10 Reasons Why The 2019 Royal Rumble Will Be The Best Ever

Greatest Royal Rumble.

Monday Night Rollins
WWE

Recent Royal Rumble history should shape - lessen - our expectations.

This decade has yielded, more often than not, Rumble match winners both uninspiring and infuriating. Cynical is perhaps the most appropriate word. 2010 saw Edge return much too early from serious injury. His abbreviated stint didn't resonate as triumph. In 2011 and 2012, WWE cynically parachuted Alberto Del Rio and Sheamus into a "main event" that looked suspiciously like the midcard, and true enough, the World Heavyweight Title for which they challenged became a glorified midcard belt.

2013 saw John Cena emerge triumphant in a cynical attempt to replicate 'Once In A Lifetime'. 2014 saw Daniel Bryan removed from the match entirely in order to avoid a scene - lol - and from 2015 to 2016, the magic of the entire event crumbled under the heavy hands of the Roman Reigns push.

In 2017, WWE opted, again, to have Randy Orton point towards the WrestleMania sign. The only remotely "fresh" development here was that he, shy of two seconds, just about remembered when to point at it, something he hilariously failed to do in 2009. This gesture - Orton relative to the last-eliminated Roman Reigns was the lesser of two evils - hid in plain sight, like a viper, the cynicism now squarely rooted in the Rumble's fading mythology.

Ironically, a cynical shift in WWE's storytelling approach may well elevate the 2019 edition into the pantheon of pay-per-view greatness...

10. The Mea Culpa In Action

AEW Avoiding WWE Mistakes
WWE

Ratings are falling because the TV product is subjectively terrible and objectively pointless - or, at least, disposable.

Those disengaged from it have naturally avoided the house show circuit: why pay for free garbage? The McMahon family has acknowledged the malaise on television, and promised to reverse course - but jaded talent has reacted as incredulously as fans to this apparent mea culpa, threatening to leave in not inconsiderable number. Meanwhile, as if finally beholden to the laws of narrative, competition to this sleeping giant looms in the form of an ROH newly minted from the departures of the Elite, and of course the Elite themselves - who have thus far marketed AEW as a sort of talent dreamland in which the creative spirit of the Indies is backed by money comparable to WWE.

Same money, significant morale upgrade. Double or Nothing, indeed, especially to the tag acts, like The Revival, that never headlined in WWE even before this new paradigm shift. All of which leads to Phoenix, the sight of Sunday's Royal Rumble. Money is no longer a bargaining tool exclusive to WWE, nor, given widespread backstage unrest, is it enough. Glancing at that card, WWE has seemingly recognised the need to update the brochure.

Looking at it in depth...


9. A Show That Paces Itself

Royal Rumble 2019 Logo
WWE

Most WWE pay-per-view cards look very good on the surface.

The key drawback, in addition to broad/inconclusive storytelling, is the sheer length of these joint-brand shows. Fans reserved energy at the expense of Daniel Bryan Vs. The Miz at last year's SummerSlam. Even dream matches are slept on in this Network Era. Sunday's Rumble, if only through a series of unconnected coincidences, should be exempt from a practise designed to artificially inflate the Network's popularity. Brock Lesnar Vs. Finn Bálor isn't going longer than 15 minutes, Sasha Banks Vs. Bayley is going even less. Straight singles matches in WWE's Women's division tend not go long for long's sake, so Asuka Vs. Becky Lynch shouldn't overstay its welcome, either. At time of writing, two matches seem destined for the Kickoff.

Daniel Bryan Vs. AJ Styles demands an epic duration and "feel" to live up to its potential. The depth of Bryan's storytelling genius and renewed enthusiasm to expand on it further deserves time, as do the respective Rumble matches. The complexion of the card should ensure a level of sustained crowd buzz. There's nothing overtly "methodical", uninteresting, nor over-familiar on it. No filler.

A card of major stakes and potential - one that complements itself, crucially - the Rumble, offering first-time PPV meetings across three fresh, major title matches, offers the sort of vitality this company seemed fundamentally incapable of a month ago.


8. The Best Of The Beast

Brock Lesnar Finn Balor
WWE

When motivated, Brock Lesnar is an attraction like no other in professional wrestling.

He wears a mischievous, impish grin in his best matches, because despite how many times he connects with it - and no one move has ever been so synonymous with one performer - his German suplex remains a disturbing gut-punch of a visual. Brock Lesnar is motivated for Sunday. He specifically requested to work Finn Bálor, knowing the slight, fiery performer is the perfect, most sympathetic breed of prey. He'll laugh in Bálor's face, too. It doesn't matter how outrageously ripped he is. What's the point of muscle when you've just had the wind knocked out of you? Again and again?

