10 More WWE Stars Who Desperately Need New Gimmicks

Triple H can rescue these WWE careers from disaster/boredom post-Vince McMahon.

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

13 workers/10 WWE acts should be giving Triple H's office door a little tap, tap, tap to see if the new head of creative has anything fresh for them. After all, 2022 marks the first chance this company has had to move on from one man's vision since the 1980s.

Vince McMahon has retired, and a three-pronged Trips/Stephanie/Nick Khan collective calls the shots now. That must inspire some wrestlers who have been toiling badly over the past 18 months or so. Finally, after feeding on creative scraps tossed from Vince's table, these men and women have an entirely new braintrust to lob ideas at.

Change is essential for them anyway.

Some of the characters you'll read about here are, in a word...crap. They're so one-dimensional it hurts, and many have been spinning from lame mini-feud to lame mini-feud without any purpose. It's in Hunter's best interests to try something new before fans give up on them completely.

Every single one of these WWE roster members could use a shake up. No, not a McMahon-style "Superstar Shakeup" (brand switch), but proper, thought-out improvements that'd make them must-see.

10. Shanky

Jinder Mahal Shanky
WWE.com

There's just no way this big man can continue dancing.

WWE has an awful habit of taking "giants" and turning them into walking punchlines that nobody is laughing at. They did it with Big Show, they did it with The Great Khali, they did it with Albert/Lord Tensai (twice!), they did it with Braun Strowman, and now they're doing it with Jinder Mahal's mate Shanky.

He dances. Isn't that hilarious? No, no it's not - literally nobody wanted the E's only plan for Jinder's heavy to end up being him shaking his arse at ring announcers. This trite idea has Vinnie Mac written all over it, and it should be one of the first to go now that Triple H is in the creative hot seat.

No-one really knows what Shanky is capable of yet, because he barely wrestles. Surely improving his in-ring skills and at least trying to capitalise on his physical immediacy should take priority over "friendly giant" b*llocks that's clearly going nowhere fast.


9. Robert Roode

Dolph Ziggler Robert Roode Dirty Dawgs
WWE.com

Suggestion: Robert Roode shouldn't revert back to his original 'Glorious' gimmick on NXT, Raw or SmackDown. That'd be a step backwards for the guy, and WWE didn't really know how to handle it on the main roster anyway. Maybe that'd be different under Trips, but meh - it's unnecessary.

He does need something post-Dirty Dawgs though.

Dolph Ziggler has moved on from their underrated tag-team, and now it's over to Bob Roode. Being honest, Roode is a wonderful worker who has always been downplayed in WWE's system. He's capable of doing so much more, and has decades of experience under his belt.

In short, the ex-TNA man is a valuable asset WWE can use to help elevate others. He should really be in that Sami Zayn mould, albeit with less of a wacky personality. Roode can reinvent himself as a grizzled veteran who's p*ssed off about being overlooked and wants the company's youth to suffer.

Bring it on.


8. Los Lotharios

Angel Humberto Los Lotharios
WWE.com

Yours truly will always maintain that the Los Lotharios idea should've been the making of Angel and Humberto. After all, handsome heels who believe they're God's gift to your eyes is heel 101, and it's the kind of thing that should facilitate automatic heat.

The bloom is off the rose they carry about with them.

Garza and Carrillo need their surnames back for starters, but they're also going to need something new if they're ever going to become a pulsating part of WWE's doubles division. The duo have good chemistry, and it'd be nice to see them used properly for once rather than being stuffed behind occasional squashes or nothing backstage skits.

Perhaps rethinking them as spitfire babyfaces who realise that constantly flirting with... everybody won't get them the Undisputed Tag-Team Titles would be the way to go. Can you imagine the matches these dudes could have with The Usos, for example? Tag magic awaits.


7. Sonya Deville

Sonya Deville
WWE.com

Sonya Deville has been buried beneath WWE's repetitive authority figure-led programming for a few years now. Two years ago, during the height of her feud with old pal Mandy Rose, Sonya showed serious potential as a wicked witch heel who would stop at nothing to be cruel.

The writing team squished that flat, then made her Adam Pearce's PA.

Since assuming that role, Deville has tumbled down the pecking order in a division that she once looked like dominating. She's one of the least-effective heels on the roster - the kind who's all bark with no bite, and that's a damn shame considering how good she looked before being creatively neutered in the summer of 2020.

WWE has taken steps away from the soft-GM assistant gig, but they'll need to conjure up something more for Sonya as 2022 sprints towards 2023. If they do, then they might just find that she's the lead heel (one not-named Charlotte Flair) that SmackDown has needed for years.


6. Max Dupri

Max Dupri
WWE

Vince McMahon reportedly blamed LA Knight for fudging his Maximum Male Models intro and removed the renamed Max Dupri from the gimmick. Then, just like that, WWE returned Dupri to the side of Mace and Mansoor but kept their hastily-introduced Maxxine complement too.

That gimmick ain't big enough for the both of them.

