10 Potentially Awesome WWE Feuds Which Failed To Deliver
Nobody drops the ball like WWE drops the ball!
Wrestling fans are an interesting bunch. WWE constantly serves us up rivalries with massive potential and then fails to follow through. What do we do in response? Take to the internet and let our complaints fly before continuing to follow the company blindly, no matter what they feed us.
By in no means is this list a scathing takedown of WWE as a whole, because, at the end of the day, the overall product isn't overly horrible. It's just that, unfortunately, many of the programs that look amazing on paper ultimately fall flat. Whether it's a dream match gone wrong or a slow-burn rivalry that didn't hit the right notes when in the ring, so many recent explosive feuds just haven't connected as well as we all thought they would. The reason behind this can't even be tied to one single thing. It could be the overhype from fans, lack of chemistry between the two performers, or as Chris Jericho once said, it could have been "A stupid idea from bad creative!"
Either way, not every dream feud can live up to expectations.
10. Braun Strowman Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura
Poor Shinsuke Nakamura, he really does appear to be trying his best. But there is only so much you can achieve when management doesn't support you.
When the Japanese star defeated Finn Bálor for the Intercontinental Title it looked like it was finally his time to shine. But no, instead he was only on TV sporadically until they paired him with Sami Zayn as his mouthpiece. Nakamura was approaching 200 days as champ and was once again picking up steam, and then Braun Strowman stepped in. Fans everywhere hoped that the King of Strong Style would pick Strowman apart with vicious kicks and devastating knees. Nakamura has shown in the past that bigger men can often bring out the best in him, as NJPW fans will remember.
To nobody's surprise, Braun ran over him in a mostly one-sided affair. Then instead of a one-on-one rematch, we got a handicap match with Braun taking on the whole Artist Collective. And Sami Zayn won, meaning the coveted singles strong style affair between Nakamura and Braun was off the table. What a missed opportunity.
9. Dean Ambrose Vs. Brock Lesnar
Now here is a feud that could have stolen the whole damn year in 2016. Sadly, a combination of an unmotivated Brock Lesnar and an uninspired creative team let this ball drop.
When Dean Ambrose stepped up to the Beast and challenged him to a No Holds Barred match of all things, fans everywhere went absolutely nuts. If this was handled right, there was no doubt that it was going to be the match of the night. At this point, every fan knew about Ambrose's past as the violent Jon Moxley, leading them to anticipate a bloodbath in the middle of AT&T Stadium. To be fair to WWE, this was never going to happen, so the fans overhyping the potential violence did play a factor in the downfall of this match.
However, WWE did commit the dastardly act of teasing us all with different hardcore legends showing up on Raw every week to offer their signature weapons to Dean. We could have gotten thumbtacks and Mick Foley's Barbie Bat; they even teased Barbie and Chainsaw Charlie in the actual match! Instead, we just got kendo sticks, steel chairs and a whole lot of German suplexes.
The now once-more Jon Moxley has gone on record many times about how many ideas he pitched to Lesnar, Heyman, creative and Vince McMahon, but nobody seemed interested. Sadly, this wasn't the first instance of Dean Ambrose's ideas being ignored.
8. Damien Sandow Vs. The Miz
Poor Damien Sandow. The man had proven himself time and time again, yet the company just never got behind him. No matter how stupid of an idea they gave him, Sandow took the ball and ran with it and with his efforts in this storyline he took the ball and outran Usain Bolt.
Sandow as The Miz's stunt double was a stroke of genius. Every week he was the highlight of Raw and SmackDown as his actions got more and more deranged, he got increasingly entertaining. Soon enough, he was the most over wrestler on the roster. It appeared that the struggling star was finally going to reach mid-card stardom at least. When the relationship began to get tense, everybody was waiting for the explosive break up and when it finally came at WrestleMania 31 when Sandow eliminated Miz from the Andre The Giant Battle Royal, the entire crowd erupted in support.
