10 Most Believable Superstars In WWE History

Believe this.

Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

What makes a good wrestler truly great? What components are crucial in creating a WWE superstar that will be remembered for the ages, long after their days in the ring are done? There's the look, the promos, the in-ring work, sure, but one characteristic sets them apart from everyone else.

Credibility.

Do you believe what you are seeing? Do you believe what this wrestler is saying or doing? You don't have to like it, but if you believe their actions could be legitimate, that's something special.

Especially today, few WWE superstars are able to capture that feeling. Blame it on the lack of kayfabe, a world where every spoken word originates from a script penned by non-talent, the expansion of social media, or even a generational difference - there's numerous theories as to why fans don't believe in wrestlers today like they have previously.

Most fans want to believe. For those few hours, they want to believe what they're watching is real - no different than Game Of Thrones, The Walking Dead, or any other dramatic television show. The following 10 superstars allowed fans to do that with ease.

The integrity and credibility behind these 10 talents should be studied by everyone in WWE today - if they want fans to believe.

10. Ultimate Warrior

Ultimate Warrior Body
WWE

Starting off the list is a controversial superstar, no doubt about that. Some loved him, some hated him, but despite all the opinions shared on the man formerly known as Jim Hellwig, one thing is not arguable - and that was the man's intensity.

Intensity is what made Warrior a WWF icon in 1990 and, along with his bizarre promos, frenetic entrances, and struggles with the in-ring "work", Warrior become one of the more believable WWE superstars of all-time. If ever there was one, the Ultimate Warrior really did seem like someone from another planet. He was so intense, so forceful, so aggressive that his characteristics felt like more than just a television character.

They say the most successful wrestling personas are the ones that are not too far removed from the individual(s) portraying them - often, it's the character's personality with the volume turned up to 11. By all accounts, that was the case with Warrior.

Unfortunately for his opponents, this believability was helped by a stiff, often clumsy in-ring style in which he never fully learned how to work. It's one of the reasons why his peers may not have taken a huge liking to Warrior, but it can't be denied: fans believed his act.


9. Macho Man Randy Savage

1988 Macho Man Randy Savage
WWE

Few superstars could match the Ultimate Warrior's intensity. One man that could - and did as one of Warrior's most memorable opponents - was Randy "Macho Man" Savage. Not only could Savage match Warrior's incredible intensity, he was just as believable a professional wrestler as the rope-shaking, face-painted maniac from Parts Unknown.

The two wrestlers were really quite similar in their approach to their characters, in that both men took their personas with deadly seriousness. Their colorful outfits, unique voices, the often out-of-this-world promos, and their wild eyed facial expressions all contributed to making Savage and Warrior feel incredibly real, if not a little bit crazy. One major difference that separated these two superstars was the quality of their in-ring performances.

While Warrior was often carried through his matches by the likes of Rick Rude, Mr. Perfect, or Savage himself, Randy was capable of putting on a ***** classic every time he laced up his boots. The original Mr. WrestleMania stole the show at WrestleManias III, IV, V, VII, and VIII - all with different opponents.

His remarkable in-ring ability went a long in way in establishing the Macho Man's authenticity as an all-time great.


8. Million Dollar Man Ted DiBiase

Million Dollar Man Ted DiBiase
WWE

One of Savage's famed WrestleMania matches, the show-closer in 1988, featured another truly believable wrestler opposite the Macho Man: Ted DiBiase.

When DiBiase joined the World Wrestling Federation in 1987 as the "Million Dollar Man", he immediately embraced the gimmick, allowing it to be taken very seriously by the fans. From day one, DiBiase's portrayal of an incredibly wealthy, overly pompous millionaire was assisted by the practice of kayfabe that pro-wrestlers still followed at the time.

With the financial backing of WWF owner Vince McMahon, even when the cameras were off, DiBiase traveled in style. First class flights, stretch limousines, fancy restaurants, and five-star hotels were everyday occurrences for the Million Dollar Man. There were even occasions where DiBiase would stand up in any given restaurant and announce that he, on behalf of himself and the WWF, would be covering the bill for everyone's meal that day simply because he could and was in a good mood.

