10 Reasons Why People Who Hate WWE Hate WWE

All WWE storylines rook the same.

Jinder Mahal
WWE.com

"If WWE Superstar X and WWE Superstar Y wrestled in the Tokyo Dome, Dave Meltzer would award the match five stars."

So goes the coldest take on all of wrestling Twitter, posted by those who you can educatedly guess have never watched New Japan Pro Wrestling - nor heard of the legendary Budokan Hall, the site of the most accumulated ***** bouts in the history of the Wrestling Observer. The irony (other than the fact that Meltzer is actually far kinder than most, your writer included) is that he is accused of bias by those gripped by WWE monomania. You can watch both WWE and NJPW, and prefer the former - but it's rare. The latter yields so much more goodwill in every conceivable department.

Hate is a strong and not entirely fitting word - but WWE's product frequently invites it. Critics and commentators don't hate WWE because they are jealous, intentionally contrarian, or wish to appear cool and or different: they hate WWE because the feeling is mutual.

Writing this article will feel like a chore, in both its coverage of known ground and the negative focus. The people who hate WWE don't want to hate WWE. The institution has consumed so much of their brief time on this planet - as much if not more so than family, education, friends and work. The product is draining, and thus so is the reception.

They just make it so f*cking easy.

10. The Fans Are Treated Like Morons

Kevin Owens Shane McMahon
WWE.com

When Shane McMahon announced that he and Kevin Owens would fight in Hell In A Cell under a further Falls Count Anywhere stipulation, two harsh, clogging truths surfaced once more.

1) WWE no longer cares for the old-school logic of the cage match, nor remotely credible gimmick match psychology.

2) WWE perceives its audience as a sea of morons who would suffocate in six pack rings, were it not for their constant exposition.

For the love of Mankind, we all knew Shane was going to perform his trademark insane bump. It's his trademark. Allusions to it were made all over SmackDown in the preceding weeks. Announcing the bump ahead of time didn't detract from the drama on the night - but it did undo the mystique. This practise is alienating, and it destroys intrigue and conversations - so it's almost just as well that the company lurches from one controversial misstep from one day to the next. Michael Cole's constant repetition and exposition on RAW, and the constant, ceaseless replays polluting the programme reinforce this idea that we cannot follow what, really, is an incredibly simplistic programme. The Hype Bros are in the midst of a split. We know this because the lingering backstage segments are blocked like a daytime soap opera - and because the commentary team points out the tense body language. Imagine if Days Of Our Lives was narrated. We're a few short years removed from an actual clap-o-meter.

The principal rule of writing is "show, don't tell". WWE shatters it, and the goodwill of the fanbase, on a weekly basis.


9. The Product Is Essentially Cursed

Jinder Mahal Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Too often, WWE resembles Rick and Morty's slant on Stephen King's Needful Things - a deeply ironic and downright antagonistic exercise in wish fulfilment.

Fans longed to see Shinsuke Nakamura evolve WWE's in-ring style further, and add a new dimension to the idea of what a WWE Superstar itself represents. Within just six months on the SmackDown brand, his workrate declined within the rote underdog mould. He now exists as a sacrificial lamb slaughtered at the behest of the cynical Jinder Mahal experiment. Fans longed to see The Undertaker ride his hearse into the sunset in order to make way for a new generation of talent. Roman Reigns, the symbol of strife, swung the ax. Fans, for years, longed to see a Cruiserweight division. We received our wish. The action is only nominal, and not at all dissimilar to what is presented on the main roster - only with fewer stars and an utter lack of audience enthusiasm. Fans longed to see Erick Rowan and Luke Harper return to TV. They did so complete with the cheesiest props this side of Rocco the dummy.

WWE recognised the shifting wrestling landscape with NXT. The stars of that show are now dimmer under the bight lights, because a man impervious to change controls the switch.

Fans long for a new WWE, fundamentally. It feels at times as though WWE recognises this - but revels in snatching the prospect away.


8. The Product Is Contrived

Daniel Bryan
WWE

This week's SmackDown saw The New Day and The Usos call a truce and draw a line under their brilliant feud. It was a good, authentic segment. It felt well-earned. And then, WWE dusted off the formula.

The Hype Bros interrupted and complained that the same two teams steal the credit every week. The same Hype Bros who decisively lost a match at Hell In A Cell. Not that that mattered; Commissioner or General Manager Daniel Bryan - really, it makes no difference, his talent occupies both roles by conveniently arguing in the ring - booked them in a Fatal 4-Way match to determine the new number one contenders to the SmackDown Tag Team titles. The idea of "number one contenders" is meaningless, incidentally; there is no formal ranking system. There isn't even a head canon version of it. In most divisions, there is a champion, their rival, and a bunch of acts beneath them with indiscriminate win/loss records.

