10 Odd One Out Wrestling Champions

Out of place championship reigns, featuring Bret Hart, Tessa Blanchard and more...

Darby Allin
AEW

At its core, professional wrestling, like all sports, is the pursuit of gold, albeit with storylines weaved through such ambitions. Wrestling is often at its best, both in action and storylines, away from the top title picture. Yet, all roads ultimately lead to an arm raised by the referee and a championship fitted to the waist.

You'd be hard pressed to remember any notable in-ring talent who never held a championship. Even if it was a brief run with the tag titles or a fleeting reign with the Hardcore Championship (or its present day variant the 24/7 Championship). Even the briefest title victory is worthy of at least momentary celebration.

A championship win allows a wrestler to engrave their name in the history books, though in the internet age this often merely equates to a curious click on a name a fan vaguely recalls.

Being a part of professional wrestling history is still an honour. However, some recipients of this tribute are outright bizarre anomalies. Even taking into account decades of title holders, some ex-champions stand out significantly more than others.

10. Ember Moon

Ember Moon NXT War Games
WWE

At the time of writing, NXT is undergoing a drastic change. While there is debate on the peaks and troughs of quality, one of the aspects of the (former) black and gold brand that has remained consistent is the booking of Women's Champions. Every woman who has held the NXT strap has gone on to main roster success or has been showered with critical acclaim for classic matches. The name that stands out amongst them is Ember Moon.

Ember, a clear favourite with fans, has the in-ring skills and look of an absolute warrior. Yet, her in-ring career feels hampered compared to her fellow former champions. Moon has been held back by ill-timed injuries, which were particularly devastating during her main roster promotion.

She suffered an elbow injury during the 2019 Women's Royal Rumble match, and an ankle injury that kept her out of action until her re-debut in NXT at TakeOver 31. Moon was unsuccessful in challenging current champion Raquel González at NXT TakeOver: In Your House.

Ember's continued popularity and skill leaves the odds in her favour of recapturing the NXT Women's Championship for a second time, if not taking a main roster title.


9. Rick Steiner And Judy Bagwell

Rick Steiner Judy Bagwell
WWE.com

In his legendary teaming with his brother Scott, Rick Steiner wasn't a stranger to teaming up with partners on the more bizarre side of life. Still, even Rick must have been shocked when he learned replacing his injured and released Tag Team Co-Champ would be Judy 'Mother of Buff' Bagwell.

While a rather out of the box mind game tactic against his rival, having to take on tag teams with a non-wrestler on the apron, it makes something close to sense in the wacky confines of sports entertainment. The storyline was halted without capitalising on the curiosity when Steiner was forced to take time away from the ring due to injury. The vacant championships were won by Curt Hennig and Barry Windham at SuperBrawl IX. Perhaps things worked out for the best in terms of fan enjoyment, though in retrospect there is a certain camp B-movie charm to watching this era of WCW.

It is worth noting that Judy never lost the championship and held the WCW Tag Titles in the same year as the likes of Sting, Kevin Nash, and The Giant. Although unlike those wrestlers, she thankfully never held the company's top prize.


8. Vince McMahon

Vince McMahon ECW Champion
WWE.com

Vince McMahon could be a dual entry on this list, having held his own company's top prize, yet his reign with the (WWE) ECW Championship is the most jarring.

Though fans can attempt to draw a separation between the original ECW Championship and the disastrous WWE resurrection of the strap, the record books put Vince's name alongside iconic ECW alumni Terry Funk, Sabu, and Tommy Dreamer. The strap around McMahon's waist was the same one Funk and Sabu decimated their bodies for in a legendarily brutal barbed wire match at Born to be Wired 1997.

Admittedly, McMahon's reign was an awesome heel move. However, it still stung seeing ECW's main prize reduced to a prop to draw heat for a non-wrestler. While Vince's reign was the low point of New ECW, a look at those who held the prize provide further damnation.

