10 Most Notorious WWE Diva Urban Legends

Sunny days, unexplained firings and Vince's devils.

You don't hear about too many scandals involving the WWE divas these days, do you? Most of the drama is reserved for the Total Divas 'reality' show. Even then, it's completely scripted and, really, the 'drama' is usually nothing more than John Cena being uncertain about marrying Nikki Bella or Paige getting a tattoo. It's totally lightweight stuff and makes you long for the days of more outrageous headlines. Before WWE went PG and cleaned up its image, there were no shortage of potentially scandalous stories concerning the WWE divas out there. Invariably, they tended to be of the 'who's sleeping with who' variety. Of course with a lot of these rumours/stories/accusations originating or gaining traction on the internet, it can be a tricky task trying to separate the fact from the fiction. The divas are a particularly easy target for fans, since their characters on television often engage in credibility-eroding acts. It's an easy leap to, say, assumed that Trish Stratus might be up to something backstage if she's willing to bark like a dog for Vince in the middle of the ring live on Monday night Raw, for example. But we shouldn't believe everything that we read and should exercise caution when we hear about a supposed affair or behind-the-scenes incident. So let's take a look at ten notorious WWE diva urban legends and try to separate the wheat from the chaff.


10. Sunny Days With Shawn Michaels And Bret Hart

The Legend: That Shawn Michaels and Sunny had a not-too-secret affair while both were working for the WWF in the mid-90s. There is also a rumour that Sunny had an affair with a married Bret 'The Hitman' Hart around the same time. The Evidence: Well, pretty much everyone involved, from Sunny to Shawn Michaels to Sunny's long-term boyfriend Chris Candido has admitted to the Shawn affair in the past. According to Sunny herself, the two had a nine month relationship while she was involved with Candido (who must have known about the whole thing). Michaels decided to stir up trouble with his on and off-screen rival Bret Hart in 1997 by claiming that Bret was having some 'Sunny days' during a Raw promo, which led to a backstage fight between the two. Bret and Sunny have both denied the rumour, claiming that they were just good friends and Michaels claim was the result of his paranoia at the time. As a side note, Sunny revealed in a 2012 shoot interview that she did have an on again/off again affair with Bret's brother-in-law The British Bulldog, who was married to Diana Hart at the time. Is It True: The Shawn affair, yes. The Bret one, no. Bret was very open about his past infidelities in his autobiography but maintains that Sunny was not one of his lovers. We should believe him.

9. Chyna Refused To Work With The Women In 2001 And Demanded To Challenge For The World Championship

The Legend: That Chyna's ego was out-of-control in 2001 that she refused to work with other women wrestlers and felt that she should be matched against the likes of Steve Austin and Triple H in PPV main events. The Evidence: There are a few reasons that have been posited for The Ninth Wonder of the World's dismissal on November 30th 2001. They range from 'she was fired because of the Triple H/Stephanie relationship' to 'she had problems with substance abuse' and everything in between. Jim Ross claimed in 2007 that Chyna was not released but chose to leave the company herself, for personal reasons. This is a story which Chyna refuted in a 2011 interview, stating:
I wanted to stay. I was not expecting to get a fax that said, "You will not be needed anymore" when I was still on contract. That was a surprise
Things had been sour between Chyna and WWE for some time. Although she was given her marching orders in November, she had been off television for several months. WWE had been displeased with Chyna's attitude, particular the idea that she was 'above' the Women's Championship and working with the likes of Trish Stratus, Lita and Ivory. Is It True: All reports at the time seem to indicate so, although the Stephanie McMahon/Triple H affair becoming public can't have helped matters.

8. A Chris Jericho/Kelly Kelly Affair?

The Legend: That Chris Jericho had an affair with Kelly Kelly. The Evidence: Pictures circulated online around 2009 that showed Chris Jericho and Kelly Kelly looking very cosy together (Google them, they're still out there). Most of the photos showed the pair in what appeared to be nightclubs. The most damning photo was of the pair sharing a kiss on the lips. Jericho has been married to his wife Jessica since 2000. They are, by all accounts, still together. Kelly has been reported to have dated several people within WWE, from Test to John Cena. Randy Orton (rather tastelessly) claimed in a 2011 radio interview that Kelly had 'slept with around ten guys' in the WWE locker room, for which he later apologised. Besides the pictures, there's not much else to go on. Most of the 'evidence' is just internet rumour and people making assumptions about Kelly and Jericho's characters. Is It True: Who knows? The trouble with the photos is that they're entirely without context. While a married man kissing a co-worker on the lips is bound to raise questions, it could be (and probably was) innocent. While it was a tad irresponsible on Jericho's part (and Kelly's for posting the pics on her official website) they should be given the benefit of the doubt.

