10 Midcard WWE Stars Who Wrestled One Huge Match

Was Rikishi really this over in 2000?

WWE is always endeavouring to discover their next breakout talent, the exciting young Superstar who will surely catapult themselves to the rarefied air of the 'Main Event'. Over the years, the number of bona fide main event guys that WWE has managed to create is not overly large, especially when you consider the sheer volume of talents that have came and went through the WWE Developmental system. While the fans have seen genuine superstars born, unfortunately the wrestling business isn't made up solely of talents like Hulk Hogan or The Rock. It's a worrying notion that in today's WWE climate, there are only a handful of legitimate main eventers: John Cena, Randy Orton, Daniel Bryan and Brock Lesnar. The company is putting their stock behind Roman Reigns, much to the chagrin of many fans, and there are a number of hungry young competitors trying to break through that 'glass ceiling' that Vince McMahon loves to mention. Guys like Seth Rollins, Bray Wyatt and Dean Ambrose will aim to establish themselves further in 2015 and solidify their spots at the top of the card. Finding a new main eventer is one of the most elusive things in wrestling, so it stands to reason that sometimes the WWE have tried to manufacture a new top talent, often by throwing a mostly untested performer into a high-profile match in order to see how they cope or by repackaging an ageing veteran. This tactic hasn't often proved successful, and has led to the following list. These are 10 WWE superstars who wrestled one massive match, which sticks out like a sore thumb when compared to the rest of their less than glittering careers.

10. Vladimir Kozlov (WWE Championship Match Vs Triple H) - Survivor Series 2008

The 'Super Athlete' Rusev has already proven to be quite the success in WWE, gaining solid heat from crowds (aided massively by the lovely Lana) and performing admirably in the ring. He is scheduled to go up against John Cena at WWE Fastlane in just a few days time, the biggest match of his young career. He is likely to fare much, much better in this pressurised scenario than Vladimir Kozlov, the WWE's last attempt to present a Russian monster heel, who helped deliver one of the worst Pay-Per-View main events in history. Kozlov made his Smackdown debut on April 4th 2008 and quickly rose through the ranks, mostly by decimating local jobbers. To the surprise of pretty much everyone, he was then quickly thrust into the WWE Championship picture, resulting in a one on one match at Survivor Series against Triple H. To say that Kozlov's lack of experience was badly exposed in this match would be an understatement. He and The Game stunk up the joint, with Hunter unable to lead the rookie to anything resembling a decent encounter. He never should have been in there in the first place. The match is only remembered at all due to the late appearance of Edge, who interfered and somehow conspired to leave with the title. In fact, WWE recognized that the match was a dud, leading to it being billed as a Triple Threat on the subsequent DVD! Kozlov went on to be drafted to ECW, then teamed with Santino Marella for a period as a comedy duo, before he was wished the best in his future endeavours on August 5th 2011.

9. The Brian Kendrick (WWE Championship Scramble Match) - Unforgiven 2008

Brian Kendrick made a surprise return to WWE on the February 12th NXT television tapings. His match is expected to air on February 25th on WWE Network, but it is currently unknown whether he has signed a new deal with the company. His previous tenure in WWE was mainly characterised by his long running and successful tag team with Paul London, with their reign as WWE Tag Team Champions lasted 331 days, the longest in history. However, he also had a run in 2008-09 as a singles competitor under the bizarre moniker 'The' Brian Kendrick. He had some success here as an upper midcard heel, with his new attitude (and tough bodyguard Ezekiel Jackson) gaining some traction with the fans. However, it was still a surprise when he was included in the WWE Championship Scramble match at Unforgiven 2008, a new concept with a 20 minute time limit. Superstars were able to temporarily become champion via pinfall or submission and the man who was 'interim' champion whenever the time limit ran out would leave with the title belt. Kendrick actually did become champion for a few short minutes during the Scramble, but didn't emerge victorious overall. Neither did the Scramble match format, as it has only been used once since, and the 'interim' title reign isn't recognized in the official record books. Oh well. Kendrick ended up being released from his contract on July 30th 2009, and went on to wrestle for TNA and New Japan before his recent, and hopefully permanent, return to WWE.

8. The Big Boss Man (Hell In A Cell Match Vs The Undertaker) - Wrestlemania 15

The Big Boss Man occupies a special place in the hearts of wrestling fans of two generations. He will likely either be remembered for his first period with WWF during the late 1980's/early 1990's, playing a prison guard character, or for his run during the Attitude Era, where he wore black SWAT gear (a look that heavily inspired the ring attire of The Shield) and was a member of The Corporation. It was during this run that he found most success, winning the Tag Team Championship and Hardcore Title. He even engaged in a controversial feud with The Big Show over the WWF Title for a short period, but arguably his most high profile match-up came at Wrestlemania 15 in 1999: a Hell In A Cell match against The Undertaker. The match itself is entirely forgettable, clocking in at under ten minutes in length. It wasn't even the main event, unlike all other Cell matches up until that point, which should have given fans the clue that something out of the ordinary was about to happen. By the time The Brood descended from the rafters and passed a noose through the roof of the cell, allowing Paul Bearer to raise it and 'hang' The Boss Man, fans were understandably aghast and mystified at this turn of events. At least it then made sense why a midcard talent had been booked in a huge match at The Showcase Of The Immortals: it was a stunt, rather than an actual wrestling contest.