On screen, DiBiase never wavered in his heel persona. Along with hiring Virgil as his bodyguard, Ted's in-ring work, arrogant promos, and the way in which he played his character all combined to make the Million Dollar Man one of the most believable superstars in WWE history.


7. Stone Cold Steve Austin

Stone Cold Steve Austin Wwf Title
WWE.com

When DiBiase's in-ring career came to an end, he began managing. His final WWF protege, before Ted left for WCW, was The Ringmaster, AKA Steve Austin. This was not a character anyone could get behind, nor was it a WWF superstar fans believed in.

Before long, Austin dropped the cheesy 'Ringmaster' moniker, along with his manager, and won the 1996 King Of The Ring as Stone Cold Steve Austin. Fast-forward roughly a year later, and Austin was well on his way to becoming the hottest superstar in the history of the business, paving the way for the WWF to overtake WCW in the Monday night ratings war.

Austin was an 'every-man': a blue collar working class superstar that embraced a no-nonsense, straight-to-the-point attitude. He talked like an everyday person, he cursed like an everyday person, he drank like an everyday person, and he even wanted to stick it to his boss like an everyday person... with one major difference. Steve actually could.

Austin's star-power allowed him to physically get the better of his real-life boss, the evil Mr. McMahon. Many fans lived vicariously through Steve, and if you're living through the actions of a WWE superstar, it's pretty safe to say it's an easy character to believe in.


6. Goldberg

Goldberg Big
WWE

While Stone Cold was helping turn things around for WWE, another bald-headed, goatee-sporting wrestler was also getting over - albeit in a rival organization - wearing black trunks and short black boots. His name was Goldberg, and he quickly became the flagship performer of the star-studded roster in WCW.

Unlike many other WCW talents at the time when Bill Goldberg came along, he brought a legitimacy that stemmed from outside the world of pro wrestling. In the late 80s, Goldberg was a college football star. He was drafted by the NFL's Los Angeles Rams in 1990 before playing for the Atlanta Falcons in 1992 through '94. This background was something WCW incorporated as part of his character, even utilizing a football tackle-like manuever, known as the Spear, as his signature move. Goldberg didn't talk often and he didn't taunt much; he just came to the ring, laser-focused, and quickly disposed of his competition before walking straight to the back.

It was a brilliant approach, one that would be replicated several times over throughout pro wrestling's future.

But the ease of believing in Goldberg is what propelled the former Falcon to an impressive undefeated streak and the top of the wrestling world.


5. Asuka

Asuka NXT
WWE

Goldberg's undefeated streak, though heavily inflated, ended at 173-0 and lasted from September '97 until December '98. This was generally accepted as the longest undefeated streak in modern pro wrestling history - until current WWE superstar Asuka surpassed it in 2017. Her reign as NXT Women's Champion lasted 510 days, the longest of any WWE champion in three decades.

From the moment Asuka debuted in NXT, she stood head and shoulders above everyone else. Her stiff striking and in-ring work were the original driving force behind her character's credibility before the victories began piling up. Asuka's multiple wins over former NXT flagbearer Bayley, and perceived future women's torchbearer in Ember Moon, only added to Asuka's reputation. The strategy by NXT booker Triple H to buck tradition and keep the title on Asuka (before a legit shoulder injury forced her to vacate) is one that paid off.

Asuka will soon make her main roster debut for RAW - and the anticipation is unlike any female superstar's in recent memory. Whether or not Vince McMahon bungles this gift, like he has so many others, remains to be seen - but Asuka has been the most believable female superstar ever to step foot in WWE.


4. André The Giant

Andre The Giant
WWE.com

Yet another Hulkamania era talent, André The Giant was probably the easiest wrestler for fans to believe in - simply by looking at him.

André was a legit giant due to a disorder known as acromegaly, in which the body continues to produce growth hormone well after it should. André was able to use it to his advantage in the world of professional wrestling, but unfortunately, it resulted in the French native passing away at the young age of 46. During his time in pro-wrestling, however, nobody was more believable than the Eighth Wonder of the World.

His 400+ lb. frame, giant-sized hands and feet, and standing as a legit 7 footer allowed fans to believe that Andre could do anything he wanted to with anyone he stepped in the ring with. Add to this his unique, monster-like voice, and the facial features that made him appear other-worldly (again, attributed to acromegaly), and Andre The Giant became one of the largest draws ever in professional wrestling.