7. Mickie James Was Fired For Reacting Badly To John Cena Breakup

The Legend: That Mickie James was fired after she reacted badly to breaking up with John Cena, who was married at the time. The Evidence: Former Spirit Squad member Kenny Dysktra was, at one point, engaged to Mickie James. The two dated during the mid-2000s for a number of years. Following Dykstra and Mickie James' WWE releases, however, he took to Twitter to air some dirty laundry about their relationship. According to Dykstra, James was having an affair with John Cena. In order for them to continue, Dykstra was moved to Smackdown to be kept out of the way (or so he claims). The disgruntled star tweeted that:
She was googling mickie james and john cena dating. I asked why, she broke down crying. Then I heard more from others. She was checking to see if it was on the net yet.
Continuing with his Twitter rant, Dykstra claimed that James wanted to date Cena and, when Cena declined, she lost the plot and was buried on television, then fired:
She wanted to date him, he said no, she flipped out backstage which led to her demise...When they were together she got the title, TV roles. When he dumped her she became Piggy James, then fired.
Dykstra came out with these allegations in 2012, two years after Mickie's release and four years after his own. Is It True: The timeline is a little vague but it's hard to know what Dykstra has to gain from making this public. By outing the company's top star like that, he's basically blackballed himself from WWE for life. He has no reason to lie but, without a rebuttal from Cena or James, if you think it's true then you're taking his word for it.

6. Chris Benoit Was Having An Affair With A Diva At The Time Of The Benoit Tragedy

The Legend: That Chris Benoit was having an adulterous affair with a WWE diva between 2006 - 2007. The Evidence: Chris and Nancy Benoit's relationship was the result of an adulterous affair: Kevin Sullivan, who was married to Nancy at the time, mandated that she and Chris should travel together when paired on-screen in WCW in 1996. Life imitated art when the two began a real-life affair. Nancy and Sullivan divorced in 1997. After the Benoit tragedy there was a lot of information reported about Chris and Nancy's personal life in the mainstream press. A lot of it was false. One interesting piece of information released was that Chris had been having an affair with an unnamed WWE diva during the final months of his life and that Nancy had found out about it. Some went so far as to speculate that it was a possible reason behind the tragedy. The question on everyone's lips, however, was: who was the diva that he supposedly had an affair with? Michelle McMcool and Victoria were two names mentioned, since they performed on the Smackdown brand with Benoit in 06/07. Irv Muchnick's controversial book Chris & Nancy published text messages that Benoit allegedly sent to another wrestler, requesting McCool's number. Is It True: Victoria addressed the rumours in a MySpace blog in June 2007. She stated:
A MySpace friend emailed me yesterday to let me know that a wrestling gossip website is claiming that they have an anonymous source or sources that say I was Chris Benoit€™s secret mistress at the time of his murder-suicide. First let me say, this is absolutely false. I invite the €œreporter€ from that website to come to my home city, and I will submit myself to a polygraph.
So she categorically denied the rumours. As for McCool? She became involved with The Undertaker soon after the Benoit tragedy. She has never confirmed nor denied the rumours and there appears to be little substance to them. Hardcore Holly, whom Chris travelled with, said in his book that Benoit was not cheating on Nancy.

5. WWE Fired Kharma Because She Got Pregnant

The Legend: That WWE fired Kharma because she had the temerity to get pregnant while working for the company. The Evidence: Well, it's not without precedent: WWE did fire Dawn Marie while she was in the early stages of her pregnancy in 2005. Marie sued WWE and the case was settled in late 2007. Marie hasn't been seen in WWE since. But is a poorly timed pregnancy the reason for Kharma's release in 2012? Kharma (real name Kia Stevens) revealed in May 2011 that she was pregnant. This news came only one month after WWE had started a big push for her on WWE TV. Obviously Kharma would need to take time out (up to a year) to have the baby and recover before she could come back to work. Unfortunately, Stevens lost the baby although she had claimed that she had given birth to a healthy baby girl. After the miscarriage, she fell into a depression and gained a lot of weight and wasn't in wrestling shape anymore. It was this, apparently, that led to WWE making the decision to let her go in July 2012. Is It True: No, WWE didn't fire Kharma because she got pregnant. She made a surprise appearance while under contract at the 2012 Royal Rumble (her only official WWE match). She was fired for being unable to shift weight while training for her comeback (as well as allegedly having a bad attitude and being difficult to deal with).

