10 Problems WWE Solved With The 2019 Superstar Shake-Up
As messy as it was, this year's Shake-Up was full of positive moves.
WWE's latest Superstar Shake-Up is finally in the books.
Held in Montreal, Quebec, Canada, it began with a busy Monday Night Raw that saw 17 individuals join the flagship show, with names as diverse as former WWE Champion AJ Styles and the newly-christened Viking Experience leaving their old homes for pastures new. Then, on SmackDown, Vince McMahon delivered on his promise of "the biggest acquisition the show had ever seen" as Roman Reigns led a group of newcomers that also featured Finn Balor, Buddy Murphy, and Bayley.
Mixed fortunes await everyone who moved homes in this year's Shake-Up, and as is always the case in this company, everything hinges on the follow-up. Regardless, WWE did a solid job of refreshing their stagnating talent pool this week. These episodes of Raw and SmackDown have become two of the year's most exciting since the brand split returned in 2016, and swathes of new booking possibilities now await Styles, Reigns, and co.
More than a mere cosmetic reshuffle, the Superstar Shake-Up went some way to addressing the myriad of problems stifling WWE's product coming out of WrestleMania 35. Let's run through its biggest steps forward...
10. Housing The Homeless
Finding permanent homes for the swathe of directionless NXT call-ups who'd spent the past few months as brand-less "free agents" was always going to be one of WWE's biggest priorities in this latest Superstar Shake-Up. Assigning them to Raw or SmackDown was a relatively dull box-ticking exercise. Still, it had to be done, and attaching these talented men and women to their new spots should bode well for their future.
Lacey Evans is now at the forefront of Raw's women's division. She planted her flag shortly before wrestling Natalya in a number one contender's match, besting the veteran and announcing her intention to challenge Becky Lynch in the near future. Elsewhere, Ricochet and Aleister Black stuck together, Lars Sullivan made Monday nights his home by battering fellow newcomer Rey Mysterio, and WWE bantered EC3 off by having Braun Strowman Chokeslam him through a panel by the stage. As far as SmackDown goes, Heavy Machinery will settle on Tuesday nights.
Their fortunes will vary, but at least Evans, Sullivan, and co. know where they're going now. Let's hope they defy their low expectations on Raw and SmackDown.
9. Freeing Cedric Alexander
Cedric Alexander had done all there was for him to do on 205 Live.
His 181-day reign as Cruiserweight Champion saw him tangle with everyone who mattered on WWE's most neglected brand, with Buddy Murphy, Mustafa Ali, Kalisto, Hideo Itami, and Drew Gulak all falling to the uber-athletic high-flyer. Alexander has floated around the top level ever since, with his most recent feud coming against newcomer Oney Lorcan, but he feels like a spare part. This has been the case since dropping the strap to Murphy last October, and he'll now follow Ali in trying to make it as a true main roster star.
Alexander is one of the most athletically impressive wrestlers in the company. He's an internet favourite, a good-to-very-good match machine, and a solid babyface. Charisma is a concern, as is his ability to show character inside the ring and out. Still, WWE can't keep guys like Cedric trapped on 205 Live forever. They'll never know if he's capable of playing a bigger role without giving him a chance, so let's hope he thrives on Monday Night Raw, continuing the trend started by Ali last year.
8. Refreshing The Intercontinental Title Picture
The Intercontinental Title scene was staler than month-old bread prior to this year's Superstar Shake-Up.
Finn Balor scored a fan-pleasing victory over Bobby Lashley at WrestleMania 35, but the preceding feud stunk. While Seth Rollins' and Dolph Ziggler's 2018 back-and-forth was fun, it was undone when Dean Ambrose unseated 'The Kingslayer' in a p*ss-boring TLC 2018, after which the likes of Tyler Breeze and Apollo Crews were shoehorned in as challengers, then Lashley's involvement and the disappointing diminishment of a belt that had recovered greater throughout the previous year.
This was addressed in the Shake-Up. Balor was sent to SmackDown, with United States Champion Samoa Joe seemingly set to replace him on Raw. The scene has therefore been blown wide open, with all kinds of fresh, new, and exciting opponents awaiting the Irishman on his new home.
Ali was his first opponent, and the two left nothing in the tank in their non-title exhibition match. Fellow newcomers Buddy Murphy and Chad Gable would make great opponents along with established SD personnel like Randy Orton, Xavier Woods, and Elias, and Lars Sullivan entering the picture probably isn't too far away either. Match quality will vary, but it least it won't involve Lashley again.
7. Saving Buddy Murphy
Buddy Murphy was too good for 205 Live.
Roped into last year's post-Enzo Amore Cruiserweight Title tournament seemingly as an afterthought, he soon became the purple brand's most interesting prospect. The weight-cutting angle gave him an immediate character hook. Afterwards, it became apparent that Murphy was far from the NXT burnout many wrote him off as, but an explosive, dynamic athlete desperate to prove himself, and prove himself he did. Matches with Cedric Alexander and Mustafa Ali placed highly on many a WWE Match of the Year ballot. Not only that, but he emerged as a fully-formed, three-dimensional personality with underrated microphone skills, and 205's undisputed franchise player.
Buddy outgrew the brand a long time ago. Now, after 12 long, hard months bumping his backside off on a show fans have been conditioned to not care about, he has a taste of the big time.
Murphy must work as hard as he did on 205 if he's to succeed in this more crowded pond, making his 2019 roadmap one of the most exciting in the entire company. Let's see if he can repeat his small stage success on SmackDown.
6. Splitting Go-Nowhere Groups
This may not be a popular entry, but WWE did Chad Gable and every Sanity member favours in this year's Superstar Shake-Up.
