10 Most Underrated Wrestling Matches Of 2019
2019 had more wrestling than anyone can keep up with, here's some of the best you might have missed.
2019 was a year of massive change in the wrestling industry. The emergence of AEW, the continued international rise of NJPW, NXT being aired every week on the USA network and so on. These changes fundamentally shifted fans' alignments, with more time spent arguing about ratings than seeking out some matches outside their usual purview.
While companies like WWE and NJPW are substantial enough to have die hard fans consuming every scrap of content produced by them, most viewers will have missed something, let alone from promotions that don't get the same amount of coverage by most news sites.
This is not a list that can cover everything, and many of these matches aren't exactly obscure, but all of the ones listed here are matches that are more than worth your time. They come from the midcard of shows you might have forgotten, episodes of television that most didn't watch, tournaments with dozens of other wrestling matches and so much more. If this list can do anything, it's a reminder that there is so much great content out there, easily accessible with a few clicks of a keyboard and mouse. We are lucky to be living in this great time to be wrestling fans.
10. Shazza McKenzie Vs. Su Yung - Shimmer 113
WrestleMania weekend is an increasingly crowded time to be a wrestling fan. Even if you're in the know, have your FITE account all set up and are watching several shows a day, the sheer amount of content means that certain shows are prioritised over others. An underrated card was from the Chicago based all women's promotion Shimmer, who delivered a top to bottom excellent night of wrestling, with the personal standout being a styles clash between notorious undead warrior Su Yung, and the perpetually underrated Australian grappler Shazza McKenzie.
This was a match built entirely around proving themselves, two women in the middle of a stacked card on a weekend where they will never be the dominant force of conversation, working as hard as they could to stand out and mesmerise the crowd. The intense action is paced perfectly, with no dull moments infecting the quality of the match. The storytelling was simple, based around the endless strength of Yung as McKenzie had to work overtime to inflict any semblance of pain. It's a testament to both women's abilities that they managed to enthrall the crowd in the way that they did, especially going on right in the middle of the card.
There's a reason why Shazza McKenzie is mentioned in the conversation for the women that AEW should sign, if you haven't seen her work a full singles match, this is the perfect introduction point. However, it's maybe an even more critical showcase for Su Yung, whose brilliant character work in IMPACT Wrestling is pushed to the test here with an opponent that knows how to maximise her strengths. It's the kind of contest that makes the winner irrelevant and puts over both women as future main event level talents in any promotion that is lucky to have them.
9. Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn Vs. The New Day - Stomping Grounds
Stomping Grounds wasn't a show that many people watched, at least compared to the majority of WWE PPVs. It will be remembered in history for its notorious main event debacle, the ridiculous name, possibly even the dismal crowd attendance, but what it should be remembered for was the best main roster tag match of 2019.
The unit of Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn were a perfect heel duo. Not tagging since 2018, the two got into sync again immediately as a merciless duo. Owens and Zayn immediately utilised clever strategy to isolate Xavier Woods, using constant tags to ensure that The New Day didn't get the upper hand until the halfway point. Zayn in particular relished his heel role, providing his trademark offence with fantastic antagonism, riling up the crowd as he destroyed the popular babyface.
Not all the credit can be attributed to Owens and Zayn of course, as the New Day were easily WWE's tag team of the year yet again. Woods remains WWE's trademark tag team babyface, with his selling reaching higher levels of sympathy and brutality with every PPV appearance. Big E continues to prove why he's one of the most underrated big men in the world, making the imposing Owens feel almost insignificant in comparison.
The match was never slow paced and yet managed to build to a perfect crescendo, with the crowd deeply invested in each move and set-piece. The four men put on a minor classic with minimal build, creating fantastic storytelling despite no belts on the line or a concrete narrative. WWE failed to do anything with Zayn and Owens as a duo following this, but it's a testament to how essential these men are in the modern WWE landscape that they left an impression in a spot designed to be forgotten.