Eyes turned to the next night on Raw to see the follow-up, yet instead of the explosion of heat we expected to see, we instead saw a small fizzle. The only thing that was different was Summer Rae now favoured Sandow over Miz and the two traded wins on Raw. Sandow then lost to Miz in the concluding match but did he continue on his wave of momentum? No. Instead he decided to play dress up with Curtis Axel for a few months. Nice.
7. Bray Wyatt Vs. Randy Orton
Many didn't expect Bray Wyatt and Randy Orton to have as much chemistry as they did when they teamed up in late 2016. But when Orton shockingly joined the Wyatt Family, he seemed like a perfect fit. He was always inevitably going to turn on the group and it appeared, on the surface, that WWE was generating a great, slow-burn rivalry that would culminate at WrestleMania 33.
Orton winning the 2017 Royal Rumble acted as the catalyst for one of the most anticipated feuds of WrestleMania season. Everything about the buildup was really good: the tension between Orton and Luke Harper, subtle foreshadowing throughout until Orton finally struck and announced he'd be challenging Wyatt for the title on the grandest stage of them all. When the match finally came, instead of an intense fight, we got a bunch of bugs projected onto the ring. The match with the most potential had turned into the worst of the night. Plus, the decision to put the title on Orton just sucked all of Wyatt's momentum that he'd worked so hard to build over the past six months.
Then the House of Horrors debacle happened and the whole feud had fizzled. Wyatt as a whole was dead in the water, only managing to return to the same heights two years later when he repackaged himself as The Fiend. Such potential wasted.
6. Becky Lynch Vs. Shayna Baszler
The Man vs. The Queen of Spades? Shut up and take my money!
That was the thoughts on everyone's minds when the feud was teased between two of the best women in the company who had yet to cross paths before Survivor Series. The stage was set, Baszler wins the Rumble and storms into WrestleMania to have a show stealer with Lynch and begin a long-dominant reign as Raw Women's Champion. Except Charlotte Flair won the Rumble because of course she did. But don't worry, Baszler still showed up to confront Lynch soon enough. However, instead of absolutely batting her, she ... bit her neck?
The build towards this momentous match also lacked the fire that it should have had. The sit-down interviews fell flat and so did the promos. Fans, however, still hoped for a highly intense contest that made up for the poor build. Instead, we got a short affair that never really got going before an awkward-looking rollup won the match for Lynch. What a letdown: two years running had a match of the year candidate from Lynch at WrestleMania been ruined by a botchy rollup.
Knowing what we know now - that being that Lynch was pregnant at the time - explains why it was such a safe match and I think every fan agrees that they'd rather a bad match than put Lynch's unborn child at risk. Hopefully, the two get another chance to show what they've got when Lynch returns in a couple of years.
5. AJ Styles Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura
When Shinsuke Nakamura and AJ Styles ended up on SmackDown in late 2017, fans went crazy at the thought that the two would inevitably cross paths. Then Nakamura spectacularly won the Royal Rumble and it was on. The dream match of all dream matches, Nakamura vs. Styles for the WWE Championship at WrestleMania. It was enough to make any hardcore wrestling fan faint.
The match itself wasn't horrible, but in reality, it was always going to be a letdown due to the astronomical expectations that had been placed on it after their five-star affair from Wrestle Kingdom 10. After this, all the feud contained was a whole lot of kicks in the d*ick. Literally. The entire feud was based around the fact that Nakamura now enjoyed to abuse Styles' special area with a myriad of uppercuts and kicks.
Why? One can assume that it was because Vince McMahon found it amusing.
Nonetheless, the whole thing reeked and got worse and worse the longer it went on and boy did it go long. Stretching four straight pay per views, fans got tired of the feud quick and Nakamura had gone from one of the most over talents on the roster to the one of the blandest in six short months. Hopefully the two get another chance to redeem themselves with a feud over Styles' newly won Intercontinental Championship.
4. Cody Rhodes Vs. Goldust
Everybody knew how much WWE dropped the ball with this feud after it happened. Then to rub salt in the metaphorical wound, AEW showed them exactly how amazing a feud between the Rhodes brothers really could be.
