10 Most Successful Wrestling Managers (Statistically Speaking)

It's all about the gold.

Paul Bearer WWE Title
WWE.com

There has been a lot of debate over the years regarding who, exactly, was the best manager in the history of professional wrestling. One could argue for Bobby Heenan based on his pivotal role in promoting WrestleMania III, or Paul Heyman for his advocacy of Brock Lesnar alone, but in wrestling, success is measured in gold. If we frame success in terms of championships won -- which is the idea of wrestling, after all -- who was the statistically best manager of them all?

To answer that question, it was necessary to not only tally the number of championships, but also to weigh them appropriately in terms of prestige. Championships were therefore tiered in the following categories:

Tertiary titles (Television, Hardcore, European, and state-specific titles of national promotions), both single and tag, are worth one point.

Secondary titles (Intercontinental, U.S., King of the Ring, and regional titles of national promotions), both single and tag, are worth two points.

World tag team titles are worth three points.

World heavyweight titles are worth five points.

Finally, only titles affiliated with a major, national promotion (AWA, WWE, WCW/NWA, TNA, ECW) were considered eligible for this list, so don't get mad when you see that we ignored the time when Jimmy Hart came to town and helped Vic Villainous steal the Western Kalamazoo Featherweight crown from your high school gym teacher, okay?

10. Mr. Fuji

Yokozuna fuji
WWE.com

Secondary Titles: Don Muraco (2)

World Tag Titles: Demolition (3), Hart/Yokozuna (3)

World Titles: Yokozuna (10)

Total Points: 18

The Devious One loved to make opponents suffer, and he managed to impart at least some of his sadism to his charges, many of whom were monstrous in their own right. He led Demolition to the tag team titles, although he eventually abandoned them for the Powers of Pain; despite his betrayal, the Demos would ultimately enjoy a reign that lasted 478 days, a record that stands to this day.

His most prestigious client was undoubtedly the mighty Yokozuna, who Fuji led to two world titles and a tag team championship along with Owen Hart. Despite these triumphs, Fuji's best-remembered partnership was likely with King of the Ring Don Muraco, with whom he filmed the still-hilarious "Fuji Vice."


9. The Grand Wizard

1010929

Secondary Titles: Don Muraco (2), Ken Patera (2), Pat Patterson (4)

World Tag Titles: Fuji/Tanaka (6)

World Titles: Stan Stasiak (5), Billy Graham (5)

Total Points: 24

When he first became a manager, Ernie Roth tried out a few identities: Mr. Clean, J. Wellington Radcliffe, and Abdullah Farouk, but his career didn't really take off until he proclaimed himself the Grand Wizard of Professional Wrestling. The Wizard's first taste of championship gold came with the team of Mr. Fuji and Professor Toru Tanaka, who won the titles twice under his aegis. 

He also guided Don Muraco, Ken Patera and Pat Patterson to the Intercontinental championship, although his greatest triumphs were his two world championship clients, both of whom dethroned the biggest babyface heroes of the day. Stan Stasiak ended the reign of Pedro Morales, while Billy Graham conquered the immortal Bruno Sammartino. 


8. Sherri Martel

Sherri Martel
WWE.com

Secondary Titles: Randy Savage (2), Shawn Michaels (2)

World Tag Titles: Rose/Summers (3), Harlem Heat (21)

Total Points: 28

In the 1980's, most managers were either gnarly, cauliflower-eared retired wrestlers or relatively demure ladies. Sherri was the best of both worlds, a nasty, four-time women's champion covered in six to eight pounds of sleazy sexuality. Sherri led Randy Savage to a King of the Ring victory and Shawn Michaels to his first Intercontinental championship, but her specialty was clearly tag team competition.

She led "Playboy" Buddy Rose and "Pretty Boy" Doug Somers to an AWA tag team championship reign, but the lion's share of her success came in WCW as Harlem Heat's Sister Sherri. With Martel at the helm, Booker T and Stevie Ray racked up a then-unheard of seven tag titles.


