10 Radical Ideas To Save Zack Ryder
Astonishingly, the man’s still more or less over: now let’s keep him that way.
Normally when I write a ‘Radical Ideas To Save’ article on an underutilised wrestler, it’s a list of sometimes contradictory ideas, any one of which might reverse the character’s downhill plunge and get them over with the audience sufficiently that the last few months of booking seem like a bad dream.
Zack Ryder’s a bit of a weird case, however. When we talk about ‘saving’ Zack Ryder, we’re not talking about some awesome Hail Mary booking to get him noticed. The WWE buried him six feet underground weeks after he won the US title in late 2011, and he’s been clawing at the coffin lid for four years now.
And yet, every time he appears on TV, the crowd sit up and go 'OH HEY'. His victory at WrestleMania 32 made grown men pump their fists in the air like they were in the bloody Breakfast Club.
I made a joke when it happened about how younger WWE fans checking out the ladder match would be asking their parents whether this ‘Zack Ryder’ was one of those guys from New Japan that everyone’s been going on about.
I got a death threat. For taking the p*ss out of Zack Ryder.
For the first time, I'm going to set out a ten step plan instead of coming up with ten separate ideas. If we're gonna do this, let's do this properly: let’s keep Zack Ryder over, to the extent that it’s virtually impossible to take him off TV and bury him again.
10. Change The Damn Music
Oh, radio. Tell me everything you know.
I’ll tell you what I know, radio: In 2016, a cheesy pop song about cruising the boardwalk picking up ‘babes’ is not a theme song for a grown man, much less a grown man who needs to persuade Important People that he’s worth taking seriously.
What’s more, the ultra-confident playah of the lyric, the man looking in the mirror and liking what he sees, who could be a rock star, who’s going to wear his pants real tight (yes, those are the real lyrics): that’s not Zack Ryder in 2016. That was barely Zack Ryder in 2011 - the guy was a massive geek who wore a headband to the ring and used the word ‘bro’ more often than Vince ‘Bro’ Russo, bro.
I’m not saying replace the song with some generic sturm und drang speed metal that makes it sound like a human headache is hitting the ring - but something a little more respectable than Justin Bieber’s sloppy seconds would be just fine.
Personally, I like the idea of using The Wildhearts’ ‘Vanilla Radio’. The transition to a song that says how sh*tbox the radio is these days: that tells a story.
9. Take Him Out Of His Comfort Zone
We need to take Ryder far, far away from that whole ‘broski’, ‘siiick’, ‘woo woo woo’ thing. No more staying hype, no more cutting promos like he’s got a college radio DJ stuck in his oesophagus.
He’s met us halfway already - he looks like a proper bloke with that beard, and his hair’s all one colour. Not only that, but whatever workout regimen he’s on, he looks jacked these days. That’s a main event look - but the gear could do with some work. Give him some tights or trousers instead of those briefs.
He needs a new finishing move, like yesterday. In fact, he could do with two. The Rough Ryder basically involves him leaping groin first at his opponents’ faces. Now, there’s nothing wrong with that, but it’s no way to win a wrestling match.
A nasty, violent finish would be perfect: the kind of thing that comes with a snap that looks like he’s punishing an absentee father every time he hits it... like the double underhook spinning lifting sitout facebuster, also known as the Angels’ Wings.
A submission as well as that would be handy, too. I’d go for the crossface chickenwing: it’s mostly identified with Bob Backlund, which is handy, but it’s also vicious as all hell and it's got that brilliant ramping up action that can occur when you grapevine the body, just like Kurt Angle's ankle lock went to the next level when he applied the grapevine.
Cesaro and Dean Ambrose have it up their sleeves, but to my knowledge no one on the roster has yet claimed it as a signature move.
8. Have Him Begin To Attack The Miz Randomly And For No Reason
The Miz and Maryse are legitimately awesome heels together, the pairing more heelish than the sum of its parts. When they cost Ryder the Intercontinental Championship the day after he won it at WrestleMania 32, they were as heelish as they could possibly be about it.
