10 Recent WWE PPVs That Were Worse Than WWE Fastlane 2016

Come on, it's not like it was Battleground

Fastlane 2016 is in the books, and it was a disappointment. Despite a card that looked fairly solid from top to bottom, nothing really delivered the way fans had hoped. The matches that looked great (AJ Styles versus Chris Jericho, Brock Lesnar versus Roman Reigns versus Dean Ambrose) didn't live up to the hype, and the ones that looked bad (The Wyatt Family versus The Big Show, Kane, and Ryback, an unannounced R-Truth versus Curtis Axel bout) were bad. Still, problems with the in-ring content could be forgiven if the booking was strong, and Fastlane fell even harder in that regard. In an ending that was simultaneously predictable and infuriating, company-approved top babyface Roman Reigns pinned Dean Ambrose to earn a title shot at WrestleMania, then stared down WWE World Heavyweight Champion Triple H to hype up a weak 'Mania main event. Yes, Fastlane was a flop - especially considering how badly it needed to deliver - but the worst Pay-Per-View in years? Hardly. Over the last seven or eight years, WWE has seemingly forgotten how to build up a proper PPV event, and it's been solely left to the wrestlers to deliver something that makes fans feel like they haven't wasted their money. Sometimes they can pull it off, but other times, time constraints and bad booking hamstring even the best of workers. The results have been Pay-Per-Views that make Fastlane 2016 look like Money in the Bank 2011. Still not convinced? Here are some recent Pay-Per-Views (from January of 2013 onward) that were worse than Fastlane:


10. Royal Rumble 2015

There's not much to say about the 2015 Royal Rumble that hasn't already been said, so here's the short version. The Rumble match itself was the worst in history, a poorly-structured, boring affair that saw crowd favorite Daniel Bryan eliminated after ten minutes, despite having made his return from career-threatening injury. WWE decision-makers hoped that eliminating Bryan early would mean that the fans would be back into the match by the end, but it didn't work that way. Roman Reigns, who entered at number 19, was hated, and a path of destruction carved by past-their-prime giants The Big Show and Kane saw other fan favorites like Dolph Ziggler and Dean Ambrose unceremoniously eliminated. Even The Rock, who helped Reigns fight off an attack from the titans, couldn't turn the crowd to his favor. A weak undercard meant that the majority of the show was fairly useless - the only saving grace was a triple threat WWE Championship match between Brock Lesnar, John Cena, and Seth Rollins. The bout - one of the wildest in WWE history - was arguably the best match of 2015 and saved the show from being considered among the worst WWE PPVs of all time. Even with the classic brawl, though, the show averaged out to be quite weak.

9. TLC 2014

With WWE Champion Brock Lesnar off hunting and collecting money, WWE made the decision to focus on younger talents in the fall of 2014. Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins headlined the Hell in a Cell PPV, where Rollins scored a win after interference from Bray Wyatt. That set up Wyatt and Ambrose for a singles showdown at TLC in the event's titular match. The main event was a wild brawl that was marred by one of the company's all-time dumbest finishes - Ambrose, looking to inflict ultimate pain on Wyatt, grabbed a TV monitor and attempted to hit "The Eater of Worlds" with it. Unfortunately, the cord was just too short to reach Wyatt, so Ambrose attempted to yank the monitor lose. That caused a mini-explosion, blinding "The Lunatic Fringe" and leaving him easy prey for Sister Abigail. Essentially, Ambrose was felled by his own stupidity. Elsewhere on the card, John Cena and Seth Rollins had a good tables match, but it wasn't enough to offset the Big Show-Erick Rowan stairs match, the Ryback-Kane chairs match, or Rusev's third PPV win over Jack Swagger.

