10 Reasons WWE Raw Will Never Be The Same Again
Big E's big win brought one night of a joy to a land of despair. But will you be back next week?
Remember when escape rooms were a big thing?
You'll have been to one, or at least probably had mates prattle on about one of them, but for the unaware or otherwise uninterested, they had their own boom period in the mid-2010s as the group activity du jour. The idea was to gather together with friends, loved ones or complete strangers and try to crack a few codes in order to get out of a room.
For those that entered into the spirt of things, the concept had tension, drama and stakes. Time limits expiring could you leave you locked in forever! One wrong move and you could end up back at the start! Those people over there are constant-eye-contact folk and you're running out of places to look when you talk to them!
It was all to play for.
The novelty eventually began to wear off shortly before our own houses became the settings, the ramifications were frighteningly real, and there was no collection of clues on how get out beyond daily doom-scrolling. In a (sort of) post-pandemic world, surely only oddballs will relish the prospect of going to one of these again? Surely all the manufactured angst can't compete with 2020/21's real deal? Surely being inside a room with people you've never met is a total waste of hours that have never felt so precious?
But then who are we to talk? We still watch three hours of Monday Night Raw every week, and that broke our brains long before the first lockdown...
10. Because It Can't Be
Seems prudent to do this one first, because it's the thing WWE rely on most from an audience that is ageing and diminishing (in number, not capacity).
WWE Monday Night Raw can never be the Monday Night Raw you first fell in love with, unless the Monday Night Raw you first fell in love with was from July 2021 and you're still all wonderfully, wonderfully new to this.
Your writer is as guilty as anybody else at this. Tuning in once a week, hoping that World Wrestling Entertainment might attempt to provide entertainment with a wrestling show broadcast for fans all over the world. But the show is not the thing they still say it is, and hasn't been for years now. Years.
"The longest running weekly episodic show" (or whatever collection of words they force into Michael Cole's ears as if they're trying to pop them after a long flight) isn't booked episodically. They drop stories cold, forget the ramifications of other ones and change advertised matches without even acknowledging the adjustment to the card.
At an admin level, Raw isn't Raw. Or SmackDown, or any other wrestling show in history. It's content, which rather appropriately leads us to...
9. Content-ment
WWE Monday Night Raw is a television show that doesn't function as a television show.
The company's YouTube channel is enormously popular and much of it is because the shortened match and promo highlights are substantially easier to digest than the show itself. Often, it feels as though this scenario is all by design; that the organisation will gladly accept a staggered drop in traditional viewers as long as they can pump up their views and clicks on the socials.
Hopefully, this reflects an era that's becoming passé (per multiple reports, USA Network haven't been best pleased with the various failings of NXT in the last) with television rights deals now the undisputed kingmakers in all forms of live sports and entertainment.
In 2021 - and especially on Monday Night Raw - WWE's output exists to be something loosely resembling what it once looked like. Just enough to keep people on the hook, but evidently not enough to drive their genuine emotional investment over the longer term. Content about wrestling, not wrestling content itself.
Only if ratings return to being the top priority at the expense of everything else will it ever be a product again.
8. The REAL New Generation
Not to be confused with WWE's desperate attempt to make the company feel young again as swathes of stars left for WCW in the mid-1990s, the real new generation that will soon fill WWE shows are those that weren't even born for that seminal paradigm shift.
Vince McMahon infamously railed on millennials during his 2014 podcast interview with Stone Cold Steve Austin, presumably because they were one of the last generations to know that wrestling didn't just have to be whatever his monopoly dictated. It's ironic - he mumbled and grumbled about these no good pesky kids just being happy to be there orthingsofthatnature, but he should have been more grateful.
Many of those wrestlers may see AEW as far more attractive working environment all these years later, compared to Gen-Y'ers and beyond that aspire to wear a "Property Of The Performance Center" t-shirt because it jives with their nostalgic longings.
Ben Carter electrified the world in just three matches for All Elite Wrestling, but choosing to chase his dream has disappeared him from view on NXT UK. It's one thing for some fans to still think WWE is the best at this. It's quite another if hoards of wrestlers agree.
7. Because SmackDown's Where The Money Is
For decades - decades, two of them - SmackDown was the undisputed B-show.
People that had been close to Vince McMahon over the years admitted it when pushed - he saw competition between the shows even when the audience didn't, and always favoured his 1993 baby live on Monday Nights over the once-fruitful secondary show getting taped and bouncing around the schedule.
It didn't even change in 2016 when USA Network converted the blue brand into SmackDown Live in line with creative reinvestment in the show. It remained 'The B-Show', and was occasionally beloved because of that, but McMahon wasn't for turning. Not until Fox dropped one billion dollars on it anyway.
Raw's not stood even half a chance since. Every draft, shake-up or randomly-invented superstar swapper will always favour Friday nights, even if McMahon does his best kissy face towards the Network that has propped his product up for the bulk of its existence.
SmackDown was a recap/rematch show for so many years in the early 2010s that it became hard to name individual memorable moments that happened over 52 weeks at a time. WWE technically can't afford Raw to fall into a similar pattern, but it's never felt closer to it.
6. Vince McMahon Doesn't Respect His Wrestlers
Speculative, perhaps, but if the Chairman had the deep rooted love he once had for all of this, half of the roster simply wouldn't act as they do.