The first New ECW Champion, Rob Van Dam, was an inspired choice, which allowed RVD to hold the championship that alluded him in his original run. From here it was all downhill, the majority of champions went against the original ECW ethos, favouring big guys such as Bobby Lashley and Big Show. Still, Vince remains the worst champion in the belt's history.


7. Oklahoma

Oklahoma WCW
WWE.com

WCW's Cruiserweight Division, particularly in its early days, is rightfully lauded as a turn in American wrestling. The Division's Championship was held by names such as Eddie Guerrero, Chris Jericho, and Rey Mysterio. In the case of these three, it propelled them to become industry legends. Though, it would be fair to hold mixed views about WCW's Cruiserweight Division

While Eric Bischoff's revamped vision of the former WCW Light Heavyweight Championship was a stroke of ingenuity and a significant part of WCW's mid-'90s success, his attention was taken away by the top of the card. Despite the argument that everything good about this period of WCW tanked by the end of the decade, the Cruiserweight Championship was among peak-WCW booking's greatest casualties.

Its death knell came at WCW Souled Out 2000, when Madusa (one of the better later champions) was defeated by Oklahoma, writer Ed Ferrara's wincing Jim Ross impersonation that mocked the beloved commentator's Bell's Palsy. Though he held the belt for just two days - the punchline saw him stripped of it due to exceeding the title's weight limit - the WCW Cruiserweight Championship never recovered.


6. Gillberg

Gillberg Light Heavyweight
WWE Network

The WWE Light Heavyweight Championship never had the same promise as its WCW counterpart. Between 1981 and 1995 it was used to cement a working relationship between the then-WWF and the Universal Wrestling Association. It was defended exclusively on UWA shows.

After UWA shut down, and the belt was one of eight titles unified to create NJPW's J-Crown Championship, WWE requested the title be returned as a prize for the company's 1997 rebooted Light Heavyweight Division.

While the division is often rubbished, not helped by WWE dropping its name in favour for the WCW equivalent, it's championship was held by future World Champions in the shape of Christian and Jeff Hardy, in-ring technician Dean Malenko, and two-time WWE Hall of Famer X-Pac. In fact, all but one champion reign had merit; the Era of Gillberg.

Gillberg was an anaemic parody of WCW star attraction Goldberg that mocked everything from his signature armband tattoos to his spine-tingling entrance. Making matters all the worse, due to the reboot, Gillberg is the longest reigning Light Heavyweight Champion, holding the strap for 453 days (17 November 1998 – 8 February 2000), though, he only defended the championship successfully twice on TV, retaining against Marc Mero and Matt Hardy.


5. David Arquette

David Arquette
WWE.com

In 2000, WCW was on its knees, grounded by a flurry of bad creative choices and the misuse of talent. However, the tainted beyond repair WCW World Heavyweight Championship was the bow on top of the company's corpse when it was delivered to Titan Towers.

The tarnished championship can not of course be blamed on a single person, yet, there is a definitive point that tipped the balance from remediable to last rites; when David Arquette went from promoting Ready to Rumble, a wresting themed movie, to becoming a World Champion in a major wrestling promotion. While wrestling fans could've been happy for fellow wrestling fan Arquette winning WCW's main prize, it came at severe cost to the company's product and fan's enjoyment.

Just a year prior, the strap was around the waists of heavy hitters such as Sting, Hulk Hogan, Bret Hart, and Ric Flair; even if these reigns were far from the most successful of these wrestlers' storied careers.

The WCW World Heavyweight Championship wouldn't have to wait too long for further disgrace. Mere months after Arquette dropped the title, Vince Russo staked a brief claim on WCW's top prize, quickly passing he belt on to Vacant.


4. Miss Kitty / ‘Hervina’

Hervina GIF
WWE Network

While women's wrestling in the West has had a tumultuous history, the worst period for the WWE Women's Championship stretches from Madusa throwing it in a trashcan to Lita taking the strap from Stephanie McMahon in the main event of 21 August 2000 edition of Raw.

