10 Most Radical Wrestling Makeovers

New look, new man.

Festus To Luke Gallows 2
WWE

While the ability to captivate the crowd in the ring is all-important, it's impossible to imagine any wrestler - particularly in today's era - ascending the mainstream ranks without a character with whom fans can connect.

Finding the right character, incidentally, is easier said than done. Virtually every possible archetype - from deranged dentist to the stars (and Jerry Lawler) to tortured burn victim who absolutely hates the date May 19 - has been used at this point, and that's just Glenn Jacobs.

As such, it's not exactly surprising to find that even some of the biggest names in the industry's history have had to go through two (and, in some cases, three or four) guises before they stumbled on one that worked. Unless you strike gold on your debut, it's pretty much inevitable.

Generally, wrestlers tend to go from A to B. That is, they portray a series of characters all with a unifying theme (both of Jacobs' gimmicks were sociopaths, for example). But, every now and then, they go from A to Z, performing a complete 180-degree turn and ending up with a character that couldn't be more different to their first.

10. Bradshaw To JBL

Bradshaw To JBL
WWE

Granted, there were one or two personality traits shared by APA heavy Bradshaw and John "Bradshaw" Layfield, the smug self-made millionaire who arrived in the ring via a limousine with decorative bull horns attached to the hood.

They were both to some extent Texan stereotypes, they both loved a practical joke, and they each had a wicked mean streak (although, to be fair, that last one is probably to do with the Clothesline From Hell, a move you can't execute unless you're seriously angry).

But there are also glaring differences which one can't overlook. The Bradshaw of old was supposed to be a no-nonsense every-man. The character who replaced him, on the other hand, was smug and elitist; the kind of guy who talks up his patriotism while insisting he got where he is all by himself.

And, to be fair, it was his resemblance to many of the world's most polarising public figures that made him such an exceptional heel. Few wrestlers this side of the 21st century have attracted such levels of hatred, and fewer still did it after years a good guy.


9. The Godfather To The Goodfather

Godfather To Goodfather
WWE

If you were asked to name the most politically incorrect wrestling character of the last quarter-century, chances are you'd point to The Godfather, a "pimp" who was followed to the ring by a cast of scantily clad women he referred to as "hoes".

The controversy that surrounded this gimmick was such that, in a cheeky wink to the puritanical critics, Right To Censor - WWE's resident guardians of good taste - actually recruited him to assist in their mission to sanitise the squared circle in mid-2000.

For a short while, The Godfather stopped referring to himself as The Godfather, instead insisting that he be called The Goodfather. He even dropped his trademark pimp attire in favour of a business shirt and plain black tie.

By design, he began to portray a character that was diametrically opposed to his previous one in just about every way imaginable. Even if it was merely in the aid of an elaborate joke, that's pretty radical.


8. Festus To Luke Gallows

Festus To Luke Gallows
WWE

Sometimes, you really have to just sit back and admire the work of the men and women in the medical profession. They may not yet have eradicated all the world's diseases, but the fact that Luke Gallows can now lead a normal life is proof that they know what they're doing.

Prior to 2009, the former Kane imposter was afflicted by a rare neurological condition whereby he would become uncontrollably angry after hearing the ring bell - something that was used to frankly disappointing effect by tag team partner Jesse.

But, after a short hiatus, he returned under an entirely different persona. Not only was he not in a near-comatose state for the majority of his waking life, he began standing up for values with which we'd never previously associated him - namely the Straight Edge lifestyle.

Fast forward a few more years, and his character has become even more removed from Festus. Now, alongside Karl Anderson, he's all about making money and taking names, and he doesn't need a bell to tell him when he can beat someone up.


7. Surfer Sting To Crow Sting

Sting To Sting
WWE

Thanks in part to WWE's - and the wrestling community's at large - determination to remember Sting as WCW's answer to The Undertaker, we tend to view him as an equally dark and brooding vigilante.

There is of course plenty of validity in that, but it also ignores the early part of The Icon's career, during which he portrayed a California surfer complete with spiky blonde hair and turquoise blue hippy face-paint (you know, like the ocean).

From there, he pivoted in the mid-1990s to the gimmick we all know and love, inspired by the movie The Crow, whose eponymous character sported almost identical white and black make-up covering the entirety of his face.

All of that amounts to superficial, surface-level difference, but there were notable changes in his persona too. Sting began playing psychological games with his opponents, the ongoing power struggle between WCW and the nWo having forced him to adopt tweener tactics.


6. The Booty Man To The Disciple

Booty Man To Disciple
WWE

In truth, you could probably come up with a list of 10 wrestling makeovers comprised exclusively of gimmicks used (and then abruptly ditched) by Brutus Beefcake, who could never quite settle on one character.

But arguably the most radical of them - at least in terms of physical appearance - was the one that he underwent during his time in WCW in the late-1990s, when he transitioned from The Booty Man, so named because of his fixation with his bum, to The Disciple.