Eric Young was drafted to Raw, splitting his chaotic group with hilarious flippancy, and it now looks like Alexander Wolfe is on his way back to NXT. This is a positive move. Sanity was a '90s wrestling act that was never going to get over on the main roster, even though they weren't exactly given an abundance of opportunities to do so. Their shtick came off corny, outdated, and unbelievable. They were over in NXT, but everyone is over in NXT. Sending the trio in different directions suits them all: Young can become a gatekeeper, Wolfe can find his feet with a new act in developmental, and Killian Dain can embark upon an overdue singles run.
Chad Gable was relieved of the Bobby Roode-shaped millstone around his neck, with the Shake-Up sending him to SmackDown. He'd worked hard to get their act over, but there was only so much he could do with Roode's damaged goods, and he, too, is better off on his own.
5. The NXT Logjam
NXT is wonderful, but the developmental brand had way too many wrestlers on its books prior to WrestleMania 35 weekend. There are over 100 men and women in the Performance Center at the moment. Only a few dozen were making television, but the bloat created a serious logjam up and down the card, leaving talented performers like Keith Lee, Dominik Dijakovic, and Mia Yim stranded with nothing to do.
Ricochet, Aleister Black, and Kairi Sane are excellent wrestlers who were as good for NXT as NXT was for them. But their time had come. Each had accomplished everything the possibly could on the black-and-gold brand, and in sticking around, they were only taking up spots that could have belonged to those who needed them more.
Sane was written out after the last set of TV tapings, while Black and Ricochet are already gone. This should create opportunities in both mainline singles titles divisions. We could say the same of The Viking Experience as well, though it felt like NXT's writers were only getting started with them as the tag scene's leading lights.
4. Workrate In The Raw Tag Division
A hurricane of p*ss drowned Raw's tag division when Braun Strowman and a literal 10-year-old captured the belts at WrestleMania 34, dooming the scene to 12 months of crap feuds, Drake Maverick wetting himself, champions who never when the gold isn't on the line, and the bloody B-Team. The booking concerns remain, but WWE at least gave us some exciting new matches to think about on Raw.
While The Viking Experience is a dumb, dumb rebranding, Erik and Ivar are two of the best berzerkers in the business. Few tandems are more exciting when they're in full flow, and they proved it again at TakeOver: New York's white-hot opener against Ricochet and Aleister Black. Speaking of their latest NXT opponents, they may have been thrown together on a whim, but TakeOver proved their prodigious singles talents can mesh as a tag team. Finally, we have the small matter of one of the best tag teams in WWE history, The Usos, whose track record speaks for itself.
Raw lost some good people on Tuesday, and how this group will fare depends on the follow-up, but the right personnel are in place.
3. Reviving The SmackDown Women's Division
With Asuka, Becky Lynch, and Charlotte Flair on-board, SmackDown's women's division wasn't exactly short of top-level talent heading into WrestleMania 35. Still, the division found itself in a slump.
The presentation was the problem. Becky and Charlotte were splitting their time between WWE's red and blue brands, with Raw the priority. This diminished the SmackDown Women's Title greatly, with champion Asuka becoming an unimportant afterthought as Becky and Charlotte chased Ronda Rousey's strap, before 'The Queen' finally came along, seized the gold, and took it to the MetLife Stadium.
Reconfiguring the group beneath Lynch, the new champion, was a Shake-Up priority. WWE nailed it. Bayley and Ember Moon came over from Raw, expanding the group's star power and potential for great matches exponentially. SmackDown also gained Kairi Sane from NXT, a solid veteran hand in Mickie James, and Liv Morgan, one of the company's most improved performers over the past 12 months. Becky, Charlotte, and Asuka remained attached to Tuesday nights as well. Rejoice!
As thin as the Raw division became this week, SmackDown is stacked, and there are now more than enough wrestlers to fill the singles and tag ranks.
2. A New Start For AJ Styles
Up until this week, AJ Styles had been a SmackDown Superstar for the best part of three years.
Sent to the show as part of the July 2016 draft, he was quick to declare Team Blue "the house that AJ Styles built," justifying the apparent arrogance with standout early performances against Dean Ambrose, from whom he took his first WWE Championship. Disappointing feuds with James Ellsworth and Kevin Owens followed, but AJ reasserted himself in 2017, ending Jinder Mahal's horrific WWE Title reign before embarking on a year-long run of his own, eventually dropping the strap to Daniel Bryan, then signing off with a WrestleMania 35 victory over Randy Orton.
AJ, like Alexander on 205 Live, had done everything on SmackDown. He needed a fresh start more than almost anyone else on the roster, and all kinds of exciting possibilities await him on Raw.
Expect Styles to play a similar role on Monday nights. He won't always be Universal Champion or an immediate contender, but he'll carry on as one of WWE's most consistent in-ring performers, a fan favourite, and a pushed commodity.
1. The Roman Reigns Conundrum
There was no way WWE could have kept a babyface Roman Reigns on Monday Night Raw without encountering major problems within weeks of the Shake-Up.
Reigns' presence on the red brand may have taken away from Seth Rollins' Universal Title run, as fans would be in a constant state of fear that 'The Big Dog' would rise up and take their favourite wrestler's championship away. Those post-return cheers would have turned to jeers - and fast. They aren't going to turn Roman, and his former partner's popularity could have diminished his own, leaving both in a lose/lose situation.
There are other benefits to Reign's SmackDown switch. Taking him away from Raw's slapdash writing team will benefit him greatly, and SD's sharper creative should help give his character new wrinkles. Shield reunions have been done to death, he had faced everyone there was to face on Raw, and Reigns was about the only name (Brock Lesnar aside) WWE could have thrown into that "biggest acquisition in SmackDown Live history" spot without looking stupid.
This is a great move across the board. Roman is an ideal AJ Styles replacement, and we look forward to seeing how his run plays out.