8. Royal Rumble 2014

WWE's attempt (and ultimately, failure) to manipulate fans into accepting a Daniel Bryan loss at the 2015 Royal Rumble was informed by what had happened the previous year. Heading into the 2014 event, Daniel Bryan was the most popular superstar in the company, but WWE executives were heavily invested in Batista, who had recently returned after a four year absence. "The Animal" was considered the favorite to win the Rumble match, but fans held out hope for Bryan. As the Royal Rumble drew to its conclusion, fans continued to believe that Bryan would win - until Rey Mysterio entered at number 30, showing that The Yes! Man was not even part of the match. The crowd booed angrily, and kept the antipathy going to the end of the show, where Batista eliminated Roman Reigns to win the Rumble match, just like everybody feared. Bryan's only appearance on the PPV came in the opener, where he lost to Bray Wyatt in the match of the night. Wyatt would later go on to cost John Cena a WWE Title match with Randy Orton, while Brock Lesnar beat The Big Show easily after a pre-match steel chair assault.

7. Night Of Champions 2013

SummerSlam 2013 was a success on a number of levels - not only was the show filled with great matches, but from a storytelling point of view, it was brilliant. Daniel Bryan cleanly defeated WWE Champion John Cena for the title, but was immediately robbed of it after Triple H turned heel and attacked him, and Randy Orton cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase. Unfortunately, The Authority became played out and repetitive almost immediately, and the Randy Orton-Daniel Bryan feud wasn't as compelling as fans had hoped. The two clashed in the main event of the next Pay-Per-View, Night of Champions, but the match didn't live up to Bryan's initial win over Cena. The former WWE Champion pinned "The Viper" to win the title back, but the three count by referee Scott Armstrong was unnecessarily fast, raising red flags. Sure enough, the next night on Raw, Bryan was stripped of the title and it was held up. CM Punk's feud with Paul Heyman (also known as "the straw that broke the camel's back) continued on the undercard, with Punk defeating Heyman and Curtis Axel in a handicap match - Axel's second match of the night. Ricardo Rodriguez was in Rob Van Dam's corner for RVD's match with Alberto Del Rio, while The Miz defeated Fandango in a match that happened on Pay-Per-View.

6. Battleground 2014

Battleground 2014 looked like a weak card on paper, but there was one match that fans were anxiously awaiting - Dean Ambrose versus his Shield-brother-turned-Authority-sellout Seth Rollins. Both men had reputations as great workers from the independent scene and had done amazing things in tag team matches, so hopes were high for one of their early singles outings. Naturally, the match was cancelled. Earlier in the show, Ambrose had attack Rollins, so Triple H decided that Ambrose needed to be removed from the building. Rollins was declared the winner by forfeit, and Ambrose managed to attack him again. In the main event, John Cena defended the WWE Title against Roman Reigns, Randy Orton, and Kane, pinning Kane (and doing Reigns no favors). Also on the show, The Miz won a battle royal to win the Intercontinental Championship, and Lana made a comment subtly praising Vladimir Putin for a real-life act of terrorism.

5. TLC 2013

It was the most important match in WWE history. Well, at the very least, the most important match in years. Most important match of the year? The month? The show? With only a few weeks of build, WWE made the long-overdue decision to unify the WWE and World Heavyweight Championships, putting both on the line in a ladder match between titleholders Randy Orton and John Cena. The match was hyped as delivering the first-ever unified WWE Champion, even though the exact same promise had been made 12 years earlier when Chris Jericho won the WWE and WCW titles. Orton won a middle-of-the-road TLC bout to become the inaugural WWE World Heavyweight Champion. The show was also infamous for hosting two three-on-one handicap matches. In the first, CM Punk defeated The Shield (despite the fact that the company wanted to put Roman Reigns over) and in the second, Daniel Bryan fell to The Wyatt Family. Nothing on the show was better than average.

4. Battleground 2015

Ever since Seth Rollins stole the WWE World Heavyweight Championship from Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania XXX, fans clamored to see "The Beast" get a shot for revenge. In July, Rollins had disappointed The Authority one too many times, so they finally announced that Lesnar would get his rematch at Battleground. For all his talent, Rollins had been booked terribly as WWE Champion, only cheating or lucking into even the smallest of victories. That wasn't about to change at Battleground. Lesnar beat the living daylights out of Rollins for nine minutes, then hit him with the F5 and made the cover. After the two count, the lights went off. When they came back on, Rollins and the referee were simply gone and The Undertaker was in their place. Undertaker attacked Lesnar to end the show, and no decision on the main event was ever rendered. The only bright spot on the show was the blowoff to the John Cena-Kevin Owens feud, and even that ended sourly - Cena's clean win over Owens bumped the prizefighter down to the midcard, where he remains today. The less said about the continuation of the Randy Orton-Sheamus and Bray Wyatt-Roman Reigns programs, the better.