4. Why The Kat Was Fired

The Legend: Just why was former WWE diva The Kat released from her contract in February 2001? The Evidence: The Kat was one of the WWF's most popular female performers from late 1999 to early 2001. The real-life wife of Jerry 'The King' Lawler, she was involved in some pretty infamous moments including the time that she flashed her breasts (against the orders of management) at Armageddon 1999. Kat was involved in a storyline with the Right to Censor group in early 2001. Their feud resulted in a match between Lalwer and RTC foreman Steven Richards at No Way Out where, if Lawler won The Kat would get her 'right to nudity' but if Richards won then The Kat would have to join the censorious stable. Richards won the match and The Kat joined the group and then, just two days later, she was gone. Vince McMahon fired her. Lawler was understandably upset and demanded an explanation but none was forthcoming. He quit in protest. The Kat stayed quiet for years but when she did resurface and gave interviews in the late 2000s, she could not come up with a reason herself. The Verdict: So just why was The Kat released? There have been many reasons given but none appear concrete. One reason is that Chyna didn't want her around anymore and was jealous at The Kat being offered a Playboy cover shoot. Other sources cite The Kat having an attitude problem. Nobody can really give a definite answer as to why and, until Jim Ross or Vince McMahon come out an say outright, we'll probably never know.

3. Christy Hemme Was Released For Having An Affair With Triple H

The Legend: That Christy Hemme was released by WWE in December 2005 for 'acting inappropriately' around Triple H. The Evidence: Christy Hemme's release caught a lot of people off guard in 2005. She was reportedly well-liked by people backstage, was keen to learn and improve and already had a WWE-promoted Playboy spread under her belt. Out of all of the prospective divas of the time, Hemme was deemed to have the greatest upside. She had relocated to Louisville, Kentucky (home of OVW) so that she could continue to hone her skills even when she wasn't on the road. Hemme had done everything the company had asked of her, including giving Lillian Garcia a kiss on Raw (which was apparently punishment for Garcia partying a little too hard during a tour). With news of her release, the internet rumour mill went into overdrive. One reason that was reported was to do with Hemme 'acting inappropriately' around Triple H. Word got back to Stephanie who, needless to say, was less than pleased with Hemme's 'excitement' about travelling with her husband. Is It True: Neither Hemme, Triple H, Stephanie nor anyone from WWE has ever said that it is. Just after her release, Hemme cited budget cuts as the reason for her dismissal. In 2008, however, she gave a much more cryptic answer in an interview with the TNA website. Hemme said:
My departure from WWE was on my own terms because I stuck to my guns on my morals and values as a human being. I knew in my gut that it would be the end, but I also knew that carrying guilt for knowingly doing something against what I believed wasn't worth getting ahead. Leaving broke my heart... but doing the right thing is something I will always be proud of.
Take from that what you will.

2. Melina And Batista Had A Relationship While Melina Was With John Morrison

The Legend: That Batista and Melina had a very open relationship in 2005 whilst Melina was dating John Morrison. The Evidence: Melina appeared on the Ross Report podcast with Jim Ross in early March 2015 where she addressed the rumours of a relationship with Batista. She categorically denied the rumours and claimed that it was those rumours that, in part, led to her breaking up with Morrison. It's interesting that Melina denied the rumours because pretty much everyone else, including Batista, has confirmed them. He wrote in his autobiography that although they started as friends, their relationship became 'physical'. Batista elaborated in an interview with the Charleston-Post Courier in 2007:
He was always aware of what was going on, and she was very honest with him. They split up and moved apart, and we started dating each other. She still considers him her best friend in the world. But he always knew exactly what was going on.
Apparently the fact that Morrison openly allowed Melina to engage in a sexual relationship with Batista got him some heat backstage and rumour has it that even Vince McMahon looked down on him for it. Is It True: Melina may claim otherwise, but she and Batista had a relationship. Batista is a known ladies man and there are enough former wrestlers backing up the story for verification.

1. Vince McMahon Has Had Affairs With Several Divas

The Legend: That WWE owner Vince McMahon has had affairs with several past WWE divas. The Evidence: Vince McMahon is a man who clearly thinks (or thought) quite highly of his ability to perform sexually. There was a period in the early 2000s where he was intent to convince the world that he was a genetic jackhammer, able to satisfy any woman's needs. He had storylines where he was involved with divas Trish Stratus, Torrie Wilson, Stacy Keibler and, most notably, Sable and Candice Michelle. Vince clearly delighted in making out with each of them and not a week seemed to go by that Vince wasn't seen doing the tongue tango with one of his female performers. Of course for some people it's hard to differentiate between fantasy and reality and some began to assume that Vince was actually sleeping with divas behind-the-scenes. They cited a 2001 interview that Vince gave to Playboy in which he admitted to having cheated on Linda and bragged about his sexual appetite. But no diva, past or present, has come out and spoke of any affair with Vince. Until they do, it's all just internet rumour and speculation. Is It True: Is it implausible to think that something could have happened between a testosterone-filled Vince and one of his gaggle of WWE divas? No, it isn't. But that doesn't mean it happened. Wrestling is (or was) a pretty seedy business, and there are many a tall tale of shady goings-on. But, at the end of the day, they're just rumours.

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...