8. Nick Gage Vs. Killer Kross - Josh Barnett’s Bloodsport III
Nick Gage appearing on Bloodsport is a dream come true for anyone familiar with his catalogue. The infamous ex-con deathmatch wrestler has become increasingly popular over the last few years as one of the few stars that respects the art of kayfabe. Everything about Nick Gage dispels the imagery of artifice; he's one of the rare wrestlers in the 2010s to feel just as dangerous as he alludes to being. Anyone who has seen one of his GCW title defences or any gnarly act of barbarism he's inflicted knows for a fact that he is a terrifying once-in-a-lifetime performer.
Gage isn't exactly known for his shoot style grappling despite his evident skill at it. His opponent, Killer Kross, is known for his ability on the mat and his relentless sadism. He is the type of wrestler that can knock someone out with a single strike, or wrench their arm out of their sockets with submissions. The two men being paired together in an environment as unique as Bloodsport seemed to promise true violence and greatness, and they completely delivered.
This is the shortest match on this list: it's only a few minutes and they go by fast. Gage is wrestling with malicious intensity, lunging at Kross with punches and brutal kicks, whereas Kross is working smarter while maintaining aggression. They're scrambling to knock each other out immediately. The storytelling was masterful in its simplicity, and it was the only encounter on Barnett's third Bloodsport event to truly blur the lines between work and shoot. The sequence of a gnarly kick to the head immediately following a brutal German suplex is euphoric in a way that only wrestling can be. It ends with a choke out, a call out and everyone in the audience screaming for more.
7. Shingo Takagi Vs. Yoshinobu Kanemaru - Best Of The Super Juniors 2019 Day 5
Shingo Takagi is arguably the wrestler of 2019 in terms of consistency, the man dominated two tournaments with matches of the night scattered across weeks and months. While his matches with Tomohiro Ishii, Will Ospreay and LIJ stablemate Tetsuya Naito are widely acclaimed by fans and critics, others slipped under the radar. It's understandable that a man who delivered so much fantastic wrestling in just one year would have matches that aren't as widely seen. One of his most overlooked bouts, up there with the best he put on in the entire calendar, was one with Suzuki-gun’s cheating mastermind, Yoshinobu Kanemaru.
The two battled in a war, the bigger Takagi having the size, speed and strength advantages, while Kanemaru utilised his veteran instincts and cheating to keep the scales balanced. This match was interlaced with perfect interference, the presence of Taichi trying to destabilise the match being hilarious and genuinely tense. Shingo's undefeated singles streak felt seconds away from ending at times. The match was one of the fastest paced of the tournament, with the action happening rapidly and Kanemaru's disgusting rule breaking making a substantial impact on the crowd's reaction. This is perfect in ring storytelling, reminiscent of Dude Love vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin from Over the Edge '98.
This, unlike many New Japan matches built around interference, manages to make it a benefit of the greater narrative and eventual babyface triumph. Instead of ruining a great match, it adds to the aura around both men, making Shingo look like a conquering warrior for being able to survive so dominantly. However, the most important positive of the match is that it's fun! A lot of tournament wrestling is so serious and anxiety inducing that putting on a main event designed around entertainment value is extremely refreshing and welcome.
6. Hiroshi Tanahashi Vs. Shota Umino - New Japan Cup Day 3
One of the most emotional and common stories in professional wrestling is the veteran versus the rookie. The story of a young worker trying desperately to overcome their mentor, or a person so respected within the industry that beating them would change their career forever. It has been the concrete foundation for some of wrestling's greatest feuds, from Ric Flair and Sting, to Hiroshi Tanahashi and Kazuchika Okada among others. Tanahashi was instrumental in making Okada the ace of New Japan that he is today, with their series ensuring that Okada could be taken seriously as the top guy. Tanahashi's work with Young Lion Shota Umino is different than his feud with Okada, but no less powerful.
This wasn't a match based around hatred or even competition. The result was enshrined, there was no chance of a Young Lion beating the defining NJPW wrestler of the century. It was a match built around respect, and the beauty of even sharing a ring with a legend. Umino was openly emotional at being able to work Tanahashi, especially as the match was being refereed by his father, and Tana seemed equally overwhelmed at being the man trusted to make this boy's career. Their match was enthralling, with the crowd invested in every second, being so drawn to the rookie's passion and heartfelt devotion to the art of wrestling.