3. Survivor Series 2015

Seth Rollins's seven-month WWE Title reign came to an abrupt end in November of 2015, when he was forced to relinquish the belt following a knee injury. Immediately, a 16-man tournament was announced, and with names like Tyler Breeze and Stardust involved, it was clear just how shallow the company's roster had become. Leading into Survivor Series, Roman Reigns, Alberto Del Rio, Dean Ambrose, and Kevin Owens were still alive in the tournament, with fans hoping for an exciting swerve that would turn the former Shield brothers against one another. Sure enough, it came down to Reigns and Ambrose, but instead of one of the men joining The Authority to become a new corporate champion, Reigns won cleanly. After that, he refused Triple H's offer of joining the heel stable, so Money in the Bank winner Sheamus came out, cashed in his briefcase, and became the new champion - after losing in a traditional Survivor Series bout earlier in the evening. Fans were livid. The much-hyped Undertaker/Kane-Wyatts match was a grave disappointment after Undertaker's strong showings against Brock Lesnar in previous months, and the Charlotte-Paige match (which was built around Paige insulting Charlotte's deceased brother Reid) actually saw fans turn on Charlotte. The Pay-Per-View was far and away the worst of 2015, and a show better left forgotten.

2. Battleground 2013

Maybe there's just something about the name "Battleground." After the controversial finish at Night of Champions 2013, the WWE Championship was held "in abeyance" (because "vacant" is too old-school a term for Vince McMahon). It was decided that the two most recent champions - Daniel Bryan and Randy Orton - would once again battle for the right to hold the title. Prior to the bout, there was pressure on The Big Show - who had been coerced into joining The Authority - to "do the right thing." As Orton and Bryan battled for the championship (but before the match had a chance to get good), Show came to the ring, attacked the referee, and punched Bryan out. Scott Armstrong ran down to help give Orton the win, but Show had a change of heart, knocked him out, and finally punched Randy Orton. The show ended with only The Big Show standing tall, and no WWE Champion. With an undercard that featured CM Punk versus Ryback and The Real Americans versus Santino Marella and The Great Khali, the show was a ripoff to every fan who spent $44.99 on it (this was a few months before the WWE Network launched). The show's only saving grace was a tag title match pitting The Shield against Cody Rhodes and Goldust, but it wasn't enough to stop Battleground from being voted the Worst Major Wrestling Show in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's 2013 awards.

1. Survivor Series 2013

After Battleground, The Big Show became The Authority's number one enemy. When Randy Orton won the WWE Championship at Hell in a Cell, the stage was set for a confrontation between the company's top heel and the giant he had helped torment. The only problem was that the fans didn't care. The main event of Survivor Series, pitting the two against each other, was slow and plodding, drawing a "boring" chant from the WWE Universe (think about how infrequently that happens to a PPV main event). John Cena and Alberto Del Rio had a disappointing match, as did CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, and The Wyatt Family. Throw in a couple of terrible/meaningless midcard bouts, and you've hit rock bottom. The 2013 Survivor Series was the lowest-selling edition of the event in its 29-year history. Three of the show's matches finished in the top five in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's "Worst Match of the Year" award polling, including the main event at #2 and the "Total Divas" versus "True Divas" Survivor Series style match at #1. For another perspective on how bad Survivor Series was, just seven months later, WWE returned to Boston's TD Garden for Money in the Bank 2014. That show was a solid outing with a great MITB ladder match and several other good contests - but it was also notable for a large sign in front of the hard camera which simply read "SURVIVOR SERIES SUCKED."

Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013