Lesnar is a performer of some range. He'll sell shock at Bálor's adrenaline-fuelled comeback, which might manifest after Lesnar first brutally cuts off a sling blade. Not quite sure on the logistics of that one, but Lesnar is so awesome when he gives even half a sh*t that he becomes fantasy booking clay. Bálor in a match like this must pick his spots, knowing that most don't get any - and Lesnar's history with diverticulitis is a route to Incredible Near Fall City, if arrived at by way of the Coup re Grace.

And actually touched on by a dismal commentary team.


7. Pure Adrenaline

sasha banks ronda rousey
WWE.com

Something about Ronda Rousey Vs. Sasha Banks sets the nerves jittering.

You don't doubt Ronda Rousey. She takes the finger-wagging arms of doubters and throws them over her shoulder in one seamless, fist-pumping motion. But.

But.

Sasha Banks is an excellent performer, but an exuberant one prone to error - and one who at times struggles to control the adrenaline coursing through her. In a way, despite being far more exciting than many of the slower, basic opponents Ronda has faced so far, Sasha may represent the biggest challenge. This thing is going to be - given the performers and the dynamic, it can only be - absolutely f*cking furiously paced, which may result in either an awesome rush of relentless drama - or a chaotic mess.

We should see at least a version of the Boss in this fight, too. This is long overdue. Over three years overdue, really: to force the less experienced Rousey into a mistake, the old Sasha needs to recover that Full Sail swagger by slapping her plush across the face. If she wants to reduce Ronda to tears, to truly recapture the savage magic of 2015, Sasha should blow her husband a kiss across the barricade.

Fast, Furious or car crash - you'll keep a tight grip of the wheel, whatever happens.


6. A Potential Classic Of A WWE Championship Match

Daniel Bryan AJ Styles
WWE

Re-watched in it entirety, the storytelling within the Daniel Bryan Vs. AJ Styles programme is legitimately outstanding.

It's all in Bryan's eyes. In the first match, he sold a sense of quiet panic and dismay; having injured himself in the early phase, he was all too aware that he faced a battle to level up to a man that had surpassed him in recent years. The match reflected the failure of his babyface character. In his second, successful attempt to unseat AJ, his eyes wandered throughout, as if searching deep within his conflicted psyche for a way to win. In the end, he won by any means necessary. Having fully reconciled the betrayal to himself, at TLC, the literally renewed Bryan, still searching - he called this "deep thinking" - discovered a new layer of his immaculate in-ring genius and trapped AJ in an array of new holds and counters to retain his title.

The story culminates on Sunday. With Bryan's famed in-ring IQ at its most formidable, he'll know exactly how to play to the bumper, stadium-sized crowd - and the story, brilliantly, justifies the broader and more pulsating match best suited to it.

Bryan is at his most intelligent, Styles at his most motivated - a dynamic that should erupt into a firecracker for the ages.


5. The Man Comes Around To Banter Off The Naysayers

Asuka Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Sadly, inevitably, it has already started.

The Becky Lynch backlash is brewing, albeit quietly, on the same social media platform Lynch has perfected with her awesome brand of savagery. She is "overrated", some people are saying. She's generating noise, not numbers. SmackDown creative is leaning too heavily into the whole "badass" thing. And while it's somewhat true that Becky is better at showing us her character than the Writers are at telling us, this Sunday's fascinating Women's Title match promises yet another reminder of why she is so popular at the grassroots level.

Technically outmatched by her more skilled opponent, Becky must continue to do what what she has done to arrive as The Man in the first instance, and fight. And if that's another parallel to Steve Austin - it reads much like his plight at WrestleMania 13 - it is an unapologetic one.

Becky must show that unparalleled, unmatched fire, the desire to succeed in a role they never really wanted her to fill. As an incredible, multi-faceted pro wrestler better than most at conveying dominance across every inch of that squared circle, Asuka is the perfect opponent to act as a roadblock to Becky's date with destiny in New Jersey.

The dynamic has awesome potential as a match, and what's more, the machinations surrounding 'Mania - of how WWE arrives at the rumoured Triple Threat - render it difficult to predict.


4. WWE Has Relearned How To Book The Rumble Match

Roman Reigns Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE

Last year's Men's Royal Rumble match was among the best ever. The best, writing subjectively.

