8. Jeremy Piven Dated Kelly Kelly After Guest Hosting
Story: Jeremy Piven is an actor best known for his work in the TV show Entourage and a number of films. He guest hosted WWE Raw on August 3, 2009 and famously botched a line when he said "the Summerfest" instead of SummerSlam. He really wasn't a good guest host, but he was memorable because of his botch. Shortly after his appearance, Jim Ross noted in an online blog that Piven actually attempted to get phone numbers of various WWE divas. Guess which one he got? The number of Kelly Kelly. She's the diva that had the rep for sleeping around with the most guys in WWE when she was in the locker room, so it's not that much of a surprise. A few weeks after his appearance on Raw, Piven was photographed at a New York Jets NFL preseason game with Kelly Kelly sitting in the stands with him. They were also photographed outside of a hotel room.
Why People Believe It: The pictures tell the story.
Should We Believe It: Yes. They didn't date for that long and maybe it was just a one time thing, but it did happen. As an aside, Piven is 22 years older than Kelly Kelly. Way to go, Jeremy. Kelly "retired" from WWE when she was only 25 years old and is now engaged to former NHL player Sheldon Souray.