10 Oddest WCW Storylines Of All Time

The storylines that made us all scratch our heads in confusion...

Goldust Fire Much like WWE today, WCW had a lot of TV time to fill during the 1990s. While WCW didn€™t always have the overwhelming schedule that they had in the midst of the Monday Night Wars, the organisation had still been running for a very long time, and was constantly having to try and come up with engaging stories and ideas to either survive or flourish €“ depending on what year we are talking about. Some of these storylines were superb. Much has been written already about how the company stumbled into crafting the mythos of Goldberg in a way that couldn€™t be more perfect. And even more has been written about how the nWo changed the wrestling landscape forever. But what we are interested in here is the stuff that confused us, and left us scratching our heads. WCW had its fair share of odd storylines that no doubt were the result of poor planning, short term tunnel vision, and desperation. Surprisingly though, not all these stories come in the dark final days of the company before being shut down. They are constant throughout the entire history of the company. Equally surprising is the fact that not all these storylines are actually bad as such €“ they just don€™t make sense like they should, or are missing key elements that would make things logical. Regardless of how you feel about the following ten storylines, hopefully we can all agree that they weresome of the oddest ones to grace our screens.

10. The Tonight Show With...Eric Bischoff?

WCW has gotten a lot of flak for its use of celebrities, particularly from WWE €“ which is strange considering the abysmal state of celebrity involvement in WWE over the past few years. In fairness to WCW though, some of these celebrities they used were okay. The Karl Malone and Dennis Rodman feud was a brilliant combination of reality and fiction, even if the wrestling was subpar. And for all the words written about David Arquette€™s infamous reign as WCW Champion, at least the organisation had the smarts to do the whole thing in a very tongue in cheek fashion. There were at least a few laughs from a frustrated Courtney Cox Arquette trying to tell her deluded husband that he wasn€™t actually the champion. The Jay Leno angle on the other hand€well that was just odd and confusing from the start. The whole thing started when Eric Bischoff decided that he apparently wanted to mimic the success of Tuesday Night Titans and start a wrestling talk show. However in typical Bischoff form he didn€™t do a huge amount of planning and simply constructed a $75,000 talk show set and went about interrupting his already watered down three hour Nitro broadcast to talk smack about whatever was on his mind €“ including Jay Leno. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wtHOt-hLaX8 This is already kind of strange in itself, but things just became downright surreal when the segment continued on, and a kayfabe war of words between Leno and the nWo inexplicably began. Smelling a continuation of the mainstream exposure the company had experienced the month before with Rodman and Malone, Bischoff upped the ante and increased the time dedicated to this talk show war (on his alleged wrestling show mind you) leading to a match at Road Wild 1998 which is as infamous as it is painful to watch. For those few that have never seen the match it should be noted that Jay Leno wasn€™t just on the winning tag team, but he made the winning pin. The whole thing kind of fizzled away after this and within a few months Hogan was back to being a guest on Leno€™s show as if the whole affair had never really happened, which only added to the cynicism the fans had towards the angle, and the overall confusion it caused.

9. New Blood Vs Millionaire's Club

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2hmKeVUxmI For all the abuse that Vince Russo cops regarding his time in WCW (most of which is probably deserved), some people can agree on giving him partial credit for one thing - his attempt to elevate new stars in a company which was still being headlined by borderline senior citizens. After all when Russo was one of the writers at WWE the depth of the roster was immense, and there was a substantial rise in mid card talent. So when he and Bischoff came up with the idea of a storyline which pitted the frustrated young members of the WCW roster against the egomaniacal old wrestlers desperately clinging on to their spot, the angle logically sounded like it could be red hot. Of course this being WCW in the year 2000 things didn€™t go quite like that. The major problem that made the angle so odd was that it seemed the heels and the faces were the wrong way round. The New Blood, comprised of mostly young WCW wrestlers who had been relegated to mid-card purgatory (think guys like Booker T, Billy Kidman, and Chris Kanyon) were the heels. The old guys who had done everything they could to hold on to their spot at the expense of the long term sustainability of the company (think Hogan, Kevin Nash, and Lex Luger) were the faces. It was like having Apollo Creed as our sympathetic protagonist, and having him overcome the plucky underdog Rocky using his wealth and power. Depending on whose account you listen to there are multiple reasons for this. Some cite the stubborn refusal of the old guard in putting the new guard over. Some cite the fact it was simply a case of the New Blood not being believable contenders. Whatever the reason(s) the sheer weirdness of what should have been a pretty straightforward angle lead to its hasty abandonment after just a couple of months and it was back to the same old madness in WCW. This was despite the promise the storyline held as a really interesting angle, and a chance for the lower and mid card talent to get over for a change.