7. Heath Slater & Justin Gabriel (Money In The Bank Ladder Match) - 2011

The above picture may confound even the most dedicated member of the WWE Universe. Is that Heath Slater and Justin Gabriel holding the WWE Tag Team Championships, you might ask? Well, yes, as hugely unlikely as that may seem, Slater and Gabriel held those titles on THREE separate occasions. But hey, this was during a period where John Cena and David Freaking Otunga held the belts, so maybe WWE Creative was asleep at the wheel when all this was happening. Geez. Ok, so maybe Slater and Gabriel weren't entirely horrible as a pairing. They are both decent hands in the ring, and Slater has some real comic timing, used to best effect during his time in 3MB. Gabriel is an incredible athlete, but could never seem to show any personality, leading to a difficulty connecting with audiences and to him eventually walking out on the WWE a few weeks ago. Therefore, neither man's resume would seem to qualify them for a spot in the Money In The Bank Ladder match, but yet there they were in 2011, presumably to make up numbers. Sharing the ring with established stars like Kane and Sheamus, as well as up and comers like Wade Barrett, Cody Rhodes and eventual winner Daniel Bryan, Slater and Gabriel did look a tad out of place, but at least they can always say they took part in a match of such stature.

6. Mike Knox (World Heavyweight Championship Elimination Chamber Match) - No Way Out 2009

WE's often baffling booking tactics, Knox was thrust into the main event No Way Out 2009 as one of six men in the World Heavyweight Championship Elimination Chamber match, despite the crowd having little to know idea who this bearded behemoth was. The match itself has gone down in history as one of the best Chamber matches ever, thanks in no small part to Edge (who was at the height of his powers of winning matches he wasn't actually supposed to be in, after ambushing Kofi Kingston and stealing his spot in the Chamber) and Rey Mysterio, who put on a clinic during the final stretch. Knox was the second man eliminated, by Chris Jericho, but it's a real struggle to remember him contributing much to proceedings. It's tempting to wonder if the WWE Universe simply never got to see the best of Mike Knox. He certainly had a good look and could have functioned as a member of The Wyatt Family, had he stuck around in the company. After his release in 2010, he returned to the independent circuit before signing with TNA, where he wrestled as Knux, a member of the motorcycle gang Aces & Eights and later became the leader of The Menagerie, a band of carnival folk. Oh Mike Knox, we barely knew ye.

5. Fandango (Vs Chris Jericho) - WrestleMania 29

"It's Fan....Dan...Go!" March 1st 2013's episode of Smackdown saw the debut of Fandango, a ballroom dancer who was extremely fussy about the way people pronounced his name. So fussy, in fact, that he refused to wrestle if they got it wrong. A little over a month later, Fandango faced Chris Jericho at Wrestlemania 29 in his very first televised match. Um, what? How did that happen? Fandango's exceedingly swift rise to a prominent position on the Wrestlemania card caught a lot of people off guard, not the least of which was his opponent; Jericho has been quite open on his podcast about the fact that he was less than amused about this match at The Show Of Shows. Fandango had previously been on WWE TV as Johnny Curtis, and had won the fourth season of NXT, but had been sent back to Florida Championship Wrestling to further develop after his initial run. He had therefore wrestled in front of WWE audiences before, but not as Fandango and certainly not in front of 80,000 people. In truth, Fandango performed about as well as anyone could have expected, with he and Jericho putting on a decent midcard encounter. He went on to gain some novelty popularity due to his catchy entrance music and was once in line to win the Intercontinental Championship until he suffered an ill-timed concussion, putting a stop to those plans. His career has never quite recovered, and he currently languishes at the bottom of the WWE totem pole. That said, there is still time for Fandango, and at least he can always say he had his 'Wrestlemania Moment'.

4. Rikishi (WWE Championship 6 Man Hell In A Cell Match) - Armageddon 2000

The list of names that competed in the six man Armageddon Hell In A Cell match is like a who's who of the wrestling industry; a veritable bevy of future Hall Of Famers. Stone Cold Steve Austin. The Rock. Triple H. The Undertaker. Kurt Angle. Rikishi Phatu. One of these names is not like the others and unfortunately for Rikishi, it's his. Despite the deep irony that Rikishi actually IS being inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame Class Of 2015, there can be no doubt that his career in no way holds a candle to any of those other five competitors. His announcement for the Hall Of Fame was greeted with a healthy amount of scepticism, as it is debatable whether or not he truly deserves it. There can be no debate, however, about the fact that this match was the very pinnacle of his career, a pinnacle that he never got close to again. This match occurred during one of the least celebrated storylines of the Attitude Era, in which it was revealed that Rikishi, a babyface known for dancing and rubbing his ample posterior in opponents faces, was actually the despicable heel who had run over Steve Austin with a car. Rikishi's time as a 'Bad Man' was hilariously lampooned by The Rock during his legendary 'I did it for The Rock' promo, and the WWE had to do some hasty retconning, revealing that Triple H was the true mastermind who had paid Rikishi to do it. Ah, The Attitude Era.

