10 Match Star Ratings For AEW All Out

All Out was mostly great.

Hangman Page Chris Jericho
James Musselwhite/AEW

Several niggling issues detracted slightly from the presentation.

Jim Ross isn't as glaring a problem as Alex Marvez was at the commentary table - because Marvez, who was keen, simply wasn't good enough - but this selective enthusiasm sh*t borders on the unprofessional. Ross at various points b*llocked the referees, not through in-character moral pearl-clutching but an inherent need to impose his idea of pro wrestling onto his new company. Clearly, AEW is going for the same leniency deal as New Japan Pro Wrestling.

There, transgressions are reluctantly ignored under the idea that a disqualification finish is an anticlimax for the paying audience. It's cheeky, but not quite as cheeky as a f*ck finish designed to prolong everything. It's an acceptable plot hole, but Ross can't accept, even though it is his job to.

The show was too long and, at times, too much.

AEW All Out was an 8.5/10 show, boasting more insanity and explosive pure wrestling than Double Or Nothing, if not quite as much emotion nor sense of importance. Still, if that was AEW with the novelty fading, one crucial test has very much been passed...

10. BUY IN: 21-Woman Casino Battle Royale

Nyla Rose
AEW

The Casino Battle Royale is essentially AEW's 'How can we do the Royal Rumble without doing the Royal Rumble?' match, and it is a failure by default, because the Royal Rumble is inimitable.

Part of the joy of watching the Rumble is gluing your eyes to the entrance screen, during a lull in the action, swept up in who might appear next to make the difference. Fans ask this question during the Casino Battle Royale almost a full minute after the entrance, diluting the moment, which is diluted further as a result of the group entrance format.

The format is unworkable - but the work, in patches, was very good and very effective.

The victorious Nyla Rose starred here. There was a quality, old-school hoss recklessness to her eliminations, her power spots looked great, and the big moment - the audacious and athletic handspring kick on the apron - was pure battle royal drama fused with modern workrate spectacle. Britt Baker looked significantly better than she had at Double Or Nothing by delivering an unvarnished and authentic beating to Bea Priestley.

Ultimately, this was a lowkey triumph: Nyla got over, a personal grudge feud heated up, and at least two breakout entrants (Big Swole and Mercedes Martinez) will create buzz around a lukewarm division, in the event that they get signed full-time.

Star Rating: ★★★½


9. BUY IN: Private Party Vs. Angélico & Jack Evans

Private Party AEW
James Musselwhite/AEW

A hollow sugar rush spot-fest that pumped up the crowd big ahead of the main show, if something like a Buy In or a Kickoff has to happen, this was ideal for it.

Private Party separates AEW from WWE; still very green with an act that probably needs toning down (or at least seasoned) for the sake of their incredible potential as star performers, the hope is that working alongside veterans on television will mark their improvement. On the basis of this match, Private Party would benefit massively from a number of matches against SCU. Angélico and Jack Evans were on decent form, and their own ridiculous athleticism made for a fun mirror match sprint, but they need to take a real-looking beating from some sturdy veterans to learn how to add meaning and emotion to it all.

Marq Quen's shooting star press is unreal. He looks like that rare, genuinely cool wrestler when he puts his hands behind his head to deliver a flying headscissors. Isiah Kennedy is a standout too, but there was little connective tissue threading everything together, nor enough registering: allowing the crowd to take in the moment is as powerful as the moment itself.

Rough, rushed, but hugely exciting when it peaked.

Star Rating: ★★★½


8. SCU Vs. Jurassic Express

SCU Jurassic Express
James Musselwhite/AEW

The perfect opener to a pro wrestling show, this was tremendous; better than the very good and endearing match most projected without doing too much, it was a real accomplishment.

Luchasaurus blew the roof off the Sears Center in an awesome cameo appearance. He is a sensation; a giant dinosaur-cum-martial artist, it's a quintessentially big daft wrestling gimmick that never feels remotely anachronistic because it's so endearing and well-earned. Also, and this is impressive because Luchasaurus is a giant dinosaur-cum-martial artist, there's a nuance to his work that somehow contrives to make the tiny Marko Stunt a threat; in an early sequence, he lifted him into Christopher Daniels to allow him to pull off a flying headscissors that otherwise would have looked preposterous. It's just so wholesome, too. A Big dinosaur just wants to see his little human pals succeed. It's an irresistible act, and this dynamic made ideal use of it.

SCU proved themselves a very dependable veteran presence. Foils for an exhilarating onslaught that culminated in a jaw-dropping Luchasaurus doing good lucha things, incredibly, they then assumed control in a great heat spot in which Scorpio Sky put himself across as an elite, powerhouse athlete, adding real peril to the babyface plight.

