10 Most Momentous WWE SummerSlam Title Changes In History
The Most Important Times A Belt Changed Hands At The Biggest Party Of The Summer.
A title change in wrestling can mean many things; the crowning of a new top star; the beginning of new main event storyline; somebody forgetting to kick out at two. All special moments in their own way.
Regardless of what they mean, title changes are usually always exciting. They have produced some of the biggest pops of all time and a night can go down in wrestling history off the strength of a good one. Nowhere has this been more evident than at The Biggest Party of the Summer.
SummerSlam's history is full of huge title changes, many of which would shape the very fabric of wrestling as we know it. Historic reigns began, new stars were made, and entire eras were kicked into gear with a just three slaps on the mat.
So let's round up the best and try and work out which SummerSlam title change has had the biggest impact on WWE. Whilst that impact may have been short term for some of these entries, other title changes had far-reaching rammifications - ones that can still be felt to this very day.
10. Triple H Wins The Intercontinental Championship (1998)
SummerSlam 1998 played host to just the fifth ladder match in WWE history, pitting Intercontinental Champion, The Rock, against his babyface challenger, Triple H.
Both men had been at each other's throats for months with the assistance of their respective factions - The Nation of Domination and D-Generation X - and things finally came to a head during the semi-main event of SummerSlam.
Their ladder match is widely regarded as a classic, one of the best early examples of the format, and ended with Trips claiming the gold with a little help from Chyna. This was Triple H's second Intercontinental Championship reign, but his first as a babyface, and his performance in this match got him over with the fans like never before. That's not to say that The Rock didn't come out of this match looking good - his stock was also elevated by his excellent showing here.
This was a star-making performance for both men, evidenced by the fact that they would both become world champion for the first time within a year of this SummerSlam - Triple H's title win coming the night after the following year's event.
9. The British Bulldog Wins The Intercontinental Championship (1992)
The only major WWE event held in the UK, SummerSlam 1992 drew over 80,000 fans to the old Wembley Stadium and most of those fans were there to watch their local hero fight for the Intercontinental Championship.
Davey Boy Smith, better know as "The British Bulldog", was basically royalty in the UK. He'd come up on the popular British TV show, World of Sport, and was arguably the most famous ambassador for the sport to ever hail from Britain.
Davey Boy's fans were rewarded for their loyalty in the main event of SummerSlam '92, when Smith was pitted against Intercontinental Champion and his own brother-in-law, Bret Hart. The Hitman helped Davey Boy to his best singles match ever and one of the best matches in SummerSlam history. He took the fall to give Davey his one and only Intercontinental Championship reign in front of a jubilant UK crowd.
This title switch didn't usher in a new era nor did it propel The Bulldog to the main event. However, this is a moment that has been committed to a nation's wrestling folklore and that has to be worth something, surely?
8. The New Day Win The WWE Tag Team Championships (2015)
Nestled in amongst SummerSlam 2015's blockbuster matches of John Cena vs Seth Rollins and The Undertaker's rematch with Brock Lesnar was a fairly inconspicuous 4-way match for the WWE Tag Team Championships. Champions The Prime Time Players (no, really, they were actually the champions for a bit) defended against The Lucha Dragons, Los Matadores, and The New Day.
Big E, Kofi, and Xavier had been dethroned by The Players one month earlier and were keen to get their straps back. This is exactly what happened, as Kofi pinned one of the Matadors to reclaim the gold.
Whilst New Day winning the match was a fairly predictable result, nobody could have predicted where this reign would take them. The trio would hold the gold for the rest of the year, beyond WrestleMania, through the following year's SummerSlam before finally dropping the titles in December 2016.
The New Day clocked in a whopping 483 days with the championships, breaking a 23-year-old record for the longest single reign with tag team championships in the history of WWE. For that reason, it's impossible to argue that this title change isn't historic, even if it was nothing to write home about at the time.
7. The Ultimate Warrior Wins The Intercontinental Championship (1988)
From one record-breaking reign beginning to one ending, as we travel back in time to the very first SummerSlam. The Honky Tonk Man was scheduled to defend his Intercontinental Championship against Brutus Beefcake, but Beefers had been taken out prior to the match.
These sorts of tactics were not uncommon during Honky's reign. Through a combination of dirty tricks and a big mouth, The Honky Tonk Man had held the Intercontinental Championship for a record-setting 434 days. However, it was that big mouth that sealed Honky's fate on this night when he grabbed a microphone and issued an open challenge for the belt. Seconds later, out came The Ultimate Warrior.
Warrior charged down and hit the ring so hard he flung poor Howard Finkel about 50 feet off the apron. Warrior then ran through a disoriented Honky before flattening him with The Ultimate Splash to win the championship in just thirty-one seconds.
Not only did the longest Intercontinental Championship reign of all time come to an end in this match, but it also gave SummerSlam its first marquee moment and signalled the rise of The Ultimate Warrior all the way to the top of the company.
6. Randy Orton Wins The World Heavyweight Championship (2004)
Emanating from the Air Canada Centre in Toronto, SummerSlam 2004 is most remembered either for the 14-minute long Triple H vs Eugene match or the fact that the crowd turned on almost everything. Are these two things linked? You can decide for yourselves...
One match from this show that is less remembered than it should is its main event, which saw World Heavyweight Champion, Chris Benoit, defend against Randy Orton. After twenty minutes of back and forth, Orton countered the Crippler Crossface into an RKO to win the match and the gold.
This was Orton's first of fourteen world title wins at time of writing, but what's more important is how old Randy was when he won the belt. At 24-years-old, Orton broke the record for the youngest person to win a world championship in WWE; a record he still holds to this day.