Every effort has been made to narrow this choice down to one. However, both competitors and their subsequent reigns are a blight on the WWE Women's championship and women's wrestling.

Miss Kitty (a.k.a. The Kat) was a non-wrestler who entered the business via her marriage to Jerry Lawler. Despite this, she was awarded the WWE Women's Championship after winning a Four Corners Evening Gown match at Armageddon 1999, flashing her breasts to the audience in celebration.

Just when things couldn't seem to get any more reductive, Kitty's challenger was 'Hervina'; Harvey Wippleman in deliberately bad drag. To strain to give a minor positive slant, at least the two non-wrestlers didn't attempt to put on a traditional pro-wresting clash. 'Hervina' won the Women's Championship in a Lumberjill Snow Bunny match contested in a pool of fake snow. Fortunately, Jacqueline provided a merciful end to 'Hervina's' reign after just one day.


3. Darby Allin

Darby Allin
AEW

The AEW TNT Championship, at only approximately 18 months old, doesn't have the same vast lineage as the other titles that make up these lists. Yet, of the current holders of the TNT Championship Darby Allin is the outlier, having never previously held a WWE mid-card championship.

The inaugural holder Cody Rhodes held the Intercontinental Championship on two occasions, Brodie Lee held it once, and Miro held the United States Championship on three occasions. We'll leave internet comment sections to debate whether Darby Allin will accomplish this retroactively.

Rather than be a slight, this could be spun as further evidence that Allin is an AEW original who stands out among talent whose most notable employment was with WWE. But again, that's a discussion best for rabid comment sections.

Allin is the current longest-reigning TNT Champion, holding on to the belt for 186 days. While not wanting to reduce a championship to a prop, his run did what a midcard championship should and established Allin as a star. His reign, as well as his unique look and innovative offence, has cemented him as a talent to watch.


2. Bret Hart

Bret Hart Us Champion
WWE.com

A strong debate could be mounted that Bret Hart is the greatest wrestler to ever step foot in the squared circle, undisputedly deserving of all his championships and accolades. However, his 2010 run with the WWE United States Championship, over a decade since he won the WCW incarnation of the strap on 25 October 1999, was an odd booking decision.

Since WWE took over ownership of the US title, it is largely a prize held by up-and-coming talent who capture the weekly TV audience with either their technical prowess or over characterisation. The championship was a key part of SmackDown's '00s renaissance, bolstering the stock of wrestlers such as Eddie Guerrero, Chris Benoit, and John Cena.

When Hart won the WWE United States Championship, he was a 52-year-old Hall of Famer who'd suffered a career-ending injury. He returned to WWE TV via the feud between The Hart Dynasty (David Hart Smith & Tyson Kidd) and ShowMiz (Big Show & The Miz). Rather than put the championship on a younger member of the Hart clan, in line with the title's previous use, Bret defeated Miz - only to vacate the strap one week later.


1. Tessa Blanchard

Tessa Blanchard
Impact Wrestling

The Impact World Championship has the most obvious odd one out champion in Tessa Blanchard. Not only shattering Impact's glass ceiling, Blanchard was also the first woman to have a recognised reign with a men's World Championship. The booking provoked fierce debate among the fandom, yet, no fan could deny that it pushed Impact Wrestling to the centre of attention, a place it had not truly occupied since its TNA days.

Blanchard also went down as the company's most controversial World Champion. Shortly after her big win, reports online from former colleagues called Blanchard out for past incidents of racism and bullying that proved a stark contrast to the female empowerment angle that Blanchard rode to championship success.

Blanchard further added to her controversial run with Impact's top prize, refusing to show up for Impact tapings to defend her title. As this was during the pandemic, Blanchard was justified in not wanting to travel from isolating in Mexico with her fiancé. Yet, she allegedly refused to pre-tape content as requested and, after being stripped of the title, she reportedly asked the company for $150,000 to return the championship belt.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Darby Allin
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

An English Lit. MA Grad trying to validate my student debt by writing literary fiction and alternative non-fiction.