10 Observations From Attending EVOLVE 67 Live

Who said it was WWE's weekend?

Thatcher Gulak
WWN

Anyone who follows independent wrestling knows that over the past year, EVOLVE Wrestling and WWE have developed a relationship. While the details of the arrangement are only known to the relevant parties, there's been a clear overlap between the two promotions.

First, it was Matt Riddle - WWE had interest in the former UFC star, but wanted him to get more seasoning, so they asked EVOLVE to sign him. Johnny Gargano was the next example of the symbiosis, as the face of EVOLVE popped up on NXT and has competed for the brand on a regular basis. Meanwhile, WWE stars like American Alpha and Sami Zayn made appearances at EVOLVE shows, driving up attendance.

Today, WWE has nearly unbridled access to EVOLVE's talent. Many of the group's stars - from Drew Gulak to TJP to Tony Nese - have taken part in the Cruiserweight Classic, and reportedly, EVOLVE contracts feature an out saying that stars can leave the company to sign with WWE.

EVOLVE also continues to benefit, as for the second time this summer, the company has run a "double header" with WWE. Hours before TakeOver: Back to Brooklyn, EVOLVE ran an event in the borough, allowing fans in a wrestling mood plenty of time to see both shows - and with a card that boasted some of the best talent on the indies, there was no reason not to make it a full day of wrestling.

Here are 10 observations from attending EVOLVE 67 live:

10. Ethan Page Is The Gatekeeper

1173286

"All Ego" Ethan Page is one of the most promising talents in EVOLVE. The young Canadian star was the most hated heel in the company last year when he engaged in a blood feud with Johnny Gargano, but after losing the blowoff "I Quit" match, he's turned over a new leaf. Since then, he's tried to walk the line and get Gargano to forgive him.

"Johnny Wrestling" hasn't been so quick to forget, but Page is such a good babyface that the fans have accepted him. The less-aggressive version of "All Ego" has come to Gargano's defense on many an occasion, but he hasn't really engaged in many of his own feuds. As such, over the past few months, he's found himself taking on talent in tryout matches.

Those matches usually don't go too well for the newcomers. At EVOLVE 58, Page made mincemeat out of Darby Allin, though the unorthodox Allin's bravado in the face of punishment has won him a spot in the company. At EVOLVE 64, he destroyed Wheeler Yuta.

On Saturday, Kobe Durst got his chance, and he didn't do any better. Once again, Page scored a decisive win with the Package Piledriver, proving that the competition in EVOLVE is stiffer than it is elsewhere on the indy scene.


9. Cruiserweight Classic 2?

Peter Kaasa
The Post and Courier

If the rumors are to be believed, WWE's Cruiserweight Classic may become an annual event. If, indeed, the company ends up looking for a brand-new slate of 32 cruiserweights next year, EVOLVE would be a good place to start. Men like Fred Yehi and Marty Scurll would be great additions to the tournament.

Another star who could easily draw some eyes in the CWC is Peter Kaasa. The diminutive-yet-muscular star has drawn comparisons to Neville, and while he's only wrestled a few matches for EVOLVE, he's coming off of a tour with Dragon Gate and his stock in wrestling is higher than ever. He was in action at EVOLVE 67, taking on a stylistically-great opponent in Tony Nese.

Nese, of course, was part of the inaugural Cruiserweight Classic, which has increased his exposure exponentially. There's no doubt that Kaasa would love to be in Nese's shoes, and the first step was a great showing against him. While the match was a little disjointed in places, both men got a chance to show just how athletic and skilled they are. Nese won, but Kaasa has great things coming in EVOLVE and elsewhere.


8. Matt Riddle Should Be EVOLVE Champion

1252511

Matt Riddle and EVOLVE Champion Timothy Thatcher have a controversial relationship with each other that dates back months. In March, the then-undefeated Riddle took on Thatcher for the title, but the champion cheated to retain. In an April rematch, Riddle hurt Thatcher so badly that the match was stopped, but the title didn't change. Friday evening in Maryland, they had a rubber match, and Thatcher won.