The Ascension and Breezango were also permitted entry into the match. The last guy who goofed off backstage in real life - Jimmy Jacobs - didn't get rewarded. He was fired. This trash strategy has become so enduring that it's the norm. It shouldn't be. It unravels the whole enterprise as a farce. We're meant to believe in wrestling. Even if that is a quaint insight, it's not as if the formula is entertaining. It's a schoolyard squabble written by hacks. And, when the performers forget those lines, the results are cringe-inducing. People felt pity for Bobby Roode when he accidentally skipped the script on Tuesday. Bobby Roode. He's meant to be glorious.

It's just wrestling, is the counterargument. It's just entertainment. Watch the matches. Stephanie McMahon is fond of comparing WWE to a great novel or a classic motion picture. It's honestly laughable.

Thank Christ for the performers.


7. The World (Wrestling Entertainment) Won't Listen

stephanie mcmahon
WWE.com

Stephanie McMahon spoke at the Most Powerful Women Summit in Washington, D.C. this week, at which she had the following to say:

We’re taking feedback in real time. Our audience tells us what they love, what they don’t like, and - worst - what they don’t care about.

This, obviously, is horsesh*t.

All but the most ardent loyalists retained their support of the Jinder Mahal push in the wake of Hell In A Cell, at which the joke ceased being funny. Even the Indian market hasn't responded to his WWE Heavyweight title run. Fans could not have made their support of Braun Strowman over Roman Reigns any clearer in 2017, and yet the Big Dog is going to WrestleMania - on the subject of which, Steph also suggested we have the power to alter plans for it. Somewhere, CM Punk smirked that trademark smirk of his.

The response to Titus O'Neil and his 'Worldwide' brand is muted. They don't care about it. And yet, corporate sponsors - the real driver of WWE content, in addition to Vince McMahon - impose RAW's third hour and the aimless filler that comes with it for monetary reasons which, while reasonable, feed the belly of the beast far more than they feed the imagination of the audience.

More examples to the contrary are so numerous that they aren't really required; Steph's statement stands alone as a blackly comic punchline in itself.


6. "Wins And Losses Don't Matter."

Asuka Ember Moon
WWE

So sayeth the Road Dogg earlier this year - but he was only parroting the deliriously stupid company line.

The mentality in the company is that wins and losses don't matter - not to the internal logic of the shows, nor to the betterment of a performer's career. Meanwhile, in the same breath, we are asked to buy into Asuka's awesome winning streak because winning several consecutive matches in credible fashion has elevated her into an über-credible force. We respond enthusiastically because the resulting stakes behind her matches are major. Every Asuka match feels like a big deal - as opposed to most matches on RAW and SmackDown, and even pay-per-view, which are fought between a performer the company is pushing, often tentatively, and a performer they have lost or have no interest in. The former soon becomes the latter, and the latter soon becomes the former, and on the merry-go-round we remain.

This mentality fosters apathy. Why bother?

Why bother making a personal investment in the careers of Erick Rowan and Luke Harper, if history has taught us that it's pointless?


5. The Company Is Toxic

Warrior Heenan
WWE.com

The idea that WWE is this progressive, philanthropic organisation is legitimately insulting. The recent Dana Warrior segments were so horrendously timed, it would have been laughable - were it not for the very recent and upsetting death of Bobby Heenan, whom her husband so callously disrespected in his final years.

The recent death of Memphis wrestling legend Lance Russell - a thoroughly nice man in a notoriously unpleasant industry - didn't warrant a passing mention on WWE television. There is no way of monetising his historic, localised legacy to a modern, international audience, obviously - but a brief gesture of respect was naturally lost on an organisation lacking it. Also ignored was Sami Zayn's funding of a mobile medical clinic in war-torn Syria - a profoundly, genuinely philanthropic gesture WWE refused to publicise. It's hard not to infer that the mere location of the country was simply too scary-sounding to risk alienating the domestic audience. Or perhaps Zayn, prior to his recent heel turn, just wasn't worth giving the PR rub too.

This inherently awful and petty attitude is often curiously transposed onscreen. Enzo Amore is the most recent example of many, countless on-air punishments. He is afraid of heights, so at SummerSlam, WWE stuck him a shark cage and elevated him into the air.

Be a star, etc. etc.


4. Match Layouts Are Becoming Increasingly Simplistic

Ziggler Nakamura
WWE.com

WWE's loaded roster is stupidly talented. The company's pay-per-view output has largely disappointed in 2017. The talent on that roster is regulated by road agents and the tunnel vision of Vince McMahon. These three factors are depressingly intertwined.

Charlotte Vs. Natalya was good, but they are capable of great. The drama centred around Charlotte's injury, but the immediate and one-dimensional nature of it cut them off at the knees, appropriately enough. We weren't given enough of a reason to get behind Charlotte, or reasons. It was more conditioning exercise than rich, multi-faceted storytelling. The structure echoed the company's perception of its fanbase. The obvious intention was to cast Charlotte in a sympathetic light - but they could not have achieved this in a more obvious way. Charlotte's brilliant selling was almost unnecessary. We were battered over the head with the gist.