People literally bought into Andre The Giant. Without this strong credibility, the largest event in WWF history, WrestleMania III, likely wouldn't have had the impact we remember it for today.


3. Bret "Hitman" Hart

bret hart wwe champion
WWE.com

Not every great wrestler needs to be a physical powerhouse in order for fans to believe in them. In fact, if one were to go completely on the performance aspect of pro wrestling, no one was ever more believable than Bret "Hitman" Hart.

Bret always gave his all in his performances, including a consistent focus on selling, constant attempts at innovation, and a commitment to making his matches look and feel real. Bret perfected the art's little details not seen today, like leaving his mouth open as if he was huffing-and-puffing, grasping for air (despite not being legitimately gassed), or getting in the referee's face after that close 2-count.

Despite his excellent abilities, you'll never once see a Bret Hart match in the WWF where it looks like he's "performing". Nothing feels fake or choreographed, and he can't be seen calling spots. Even his interviews are ultra serious, focusing on the task at hand of defeating his opponent. Segments like his pre-match SummerSlam '92 promo, his interview work building to WrestleMania VIII, and his entire 1997 heel run and the months leading up to it are just a few examples of classic, believable Bret Hart.

He's unfairly criticized for "taking himself too seriously", when the reality is more talents need to treat their character as seriously as Bret did.


2. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle
WWE

Nothing says legit like an Olympic gold medal. That's exactly what Kurt Angle has that no one else in WWE can lay claim to. Kurt won the honor in the 1996 Olympic Games in Atlanta, Georgia - and shortly thereafter was offered a lucrative contract to join the World Wrestling Federation. Kurt believed in himself, maybe a little too much for the world of professional wrestling.

During initial contract negotiations, Angle was so high on himself that he outright told Vince McMahon and the rest of WWF brass that he would never be able to lose to another wrestler because of his illustrious amateur career. A couple years later (and a couple hundred thousand dollars lighter), Angle signed a contract with the company and, in 1999, debuted for the WWF.

It didn't take long for Kurt to catch on to the business; he's often (and correctly) credited as being the quickest rookie to ever grasp the art form.

Angle's in-ring work was second-to-none and his intensity (plus, intelligence and integrity of course) was so well accepted by audiences that he won every major singles title within his first 12 months in the WWF.


1. Brock Lesnar

Brock Lesnar Tattoo
WWE.com

It's incredibly difficult to surpass an Olympic gold medalist, in terms of believability in pro wrestling, but somehow, Brock Lesnar has managed to do that.

After winning the NCAA Heavyweight Championship in 2000 following a second-place finish in '99, Brock Lesnar arrived in WWE with an impressive pedigree. Like Angle, he quickly rose up the WWE ranks and, 6 months after debuting on the main roster (even faster than Kurt), Brock became the youngest WWE Champion in history at 25. In '04, Brock left WWE and eventually turned towards the incredibly tough, competitive environment of the UFC. In 2008, Lesnar defeated Randy Couture to become the new UFC Heavyweight Champion - a title he would successfully defend multiple times.

All these accomplishments provided Brock with an even more impressive background when he returned to WWE in 2011 than when he first joined the company in 2002. A couple of unprecedented victories over The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXX (ending The Streak) and John Cena at SummerSlam 2014 (a one-sided main event squash match for the WWE Championship), and Brock Lesnar can easily lay claim to being the most believable WWE superstar of all-time.


In this post: 
Brock Lesnar
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A former stuntman for Paramount Pictures, Matt enjoys sports, water skiing, driving fast, the beach, professional wrestling, technology, and scotch. At the same time, whenever possible. Having attended many famous (and infamous) shows including WrestleMania XV, In Your House: Mind Games, and the 1995 King of the Ring, Matt has been a lifelong professional sports and wrestling fan. Matt's been mentioned in numerous wrestling podcasts including the Steve Austin Show: Unleashed, Talk Is Jericho, and Something To Wrestle With Bruce Prichard. As a former countywide performer, Matt has been referred to as Mr. 300 for his amazing accomplishments in the world of amateur bowling. He is also the only man on record to have pitched back-to-back no hitters in the Veterans Stadium Wiffle Ball League of 2003.