10 Most Inept General Managers In WWE History
Mr. McMahon has a lot to answer for...
WWE’s over-reliance on authority figures is a well-worn topic at this point. The company have spent much of the past few decades shoehorning such characters into Raw and SmackDown’s most important storylines, often at the expense of regular talent. Stephanie McMahon emasculating and dressing-down active members of the WWE roster is still a common sight in 2016, and with General Managers and Commissioners still dominating much of WWE’s airtime, the trend isn’t disappearing any time soon.
It’s hardly surprising, given this company’s tendency to take a good thing and do it to death. Eric Bischoff’s villainous WCW persona might have introduced wrestling fans to the “evil boss” concept, but Mr. McMahon undoubtedly perfected the act. WWE have tried to replicate the character’s success on countless occasions since, but it wore thin a long time ago.
The likes of Vince, William Regal and Daniel Bryan prove that a well-written authority figure can still play an important role in wrestling, but WWE’s haven’t always been the strongest hands, particularly throughout the modern era.
WWE history is a minefield of Raw and SmackDown General Managers who were just straight-up bad at their job and accomplished very little as a result. Here are the limp, ineffective, and unassertive GMs who never convinced fans of their authority, AKA the 10 most inept General Managers in WWE history.
10. Donald Trump
Donald Trump has had various flirtations with World Wrestling Entertainment over the years. An alleged lifelong wrestling fan and friend of Vince McMahon, his Trump Plaza has played host to two WrestleManias, and he’s been featured on a number of shows himself. Most notably, Trump stood in Bobby Lashley’s corner as he competed against Umaga (who had McMahon in his corner) in a ‘Mania XX “Hair vs. Hair” match.
Lashley won the match and he, Trump, and Stone Cold Steve Austin shaved Vince bald as soon as the match was over, but let’s be honest, if there’s anyone who could benefit from cutting it off and starting again, it’s The Donald.
Trump assumed a brief authority figure role in June 2009, when McMahon announced that he’d sold the show to the current US Presidential candidate. Trump confirmed the move, but his spell as GM lasted just a single night: Vince bought Raw back the next week, and Trump hasn’t appeared since.
So why the inclusion? Trump wasn’t in power long to enact many major changes, but he did introduce the concept of Raw’s weekly guest host/General Manager, another of Raw’s most derided tropes over the years. This makes Trump directly responsible for Dennis Miller’s horrific showing on the 2009 Slammys edition of Raw, the shambolic Jeremy Piven/Ken Jeong episode, and a host of other guest GM-related crimes.
9. Teddy Long
Teddy Long is a charismatic guy. He’s occupied a number of different roles throughout his 30-year career in the wrestling business, and his loose personality initially made for a welcomed contrast to the stiff, all-business types that typically occupied Raw and SD’s GM roles. Moreover, he ruled the roost on SmackDown for four full years before moving on to ECW, then back to the Blue Brand. He must have been a good General Manager, right?
Absolutely not.
The idea of throwing Long - who’d worked exclusively as a manager and referee for WWE up until then - into an authority role felt random enough, but his reign was characterised by one thing alone: repetitiveness.
Teddy Long had precisely two solutions to any given problem. If a single wrester is getting unruly, he’s going one-on-one with The Undertaker. If a group of four or more workers are causing a ruckus… it looks like we’ve got ourselves a tag team match, “playa”.
Long undoubtedly has his strengths as a performer, but his inept decision-making has become a running joke in professional wrestling. Can anyone name a single memorable thing that Teddy did throughout his tenure as GM?
Didn’t think so.
8. Jonathan Coachman
The Coach carved out a nice little career for himself in WWE. He joined the company in 1999 after working for a Kansas City news station, during which he acted as a correspondent during coverage of Owen Hart’s passing, and initially operated as an interviewer and commentator for WWE.
Treated mostly as a punching bag for The Rock’s crude humour through his early days, Coachman became Eric Bischoff’s assistant in 2003, and ascended to the position of interim Raw General Manager throughout 2006 and 2007. He’d act as the show’s authority figure when the McMahons were absent, and “enjoyed” a six-week spell as a fully-fledged GM following Vince McMahon’s on-screen death in June 2007.