That’s got to rankle. So much so that no one could blame Ryder if, every time he saw the Miz and his stupid clothes and his stupid hair and his stupid, stupid face, he felt irrationally compelled to attack him and, I don’t know, put him in the crossface chickenwing and thrash him about like a landed sea bass, Crazy Bob Backlund style.
It should get to the point that The Miz is complaining to management, scared of his own shadow, hiding behind his own wife when he enters a room.
It’s the first step in a sea change for Ryder’s persona, and it doesn’t hurt that both he and the Miz can gain heat over the mini-angle. Miz looks more heelish and cowardly, and Ryder looks - for the first time - like someone you don’t want to screw with.
7. Head Over Heels
It's reductive, sure, and for anyone else except Cena it's not a radical move - but it's been a long while since Zack Ryder was anything other than a merch-whoring white meat babyface. Now he has no merchandise, so theoretically he has nothing to lose.
To begin with, the turn should be a minor thing: the backstage assaults on the Miz, the adoption of a particularly aggressive couple of finishing moves, a less tweenage theme song… then we can have a couple of generic angry promos, those ones that say, “dancing around and smiling did nothing for me, so now I wish to give the whole world a brainbuster right onto the metaphorical steel steps of life, oh yes I do”.
Nothing flashy just yet, because we’re building to something a little bit odd.
6. Partner Him With His Partner
As all true blue wrestling geeks know by now, Matthew ‘Zack Ryder’ Cardona is going steady with Tenille ‘Emma’ Dashwood, and has been for a number of months. The two are so tight that they’re attending official WWE functions together and using possessive pronouns on Instagram and everything.
Right now, Emma’s undergoing something of a career renaissance as a vicious heel in the reborn Women’s Division, which is absolutely as it should be. It was her performances in developmental with Paige that kickstarted the additional interest in women’s wrestling in NXT, and ended up changing the face of women’s wrestling on the WWE main roster.
Once Ryder’s turned heel, even subtly, the two should partner up on television as well, accompanying one another to the ring.
As an on-screen character, Zack's always been a bit of a sad sack, and despite his party-boy image has never had any real luck with the ladies. Showing him in a mature relationship with a smoking hot, incredibly dangerous submission specialist would go a long way towards remedying some of that, which helps when taking the character seriously.
Plus, the pair of them look good together suited and booted for a night out: imagine how good they’d look beating seven shades of sparkling sh*te out of some rube and then laughing about it all the way up the ramp.
5. Have Him Go Bananas
This is the turning point, the fulcrum around which these character tweaks become a full-blown personality transplant. After a month or so of grumpy heelishness, Zack Ryder needs to go crazy: again, like Bob Backlund crazy.
Cutting a promo in the middle of the ring after an irritating loss - let’s say the WWE’s favourite, the distraction roll-up - Ryder starts pacing back and forth, ranting about his treatment and how he’s not going to take it anymore.
It’s the aforementioned ‘kissing babies and rescuing kittens never got me paid, yo’ promo, but twisted and yanked around until it looks like a dumpster fire. He screams
about how he told the world about his childhood cancer and no one gave a handful of cr*p; about how he, Zack Ryder was literally the Make-A-Wish kid that beat cancer and came back to make it to his dream of wrestling for the WWE; and about how Mr. Make-A-Wish himself, John Cena, went and buried him just as he'd won the US title.
He should be raving, as he slags everyone off and attacks Cena: spitting all over the place, beard gone all ragged and crazy. It should look and sound like a meth-addicted hobo threw up on Randy Savage.
4. The King Of Smackdown
It gets stranger, because at a certain point Ryder becomes the only member of the roster to be Smackdown exclusive.
One week Ryder appears on Smackdown… but he’s not booked. He just walks to the ring and refuses to leave until he gets a match. Once he gets one (against, let's say, Tyler Breeze or one of the Social Outcasts), he creams them, wins defiantly, and then leaves.
Next week, it’s the same thing. The week after, the same. By week four it's been a month of Ryder Is Smackdown, and he's not going anywhere.