This wasn't a match about moves, nor a win or a loss. It was a match about how beautiful it is that we have this sport, that people can devote their lives to breaking their own bodies and find solace in that. It is some of the most emotionally profound art of the year, not just in professional wrestling, and is essential to check out for any wrestling fan who missed it.
5. Chad Gable Vs. Gentleman Jack Gallagher - 205 Live - June 11th 2019
Chad Gable, after being wasted for years on the WWE main roster and just a few months out from a name change that has seemingly destined him for obscurity, turned up for a couple of shows on 205 Live with a new haircut, new gear, and proved to everyone that he is one of the best. Gentleman Jack Gallagher, one of the most underrated technicians in professional wrestling, was the perfect opponent for Gable to display his talents with.
The match was devoid of traditional big moments associated with WWE wrestling. It felt like a substantive alternative to the usual style - what 205 Live was designed to represent. Both men utilised their technical grappling skills and light weights to effectively work each other down with holds and limb targeting. Due to their smaller sizes, they're both increasingly quick and have high stamina, making it an elaborate waiting game for an open opportunity to capitalise on. Unlike a lot of modern WWE, there's never a substantial advantage from either man, both are positioned on equal ground for most of the contest, yet both look better as a result.
The match ending in a botched countout was upsetting at the time, but works in hindsight as a fitting conclusion to this fragment to the narrative. Neither man could outwork the other that night, Gable only picking up the victory due to circumstances on the ropes added fire to both men in their excellent rematch a few weeks later, which was more intense and less grounded than this encounter. The storytelling that they brought to this match was mesmerising enough to capture a notoriously burned out post SmackDown crowd, which is proof of the connection that Gable's able to create with audiences. It's evidence that 205 was a beautiful source for wrestling last year.
4. Buddy Murphy Vs. Akira Tozawa - Elimination Chamber 2019
Buddy Murphy’s Cruiserweight title run was one of the most underrated title runs in recent WWE memory, the Australian regularly putting on minor classics on pre shows and half empty arenas. After winning the title from Cedric Alexander in a stadium in his home country and successfully defending the belt on the main card of Survivor Series, it was disappointing to see him relegated to pre-shows for the remainder of his title run. Thankfully, that didn't affect the quality of his matches. The fatal 4 way at the Royal Rumble was well received and is remembered for being KENTA's last major match in the company. However, slipping under the radar was Murphy's incendiary defence against one of the best junior heavyweights in the world, Akira Tozawa.
The storytelling that the two enacted was stupendous, the desperation of Tozawa to have a proper run with a title he never got to make his own is contrasted by the viciousness of Murphy, a man obsessed with the preservation of his reign. The two men stiffed each other with brutal knees, suplexes and incredibly risky spots, going out on a limb to steal the show before it even officially started. They managed to outperform everything besides the Men's Elimination Chamber which is a staggering accomplishment.
Murphy and Tozawa might not have been elevated as further up the card as this match would suggest, with Tozawa being sadly treated as a glorified jobber on Raw as of late, but this match lives forever as one of the best WWE pre-show matches produced in recent memory. It legitimately ranks up there with the best PPV matches of the year, without officially being on the main card! A must watch if you overlooked it at the time.
3. Tomohiro Ishii Vs. Taichi - Dominion 2019
2019 was the year that proved to the world that Taichi was one of the greatest wrestlers in the world. Fans of Suzuki-gun will have recognised his abilities long before now, but for the majority of wrestling fans prior to this year, Taichi was on the lower echelon of NJPW superstars. While his couple of matches in the New Japan Cup were great and his Openweight title win over Jeff Cobb was a great styles clash, he was still doubted as a singles star. The groundwork for that change truly started at Dominion 2019, in a rematch from the Cup, against one of the best wrestlers in the world, Tomohiro Ishii.