Luchasaurus blew the roof off the Sears Center in a second awesome cameo appearance: every awesome athletic thing he did was met with a blitzkrieg pop-pop-pop-pop-pop reaction.

A sh*tload of fun.

Star Rating: ★★★¾


7. Kenny Omega Vs. PAC

PAC Kenny Omega
AEW

In which the best version of Kenny Omega surfaced and plunged in confidence to put over PAC as a major, disrupting threat to AEW's packed main event picture.

The level of intricate detail in this match was incredible. Artful. The finish was foreshadowed within the opening, character-driven flex. Omega invited PAC to the ropes, aware that the Bastard would throw himself to the mat in a rope-run dance. Omega, with a real prick-like psychology, stepped lightly on his back. PAC in response, wrestling with a more serious disposition - in great contrast to Omega's Being The Elite promo, in which he criticised Jon Moxley for failing to do precisely that - drove his foot deep into Omega's spine.

A match built on shifting parity, PAC flipped out of Omega's Kitaro Crusher in a jaw-dropping moment, again, to put himself over as the real wrestler in contrast to Omega's (in character) pursuit of putting himself over as the best performer. The absurdly physical aerials were too committed, if anything - the more confined ringside environment endangered both men, resulting in a glaring botch at the finish - but they enhanced the explosive surge of the story.

The finish was inspired. PAC was put over with a real conviction, and the shock Brutaliser will inform the drama of the sequel, in which Omega will be reluctant to even attempt his One-Winged Angel.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


6. Jimmy Havoc Vs. Darby Allin Vs. Joey Janela - Cracker Barrel Clash

Darby Allin All Out
James Musselwhite/AEW

An absolutely piss-funny and demented hardcore match, obviously, a lot of people were going to despise it. This worked so well because every performer in it knew this, and gave no f*cks.

Joey Janela was wonderful value. Putting himself over as charming masochist, that facial expression he pulled when bantering off the idea of using a tennis racket as a weapon was sublime, bloody hell. He looked like Cornette would look at literally every other point in the match. Darby Allin was a joy to watch, too, absorbing insane punishment to further get over as a marketable wild man. He drove a skateboard covered in thumbtacks into Janela's back in a great hardcore spot brimming with character, but to focus too heavily on the spots does the match something of a disservice.

Janela and Allin (literally) pinpointed Havoc as the most dangerous man in a dangerous match, and aimed to sideline him immediately. He responded by carefully strategising around the lunacy and suffering the least amount of pain. A minor comedy horror masterpiece, this attraction defined AEW's selling point.

Expressive, funny, violent - this wild burst of unregulated creativity was refreshingly different from the studious formula of acclaimed wrestling elsewhere.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


5. The Dark Order Vs. Best Friends

Dark Order AEW
James Musselwhite/AEW

A solid-to-good tag team match, that is far from ideal, given the reaction to and clear, major plans for the Dark Order tandem.

They are not over, and they are not over in front of a crowd that is very willing to immerse themselves in AEW and its promise of a revolution. That's the telling part. If they can't get over in front of flown-in ultra-hardcores, who will they get over in front of?

It's the act, not the talent.

The Creepers are borderline problematic, if you pay close enough attention to their acting, but perhaps mercifully, nobody cares. AEW will only ever get a hot finish out of this act; the build means little, because they are so cold, and they are so cold because there's no sense of character beyond "Let's just do some spooky sh*t since we'll get sued if we're the Super Smash Brothers".

The work is very good, as it was here; the colossal Evil Uno is terrifying under virtually every other criteria (another indictment), and his impressive top-rope somersault senton drew a big reaction amid the polite applause. Chuck Taylor's big plancha spot, immediately after which he sprang up and sauntered up the ramp, looked excellent, but he didn't look like he'd overcome anything formidable to put him over as a badass, or this spot as something that really meant anything.

Star Rating: ★★★¼


4. Riho Vs. Hikaru Shida

Riho Hikaru Shida
James Musselwhite/AEW

Much like the previous match, this suffered from a burned-out crowd - a byproduct of AEW's strange decision to structure All Out like a WWE pay-per-view, on which matches are fated to die by following something that cannot be followed.

The story was absorbing enough to pull the crowd into it by the finish; Hikaru Shida brutalised Riho's back, which Riho sold with an authentic agony. The dynamic was worked well; Shida, having just made one AEW appearance, positioned herself as the superior and stronger (storyline) performer by cutting off Riho's fiery babyface offence. When Riho attempted an arm drag, Shida stopped still and applied an arm bar.