8. Lost In Cleveland

It is understandable that Mick Foley doesn€™t necessarily look too kindly on his time in WCW. After constantly sacrificing his health and wellbeing in some of the most brutal matches in the company€™s history (including that one time he lost an ear), Foley was never able to earn any real respect or career advancement. There are a lot of examples that Foley cites in his books of odd treatment and storylines in Atlanta, but there is one particularly shining example that stands out€“ the Lost in Cleveland debacle. Foley and Big Van Vader had been having an intense rivalry, and in one of their televised matches Vader delivered a sickening power bomb to Foley on the concrete outside the ring that made him black out. Whilst an incident like this could potentially be turned into wrestling storyline gold, Dusty Rhodes (who was booking at the time) managed to turn it into wrestling storyline mould. Rather than simply using the event to intensify the rivalry to new heights, Rhodes (who was in the midst of a fascination with making short films that would make Ed Wood blush) told Foley of his plans to turn him into an AWOL vagrant with amnesia that was induced by the power bomb. Understandably Foley was sceptical about the logic of such a storyline direction, but when told that he€™d be paid to be off the road for a few months, he did what any wrestler would probably do in the same situation and said €˜yes sir€™. This lead to some of the oddest of vignettes and creative choices in the history of a company now known for specialising in odd vignettes and creative choices. Essentially Foley was to play a character who not only couldn€™t remember being Cactus Jack, but was convinced he was a sailor. He was living on the streets in Cleveland with a €˜colourful€™ cast of vagrants and crazies including a girlfriend called €˜bang bang€™ - despite the fact this was Cactus Jack's catchphrase and he supposedly couldn€™t remember being him. WCW then profiled these revelations through some of the cheesiest false news reports ever committed to television. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tQ2p91aWdA As if all this wasn€™t convoluted and odd enough, they ended the angle by doing a swerve and having Foley reveal that he was pretending to be an amnesiac the entire time. So essentially months of filming and bizarre news stories were thrown out the window to bring the angle back to where it should have been from the beginning.

7. Seven

Because of its brevity, people often associate the character of Seven as just being in a gimmick when in actuality it was an entire storyline €“ albeit a storyline that was the textbook definition of an odd and possibly misguided narrative. The story of Seven began when creepy vignettes were shown in which Runnels, powdered in all white so that his face pretty much looked like a real life Michael Myers mask, was lurking outside of a child€™s bedroom and commanding him to join him. His deep growling voice, and some interesting filming choices made for a very contrived yet somewhat entertaining series of mysterious vignettes, and implied that a supernatural character of sorts, was going to debut on WCW. This was no doubt inspired largely by the popularity of characters like the Undertaker and Kane in WWE. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QWtXAtGJ4JQ So far then, this was all pretty straightforward. But when Standards and Practices saw what was happening, they wanted to put the kibosh on the whole thing out of fear that the character could be seen as a child abductor. Thus Russo made the decision that they should kill the character before it even debuted and then things took a turn for the strange. Russo discussed killing the gimmick with Runnels (who created the character) and it was decided that rather than simply cut their losses and abandon all the work they had done with Seven, they€™d give him an entrance where he would cut a worked shoot on the company, the industry, and his history as an over the top performer. This would set the stage for Runnels to abandon the gimmick and then re-debut as simply Dustin Runnels. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xkin5d_goldust-wcw-debut-as-seven_sport So Runnels appeared as Seven in what was actually a pretty impressive entrance and then cut a blistering promo which is still remembered today, as much for the confusion it caused amongst the fans watching in the arena and at home, as much for its entertaining content. He then started to wrestle as Dustin Runnels €“ the normal man who was sick of over the top gimmicks like Goldust and Seven. And so that was it €“that was the end of the Seven storyline. Was it convoluted? Yes. Was it odd? Definitely. But what is it also original? Absolutely.