The extended bit in which Heath Slater acted as punching bag followed comedy's rule of repetition fabulously; comedy was elsewhere kept to a minimum, vanquishing a sh*tty trope while at the same time reorienting the match as serious, must-win business; Finn Bálor entered an Iron Man performance in which he actually dictated the flow of the action and enhanced his reputation ahead of an excellent, feature WrestleMania match; two NXT acts were booked to star...on the main roster!; the talented field elevated the often dull mid-match phase into something exciting; the drama of the finishing sequence was as electric as it was manipulative as it was, ultimately, sorely-needed: the whole thing restored the magic of a match weighed down by antagonistic, broad bullsh*t in the abysmal years prior.

Everything points towards a continuation of this form. WWE's main roster is loaded with under-utilised talent desperate to impress, reducing the need for cheap surprise entrants and worse, all of the bloody commentators - and, not least, the potential crop of winners...


3. 30 Men Enter; No One Obvious Man Wins

seth rollins bobby lashley
WWE.com

This decade has largely followed a tiresome trend: the fans select a guy (Daniel Bryan, Dean Ambrose), the office selects a guy (Roman Reigns, Roman Reigns), and the office project squashes the organically popular star in the end.

2019 is fascinating, in that neither of those things feels true. WWE has telegraphed Seth Rollins' victory on RAW, but there's always the sense, what with him being popular among the customers (what a company this is to write about), that WWE may not pull the trigger on his headlining WrestleMania 35. It's difficult to escape that when, sprinting towards him at the top of RAW is an ultra-ripped, taller, more imposing Vince McMahon guy in Drew McIntyre - a guy who in late 2018 received the sort of babyface reactions that might convince Vince McMahon that he can move the needle Rollins hasn't yet.

But then, the slightly inconsistent Rollins on his best day is a machine of stamina. The Rumble is a match perfectly suited to the best version of himself.

Neither of the two RAW frontrunners is despised by nor wholly uninspiring to the audience, and neither is depressingly over-familiar. Braun Strowman is the unknown quantity here, too. We no longer know the extent to which Vince wishes to protect him; if nothing else, his appearing in the match adds another layer of fascination to it. And Christ knows what WWE has in mind for SmackDown, a brand with no clear top, 'Mania-worthy babyface beyond AJ Styles.

The fabled Road to WrestleMania is obscured by fog, but that's far more preferable than the clear, cynical route travelled this decade.


2. From An Inauspicious Start...

Tamina Snuka Lana Nia Jax
WWE

Last year's Women's Royal Rumble - the first of its kind, if you recall! - took an age to get rolling.

Marred by hesitation and confusion in the opening phase, with rusty veterans and ring-ready full-timers alike overawed by the occasion, it eventually settled into something that matched the relentless hype. Trish Stratus and Asuka stole a match that the sequel should trounce in every respect. Evolution's Battle Royal accomplished more with less; the women of WWE had adjusted quickly to an unfamiliar match type, and the omens for Sunday are therefore promising.

The field, which for unfathomable reasons WWE announced ahead of time, supports this optimism. Charlotte Flair should anchor the match, to ensure a consistent level of quality - but even if she doesn't, a backdoor win provides ammunition for Becky Lynch's sharp shooting. Nia Jax remains deeply unpopular, which WWE can mine to create a strain of anxiety-driven heat. A repeat of Ember Moon's excellent Evolution showing should provide a contrast, adding to both the din and the drama, and there exists scope to create a layered story emphasising athleticism (Naomi), comedy (Carmella) and old-fashioned, cruel Rumble hope (Bayley).

WWE didn't announce every entrant, so expect some faces from yesteryear - faces that unlike their male counterparts have not weakened the currency of nostalgia.


1. The Great Unknown

Mustafa Ali Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

In recent years, WWE has paved the Road To WrestleMania much too linearly. We knew the destination before even set off on the journey, which would be fine, if we were going to Disneyland. We weren't going to Disneyland. We were going to less celebrated tourist traps Twice In A Lifetime and RomanWinsLOL.

This year is different. Of the seven matches expected to make the main card, at least four are accumulator-killers, and those with more obvious outcomes - Lesnar Vs. Bálor in particular - will succeed in spite of the predictability. His fans aren't rooting for Bálor to win; they are hoping for an eye-catching display of grit and ingenuity in the mouth of the Beast. Sasha Banks is in a similar position. She isn't headlining 'Mania, but is the perfect, traditional Rumble title bout challenger, in that, if she excels here, she enters contention for next year's 'Mania, à la Chris Benoit between 2003-4. You wouldn't expect WWE to switch its flagship prize to AJ Styles - but looking at the state of SmackDown's babyfaces, it's not beyond the realm of possibility.

With a spectacular, stadium-sized backdrop propping it up, enhancing the show through production even the modern, lazy approach can't make ugly, Sunday's super-show holds the potential for something very special.

Soberingly, you could make that same argument for WWE on the whole - but WWE, at last, has the impetus do make something special of it.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!