Watching Riddle - who's only been wrestling for about a year and has taken to it about as quickly as Kurt Angle did - compete against the WWE-bound Tommy End, though, it was clear that he should really be the group's champion. The bout was excellent, worked in part like a shoot-fight (End is an experienced kickboxer), but also full of pro wrestling drama. There were hard strikes galore and plenty of submissions, with Riddle finally making End tap out.

I'm not sure exactly what Riddle is contractually allowed to do, but given that WWE has reportedly lost interest in him (he's a fervent marijuana enthusiast), EVOLVE should be pushing him to the moon and every other company on Earth should be checking his availability.


7. Alexander The Great

Cedric Alexander
AML Wrestling

For many years, Cedric Alexander was a mainstay in Ring of Honor. In May, though, he left the company, reportedly to pursue a career with WWE. He soon started taking bookings with EVOLVE, and was then announced for the Cruiserweight Classic.

Alexander is out of the CWC, having lost to Kota Ibushi in the best match of the tournament thus far, but he's participated in a lot of "Cruiserweight Classic Showcase" matches for EVOLVE. When the promotion came to Queens in July, he took on Johnny Gargano in a fast-paced blow-away encounter, and on Saturday, he was in action against Zack Sabre Jr.

This bout, given Sabre's submission-based style, was slower, but no less great - in fact, it was the best match of the day, NXT included. Sabre used his devastating array of holds, while Alexander's high-risk offense made an incredible counterpoint. Both men started as faces, but as the crowd favored Alexander, he played to them more while Sabre started working heel.

Sabre eventually scored the win, but Alexander came off like a star. Even though he's been eliminated from the CWC, he deserves to be the centerpiece of Raw's upcoming cruiserweight division. His signing would be a loss to the independent scene, but he'd make an ideal WWE Cruiserweight Champion.


6. Bad Zack

zack sabre jr
Twitter/@zacksabrejr

Zack Sabre Jr. has been a popular star in EVOLVE for a long time, but for some reason, the fans at EVOLVE 67 turned on him as the match went on. Maybe it was because Alexander was so great, or maybe they were all in an Olympic state of mind - after all, there were shouts and chants of "USA" at Sabre's expense. In any event, Sabre started working heel on the fly, eventually winning the match.

After the bout, the talented Englishman demanded a microphone and cut a promo that, while not flashy, got his point across. He insulted the fans for getting on his case, then made it perfectly clear that he was focused and after one thing - the EVOLVE Championship. Sabre put Timothy Thatcher on notice, as well as anyone else who might think about making a run at the organization's heavyweight belt.

Being that Timothy Thatcher finally wrapped up his feud with the Catch Point stable later in the show, it's not clear exactly what his next move will be. A feud with Sabre could work, as ZSJ attempts to add another prestigious independent belt to his collection.


5. It's Only Smoke And Mirrors

Cody Rhodes EVOLVE
WWN

The big draw for EVOLVE this past weekend was the independent debut of Cody Rhodes. Rhodes left WWE of his own volition in May, and with his no-compete clause having come to an end, he was ready to forge out on his own. His first non-WWE match came in Maryland on Friday evening, where he defeated Zack Sabre, Jr.

The question on many fans' minds regarded how Rhodes would perform in a totally different environment, one where different strengths are emphasized than in WWE. Unfortunately, his match against Chris Hero on Saturday was a letdown in that regard. While not bad by any stretch of the imagination, it felt like there were a whole lot of bells and whistles, as opposed to the traditional great action found in EVOLVE main events.

To start, Hero refused to shake Rhodes's hand, so Rhodes ran around the building shaking hands with fans. After a bit of action, they brawled around the arena and up onto the concession stand. The crowd was hot for it, and once they got back in the ring, they built to the finish, which saw Hero win after Drew Galloway hit Rhodes with a cowbell. It felt more like a WWE-style match than an EVOLVE one, and that's not a compliment.


4. Point Taken

Timothy Thatcher
EVOLVE

As mentioned, EVOLVE Champion Timothy Thatcher was only able to score a tainted victory over Matt Riddle in the spring, which led Riddle's Catch Point stable to denounce Thatcher as champion. In response, Thatcher relinquished the physical belt (though not the title of champion) until he could prove himself by beating everyone who was in Catch Point at the time of the Riddle match.

