Negra II, who was later replaced by a third La Parka Negra, though none of those changes were acknowledged.


3. Sin Cara

Sin Cara Sin Cara Negra
WWE.com

The biggest non-WWE draw of the 2000s, Místico was hailed as a major coup when he signed for WWE in 2011.

However, rather than being sent to a developmental territory to acquire the necessary skills to make the transition to American competition, the newly christened Sin Cara was immediately thrust open WWE audiences.

The enthusiasm to establish Sin Cara as an instant attraction, however, quickly backfired.

Beginning as a featured babyface aligning himself with John Cena, it quickly became apparent that without the additional ring time to get used to WWE competition and not speaking any English, the Sin Cara project was destined for failure.

Suspended for a suspected steroid use merely months into his run, Místico was replaced under the mask by developmental talent Jorge Arias.

Returning to feud with the impostor Sin Cara, the former Místico won a mask vs mask match in Mexico city, where the fake Sin Cara was unmasked and named as Hunico.

Subsequent attempts were made to accommodate Sin Cara, but injuries attempts to learn the language and wrestling style proved ultimately futile.

The former Místico returned to Mexico in January of 2014 while Hunico went on to permanently assume the poisoned chalice of Sin Cara in WWE.


2. Max Moon

Max Moon Pose
WWE.com

Konnan's star was burnishing in Mexico when the WWF made overtures to him in 1991.

The first ever EMLL heavyweight champion and the company's headline attraction, Konnan was simultaneously starring in a hit Mexican telenovela.

Wrestling for the WWF sporadically under different aliases, while developing a character idea he had seen in a Japanese anime, Konnan controversially left EMLL to found AAA in May of 1992.

The defection to AAA, which took the majority of EMLL's roster with him, sent shockwaves through lucha libre, with Konnan at the forefront of the move.

So, it hardly came as much of a surprise that when he debuted as the confetti shooting cyborg from outer space, the Comet Kid in September 1992, that Konnan might not be able to hold up his end of the bargain.

After but three televised matches, during which the characters name was changed to Max Moon, Konnan abruptly left to return to Mexico, following a dispute with Vince McMahon over missing shows.

Having heavily invested in a $13,000 suit for Max Moon, the WWF handed the gimmick over to the another former masked man, Kato, Paul Diamond.

Diamond had a multi-month run as Max Moon before the WWF admitted defeat and kyboshed the gimmick in 1993.


1. The Patriot

Imposter Patriot
WWE/CC, Mike Kalasnik - Flickr

Del Wilkes had a stellar career in the AWA, AJPW and WCW before being recruited to join the hodgepodge collection of emblematic Yankees feuding with the Hart Foundation in 1997.

Immediately inserted into a feud with WWF champion Bret Hart, the Patriot's WWF run would come to a quick halt after a tricep injury ended his career four months later.

So imagine Del Wilkes' surprise when, now working as car salesman, the Patriot started popping up at independent shows in the North East in the 2000s.

Sporting an identical mask and stars and stripe attire, the impostor Patriot was even allegedly claiming to be Wilkes when asked.

In one of wrestling's most carny moves, the faux Patriot was actually a former WWF wrestler himself Tom Brandi.

With his Salvatore Sincere 8x10s proving harder to shift than a package holiday STD, Brandi had donned the eagle mask - and forgot to tell Wilkes.

Upon finding out the news of the gimmick infringement, Wilkes condemned Brand's less than sincere identity theft, denying, as some had suggested, that he had never flogged the gimmick to him.

Brandi, however, was unstirred. Claiming there were "at least 12 other Patriots" and innumerable Doinks on the indies, Brandi went on to compete as the Patriot for well over a decade of weekend warrioring.


In this post: 
Sin Cara
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

M is a writer and editor based in Paris.