For one example from the most recent edition (and this could absolutely be applied to every single episode), take United States Champion Damian Priest. A prospect that hasn't yet been ruined despite debuting all the way back in January, the 'Archer Of Infamy' benefitted from his WrestleMania build alongside Bad Bunny and a minor break shortly after the 'Show Of Shows' that kept him hot for the summer months.
A United States Championship win at SummerSlam was well received, but the rematch feels entirely unnecessary. And that's not even the worst of it.
A routine title defence against Jeff Hardy was too routine, and Priest was booked more like a superfan than a superwrestler. This is rooted in a top-down disdain for what exists today versus what made McMahon loads of money in the past.
When - as Stardust - Cody spoke about "young men dying", this is what he meant. And Priest is no spring chicken!
This isn't just a wrestler problem, either...
5. Vince McMahon Doesn't Respect His Writers
Or he doesn't respect their time. Or their process. Or their work.
So no, he doesn't he respect his writers. He can't do - if he did, he wouldn't arrive at Raw shortly before airtime and tear the whole script up over and over again as we've all heard about over the last few years.
It was this precise indiscretion that WWE documentaries used to savage WCW for during its decline, but the practice since been normalised because, it would seem, McMahon likes it this way. A system that was set up to allow him to have a bit less needless control now finds him assuming the reins at the worst possible moment - with hardly any time before air.
Raw takes the brunt of it, and has in recent years undergone some flabbergasting changes as a result. Remember all matches being 2-out-of-3 falls ones? It's a bit like how they're all "contender" scraps now, as if that really means anything.
There was a time when McMahon used to call himself a genius on screen as a heel and people agreed. When he does it now, it plays as parody. He's lost control of his own narrative - there's no way he should be in charge of anybody else's.
4. The "Changes" Are Never Real
Monday Night Raw can't ever been an objectively great wrestling show in the spirit of its old self because that spirit was strangled and crushed by the need for snackable, disposable content.
If it feels like this point is getting repeated ad nauseam, it's because the ramifications of this decision have a knock on effect across multiple strands of the show.
WWE are locked into a formula that was super successful for around three to four years. It's incredible that they consider it a winning one in the face of the numbers - especially so when viewing the grand decline since Triple H cut that 2014 promo mocking "Mark and his buddies" for complaining online.
A cool-looking new ramp is never enough. Moving the commentary desk a bit isn't enough. Added pyro literally isn't enough - they only keep it for a few weeks and then it gets reduced and eventually eliminated all over again. The broader philosophical changes are lightyears away, and Raw can't be anything like what it was until even one of those is addressed.
3. Big E's Victory Felt Like An Outlier
Big E's WWE Championship victory was universally received as a) an awesome thing, b) an awesome thing that only happened when it did because WWE were rattled by ratings pressures placed upon them by AEW Dynamite and c) an awesome thing that should have happened ages ago.
And in that order, too.
Everybody loves him for all that he is. A tremendous wrestler, an awesomely entertaining babyface, a killer heel, a supreme tag worker and the type of heroic personality in real life that transcends WWE's stale and stoic aesthetic, E is a perfect choice to be WWE Champion.
But he's been all these things for years. A victim of just about every systemic ill, it's taken him this long for f*ck knows why, and for everybody is elated it happened, the questions won't stop being asked as to why it's taken so long.
Nor will they be dropped when discussion moves to the hotshotting that got them here. Again, E is a rule-proving exception - WWE panic book Raw almost every week. In this case, the company just delivered something people actually wanted.
2. Three Hours...
...and they'd make it longer if they could.
Nick Khan was being glib for the purposes of a tasty quote when he noted how financially beneficial a fourth hour of Monday Night Raw would be to WWE's bottom line, but it's because this is true that the company would absolutely take it if USA Network made an offer.
Nothing is forever in pro wrestling and the three hour Raw's look here to stay for years and years to come, but the reality is that it's precisely as likely that the former flagship would add an hour as take one away. The wrestling landscape looked awfully different in 2018 when WWE last secured its status for another five years, but how different will it look from now in 2023 when that one expires?
A recent demographic defeat at the hands of AEW Dynamite generated an ultimate people-pleasing moment in Big E's WWE Championship victory on the very next show, and the sheer joy around this individual moment was enough to make most people forget that the broadcast had been diabolical for most of the year.
The run-time, much like the creative direction, is only changing as per the whims of whomever pays the most for it.
1. Because Vince McMahon Is Going Nowhere
The balance of power in NXT shifted recently, seemingly removing Triple H and Shawn Michaels from the top table in favour of longstanding toadies Bruce Prichard and/or John Laurinaitis. This was a reasonable acknowledgment that the show badly needed a reboot, regardless of the outcome.
This has never ever been mooted for Monday Night Raw and never ever will be. And even when they approach an attempt, it feels forced and phoney. It was in 2018 when The McMahons arrived and promised grand changes that never remotely materialised. If Vince McMahon believes nothing is wrong, then nothing is wrong. And the only thing he ever dislikes about Raw is other people's work.
If Triple H can't argue the toss about Monday's show in response to his father-in-law's own b*llocking of his Tuesday changes, nobody can. Every now and then, rumours emerge about a possible sale of the company, before disappearing from view because it's just not happening, is it?