After taking care of TJP and Tracy Williams earlier in the summer, he defeated Riddle in Maryland on Friday. That just left stable leader Drew Gulak, who got his crack at the champ in Brooklyn. The match was very hold-oriented, which probably would have gotten over better in a different place in front of a different crowd. Immediately following the Rhodes-Hero brawl, this felt like a cooldown match, and in an 80-degree building, fans wanted action to keep their minds off the heat.

In the end, Thatcher hit Gulak with a headbutt and pinned him, re-establishing the legitimacy of his reign and ending his feud with Catch Point. After the bout, he continued to beat down Gulak, locking him in a choke and turning heel in the process. Given the recent fan response to the champion, it couldn't have come at a better time.


3. A Bit Of A Mess

EVOLVE 67
WWN

The main event, as advertised, was a six-man tag team match for the EVOLVE Tag Team Titles. Champs Drew Galloway and DUSTIN were joined by Ethan Carter III to take on Catch Point's Fred Yehi, Tracy Williams, and TJP. If Catch Point could win, the two team members of their choosing would get the belts.

The match started abruptly, as Williams ran out to save Drew Gulak from Timothy Thatcher. After that, the three heels attacked Williams and a brawl broke out, which Yehi and TJP joined. Williams ended up getting kayfabe hurt (though he left under his own power), making it a handicap match. Still, Yehi made it clear that Catch Point was still willing to fight, and they were joined by Ethan Page, making it a fair three-on-three contest.

Despite the hot setup, though, the match was a bit of a disappointment. There was some brawling around and in the ring, but that stuff can be hard to follow at an indy show with no screens. There were also no major surprises or storyline developments. After about ten minutes, the heels scored the win, ending an uncharacteristically weak EVOLVE main event.


2. Later, Slater

Heath Slater
WWE

As strange as it sounds, there's one thing that would have gone a long way toward making the main event feel important: a run-in from Heath Slater.

While Slater may not actually be the hottest free agent in wrestling, his recent attempts to get signed by either Raw or Smackdown have been entertaining parts of each show - and the fact that he's not contractually tied down to a brand in storyline means that an EVOLVE appearance could have been logical, if WWE signed off on it. There was certainly some talk to that effect, as EVOLVE's news blasts had mentioned being in negotiations with Slater.

The one thing that has yet to come out of WWE's relationship with EVOLVE is actual physical interference from a WWE talent at an EVOLVE show (Ethan Page trash-talked Sami Zayn during Zayn's Queens appearance, but that's about it). Had Slater run in during the match, it would have been a shock that the fans would have loved - and given his history with Drew Galloway, it would have made storyline sense as well.

Yes, a Heath Slater appearance would have been implausible, but given that Daniel Bryan, Cesaro, and Tyler Breeze all walked through the crowd at one point on their way to the locker room, would it have been impossible?


1. The Fix Is In

Johnny Gargano
wiki

After the match, the victorious heel squadron wasn't satisfied. They still had a question that needed to be answered.

Earlier, the group had made an offer to Joey Styles, who was making his first indy appearance since being fired by WWE. They wanted him to serve as mouthpiece for their anti-WWE stable, and they needed to know where he stood. Styles rejected the offer in no uncertain terms, but said that instead, he was going to play matchmaker.

The September 11 EVOLVE show in Queens - which will be Johnny Gargano's last show before joining WWE full-time - was advertised to have a main event of Gargano versus Cody Rhodes, but Styles was changing it. Instead, Gargano and Rhodes would team up in order to face Drew Galloway and Ethan Carter III.

Galloway and Carter were elated to get the opportunity to destroy their enemies, while Rhodes - who had run-in after the main event - was glad to get his hands on Galloway. Gargano wasn't there, as he was at Barclays Center for NXT TakeOver.

The match will likely be an exciting contest, but given that Gargano's swan song is now a bout against hated rivals rather than spirited competition with another big name, Ethan Page has the perfect opportunity to finally bury the knife in his old enemy's back. Page has been trying to win Gargano's respect for a year, but despite his seemingly-genuine nature, his quest for redemption always seemed a little too tidy to be true. At EVOLVE 69, the other shoe drops.


In this post: 
evolve
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013