6. Warrior VS Hogan II

Where to begin with this storyline? There were many things odd about it, but what was probably the oddest was how WCW managed to completely screw up what had to be one of the simplest storyline opportunities in the history of the industry. When Warrior made an appearance on Nitro in 1998 and proceeded to spout what felt like two hours of incomprehensible gibberish at Hollywood Hogan, the audience should have known what they were going to have in store for them. But their misguided optimism was relentless. After all, Warrior and Hogan at Wrestlemania VI was one of the great Wrestlemania main events and by mid-1998 Hogan was starting to gather some real €˜X-Pac Heat€™ from an audience that had grown tired of his shenanigans, so there was a myriad of options to make this storyline engrossing. Unfortunately what the audience got what was an odd collision of the supernatural, the boring, and wrestling storytelling from another era. Rather than a simple rematch with a slow build, WCW (no doubt at the behest of Warrior and Hogan who both had creative control clauses in their contracts) set about creating one of the most intelligence insulting, and nonsensical storylines they could. Warrior wasn€™t just hyperactive €“ he was now a superhero. In the two years since he had last been on an active roster these were some of the new skills that the Warrior had somehow managed to acquire: He now had the ability to appear in the ring using smoke; he now had the ability to appear in Hogan€™s dressing room mirror so that everyone could see him except for Eric Bischoff; he now had the ability to brainwash Z grade wrestlers like Ed Leslie; and he now had the ability to get paid seven figures for competing in a number of matches that could be counted on one hand. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78XbX5tVFeY Needless to say the mixture of supernatural cults, superhero powers, and some of the most confusing storytelling in the company€™s history grew very tiring for the fans very quickly. When Hogan and Warrior competed in a match at Halloween Havoc 1998 that can only be described as €˜craptacular€™ the madness thankfully came to a screeching halt. While mercifully it€™d be the last we€™d see of Warrior in WCW, Hogan still had another couple of years to test the audience€™s patience and wring what little was left out of the dying company for himself.

5. White Castle Of Fear

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EwYh9oX1vTE This is the second entry on this list to feature some of Dusty Rhodes€™ fabulous film making. This time it was Sting who was subjected to the maniacal whims of a clearly deluded Rhodes and his penchant for making both wrestlers and the audience regret ever getting involved with the product. This breath-taking piece of storytelling came just a couple of months before Foley got the pleasure of making his own mini movies. Luckily both Sting and Foley would go on to be legends and came out relatively unscathed from these narrative disasters (although it wasn€™t like this was the first time Sting had been put in an odd scenario€as we€™ll soon see). Much like with €˜Lost in Cleveland€™ this storyline was based around a Vader feud. However Vader had a much more central role in this one than he did with Foley, and it is fair to say this role basically made him look like a buffoon instead of the fearsome monster he was supposed to be. The storyline should have been simple enough. Vader has title; Sting wants title; Vader and Sting wrestle for title. But as you€™ve guessed it didn€™t pan out like that. Instead the story took an extraordinary detour into surreal territory when it was revealed that not only did Vader own his own castle in the Rocky Mountains (where it was still warm enough for Vader to simply wear his Lycra wrestling gear) but he wanted to Sting to join him in some sort of game. Oh and the castle was called the €˜White Castle of Fear€™. That should be highlighted because we think that sounds like something a couple of five year olds would call their pillow fort. Rather than thinking to himself that this was all absolutely insane and that maybe he shouldn€™t go by himself to a place called the White Castle of Fear, Sting instead chartered a helicopter and joined Vader in his party. While on the Chopper we got to hear Sting€™s inner monologue and what we assume were his own mental visions of Vader taunting him as fake snow blew across his husky frame in shots that rivalled all the sophistication of a Kindergarten presentation. Upon arrival Sting and Vader engaged in a tug of war (no really €“ they engaged in a tug of war) and then the screen faded to black with an ominous €˜To Be Continued€™ coming up across the screen, just so the audience knew they had more of this crap to come. They then wrestled at Superbrawl III in a €˜White Castle of Fear Strap Match€™, which in fact was actually just a strap match. Sting would accidentally launch Vader into the final corner giving Vader the win, so he could retain his title while Sting still looked strong and the feud would end. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ihwAbLHpMRw Actually we€™re just kidding, that would€™ve been far too normal. In fact the title wasn€™t even on the line in this match. The match was actually €˜unsanctioned€™, so essentially Sting risked going up into the mountains for absolutely no reason at all and this storyline had absolutely no meaning whatsoever. Fantastic.