The Stardust character had run its course long before the tensions between the brothers and a big blow-off WrestleMania match between Goldust and a heel Cody Rhodes, NOT Stardust, could certainly be a match of the year candidate. Both men seemed more motivated than they had been in years to make it work and according to them, both pitched many ideas for different avenues the feud could go down. One intriguing idea even involved Cody developing a split personality, this being four years before The Fiend came to town.
As much as the performers were invested, the company just didn't seem to be. The feud was mostly built through WWE.com exclusive segments and their pleas for a WrestleMania match, even on the Pre-Show, were denied and the contest was relegated to Fastlane.
The match itself was just plain. Not horrible, but it didn't set the world on fire like it could have and like it did the second time around four years later.
3. Seth Rollins Vs. Dean Ambrose (2018)
But how could this feud possibly be on this list? It was such good sh*t! Right?
When Ambrose returned in the summer of 2018, fans were delighted, everyone expected the man to bring a renewed frenzy to weekly television. He looked jacked and ready to fight in the best shape of his life. But everything about this was just horrid. From the moment Ambrose turned on Seth Rollins, the next five months just kept going downhill. Not one bit was as entertaining as the program that occurred between the two in 2014. First came the uncomfortably insensitive insulting of cancer suffering Roman Reigns, then came the gas mask (thank god that he drew the line at a pooper scooper).
None of the matches between the two piqued any interest and out of nowhere, it was all scrapped. Why? Because the company had realised that Ambrose was serious about leaving and turned him face once more for one last Shield reunion.
Sadly, I don't think we will ever see these two mix it up in a WWE ring ever again. But hey, crazier things have happened.
2. Bayley Vs. Sasha Banks (2018)
Man, 2018 was really a bad year for repeat feuds.
Bayley and Sasha Banks' feud in NXT was and still is one of the best ever produced by the black and gold brand, so fans were pumped to see it play out on a larger stage. When Sasha and Bayley ended up on the same brand we all knew the two were destined to cross paths once more; it was a matter of when, not if. The moment Sasha turned on Bayley, fans rejoiced at the return of the badass boss character.
It got off to a good start with both women exchanging attacks, but then that's all they did. Then in a bizarre move, they tried to repeat the magic that was Kane and Daniel Bryan's trip to therapy. Even Dr Shelby himself made a return. It was definitely not the same, and all the segments were awkward and weird. Then like nothing happened, they were suddenly best mates again taking on the world as a tag team. The two didn't even get a blow-off match on Raw, let alone on a pay-per-view.
Granted, WWE have redeemed themselves with the story that they're telling with the pair currently. Somehow, they have turned one of 2018's worst feuds into 2020's best. Slow building and full of foreshadowing, it appears that WWE have gotten it right this time.
1. Seth Rollins Vs. Bray Wyatt
Some might say that the reason this feud flopped so hard was that The Fiend was inserted into the World Title scene way too early, a sentiment that yours truly also agrees with. However, there is no escaping the fact that this feud absolutely stunk up television screens every week.
The Fiend was the hottest new thing on the scene and Rollins was riding high coming off his conquering of Brock Lesnar. On paper it seemed like a match that would produce magic between the ropes. The build-up was sub-par with the same attacks occurring every week, but fans hoped that the pair would make up for it in a fiery Hell In A Cell encounter. When it came, the whole thing was just bizarre. The cage was bathed in dark red lighting which made it almost impossible for anyone in the stands to see through the already dark red cage. Not only this but we got Seth Rollins hitting Wyatt in the head with anything he could find. Did Rollins vanquish The Fiend? Did Wyatt make a paranormal comeback? No, Rollins was somehow disqualified, in a match where one of the main selling points is that there are NO DISQUALIFICATIONS!
After this, there was no going back. The whole thing was so bad that it turned Rollins heel in the eyes of the fans. Thank God that the company caught on otherwise we wouldn't have the godsend that is the Monday Night Messiah (pardon the pun).