One week, someone tries to book him onto RAW: he refuses to come out and forfeits the match. Backstage ten minutes later, Renee Young asks him where he was, and he simply states that he’s contractually obliged to come to RAW, but no one can make him wrestle. He's a Smackdown guy.
That backstage interview gets played the following week on Smackdown before his next match. He steamrollers his opponent: and as he’s celebrating, Mauro informs us at home that next week, Ryder will face Cesaro.
Cesaro beats the cr*p out of Ryder, but he won't lie down. The Swiss Superman begins to get frustrated, keeps telling him to stay down. Ryder refuses, telling him him “this is my show”.
Eventually Ryder gets a flurry of offence, and three close two-counts in a row, before Cesaro hulks up and demolishes him. Groggily standing up, Ryder allows Cesaro to shake his hand, but holds on, pulling him closer, the camera just picking up him reminding the big man, “this is my show”.
On commentary, Mauro grudgingly puts over the fact that there's no quit in this guy, while Lawler is a little less equivocal about the new Zack Ryder: he says he’s completely cuckoo.
3. Give Him A Hero's Entrance
It’s around this point that Ryder’s entrance begins to get more and more elaborate: hero poses, a light show, that kind of thing.
It’s not a dramatic special effects extravaganza, however. Ryder knows by now he can’t expect anything grand from the WWE: he and Emma bring on their own spotlights before his music hits, carting them onstage in a little wheelbarrow and packing them all up again after they leave, and the pyro noises come from a WWE mic being held up to an MP3 player on full volume.
Despite this, both Emma and Ryder take the whole thing very, very seriously.
2. Tournament For The Intercontinental Championship
The company’s secondary singles title is up for grabs: either it’s been vacated, in which case the tournament is to crown a new champion, or there’s no clear challenger, in which case the tournament is to choose a number one contender.
Whatever the case, the story of this tournament, held on a combination of free television and pay-per-view style event, is that Ryder will not give up. He’s facing upper midcard nasties like Sheamus, like AJ Styles, like Kevin Owens, men who’re supposed to be better than him, and he just will not lie down.
Understand that this isn’t Ryder showing clean cut babyface fire. He’s angry, beard bristling with rage - he refuses to quit because whatever weird obsessive engine is driving him simply won’t allow him to stop.
And so he keeps getting up, and he keeps kicking out, and he keeps pulling out a victory at the last minute. As the tournament goes on, the story stops becoming about who will come out on top, and starts being about who on earth can put Zack Ryder down long enough for a referee to count to three.
It’s the Brawl For All (or a worked version), with Ryder in the Bart Gunn role. Eventually it comes down to Ryder and Cesaro, and Ryder finally makes the big man submit, Cesaro trapped in the crossface chickenwing for far, far too long.
1. Affirmative Action
By now, anyone with their wits about them has recognised a pattern: a former clean cut babyface turned unstable, hot-tempered but eccentric heel finds within himself a surprising intensity in the ring and begins to win matches.
Yes, it’s the 2012 Daniel Bryan comedy heel persona. Over-the-top and bafflingly odd, the heel can do heelish things and say heelish things but remain sufficiently entertaining that the door’s open wide for fans to turn him babyface if they choose.
It’s a fine line, obviously. To begin with, all it’ll take to go the fully villainous route is cheap-shotting the wrong person at the wrong time. Nonetheless, the objective in all of this is twofold.
On the one hand, it’s to maximise whatever television time Ryder gets and ensure that however long it is that he remains onscreen, and whatever he’s asked to do, the crowd remembers.
On the other hand, it provides a clear path to getting noticed and staying noticed with an idiosyncratic character that keeps people guessing as well as entertained.
From there, provided crowd reactions remain consistent, Ryder can either devolve to become a proper WWE heel - beating up beloved babyfaces, cheating to win, having friends and a consistent moral code - or he can continue to walk that fine line, as Bryan, Eddie Guerrero and others did before him.
But really, as I mentioned at the beginning, the only true goal in all of this is to make sure that WWE don’t lose track of Ryder again to the extent that they did between 2012 and 2016.
After all, it’s difficult to bury something that won’t stay down.