10 Most Emotional Wrestling Matches

"No More Tears" means nothing in pro wrestling...

Fastlane The Shield

Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose have lived the past six years plus as close friends sharing the same dreams in WWE. At Fastlane on Sunday, one could see how much a seemingly filler six-man tag main event meant to the trio; it could be a watershed match for these guys as The Shield, but there's something more important to them.

The emotion of the moment.

Emotion, whether happiness, sadness, anger, fear or a combo of all the above, has been part of the wrestling sphere since forever. Indeed, provoking a certain feeling from the audience is part and parcel of the industry, and it's those hooks that keep people coming back for more. Feeling something, it seems, is an addictive thing.

You won't be shocked (another emotive response!) to see names like Ric Flair, Daniel Bryan, Bret Hart and The Undertaker on this list. You might, however, be slightly surprised by some of the matches chosen from their careers, or the feelings they conjured up in fans worldwide when watching them. Again, emotion comes in many different forms...


10. CM Punk vs. John Cena (MITB 2011)

Cm Punk Money In The Bank 2011
WWE.com

...like the threat of rioting if fans don't get a result which leaves them euphoric.

At Money In The Bank 2011, that was exactly what was on the cards. People in Chicago were there to see one result and one result only: a CM Punk win over villain of the piece John Cena. If they didn't get it, then they were going to tear the place apart, and possibly Cena for having the audacity to upend their hero on such a passion-fuelled night.

WWE chose the smart option by putting Punk over clean as a whistle. Had they booked any other outcome, there may have been hell to pay, and everyone knew it. There was a mob-like atmosphere to the air that night, and it was potentially hazardous if the hometown boy didn't win the WWE Title.

Every offensive move from Punk was met with wild cheers, and every strike from Cena was greeted like the dubious babyface was punching a puppy. This was Chicago's night, not WWE's, and so the pop that ushered in Punk's victory was one of the biggest in company history.


9. Christian vs. Alberto Del Rio (Extreme Rules 2011)

Christian World Title
WWE.com

Edge must've already been an emotional wreck when he pulled into Tampa on 1 May 2011. The prior month, he'd officially retired from wrestling due to serious, career-ending injuries, and he vacated the old World Heavyweight Title into the bargain. Adding to the rollercoaster, his best friend won it at Extreme Rules.

Tears fell like rain.

As soon as Christian hauled the strap down from atop his ladder perch, the live crowd could sense that this meant everything to both childhood friends. They'd been through so many memorable moments together, but this one belonged exclusively to Christian. For the first time, he was the one standing in his own spotlight, and Edge could only look up at him with pride.

WWE's cameras caught an excellently affecting moment when they snapped a crying Edge soaking his pal's success in. That, along with Christian's own amazement at finally bagging the big one in WWE, made this extremely special.


8. Ric Flair vs. Big Van Vader (Starrcade 1993)

Ric Flair Vader Starrcade2
WWE.com

It's borderline laughable to fans now, but it was believable that then-44 year old Ric Flair could walk away from the biz for good in 1993. That's why there was so much riding on his 'Career vs. Title' match with Big Van Vader at the 10th anniversary of Starrcade, an event Flair had headlined first against Harley Race.

People were willing to buy into the notion that the 'Nature Boy' (who was returning 'home' from a stint in the WWF) might be done, and they took the physical threat of Race's man Vader very seriously. This, if you haven't seen it before, is traditional wrestling drama done right. Everyone played their part, even announcer Gene Okerlund when he visited the Flair household and interviewed Ric en route to the arena.

It was simple, yet genius, and it told the tale of a man who may well be ousted from the industry he adored by a ruthless heel. By the time Flair arrived at Charlotte's Independence Arena, his adoring throngs were whipped into a fervour by the growing belief that maybe, just maybe, he'd topple the beastly Vader and become World Champ again.

When Ric did, the place went berserk.


7. Eddie Guerrero vs. Brock Lesnar (No Way Out 2004)

Eddie Guerrero WWE Champion
WWE.com

"Ugh, he's so tiny".

Those, according to Bruce Prichard on his podcast, were the words of Vince McMahon when he clapped eyes on Eddie Guerrero for the very first time. To the boss, there was zero chance that his new fiery Latino signing would ever become WWE Champion. Guys that size had to possess something very extraordinary to make it practical.

Good news: Guerrero did. He, without hyperbole, was one of the most talented, over and cherished stars of a generation when he rocked up to No Way Out 2004 for a match with McMahon pet project Brock Lesnar. In an inspiring moment, Vince changed his mind and decided to put his biggest prize on Eddie. History was made, and Kleenex sales went through the bloody roof.

There's a beautiful picture of Eddie standing on the entrance ramp with the WWE Title in his right hand and the referee raising his left. His eyes are puffy from crying, and it's clear to see he was overwhelmed by what had just happened. Rarely has the chant, "You Deserve It" been more apt.


6. Daniel Bryan & Shane McMahon vs. Sami Zayn & Kevin Owens (WrestleMania 34)

Daniel Bryan Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Alright, alright, so you're already outraged that another match isn't here. WrestleMania XXX, the site of Daniel Bryan's first WWE Title coronation almost was, but consider the journey for a second. In the following four years, Bryan would go through so much emotional torture that it seemed impossible he'd ever wrestle again.

Then, when rumours started to circulate about his health improving, most figured he'd work outside WWE. They'd never let him work in a company ring again, surely. So much for that. On 20 March 2018, Daniel proudly stood mid-ring on SmackDown and announced he'd been cleared by WWE doctors to resume his career.

His rousing speech about fighting for your dreams was as dramatic as it was poignant. This was a man who was living proof of what he was saying. Suddenly, WrestleMania 34 took on more significance as the event hosting Bryan's comeback match.

The whole thing was a blur, and that speaks to its emotion. Bryan could've been wrestling a WWE Brawlin' Buddy toy that night for all fans cared. They were just so happy to see him doing what he loved.


5. Randy Savage vs. The Ultimate Warrior (WrestleMania VII)

Randy Savage Miss Elizabeth WrestleMania VII
WWE.com

Love, now there's a powerful tool that can be used to stir emotion.

At WrestleMania VII, the WWF didn't have to try too hard. They had a purpose-built, natural story of two lovebirds who had grown apart on screen when Randy Savage disgusted Miss. Elizabeth by once again turning heel. So, what changed? Randy's career prospects, that's what.

He lost to The Ultimate Warrior at 'Mania, and that meant (in storyline) he was done; in reality, the plan was to lessen Randy's workload as an in-ring talent. Consequently, Savage turned babyface when his manager Sherri hammered him post-match and Liz made the save. True love overcomes all was the overarching narrative.

When Randy and his darling Elizabeth embraced for the first time in years, fans lost their sh*t. Grown men were sobbing in the stands, women were yearning for a love so strong in their lives and everyone collectively fawned over the moment. A wedding was to come, and that meant more tears.


4. Shawn Michaels vs. The Undertaker (WrestleMania XXVI)

Shawn Michaels Retirement
WWE.com

Most wrestlers would be lucky to have one memorable run in wrestling, let alone two. Then again, not many are Shawn Michaels. His stint in WWE from 2002-2010 arguably topped his first from 1987-1998. It was world class, and nobody wanted to see it come to an end. Sadly, they say, all things must.

To borrow another cliche, if you're gonna' go out, do it in style. Ol' HBK sure did.

His back-to-back matches against The Undertaker at WrestleManias XXV and XXVI are legendary, but it was the latter that inflamed the senses and had tear ducts swelling. Michaels' sad puppy dog face as he waved to fans in Arizona captured the dawning realisation that he was readying to say goodbye for good.

Well, not for good, because Shawn returned at Crown Jewel last year. That, despite what any critics say, cannot sully the impact of his 'proper' send off in 2010. The saddest part of it was that Michaels, had he wished, could've easily gone on for years at half speed and still been the best on the roster.


3. Bret Hart vs. Shawn Michaels (Survivor Series 1997)

Montreal Screwjob
WWE.com

You knew it was coming.

Emotional matches in pro wrestling history can't come up without the infamous 'Montreal Screwjob'. It's one of the most discussed incidents in WWE ever, and with good reason. It offered a different kind of emotion to everything else out there, if only 'cause it was 100% real and dangled backstage politics in front of the viewer.

There's a quite dizzying amount of turmoil to be found in Bret Hart's story. His anger at Vince McMahon's treachery, the volley of spit he aimed at his gaffer's face when he realised he'd been had, Shawn Michaels' brattish display as he left the arena with the WWF Title and his cries of innocence when confronted by a distraught 'Hitman' in the locker room are still all too much around 22 years on.

That's before one even gets to Bret punching Vince, drawing out the letters 'WCW' with his hands as the pay-per-view ticked down and the fallout of "Bret Screwed Bret" which led to the Mr. McMahon character. Survivor Series '97 will forever be remembered as one of WWE's most controversial nights.


2. Chris Benoit vs. Bret Hart (WCW Nitro, 1999)

Bret Hart Chris Benoit Owen
WWE Network

Things got 100x more emotional for Bret when he heard the news that his baby brother Owen had tragically passed away following an accident at the WWF's Over The Edge show in 1999. WCW hadn't been a happy place for Hart anyway, and now he had to deal with the heart-wrenching fact that he'd never see his sibling again.

In October of the same year, WCW (to their credit) handed Bret the chance to pay tribute to Owen the only way he knew how. He'd wrestle Chris Benoit on Nitro in a technical clinic, one that'd give Bret the chance to celebrate Owen's legacy in the very same arena he'd fallen to his death some six months before.

There was emotion before the bell rang, to say the least.

Some may be annoyed that Benoit is here. To those folks, this writer says look at the bigger picture. This wasn't really about Benoit anyway. Nah, it was more about Bret wrestling a fellow Canadian on a night when he wanted the chance to look up to the heavens and say thank you to his brother.


1. Ric Flair vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania XXIV)

Ric Flair Shawn Michaels Wrestlemania 24
WWE.com

Let's end on a less morbid note.

If people had believed Ric Flair's career might end back at Starrcade '93, then they were really positive it could by 2008's WrestleMania XXIV. The angle had Flair wrestling a potential last match every time he stepped foot in the ring, and that included his 'Mania miracle against Shawn Michaels.

Aged 59, Ric somehow upheld his end of the bargain and delivered the kind of match a Flair-adoring kid-come-superworker like Michaels must have always dreamed about. This, without question, was the best bout Ric had worked for years and years, possibly decades. It was destined to end in tears.

HBK's pre-Superkick whisper of, "I'm sorry, I love you" told it all. So did Flair's bubbling as he pictured retirement from the ring, and a remorseful Shawn contemplating what he'd done on the ring apron. The next night, Flair would get a fitting send off by WWE. Even though he'd spoil things a tad by returning to the ring a few times afterwards, nothing could destroy the emotion of 'Mania.

What other matches would you consider the most emotional, and why? Let us know down in the comments!


Watch Next


In this post: 
The Shield
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.