A Disciple of whom, you may be wondering, the answer of course being Hulk Hogan. Beefcake, having been a long-time, real-life friend of The Hulkster, started portraying a character that worshipped at the nWo leader's feet, sporting black, biker-themed attire by way of homage.

Given that he had previously been wrestling in bright-coloured (and, obviously, super tight) pants - and, prior to that, as The Zodiac, black and white face-paint - this was a pretty substantial departure.


5. The Ringmaster To Stone Cold

Ringmaster To Austin
WWE

It seems somehow wrong not to include Stone Cold Steve Austin on this list, considering that - after his makeover in 1996 - he would go on to enjoy perhaps the greatest five-year run of any wrestler in the history of the industry.

Given his success, it's pretty incredible to think that he began life in WWE under the guise of "The Ringmaster", a member of the wrestling nobility who was awarded the Million Dollar Championship by Ted DiBiase on night one.

Put simply, this gimmick didn't suit him at all. His promo delivery style was too tenacious, too confrontational for anyone to believe that he was cut from the same cloth as performers like Bret Hart and Mr Perfect. He was something entirely different.

Luckily, wiser heads soon prevailed, and The Ringmaster had disappeared from our screens entirely by year's end, replaced instead by Stone Cold Steve Austin, a beer-chugging anti-hero with a penchant for getting on the wrong side of the powers that be.


4. Matt Hardy To Woken Matt

Matt Hardy To Woken Matt
WWE

Matt Hardy has become one of wrestling's great character actors over recent years, but you don't have to go back very far to find The Woken One in the role of a bland babyface whose defining personality attribute was that he was the "sensible" brother.

In fact, Matt was so vanilla prior to his Impact awakening that various attempts to turn him into an arrogant heel - outside of a brief spell as "Version One" in 2003 - largely fell flat. Even when he launched vicious, personal attacks on Jeff, it just seemed like the feeling wasn't really there.

None of that is to imply that he's ever been a poor worker. For years, he was one of the great unsung heroes of the WWE midcard alongside the likes of Shelton Benjamin and Carlito - but it was the lack of a unique selling point that kept him from grasping the brass ring.

The radical makeover he underwent in 2016, the end-game of which being his hugely popular Broken/Woken gimmick, helped turn around his fortunes in the ring. Suddenly, he had impetus, a reason for people to care - something that is hard to come by for performers who have been around so long.


3. Cody Rhodes To Stardust

Cody Rhodes To Stardust
WWE

Versatility has always been one of Cody Rhodes' great strengths. He's been in equal parts effective as a face and a heel, and has even managed to appeal to hardcore and mainstream audiences alike without turning his back on either.

But perhaps his greatest chameleon act came in 2014, when he began portraying Stardust, a nod both to his dad - who had briefly used the same name during his AWA days - and of course his eccentric older brother.

Physically speaking, this makeover was incredibly bold. Cody's previous gimmick was explicitly rooted in what a "dashing" young buck he was; to go from that to wearing a skin-tight spandex body suit and head-to-neck bright-coloured face-paint is a pretty sharp turnaround.

The persona, too, was completely removed from anything he had done before. Where he had previously played the role of an entitled, wrestling-in-my-blood second-generation rookie, he was now trying to entertain the crowd, appealing to the nostalgia of yesteryear.


2. Steel/Oz To Diesel

Oz To Diesel
WWE

It's hard to believe that Kevin Nash came to personify wrestling cool, considering that he started out in WCW in the early 1990s sporting a bright orange mohawk as part of a tag team going by the "Master Blasters".

The worst part is that wasn't even the height of his humiliation. After ditching Steel, Nash would subsequently portray Oz, a character who came to the ring wearing a luminous green cape and novelty white beard, in a nod to - you guessed it - The Wizard of Oz.

Thankfully (for him at least), on his arrival in WWE in 1993, someone in the back realised that this seven-foot giant with the movie star looks was potentially capable of more than comedy, and he was promptly repackaged as Diesel, Shawn Michaels' uber laid-back bodyguard.

The rest, as they say, is history. Not only did Nash become one of Vince McMahon's biggest stars of the early-to-mid 1990s, he returned to WCW later on in the decade to show them exactly what they had been missing.


1. Johnny Polo To Raven

Johnny Polo To Raven
WWE

If ever there was a case study that illustrated the stark difference between pre-Attitude Era WWE and Paul Heyman's envelope-pushing ECW product that partly inspired it, it's probably Raven.

Before he became one of the wresting industry's great enigmas over on the east coast, Raven was working for Vince McMahon, playing the role of a jumped-up, cocky heel so generic and nondescript that it would probably make Kenny Dykstra blush.

After his release in 1994, however, he rocked up in ECW almost unrecognisable from his previous appearances in the squared circle. Instead of talking about how much he really, really wanted to win wrestling matches, he started waxing philosophical, using quotes from Edgar Allan Poe.

For this transformation, you can only really credit the fact that Heyman ran a much less tight and controlling ship in Philadelphia. Rather than asking his performers to conform to rigid wrestling archetypes, he allowed them the freedom to go places the business had never been before - and it paid off in a huge way.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Luke Gallows
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor