10 Most Chilling Wrestling Gimmicks Ever

Worm-eating nightmares, psychotic clowns, and flesh-devouring cannibals...

paul bearer undertaker
wwe.com

Pop quiz: where can characters depicted as real-life athletes mix with those said to be from the underworld? Why, in the wacky realm of pro wrestling, of course! Where else could you find an industry once happy to present Bret Hart as an athletic champion on the same roster as nightmare fuel like shaman witch doctors and undead zombies?

Wrestling has always been weird, and the sooner people get to grips with that the better. "Weird" shouldn't be taken as an insult either, because wrestling is also absolutely wonderful. It's home to some of the best athleticism on the planet, but also characters that make you check underneath the bed or make you terrified to go to the toilet alone in the middle of the night.

Some fans may have grown up to see through these ghoulish guises, but that doesn't change the fact a quick jog down memory lane can bring feelings of fear creeping back up...

10. Bray Wyatt

bray wyatt
WWE.com

Only in wrestling could a bearded cult-leader with possible serial killer vibes be considered for a babyface run. That's the fate staring Bray Wyatt in the face, such popularity coming despite the fact he reminds everyone of a character from the old Goosebumps TV series. Wyatt is spooky, and that'd be true even if he didn't occasionally walk upside down like a human crab.

When he's not encouraging everyone around him to "Run", Bray has been followed to the ring by huge men wearing sheep masks and even once sported goat horns that make him look like the devil. The beauty of Wyatt's gimmick is that it instantly reminds older fans of classic gimmicks from the cartoon age of wrestling.

If only WWE didn't consistently undermine Wyatt on television, perhaps he'd be higher on this list. The potential is there for Bray's 'Eater Of World's persona to be even scarier if his paymasters didn't deem it necessary to leave his powerful promos looking empty inside the ring.


9. Se7en

Seven WCW.jpg
WWE Network

If there's one thing The Undertaker taught everybody in the early-1990s, it's that large hats and dead-looking eyes are frightening. Using that template, Dustin Runnels debuted the Se7en character in WCW towards the end of that decade. Had it lasted longer, toilet roll sales would have gone through the roof.

Floating to the ring and ominously looking down at the cameras, Se7en had previously been seen peering through the windows of children. No, he wasn't wrestling's own version of Jimmy Savile (himself a wrestler, mind); Se7en was instead all about the 'Seven Deadly Sins' and more akin to a twisted nightmare festering in a kid's mind.

Watch 2014's The Babadook for an example of what may have been possible with Se7en had Turner's standards and practices not grown worried the character would come across as a child snatcher. WCW aborted the concept completely as soon as Se7en debuted on TV, but it could have been special.


8. Mankind

Mankind WWE
WWE.com

So dedicated to the idea of paying Mankind effectively was Mick Foley that the madman ripped chunks of his own hair out during performances. Somehow, Mankind later became a lovable idiot character fans admired, even though Foley had played the Leatherface-style masked persona perfectly for years.

Screaming like a stuck pig and tormented (at least according to the WWF's announcers) by his own thoughts, Mankind was an amazing character from 1996-97. That first year of Foley's run in particular threw up countless memorable moments that turned Mankind from potential cartoon disaster into one of the promotion's most horrific assets.

A slick backstory involving childhood genius also came into play at points. Walking to the ring as moody music blared over the PA system, Mankind was then soothed post-match by gentle piano lullabies that caused him to rock back and forth. Long before 'Mr. Socko' and babyface brilliance, Mankind was eerie as hell.


7. Goldust

Goldust and Marlena
WWE.com

Chilling for an entirely different reason to almost every other character in WWE/WCW history, Goldust's ingenuity lay in playing off real-life prejudice. Initial Hollywood characteristics upon his debut in 1995 swiftly gave way to a homosexual overtone that turned Goldust into one of the WWF's most original gimmicks ever.

This was another winner in the 'frightening as heck' category for Dustin Runnels. If anything, his later guise as Se7en in WCW was always going to struggle when following such an almighty example of acting ability. Watch any Goldust performance from the first few years of his run and be prepared to experience supreme believability.

It was conceivable that Goldust lusted after fellow superstars in a bid to leave them racked with doubt, just as it was believable that this blonde-wig wearing freak didn't follow the same unwritten rules of social conduct as everyone else. Pushing the envelope and played to the hilt, Goldust's creep factor was majestic at first.


6. Papa Shango

Papa Shango
WWE.com

Visualise being a kid watching WWF programming in 1992. Just as you've come to terms with The Undertaker and actually started to like the undead zombie with the dull stare and deliberate movements, along comes a shaman witch doctor (possibly from hell) to provide fresh scares.

Papa Shango is something of a missed opportunity for the WWF. Charles Wright - the man behind the face-painted gimmick - could work, and he really should have been a success. Unfortunately, Shango was only ever destined to stick around for a year or so before being canned. All those potential scares, lost forever.