4. Kevin Nash, Randy Savage, And The Hummer

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IkURI9m8zHo In 1999 Kevin Nash was feuding with a returning Randy Savage, complete with a newly darkened outfit, a newly steroid inflated physique, and a new valet named Gorgeous George. The feud was initially pretty standard stuff until a particularly ridiculous segment in which Macho Man hijacked Kevin Nash€™s limo and locked him inside. Savage escaped from the limo while Nash tried to unlock the doors in a panic. Suddenly a white hummer careened into the limo at high speed, assumedly mangling or at least injuring, Big Sexy (and the unfortunate cameramen who were in the limo filming the interior from two different angles - but let's just forget about them). Nash crawled out of the wreck looking broken down and seriously injured, and it appeared the Macho Man had one upped the seven footer. WCW was hoping that their fans would be abuzz with the question of who was driving the Humvee. A similar angle had worked in WWE with Stone Cold getting hit by a car. However in their rush to replicate this aspect of the storyline, it appeared as if WCW forgot that angle was a bit of a fizzer when it was revealed that Rikishi was inexplicably the driver. WCW should have taken that as a warning sign, but of course they didn't and they forged ahead anyway. The question of who drove the Hummer became one of their biggest storylines of the year, and one of the strangest too. WCW wrung the storyline out for months over multiple PPV's hinting that it could have been Sid Vicious, Hogan, or even Sting(!). They dropped the storyline once only to bring it back almost immediately, and then just after they brought it back Savage left the company because he just couldn't cope with the insanity any longer. Nash was also forced into a storyline retirement at this time, but somehow WCW thought they could still keep the question of who was driving the Hummer in the air even though fans had lost interest months ago, and the two main characters involved in the storyline were no longer on screen. Eventually the storyline was simply just dropped altogether and never spoken of again. What is also surprisingly odd about this storyline in hindsight is just how little WWE has learned from it, and how rather than being an anomaly, this technique of €˜let€™s just pretend it never happened€™ story telling is more common than ever today. So in that regard maybe WCW were just ahead of the curve.

3. Harlem Heat 2000

The less said about this storyline the better, as fourteen years later we€™re not even sure we understand what the hell this was about. So here is our attempt to sum this one up in a nutshell: Harlem Heat (Booker T and Stevie Ray) were having relationship problems with each other like all tag teams inevitably do. Stevie Ray thus got a new partner who called himself Big T, and so he brought in a lawyer named J Biggs to€make it official we guess? Biggs then told Booker T that if he called himself Booker T, then he would be sued for copyright infringement since he was no longer part of Harlem Heat. €˜Booker€™ was fine mind you, it was just €˜Booker T€™ wasn€™t. This lead to a conflict between the former Harlem Heat members that made pretty much zero sense and bored the life out of the crowd, as WCW lay on life support getting weaker every day. Aside from the fact the core of this feud was about a name, what was so puzzling and odd was the assumption from WCW creative that the WCW audience had even a modicum of interest in the ins and outs of copyright legislation. Nothing kills a wrestling storyline faster than litigation being brought into the story because litigation is boring at the very best of times. Wrestling exists in a parallel universe where laws don€™t really matter, and where all problems ranging from infidelity to financial fraud are sorted out in the ring immediately. That€™s part of the appeal. The idea that fans would be interested in legal intricacies of how the alphabet can be distributed amongst the roster is gobsmacking. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x82elv_kidman-booker-t-vs-harlem-heat-2000_sport And of course in the end it all meant nothing as after a while the story was disposed of and Booker T would go back to being known by that moniker for the rest of his career.