7. Paul Bearer

Undertaker Paul Bearer
WWE.com

World Tag Titles: Kane/Mankind (6)

World Titles: Undertaker (10), Kane (10)

Total Points: 26

Paul Bearer never had a very varied stable of wrestlers, but he sure could pick his charges well. It probably helped that Kane and the Undertaker are both seven foot tall immortals possessed of elemental powers, but Paul's expert guidance surely didn't hurt.

Almost immediately buying out Undertaker's contract from Brother Love, Paul would guide Undertaker to his first WWE championship, and blackmail his way back into the Deadman's life during his second. 

He'd ultimately bring in the more coachable Kane, who failed to unseat Taker but briefly took the title off Steve Austin and formed a championship team with Mankind. After years of trying, Bearer and Kane finally enjoyed an extended world title reign in 2010. 


6. Jim Cornette

Jim Cornette Jeff Jarrett
WWE.com

Secondary Titles: Jeff Jarrett (2), Barry Windham (2)

Secondary Tag Titles: Midnight Express (4)

World Tag Titles: Rock and Roll Express (3), Hart/Bulldog (3), New Midnight Express (3), Hart/Yokozuna (3), Midnight Express (6)

World Titles: Dan Severn (5), Yokozuna (5)

Total Points: 31

Mama Cornette's baby boy, like Sherri, owed much of his career success to his tag teams. The Midnight Express are his best-remembered (and most decorated) pairing, but he had a fair amount of success with various pairings within his mid-90's Camp Cornette stable.

 His managerial partnership with Mr. Fuji proved especially fruitful, as the addition of the mighty Yokozuna brought the Camp both world heavyweight and tag team gold. Corny's greatest coup, however, was the short-lived NWA invasion of WWE programming, during which the NWA world heavyweight and world tag team championships were returned to national prominence. 

Under Cornette's control, naturally.


5. James J. Dillon

Four Horsemen
wwe.com

Tertiary Titles: Barry Windham (1), Arn Anderson (1), Tully Blanchard (3)

Secondary Titles: Tully Blanchard (2), Lex Luger (2), Barry Windham (2)

Secondary Tag Titles: The Andersons (2)

World Tag Titles: Anderson/Blanchard (6)

World Titles: Ric Flair (30)

Total Points: 49

James J. Dillon was a journeyman wrestler and manager of scrubs that happened to look like a sleazy lawyer, which he parlayed into a gig managing villainous playboy Tully Blanchard. When Tully joined up with Ric Flair and the Andersons, Dillon came along for the ride, becoming the official business manager and CEO of the Four Horsemen.

In this role, JJ oversaw a handful of  US, TV, and tag title wins, but obviously his greatest triumph was managing Flair to six of his sixteen world championships.


4. Captain Lou Albano

Lou Albano
WWE.com

Secondary Titles: Don Muraco (2), Greg Valentine (2), Pat Patterson (2)

World Tag Titles: The Blackjacks (3), Headshrinkers (3), Executioners (3), Yukon Lumberjacks (3), Moondogs (3), British Bulldogs (3), Valiant Brothers (6), Fuji/Saito (6), US Express (6), Wild Samoans (9)

World Titles: Ivan Koloff (5), Fabulous Moolah (5)

Total Points: 66

Best known for his long-running stewardship of the Wild Samoans, Captain Lou was the guiding light for a record-breaking 10 teams to 15 world tag team championships. He also had success in the singles ranks, leading Don Muraco and Greg Valentine to Intercontinental titles, and briefly managed IC champ Pat Patterson after buying his contract from the Grand Wizard.

The Captain also managed the Fabulous Moolah at MTV's War to Settle the Score, and even witnessed the end of Bruno Sammartino's seven year reign from Ivan Koloff's corner.