Though nowhere near as bad as some of this list’s entrants, Coachman suffered by being completely unsuited to the job. WWE had taken an entirely unremarkable former Sunday Night Heat commentator whose greatest claim to fame in the company was being forced to sing and dance on-camera by The Rock. What kind of authority can a man like that possibly have?
Coachman’s broadcasting career has taken off since leaving WWE, and he was relatively effective at drawing crowd heat, but you’ll struggle to find many men less suited to being Raw GM.
7. Hornswoggle (Or, Raw's Anonymous General Manager)
The Anonymous Raw General Manager angle remains one of WWE’s most contrived stories of the past decade. Kicking off in June 2010, Vince McMahon made the decision to fire Bret Hart, set up a laptop at ringside, and had an anonymous figure call Raw’s shots via emails read by Michael Cole.
It was a complete disaster. There was a certain degree of intrigue around the Anonymous GM’s identity to start (Shane McMahon’s name was regularly brought up), but the angle slowly petered-out. WWE reportedly started the story with no plans concrete regarding the GM’s identity, panicked for a solution throughout the story’s lifespan, and paid it off in the most unsatisfying manner imaginable: Hornswoggle.
A universally despised angle, but the Anonymous GM was able to enact a certain degree of authority over Raw at angle’s inception. This saves him from a higher position, but the fact that Hornswoggle wasn’t revealed as the man behind it until so long after the laptop had disappeared more than justifies his inclusion.
6. John Laurinaitis
Transitioning the former Johnny Ace from his backstage role to a General Manager’s position looked to be an attempt at capitalising on his growing reputation as a backstage politician and authoritarian. Name-dropped in CM Punk’s infamous “pipe bomb” promo, Laurinaitis went on to appear as Vince McMahon’s stooge throughout the summer, before being appointed Raw General Manager in October 2011.
His early days were shambolic. Barely able to string a sentence together, Laurinaitis’ segments were cripplingly boring and incredibly difficult to get through. “People Power” had its supporters, but Big Johnny’s lack of naturally charisma and irritating voice made it tough to take him seriously, particularly when he started hanging around with a coffee-slurping David Otunga, and driving a scooter to the ring.
Laurainitis’ spell on SmackDown was even more embarrassing. Earning control of the brand at WrestleMania XXVII, Laurinaitis had next to no positive impact on the blue brand. He was so focused on Raw storylines and feuding with John Cena that he struggled to get anything done on-air, and was fired after just three months on the jobs.
A memorable authority figure, but definitely not an adept one.
5. Mick Foley
Mick Foley was fantastic in his role as WWE Commissioner in the early 2000’s. He’s one of the most likeable personalities in WWE history, and while he didn’t have a huge impact in the role, he was a much-needed alternative to the McMahon family’s rampant nepotism. All Foley wanted to do was swing his gavel and make sure everyone had a nice day.
Who could possibly hate on that?
His inclusion isn’t for his time as Commissioner, nor his brief spell as co-Raw GM with Steve Austin. No, Mick Foley is here for his current bumbling General Manager persona on Monday Night Raw.
Foley is currently being presented as a guy who has no clue what he’s doing. His decisions regularly cause problems for his roster, and, more importantly, Stephanie McMahon. He and Steph have come dangerously close to butting heads on a number of occasions, and after failing to control the ongoing Kevin Owens/Seth Rollins/Triple H situation, Mick’s future doesn’t look good.
Whether deliberately or on purpose, Foley even flubbed the Cruiserweight Division’s introduction this week. From a storyline perspective, it looks like Mick is being set up for an eventual fall, but while Daniel Bryan does a solid job on SmackDown, Foley is a wet blanket on Raw.
4. Tiffany
Tiffany debuted in WWE’s ECW revival as GM Teddy Long’s assistant in June 2008, and succeeded Long in his role when he moved back to SmackDown 10 months later. She was relatively active early on, and her first course of action was to set up an elimination tournament to crown the number one contender to Jack Swagger’s ECW Championship, but the wheels came off just a few weeks into her promotion.