2. Hulk Hogan And The Dungeon Of Doom

Despite the fact that Hulk Hogan was starting to alienate as many WWE fans than he was appealing to by the end of his run there, WCW leapt at the chance to bring him into their organisation, so he could bring with him some mainstream credibility. His addition to the roster legitimised the company in the eyes of casual viewers and mainstream outlets, but unfortunately it wasn€™t 1986 anymore, and people grew very tired of Hogan€™s shtick with great haste. The battle between Hulk Hogan and the Taskmaster Kevin Sullivan€™s Dungeon of Doom stable is widely considered to be a storyline that isn€™t just odd, but was indicative of all that was wrong with WCW and Hogan in the years prior to the formation of the nWo. After failing to kill Hulkamania with his previous stable, the Three Faces of Fear, Sullivan formed the Dungeon of Doom to have another crack, which in itself is really a lazy beginning to a story. The Dungeon had a prestigious roster consisting of Earthquake John Tenta who was now renamed €˜the Shark€™ and was now clothed in a not so menacing baby blue ensemble with cartoon shark teeth on it; €˜the Zodiac€™ who is more commonly known as Ed Leslie €“ Hogan€™s best friend; and others such as Meng, Vader, Kamala the Ugandan Giant (yes it was as racist as it sounds), and for a while the Giant. It should be noted that at first the Giant was also said to be the son of Andre, much to his chagrin and seething frustration. They would also later feature a mummy inexplicably called €˜the Yeti€™, and a character called €˜Loch Ness€™ (no...really). There is probably too much to write about with this storyline as it went on so long but needless to say high points include the revelation that the Zodiac (Hogan€™s best friend remember) was in actuality a spy for Hogan all along; Hogan going €˜dark€™ and dressing in black for the first time because of the madness the Dungeon had inflicted upon him (only to be back to yellow and red immediately after); and numerous vignettes like the one below that will leave you wondering how on earth those involved could have ever thought that this was a storyline that could ever go over, and be taken seriously by the audience in the arena and at home. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pretEZVIXv4 We might think that WWE makes some odd storyline decisions today, but it would be hard to top this awful narrative. Although, in the pantheon of odd storylines, this still wasn€™t the apex€

1. Robocop - WCW Icon

Sting Robocop While again we point out that WWE has been absolutely woeful in its use of celebrities in recent years, at least by and large the celebrities have been themselves rather than the characters they play in their respective mediums. For some reason though WCW thought it would be great to do the opposite of this and create odd storylines, or simply €˜enhance€™ regular storylines, by utilising fictional characters playing themselves in the real world. The first example of this was the legendary Robocop affair at Capital Combat 1990. For those few of you unfamiliar with this glorious piece of wrestling history we€™ll bring you up to speed. Robocop 2 was being released in 1990, so naturally WCW figured that it€™d be wise to pair up their baby face superstar Sting, with the fictional character to help him combat the threat of the Four Horsemen. Vignettes had been aired on WCW television showing Sting and Robocop teaming together, but vignettes are only one part of wrestling storytelling, and the fans hoped against hope that WCW wouldn€™t actually go through with having the two team up live. Of course WCW ignored their wishes and at the Capital Combat PPV when the Four Horsemen had Sting locked in a giant bird cage (?) it was Robocop that broke Sting out in a spot that can only be described as insulting and humiliating for all involved. Ric Flair, considered in many circles to be the greatest pro wrestler of all time, had to cower in fear at the sight of some guy wearing a birthday party quality Robocop suit, in a segment no doubt missing from his top ten proudest moments in wrestling. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Afr0xwde0Aw What was going on in the mind-set of those in WCW, we€™ll never really be able to conceive of or understand. Well that€™s not quite true. We know they saw money for some reason, we just don€™t understand why. But at least after this legendary failure the suits who would run WCW in later years had learned from Jim Herd€™s mistake and didn€™t try anything like this again. Until 1998 that is. Having somehow forgotten that as much as wrestling fans are aware that what they are watching is predetermined, they still don€™t like feeling like complete morons for supporting a company, WCW tried to blur the lines between fiction and reality. This time Rick Steiner was the lucky individual to have his memory tarnished as he got into a verbal altercation with the doll Chucky from the movie Child€™s Play (or to be specific the sequel Bride of Chucky which was being released at this time). Yes Chucky. A murderous doll. At least Robocop was tall we guess? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hz1DHgdVKeE Chucky was there to warn Rick Steiner not to get in the way of Rick Steiner during their upcoming bout at Halloween Havoc. Why? It was never explained. But Chucky broke the fourth wall talking about his love scenes with Jennifer Tilly in the movie, and plugged the flick in a way that was about as subtle as a jackhammer. So the point of this whole thing was for the audience to somehow believe that Chucky was real and was€playing himself in the movie? It€™s really hard to try and make sense of it. The fact that Chucky had an opinion on who he€™d rather see emerge victorious out of Rick and Scott Steiner is arguably the least confusing aspect of this (mercifully) brief storyline that went beyond odd, and into the idiotic.

In this post: 
WCW Goldust
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Contributor for WhatCulture across the board, and professional student. Sports obsessed. Movie nerd. Wrestling tragic. Historical junkie. I have only loved three things my entire life: my family, Batman, and the All Blacks.