Braun Strowman was another victim of these broad strokes. At No Mercy, he was an interchangeable prop thrown around by Brock Lesnar to convey the Universal Champion as a monster. Shinsuke Nakamura devolved from badass to underdog at Backlash. In the process of being normalised, Nakamura was stripped of his aura and originality. The layout was designed to galvanise the crowd, but achieved the opposite. Once more, the feeling that WWE and its fanbase exist in a constant state of polarity was unshakeable.

What's worrying is that WWE gets less nuanced by the week.


3. Plot Hole City

Charlotte Natalya
WWE.com

In an age in which there is disproportionate in-ring action, WWE's inability to craft unique stories leads them to build wrestling matches via wrestling matches, doubling down on the deadening effect.

Again, consider Natalya Vs. Charlotte from Hell In A Cell. The result negated their encounter on the previous episode of SmackDown, which itself was problematic. Natalya cleanly tapped Charlotte out. Carmella's distraction allowed Natalya to apply the Sharpshooter in the first place, but she took an eternity to recline into it. It wasn't opportunistic; it was methodical. That match might as well have not happened. Ditto Hell In A Cell; after dominating more or less the entire 12 minute duration, Natalya, apparently threatened by Charlotte's mettle, intentionally disqualified herself. The woman she cleanly swatted aside five days prior was fighting on one leg, and she decided to virtually guarantee a rematch instead of successfully putting her away - something of which she was evidently capable.

The SmackDown doubles match was meant to cast doubt over Sunday's outcome. The Hell In A Cell finish existed purely, against all established storyline logic, to prolong the feud, the intrigue and drama surrounding which barely exists anymore because we've been conditioned to receive it as meaningless.

Dig deeper, and the plot holes render escape impossible. Jinder Mahal has relied on interference to win no less than four of his major PPV title matches this year. Nothing within storylines acts as a deterrent to his actions. Of all people, he escaped the Cell on Sunday. We've seen a heel take an intentional count-out or disqualification in every SmackDown PPV since WrestleMania. Nobody has been fined, suspended nor forced to relinquish their title. It's dramatically deflating and bereft of logic.

If retaining a title is as easy as walking out on a match with no repercussions, why doesn't everybody do this all the time?


2. The Future Is Bleak, And The Present Is Grim, But...

sami zayn nakamura.jpg
WWE.com

Why bother making a personal investment in a performer?

As much as I think Roman Reigns is fantastic, he's clearly the entire focal point of the company's immediate and long-term future, wider fan sentiment be damned. Virtually every other full-time performer, with the exception of Randy Orton - a man who has occupied a top slot for 13 years - is not immune to inconsistent booking. Kevin Owens may be the exception, but the rule proves the pessimists right.

Shinsuke Nakamura is dead in the water. Try travelling back in time to April 2016, predicting that, and not making a neckbeard fool of yourself. WWE almost had to turn Sami Zayn heel because he was buried from whence he came. Try travelling back in time to April 2016, predicting that, and not making a neckbeard fool of yourself. Neville, like so many before him, was set to drop off a cliff after exiting the title picture in a company unable to craft compelling stories outside of it. At least he knew, and was not content with his lot.

An entire generation of fans has been conditioned to fear the worst. The six year-old Hulk Hogan fan in me despairs at the all-pervasive lack of hope. That strikes another thought: heels absolutely dominate feuds. The lengthy, reassuring babyface title reign is now prehistoric. Wrestling, as I've written, operates best as an emulation of sport in which our guys get to win. But they don't win anymore. There must be a correlation with the largely silent TV crowds on any given flagship broadcast.

NXT isn't as buzz-worthy as it was between 2014-15, despite the TakeOver specials maintaining the superb, company-best form in the two years since. Has the largely abysmal treatment of main roster promotions robbed NXT of its positivism and, consequently, its viewership?


1. ...We Can't Help But Come Back

NXT TakeOver WarGames
Twitter, @TripleH

The obvious answer is to simply stop moaning, or stop watching - which is easier in theory than it is in practise, even for those who don't write about the industry for a living.

Even in 2017, The Year of the Jinder, with its Punjabi Prisons and Horrific Houses, WWE is selectively magnificent. Goldberg Vs. Brock Lesnar was a sensational antidote to the bloated WrestleMania 33 card, capping off an unexpected triumph of a programme. The New Day Vs. The Usos rivalry was sensational in-ring and from the elusive character perspective. The RAW Tag Team title scene has provided genuine emotion and match quality, enjoying the warm reception of an Indian summer. NXT is still great. We're getting WarGames next month. War. F*cking. G*mes. This company always finds a way to bring you back. It must be doing something right.

Even when we rage against the cornball scripted dialogue, such a clear barricade to a performer's career, the typewriting monkeys deliver a classic. Baron Corbin's "Cry, cry, cry and I will buy a boat to sail down your river of tears" line was pure poetry.

WWE is a company in a luxurious position, and has become gluttonous. But we're getting WarGames next month. War. F*cking. G*mes.

And so the loop continues.

Enjoy this article? Then buy my book, you mother!


In this post: 
Jinder Mahal
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!