When he wasn't causing babyfaces like The Ultimate Warrior to spew otherworldly goo from their lungs, Shango was carrying around shrunken heads and ever-shrouded in smoke and mystery. Wright's facial expressions alone were enough to cause wide eyes from kids and adults alike during his brief run under the gimmick.


5. The Undertaker

The Undertaker Ministry of Darkness
WWE.com

You had to know this guy was going to pop up at some point. By far one of the most infamous gimmicks in pro wrestling folklore, The Undertaker has only just (potentially) retired from active wrestling. Should WrestleMania 33 be his last hurrah, then 'Taker leaves behind decades of hair-raising moments.

It isn't just the original 'Deadman' Undertaker that qualifies either, because fans who watched during the 'Attitude Era' will recall a character who attempted to crucify Steve Austin and sacrifice Stephanie McMahon. All the while 'Taker acted like some sort of infernal overlord. The 'Ministry Of Darkness' gimmick was by far one of the best incarnations of Undertaker.

Go back to those early days of 1990-93 for a character that left children petrified of the giant zombie ambling his way towards ringside. Paul Bearer, 'Taker's long-serving manager, must take some credit for feeding the fear machine too, because his shrill performances complemented the mute, haunting presence of The Undertaker amazingly well.


4. Kane

Kane WWE
WWE.com

Take The Undertaker, blend him with Michael Myers from the Halloween movie franchise and you'd have the freakish aura of Kane. The character would become less fearsome over time, but the original masked man was utterly horrifying when he first appeared in late-1997. Even Paul Bearer's warnings to Undertaker that his brother was incoming were palpable.

Said to be impervious to pain, devoid of human emotion and burned beyond repair by fires as a child, Kane really should have made adults laugh during the late-90s - that was the era of more realistic characters like Steve Austin, after all. Instead of mirth though, fans were struck by great performances and an intoxicating feud between so-called siblings that peaked at WrestleMania XIV.

WWE have mucked around with Kane's backstory so much that they've killed the impact of it, but even watching old Kane appearances on the Network still sends a chill up the spine. Bathed in red light and accompanied by unnerving organ music, Kane was always good for a fright during the first few years of his tenure.


3. Kamala

WWE

Taking every opportunity he could to remind viewers of what might happen should Kamala get his hands on them, Bobby Heenan regularly said on commentary that the cannibal would put them in a big pot. Oh yeah, he was saying this when the WWF largely catered towards young children. Lovely.

If the prospect of being eaten alive wasn't enough to scare people, then the imposing sight of Kamala himself would do it. Led to the ring by his 'handler' Kim-Chee and manager Harvey Wippleman, the 'Ugandan Giant' looked dangerous and out of control as he slapped his belly and contorted a face covered in tribal paint.

Kamala was never the best in-ring performer, but that mattered little when he had such an intimidating gimmick. Credit must be dished out the way of Jim Harris (the man behind the character), because he turned Kamala into a believable horror, one who would apparently enjoy eating fans.


2. The Boogeyman

The Boogeyman
WWE.com

"I'm the Boogeyman, and I'm coming to get you," is a catchphrase that few will ever forget. The Boogeyman was never treated very seriously as a top threat in WWE, yet there was always a sharp intake of breath whenever he gyrated violently or consumed another gut full of live worms.

For the avoidance of any doubt, those worms were not fake. In other words, Boogeyman was actually eating the annelids on live television like they were popcorn, a move that instantly disgusted fans around ringside and put everyone off their overpriced hot dogs. Add face paint, twisted facial expressions, and childlike fear into the mix and he was very effective.

Much like Papa Shango, The Boogeyman has become more infamous after his run than during it. Marty Wright (no relation to Charles), must have loved scaring the pants off of fans each time he showed up to smash another clock over his head. Those worms though, was there really any need?


1. Doink The Clown

Evil Doink the clown
WWE.com

Curse the WWF creative team for trying to turn Doink The Clown into a happy, smiling babyface. That was never the way Doink was supposed to be, at least not when Matt Borne went under the greasepaint and green wig. During Borne's time as the clown, Doink was a demented jester with a smile so sinister it could make your blood curl.

Debuting in 1992, the mischievous, downright evil prankster had a sad aura hidden beneath the striking circus colours. Much like Papa Shango, Doink was a much better in-ring worker than he was given credit for in the WWF, but it seems Vince McMahon was much more interested in turning his resident clown into a fan favourite than pursuing Borne's twisted vision.

An awful lot of people have an irrational fear of clowns. Matt Borne's portrayal of Doink made that easy to understand, most notably when he was giggling away like a man possessed or playing tricks on unassuming audience members.

When Doink turned babyface, crowds chanted "Kill The Clown". Upon Doink's debut, there were likely some wishing the same fate, albeit for very different reasons.

-

What other characters would you consider wrestling's most chilling? Let us know your frightening thoughts down in the comments section below!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.