10 Recent Wrestling Gimmicks That Already Look Done For
These superstars look like they might need to go back to the drawing board.
A change of gimmick can breath new life into an act.
Look at Chris Jericho. When he became the first AEW Champion, a lot of people were saying he was an old, over-the-hill wrestler and the burgeoning company should have plumped for one of the newer stars as its inaugural World Champ. Jericho responded by becoming 'Le Champion' and went on arguably the best run of his career. His transition since from a bland face into 'The Wizard' has once again re-energised a character who constantly changes things up for the better.
When things get stale, a change can be a good thing. Remember how it felt like WWE had fumbled Daniel Bryan's incredible return but then course corrected with the amazing 'New Daniel Bryan'? Or how The New Day were irritating gospel men, so transformed into the charismatic trio they are today?
Then you have Roman Reigns, whose switch from Big Dog to Tribal Chief has created a megastar.
With any change, you need to have a clear direction and plan in place, and when it becomes clear there isn't one, things can very quickly spiral into irrelevancy. If you don't get off to a good start, or you don't quite stick the landing, then it can be over before it starts.
Unfortunately, for the names on this list, it feels like that descent has already begun.
10. Hit Row
Of all the returns since Triple H took control, and there have been many, the one that raised the most eyebrows was the return of Hit Row.
It's good to see people getting a shot at the big time, and mixing things up should be encouraged, especially on a roster that has felt stale since the mass releases over the past few years. But there are a couple of things that are working against Hit Row, and they are both big factors as to why the crowd interest has already seemingly cooled.
Firstly, their initial stay on the main roster was, to quote the late, great Randy Savage, "a cup of coffee in the big time". They were gone before they got started, so unless you watched NXT during the dying embers of the black and gold era, which evidently people didn't, Hit Row weren't much of a concern.
Secondly, whilst the group certainly have charisma and bucket loads of confidence, the act isn't the most explosive in the ring. And lastly, these three were primarily background noise to the real star of the faction, Swerve Scott, who has since found success as one of the most interesting heels in All Elite Wrestling.
Without their frontman, Hit Row feels like an incomplete act, and after a few not so impressive in-ring outings and that awful rap segment, it's hard to see them as genuine threats to the Usos. In fact, it's hard to see much for them going forward.
9. Luchasaurus
This one is a victim of poor timing.
There was always a going to be a ceiling for a wrestler like Luchasaurus. In-ring, he is an explosive big man, and was beloved as the menacing dinosaur pal of rising star Jungle Boy. As Jurassic Express, the duo were a lovable act and even reigned as the AEW Tag Team Champions.
But Jungle Boy was always the focus of the duo. Positioned as one of the 'pillars' since day one, the entire act was to help build Jack Perry as a future star, which was also the reason the pair's alliance with Christian Cage. The wily Canadian veteran provided great guidance, and we all knew Christian's turn would eventually happen.
When it did, it was white hot, and Cage drew the masked luchador into the middle of it. The heel turn hasn't been that effective, with Luchasaurus now donning a black mask but, without a true character, it's hard to get behind.
Unfortunately, Christian Cage came down with a serious injury right at the peak of the feud, meaning the pay-off of the Instant Classic vs. Jungle Jack is a long way off and will have significantly cooled by the time it eventually happens. Considering the entire split has been focused on Cage vs. Jungle Boy, the proposed JB vs. Luchasaurus rivalry has little heat to it, and when Jungle Boy inevitably goes over in that feud, what next for the big man?
A heel Luchasaurus already feels lost.
8. Doudrop & Nikki A.S.H.
The 'Almost A Super Hero' gimmick was a turd from the get-go, and when Nikki A.S.H. walked out cosplaying as Snowball from Secret Life of Pets 2 (seriously, look it up), it was doomed to fail. Inexplicably, Vince McMahon rocket-strapped the goofy gimmick and a subsequent Money in the Bank win and successful cash-in swiftly followed.
The fans, however, didn't follow, and pretty quickly the apparent babyface Raw Women's Champion was being booed by the live crowd. Nikki dropped the belt and plummeted down the card, which is a real shame, as she deserves so much better than she has been given.