It feels messy to effectively have two managers fawning over the same tag-team, and the former Sophia Cromwell is probably a better fit for MMM than Dupri. His run as smart-arsed jock Knight on NXT was vastly superior to anything this repackage job has achieved thus far; the man has charisma, but he's jousting for house room in a now-crowded act.

Going forwards, it'd be for the best if Maxxine assumed full control of the Models and sent her kayfabe brother packing. Then, at some point, Max can turn back into LA and start working matches again. He'd be a credit to Raw or SmackDown in-ring.


5. Queen Zelina

Zelina Vega
WWE.com

Ye olde royal gimmick is a tough ask.

Zelina Vega didn't actually do anything wrong with it. Like, she didn't suck as a phoney 'Queen' who thought everybody should bow down at her mere presence. Nah, WWE just gave up on the act far too quickly and stuck her in one of those thrown-together female tag-teams with Carmella.

That decision made a mockery of the first 'Queen's Crown' tournament, and wrecked the purpose of even slapping a crown on Vega's head in the first place. Sadly, she won't get another chance to make a first impression on fans - the Queen Zelina character is damaged goods, people.

When Vega returns from a knee injury, it'd be sweet if she had something new to show off. The first ever 'Queen Of The Ring' winner (which is effectively what that tourney was) is excellent on the mic, and deserves the chance to do more in-ring.

Hopefully, a reborn character gives her that chance.


4. Naomi

Naomi WWE SmackDown
WWE.com

Pro wrestling programming moves quickly these days, and that's something Naomi might find out to her detriment once she returns to WWE action. If she returns to WWE action, but it looks likely now that Vince is on the outside looking in and has next-to-no-say over who does what or who goes where.

Unfortunately, once the initial pop and excitement dies down, Naomi may find herself right back where she started in an over-crowded women's mix on both major brands. Put it this way: Naomi will need something better than her tired 'Feel The Glow' schtick if she's gonna thrive on Raw or SmackDown.

That won't cut it for very long.

Perhaps a bold heel turn and alliance with The Usos would freshen up their act and give Naomi something beyond her glow-in-the-dark dancing entrance. She deserves it after suffering through one of 2021/2022's worst feuds opposite fellow straggler Sonya Deville, that's for sure.


3. Dominik Mysterio

Rey Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

The smiling rookie son.

That's Dominik Mysterio's role on WWE television, and it has been since he started tagging alongside his dad as a regular act several years back. This might've been fine in 2020 when Dom first began working matches, but it's beyond tedious two years in and something badly needs to change.

Creative did toy with the thought of turning Dominik against daddy dearest by having Judgment Day (more on them later) attempt to manipulate him, but that trail appears to have gone cold since Edge returned to fend off the group's bad intentions. Basically, Dom is right back at square one and everyone's wondering what's next - probs including him.

Dominik can't keep standing in his father's shadow forever, that's clear. He'll need to stand on his own two feet at some stage, and it'd be wise to make a stab at that singles run soon. Rey isn't going to be Dom's full-time tag partner for another few years, surely.


2. Becky Lynch

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Recently-turned babyface Becky Lynch has been written out of storylines for now due to that nasty separated shoulder she suffered at SummerSlam (don't look it up during lunch!). Upon her return, 'Big Time Becks' will likely revisit some of the ballsy characteristics that captured fan imaginations during her run as 'The Man'.

Going backwards might not be the best idea.

Becky may look towards someone like Chris Jericho for inspiration - the AEW star has earned praise for continually driving forwards into something fresh. Yes, he still has elements of the old 'Y2J' character here or there, but he's not a full-time walking nostalgia act in 2022.

Lynch's next big challenge is finding a way to exist as a genuinely likeable face without dusting off the old leather jacket, furrowing her eyebrows and taking a shoot punch in the nose from someone during an in-ring scrap. Mixing 'The Man' with 'Big Time' could be a risk.


1. Judgment Day

WWE SummerSlam 2022 Judgment Day
WWE.com

Yes, as in the entire faction.

What is Judgment Day anyway? The original idea led by Edge told the story of an iconic leader who'd lost his mind but wanted to help downtrodden young stars fulfil their potential. Then, WWE decided to boot him out of the group and replace him with Finn Bálor for...reasons.

Truthfully, Bálor's time in charge has been sh*te. Judgment Day are barely a threat, and even lost to Rey and Dominik Mysterio at SummerSlam. Once Edge has had his revenge on them for kicking him to the curb, then what?! Nothing, let's be honest.

Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley are the biggest victims in all of this. They'll require new direction following that ass-kicking from their former leader. Yep, like it or not, WWE's booking strangled Judgment Day so hard it's already borderline defunct.

Which other WWE stars desperately need a new gimmick/character? For more wrestling, check out 10 Things We Learned From Sami Zayn On Stone Cold’s Broken Skull Sessions Podcast and 10 New Directions For WWE After SummerSlam 2022!


In this post: 
Becky Lynch
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.