3. Paul Heyman

Madusa Paul Heyman Rick Rude dangerous alliance
wwe.com

Tertiary Titles: Arn Anderson (1), Steve Austin (2)

Secondary Titles: Curtis Axel (2), Sabu (2)

World Tag Titles: Rose/Condrey (3), Eaton/Anderson (3), Zbyszko/Anderson (3), Team Angle (6)

World Titles: Sabu (5), Kurt Angle (5) CM Punk (5), Rob Van Dam (10), Big Show (10), Brock Lesnar (10)

Total Points: 67

Paul Heyman is the only manager on this list that's still active, so his place on it is provisional. As Paul E. Dangerously, Heyman led his charges to TV, US, and world tag team titles, but it was when he came to WWE that he had his greatest success. Channeling Sunny, Heyman managed three successive WWE champions, betraying Brock Lesnar to back Big Show, then Big Show to side with Kurt Angle. 

Later, when Rob Van Dam held the WWE and ECW titles simultaneously, Heyman would turn on Rob to give the latter championship to, naturally, Big Show. In recent years, he's been most visible as the driving forces behind CM Punk and Brock Lesnar's latter-day world title reigns.


2. Bobby Heenan

Bobby Heenan Rick Rude
WWE.com

Tertiary Titles: Killer Karl Kox (1), Masked Superstar (4)

Tertiary Tag Titles: Fuji/Tanaka (1), Tanaka/Assassin #2 (1)

Secondary Titles: Harley Race (2), Ken Patera (2), Nick Bockwinkel (2), Rick Rude (2), Mr. Perfect (4), Masked Superstar (6)

Secondary Tag Titles: Super Destroyer/Masked Superstar (2), Bundy/Masked Superstar (2) 

World Tag Titles: The Blackjacks (3), Lanza/Duncum (3), Colossal Connection (3), Brain Busters (3), Bockwinkel/Stevens (12)

World Titles: Andre the Giant (5), Ric Flair (10), Nick Bockwinkel (20)

Total Points: 88

The Brain is generally considered the all-around best manager of them all, but his championship record doesn't quite bear that out. His long-running Heenan Family won him a variety of minor championships in the AWA and WWE, but he also had his share of world champions; in the AWA, he led Nick Bockwinkel to four heavyweight championships, and in the WWE he helped Andre the Giant end Hulk Hogan's seemingly interminable first title reign. 

Although he'd later retire to become a commentator, he'd make a special exception for Ric Flair, who he'd lead, alongside Mr. Perfect, to two WWE titles.


1. Jimmy Hart

Honky Tonk Man
WWE.com

Tertiary Titles: Renegade (1), Lex Luger (1), Tommy Rich (1), Brian Knobs (3), Randy Savage (3), Austin Idol (4), Bobby Eaton (10)

Secondary Titles: Eddie Gilbert (2), King Kong Bundy (2), One Man Gang (2), Honky Tonk Man (2), Greg Valentine (2), the Mountie (2), Tommy Rich (12), Austin Idol (14)

Secondary Tag Titles: Bundy/Rude (4) 

World Tag Titles: Luger/Sting (3), Natural Disasters (3), Nasty Boys (3), Money, Inc. (6), Hart Foundation (6)

World Titles: Hulk Hogan (10), the Giant (10)

Total Points: 106

The Mouth of the South takes it by a country (and Western) mile. He had great success with tag teams in both WWE and WCW, most notably with the Nasty Boys and the Hart Foundation. He also managed real-life best buddy Hulk Hogan to WWE and WCW heavyweight titles before betraying him to help the Giant win it. 

Still, he racked up the majority of his gold in Memphis, a territory notorious for its hotshot booking. Luckily for Jimmy, Memphis used AWA championships during his time there, so alas, they count. But isn't it just like Jimmy to pull out a cheap win on a technicality?


In this post: 
Paul Bearer
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Long-time fan (scholar?) of professional wrestling, kaiju films and comparative mythology. Aspiring two-fisted adventurer.