The three matches that Taichi and Ishii had in 2019, with the third match taking place during the G1 Climax, rank up with the best modern trilogies in professional wrestling this decade. This is plain and simple, the epitome of professional wrestling, two dudes battering each other until one can't move anymore. Taichi and Ishii have the best kicks and the best lariats in the business, with Taichi matching the notoriously stiff work of Ishii instead of relying upon his love of interference.
The match started off with furious intensity and managed to sustain itself through 15 minutes of perfection. Both men's selling was on another level of quality, effortlessly portraying the adrenaline-fueled need to beat the other. It isn't the most complicated or flashy match of the year, there aren't gravity defying acts of daredevil mayhem, or terrifying suplexes on the apron like other matches from the Dominion card. It is simply ideal violence, that calls back to the best days of the Openweight belt and ensured that Taichi got to have his immaculate G1 tournament. One of New Japan's undercard highlights of 2019.
2. Arisa Hoshiki Vs. Momo Watanabe - Stardom Gold
The world of joshi is much quicker and more brutal than most Western audiences are used to. Epic matches are rarely told through length, more through physical impact and streamlined storytelling. There aren't wasted seconds or pointless moves. Momo Watanabe's reign as Wonder of Stardom champion was one of the best title reigns in wrestling, which is breathtaking considering that she was 18 at the time of winning the belt. She defended the belt in high octane bouts, going through the majority of the Stardom roster in classics against Tam Nakano and Utami Hayashishita among others, before losing to Arisa Hoshiki in a masterpiece.
Arisa's journey to the title was fascinating. She started wrestling in 2011 at the age of 16 before retiring a year later, progressing into shoot boxing and other creative endeavours. She was gone from Stardom for the majority of the decade, missing the main event runs of Kairi Hojo and Io Shirai, before making a part time return in 2018 and going full time again at the start of 2019. Her return was huge and it offered up a new challenger for Momo's legendary reign, and she ended up kicking her way to history.
The match was relentless, filled with gnarly attacks to the human body. The two women threw everything that they had at each other, wrestling like they had everything to prove, taking horrific bumps and striking furiously for an electrifying 12 minutes. The storytelling of the younger veteran versus the older fighter with ring rust was fascinating, and executed beautifully as it approached the finish. The final 30 seconds are some of the most profound you'll see in wrestling, even if you have no prior emotional connection. This and Arisa's defence against Tam Nakano are evidence that she should be considered among the wrestlers of 2019.
1. Kento Miyahara Vs. Zeus - AJPW Summer Action Series Day 8
2019 was filled with immaculate world title matches: Kofi Kingston's coronation against Daniel Bryan, Kazuchika Okada's transcendent defence against Minoru Suzuki, and this absolute classic. Two men with around fifteen moves work thirty minutes in front of a relatively small, passionate crowd. It isn't a title match expected from most pro wrestling but it is mesmerising on primal levels; it feels like a battle of the ages.
It's the perfect hybrid of puroresu's minimalist brutality and grounded contemporary workrate. Kento Miyahara is the ace of AJPW, Zeus is an intensely dominant heavyweight. Zeus took the belt from Kento in 2018 before losing it back to him. Zeus wants his belt back, Kento wants to prove his brilliance as champion. That's the basic storytelling present in the match, an incredibly simple, effective premise. They start with invigorating technical wrestling, trying to exhaust each other before chops and lariats start.
They don't save the best moments of the match for the closing stretches, but sustain consistent momentum and level of intense drama for its entirety. The match feels bigger than bouts twice its length due to the selling. Despite Zeus' size and resiliency, he becomes tired and beaten by the halfway point, desperate to fight through the pain and frustrated by Kento's refusal to go down. Kento takes more offence and eventually starts throwing his entire body at Zeus out of panic, hoping that anything will beat him.
The match is filled with suspenseful near falls, with it seemingly capable of ending at any moment. The teases of Kento's breathtaking suplex finisher feel earned, the selling of his desperation to hit the move with weakened strength is amazing. By the closing stretches, you're convinced that either man could carry the company on his back. It almost doesn't matter who wins anymore.