3. Alex Riley (WWE Championship Match w/ The Miz Vs John Cena) - Over The Limit 2011

This entry may be perceived as bending the rules slightly, given that this match was technically a one on one 'I Quit' Match between John Cena and The Miz for the WWE Championship. However, given that there are no disqualifications in this type of match-up, it ended up playing out very much as a handicap match, with Miz teaming with his protege Alex Riley to brutalize Cena for virtually the entire affair. Therefore, Riley's appearance in the main event of a WWE PPV has to make the list. Those are the rules, people. As if it wasn't obvious from the description of how the match was formed, this ended up being a debacle, the absolute worst of The Miz's brief tenure as a main event talent. It essentially amounted to 20 minutes of Miz and Riley unleashing a savage beating on Cena with no comeback...before Cena became Superman, overpowering and defeating the two men in about 2 minutes at the end. Rest assured, this was not entertaining in any way, with the World Title match from the same PPV (Randy Orton vs Christian) being an infinitely greater contest. Riley went on to engage in a short feud with The Miz and even competed in a Money In The Bank ladder match in 2011, but fell out of favour with management at some point. Until very recently, he hadn't been seen in a WWE ring since 2013 and instead forged an identity as 'The Analyst', a mainstay of WWE Network's Raw and Smackdown pre-shows, adopting a persona similar to a sports agent or colour commentator. Thankfully for the man, his #FreeRiley campaign on Twitter must have worked, as he made his return to the ring on the February 12th NXT tapings.

2. The Boogeyman (Vs Booker T) - Wrestlemania 22

It's entirely possible that The Boogeyman may have worked tremendously well as a gimmick in the early 1990's, alongside other cartoonish fare such as Doink or Papa Shango. However, given that Marty Wright debuted as the character in 2005, in the midst of an era that mostly eschewed over the top gimmicks, perhaps The Boogeyman was always destined to fail. Of course, it didn't help that Wright only started training at 40 years old and had very little natural aptitude for wrestling. It turned out he really was only good for eating worms on camera and smashing clocks over his head. Isn't wrestling weird sometimes? The crowning achievement of The Boogeyman's short career was his match against the 5-time WCW Champion, Booker T, at Wrestlemania 22. The match lasted an incredibly short 3 minutes and 43 seconds, due to Wright's suspect in-ring skills but also because he tore his left bicep at a house show shortly before the PPV. Injuries were a common thing during his WWE career, likely due to his increased age: his initial debut in 2005 had to be delayed because he hyper-extended both knees and needed time off to recover. All in all, it seemed that The Boogeyman had no real right to compete in a WWE ring, although he has appeared sporadically over recent years for quick backstage segments, always guaranteed to get a quick chuckle out of the WWE Universe. His appearance in this year's Royal Rumble was expectedly brief but amusing, as he was quickly hurled over the top rope by Bray Wyatt, a perfect example of a superstar who has been able to harness an outlandish gimmick and make it work beautifully.

1. R-Truth (WWE Championship Match Vs John Cena) - Capitol Punishment 2011

Over the course of this list, it has become clear that 2011 was some sort of experimental year for the WWE in terms of it's main event talent. Already highlighted were Heath Slater and Justin Gabriel's Money In The Bank match, as well as The Miz and Alex Riley's battles with John Cena. However, the strangest was yet to come in that year, at the Capitol Punishment PPV (an event that has never been held again), in which R-Truth faced Cena one on one for the WWE Title. R-Truth is a dependable presence on WWE programming, a fun superstar with some flashy moves and the ability to rap his own catchy entrance music on the way to the ring. The kiddies love him and he will therefore likely always have a place in the company. But in 2011, Truth experienced what can only be described as a career renaissance, where a heel turn and new 'crazy' attitude, along with his trusty invisible buddy Little Jimmy, somehow conspired to take him to the main event. Wrestling! Truth's Little Jimmy (a reference to the legions of young, merchandise wearing Cena fans in attendance) rants were pretty entertaining, and he really developed a talent with comedy on the microphone, but in no way should that qualify someone for a run at the title. The match itself was forgettable, as nobody really believed that Truth stood any chance of dethroning Cena, and he returned to the midcard after a stint teaming with The Miz as The Awesome Truth. These days he can be seen rapping and losing quick enhancement matches during his sporadic appearances on Raw or Smackdown.

Contributor
Contributor

Comics. Movies. TV. Wrestling. Video Games. Husband. Father. Geek.