Tiffany was written-off television after suffering an injury during a developmental match shortly after becoming GM. She missed several months of airtime as a result, returned in October 2010, and ECW was cancelled just four months later. Her last act was to spear Rosa Mendes after she and Zack Ryder had interfered in an ECW Title match, and that was that for Tiffany as a WWE authority figure.
Tiffany was nowhere near ready for such a prominent role at the time of asking, and her appointment never felt like anything other than another one of Vince McMahon’s cruel jokes at ECW’s expense. Tiffany would later reinvent herself as a solid wrestler in TNA, but her WWE TV appearances were embarrassingly poor, and her habit of enunciating every single word she spoke had viewers across the world reaching for the mute button as soon as she showed up.
3. Bret Hart
Installing a beloved WWE legend as General Manager can be hit or miss. When it works (Steve Austin), it’s a great way of building instant camaraderie between the authority figure and fanbase, but when it’s bad, it’s really bad.
Bret “The Hitman” Hart served as Raw General Manager for a very brief time period. His spell in charge lasted just 28 days, and coincided with his utterly pointless reign as United States Champion. His first act was to vacate said title, which R-Truth won, before setting up qualifiers for the Fatal 4-Way PPV.
This is when things started falling apart. The qualifiers included Batista, who was injured at the time, and was so affronted by Hart’s decision that he quit Raw on the same night. In his first night on the job, Bret Hart had successfully alienated one of his brand’s biggest stars. Good job, Hitman.
Things got worse, though. The Nexus were running wild through WWE at the time, and after firing Wade Barrett and declining to offer the rest of the stable contracts, Hart was viciously assaulted by the group. This complete inability to control his roster saw Vince McMahon remove Bret from his position the following week, and while he probably shouldn’t have had the job in the first place, Hart goes down as one of the least effective GMs in history.
2. Brad Maddox
Nothing about Brad Maddox’s WWE career made sense. Debuting as a crooked referee who aided CM Punk to a victory at Hell in a Cell 2012, he claimed that he acted not out of bias, but because he held a lifelong dream of becoming a WWE superstar. Quite an odd way to apply for a job, but regardless, Maddox had his chance to earn a contract against Ryback a week later, and was promptly flattened.
Maddox’s search for a job continued on SmackDown, and after serving as Vickie Guerrero’s Managing Assistant for a while, Maddox was inexplicably named Raw General Manager in July 2013. He was, of course, a complete failure, but his ineptitude didn’t always come from his own actions.
Triple H, Stephanie McMahon, and Randy Orton came together as The Authority one month after Maddox’s appointment, effectively rendering him useless. With the McMahon faction acting as Raw’s primary authority figures, Maddox was treated like a corporate puppet, and his presence was completely unnecessary.
They strung the poor sod along in his useless role for almost a year before finally cutting him loose, and Maddox made his WWE departure shortly afterwards.
Never before has a General Manager been so invisible on WWE television. He’d occasionally show up on Raw to book an inconsequential lower-card match here and there, but that was the extent of it. The Authority made Brad Maddox powerless, and WWE were never able to find the right role for him.
1. Mike Adamle
Hands up everyone who expected the top choice to be someone other than Mike Adamle.
Nobody?
Fantastic.
Mike Adamle isn’t just the most inept General Manager in WWE history, but one of the most uncomfortable performers the business has ever seen. The former American Gladiators commentator was initially brought in as an interviewer back in 2008, and famously referred to Jeff Hardy as “Jeff Harvey” in his debut.
The gaffes were non-stop from thereon out, and when Adamle transitioned from Raw interviewer to ECW announcer in April, things went from bad to worse. His errors and stiff delivery made him a stifling presence on ECW, and Adamle quickly became a laughing stock. He bombed as both an interviewer and announcer, so what did WWE do? Why, make him General Manager of their flagship show of course!
This obviously didn’t go well. Poor old Mike was just as incoherent as GM as he was in his other roles, and even after close to a year with the company, he never looked like developing into a competent performer. Routinely embarrassed on a week-by-week basis, Adamle at least had the self-respect to resign from his position in October 2008, but his unparalleled ineptitude means he’ll never be forgotten by WWE fans.