This eventually picked up and erupted into a festival of backbreakers and foot stomps traded at a gripping tempo, but the lack of build undermined the heft of the story; the audience was asked to receive and get behind Riho as a spirited babyface, but the emotional connection simply wasn't there.

Neither was a true, masterful sense of craft, which again, was showed up by the decision to present Kenny Omega and PAC so early. Shida clung to the ropes for the Alberto Del Rio foot stomp, revealing the artifice after a true showcase of the art.

Star Rating: ★★★½


3. Cody Vs. Shawn Spears

Cody AEW
James Musselwhite

The sort of match that didn't strive for a high star rating - but was also so well-worked that it satisfied the pocket of the crowd that cares about this sort of thing - this choice spot of cornball fun underscored Cody's vast appeal. He is a pro wrestler for the vast majority of pro wrestling fans, irrespective of generation or inclination.

Dressing up as a Star Trek character undermined the tone - Cody's eagerness to please all too often results in him pleasing himself - but the hot start compensated for what was too extravagant an entrance. He should have treated this match - retribution for a long, close friendship ended with a gruesome chair shot - more seriously in its presentation.

He eventually did, and it was very good, even if Shawn Spears didn't truly emerge from it as a star. He played his role, but he wasn't the focus. This was an ambitious, layered story with several moving parts, all of which did add to the heated drama. That lack of focus resulted, naturally, in distraction. The otherwise impeccable, sinister Tully Blanchard left his man in the sh*t at the finish, and Earl Hebner was very forgiving of the (obvious) chicanery that resulted in the switcheroo belt shot (weight belts: no, trouser belts: go on then).

Imperfect as a whole, the individual moments soared at their best - Arn Anderson's spinebuster tore the roof off - and Cody's babyface fire was so tremendous that it lit the whole thing up.

Star Rating: ★★★¾


2. The Young Bucks Vs. The Lucha Brothers - AAA World Tag Team Championship Match

AEW All Out 2019 Lucha Brothers Young Bucks
allelitewrestling.com

One of the most spectacular and brutal matches in the history of modern pro wrestling, the Young Bucks Vs. The Lucha Brothers was also one of the greatest ladder matches ever.

The detail was everywhere. At various points, all four men implored their brothers to "Climb, climb" just off camera. It's a very simple and minor (and necessary) thing to do, but it was crucial in presenting this as a match to win, and not just a show to perform.

But what a show it was, Jesus Christ.

It was so gripping and violent and dramatic that even Jim Ross softened his Cornette-adjacent stance and got swept up in it. The brothers wove a great, unique story around the completely f*cking demented big spots, in which each team was inseparable in quality and strategy. Matt Jackson and Fénix found themselves standing atop ladders on opposite stands of the ring, exchanging incredulous impressions before sacrificing their bodies. Most big matches on pay-per-view go 50/50; this war was a very creative spin on both that and the brothers versus brothers theme.

Matt took a Canadian Destroyer off the top of a ladder and through a table in one of the most batsh*t major league spots ever, and Nick almost broke his neck by misjudging his trajectory on his own, terrifying wipeout moment.

A strategic wrestling match with effective d*ckhead character work and death-defying delirium, this was out-of-this-world fantasti

Star Rating: ★★★★¾


1. Hangman Page Vs. Chris Jericho - AEW World Championship Match

Chris Jericho All Out
James Musselwhite/AEW

This was a very good match, but it could have been a great match under different circumstances.

Some reckoned this was cold before the show, but the crowd were up for it initially. Hangman Page literally threw himself into it, taking a disgusting back-first bump into the barricade, and for a while, Jericho performed as the best version of his reinvented post-WWE self: his physicality served the veteran versus prospect dynamic wonderfully, an early dropkick looked dynamic and forceful, and his timing was incredible - far better than at Double Or Nothing. It also served a purpose, so it needed to be: he was telling the story of an instinctive, tenured major league player, and he told it expertly.

The poetry of his blade-job was tremendous, but it didn't help the atmosphere; fans, already high on the heel's showmanship and charisma, seemed to be unnerved by it. It wasn't received as the poetic retribution it was pitched as, anyway, as sound as that pitch was.

Jericho's transitions looked slow, which is another issue he suffers from in these otherwise deeply impressive twilight years, and it compounded what was too long a run-time. The duration didn't consider how long and how heavy-hitting the show was at large, but the timing on that Judas Elbow finish was magnificent.

As was Jericho's hilariously belligerent post-match promo. Shave five minutes off his main events, and AEW has itself the perfect inaugural World Champion.

Star Rating: ★★★¾


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!