It was a remarkable achievement and a sign of the faith that WWE had in Orton at such a young age. That faith has been repaid many times over, as proven by Randy's continued successes. However, for obvious reasons, this match is never talked about in an official WWE capacity, which considerably harms its position on this list.
5. Brock Lesnar Wins The WWE Championship (2002)
SummerSlam 2002 was a stacked night of action that included Rey Mysterio's WWE Pay-Per-View debut, the in-ring return of Shawn Michaels, and a seismic main event between WWE Champion, The Rock, and Brock Lesnar.
Lesnar had made his main roster WWE debut only four months earlier, but already had a King of the Ring victory and an undefeated streak under his belt. As for The Rock, he was beginning to dip his toes in the waters of Hollywood and, as a result, was winding down his full-time wrestling career.
After a great match, Lesnar countered the Rock Bottom and hit Dwayne with a thunderous F5 to win his first WWE title at the age of just 25. This makes Lesnar the youngest person to win sports entertainment's greatest prize and, much like with Randy Orton, this win was a sign of things to come from The Beast.
Despite Randy breaking Brock's record two years later, Lesnar's title win is far more historic. Not only does it concern a more valuable championship, but it set in motion Lesnar's reign of dominance across multiple sports and laid the groundwork for him to become the special attraction he is today.
4. Charlotte Flair Wins The SmackDown Women's Championship (2018)
This entry is less about who won a championship at SummerSlam and more about who didn't. The 2018 edition of the event saw a SmackDown Women's Championship triple threat featuring champion, Carmella, Charlotte Flair, and a certain Becky Lynch.
Lynch had originally earned a one-on-one match with Carmella, but Charlotte was added to the mix upon her return to the WWE following surgery. This made Lynch more than a little annoyed at her supposed best friend, but the Irishwoman remained civil in the weeks leading up to SummerSlam. However, when Charlotte stole the victory from Becky during this match, The Lass Kicker had had enough.
Lynch attacked Charlotte after the bell, supposedly turning heel although you wouldn't know it from the rapturous applause she received from the crowd. Fans had been desperate for Lynch to portray herself more seriously and this "heel turn", coupled with their apathy to Charlotte winning yet another championship, gave them exactly what they wanted.
Charlotte's victory at SummerSlam was the catalyst for Becky Lynch's rise to stardom and her eventual spot in the main event of WrestleMania 35. It goes to show that even a disappointing decision in wrestling can come good in the end.
3. Brock Lesnar Wins The WWE Championship (2014)
If Lesnar's win over The Rock in 2002 laid the groundwork for his WWE dominance, then this match was the one that built the skyscraper. The Beast had returned to WWE in 2012, but had suffered a series of marquee losses that had severely dented his appeal. In 2014, WWE finally stopped messing Brock.
Ending The Undertaker's Streak at WrestleMania XXX would have been enough to secure Lesnar's legacy as one of the most brutal forces in pro wrestling, but WWE decided to give him even more kudos by booking him to absolute decimate John Cena at SummerSlam. The Mayor of Suplex City ate Cena alive in the show's main event and mercifully pinned him to win his first WWE Championship in over a decade.
From this win in 2014 to WrestleMania 36, Brock Lesnar was barely out of the world championship picture in WWE. He dominated the top of the card for almost six years, frustrating and delighting wrestling fans in equal measure. Lesnar's stranglehold on WWE can be traced back to this night and, for better or worse, that makes this match very important.
2. Randy Orton Wins The WWE Championship (2013)
SummerSlam 2013 will go down in history as a night that changed wrestling forever. The scheduled main event of the show ended with crowd favourite, Daniel Bryan, finally capturing the WWE Championship after a gruelling match with John Cena. This should have been Bryan's night to celebrate with his loyal fans, but a certain snake had other ideas.
Randy Orton, who was Mr. Money in the Bank at the time, made his way down to the ring and stared down a defiant Bryan. However, before the new champ could defend himself, he was sideswiped by the man who had just counted his winning pinfall - special referee, Triple H.
The Game laid out Bryan with a Pedigree and allowed Orton to cover his prone body and successfully cash in. Orton was champion, Bryan was defeated, and things would never be the same again.
This match not only signalled the beginning of The Authority - a stable that dominated WWE programming for the next two-and-a-half years - but it also set in motion Daniel Bryan's route to WrestleMania XXX and everything that followed. If you're looking for moments that shaped modern wrestling, then you won't find many more important than this.
1. Bret Hart Wins The WWF Championship (1997)
1997 was not a good time for WWE. They was losing the Monday Night Wars and were in desperate need of a shot in the arm. At SummerSlam 1997, they rolled up their sleeve.
The show's main event was The Undertaker defending the WWF Championship against Bret Hart with Shawn Michaels as Special Guest Referee. Just as his buddy, Triple H, would do sixteen years later, HBK got involved in the match with earth-shattering results. A chair shot intended for Hart accidentally struck Taker instead, allowing Bret to make the cover, forcing a reluctant Michaels to count the pin for his nemesis.
This would lead to a feud between Michaels and Taker that culminated in the first ever Hell in a Cell match in October. As a result of winning that match, Michaels got to face Bret Hart for the WWF title... at Survivor Series... in Montreal...
Yes, the single most industry-shifting moment in wrestling history can trace its roots back to SummerSlam 1997's main event and by that logic, so can the entire Attitude Era. This match may very well be the reason that WWE is still around today - how could it be anywhere else than at the top of this list?