It could be worse; she could have been named Doudrop.
The inexplicable name change for Piper Niven was a noose around her main roster run from the start, and it seemed only logical when the floundering two acts eventually came together. Both heralding from Scotland and both capable of much more, they should have been a cornerstone of a women's tag division that has never quite gotten going.
With Doudrop telling Nikki to "start taking things seriously", the pairing have been nothing but losers. They never win, Nikki still dresses in her ridiculous outfit, and Niven, unfortunately, still has the worst name in wrestling.
How are we supposed to take them seriously if the writers don't? Whatever is in store for the duo's future, their act as a villainous tag team just isn't it.
7. Ezekiel
This was fun while it lasted, wasn't it?
To be fair, the shelf life on this ridiculous gimmick was always going to be a short one, and we need to give major credit to both Ezekiel and Kevin Owens for getting it over to the lengths that they did. It's not easy to take something so ridiculous and make it the most entertaining part of the show.
For the usual slow month after WrestleMania, Ezekiel was the talk of WWE, and honestly, it defies logic how over he got. As Elias, the grappler knew how to hold the crowd in the palm of his hand, and as his 'younger brother', the former Drifter showed some pretty decent, earnest, babyface potential.
But then the bell rang and, unfortunately, Ezekiel just isn't quite the electric performer who can keep the momentum going, and once Owens disappeared from TV for a few weeks, it soon became clear how much the gimmick needed the exasperated foil provided by the Prizefighter.
Upon his return, Owens essentially killed off the character with a brutal beatdown and we probably won't be seeing Ezekiel ever again. We will see the performer, however - with Elias set to return to WWE TV on next week's Raw.
There are two positives from the whole experience. One was the great babyface potential of Elias, and two, let the man take his shirt off. What a body!
6. Trustbusters
Quick question - can you name the members of the Trustbusters?
No? Don't worry, nobody can.
Tony Khan should be given immense credit for always trying to build some sort of reason or attaching stakes to a match-up, but there are times when even he gets in his own way. All Elite Wrestling has shown over the last three years that having multiple stables an alliances can work in wrestling.
Whilst WWE has tended to shy away from them in recent years, AEW proved that an interconnected world can have its benefits, but sometimes things get thrown together and absolutely nobody cares. The formation of the Trustbusters is definitely one of those things.
Ari Daivari barely registered when he became #AllElite, Slim J has done next to nothing, and, despite all the potential in Parker Boudreaux, he's had such little in-ring time that he is nowhere near ready for a TV spot. All of this dominated an episode of Rampage, purely to try and fill a space in the Trios Tag Titles tournament, which, as we have seen with the WWE women's tag division, if you don't have enough teams, maybe don't do it then?
The Trustbusters have flailed on Dark and Dark: Elevation since that tourney and, most likely, won't be a pressing concern going forward.
Also, did you know Sonny Kiss turned heel and joined the stable? No? Don't worry, nobody did.
5. Dolph Ziggler
A WWE staple for over a decade and a half, it's pretty difficult to say Dolph Ziggler looks done for when he has had so many returns and failed pushes, but this past summer, something really strange happened.
In the dying embers of Vince McMahon's bizarre creative control, the 'Show Off' returned out of nowhere, dressed in a smart suit and with dry hair, and took a seat at ringside for Austin Theory's match with AJ Styles. There were no explanations and, at the end of the match, Ziggler obstructed Theory from using the Money in the Bank briefcase and then ended the show by blasting the MITB contract holder with a superkick.
What followed was a dull feud, with the veteran wanting to teach Theory respect (why?), and a month later Theory beat Ziggler on Monday Night RAW and that was that. All done.
For the following few weeks, Dolph mulled about with AJ Styles and the Judgement Day, but he hasn't been seen for nearly two months. Whatever plans were in place seem to have been scrapped, and once again, the former two-time World Heavyweight Champion finds himself kicking his heels in catering.
There is a terrific pro wrestler in Dolph Ziggler, but once again, it seems like he won't be getting the push or the airtime needed to really break through. As has been the case for over 15 years.
4. The Embassy
Ring of Honor, whilst providing us with some great in-ring action, hasn't really been the success that Tony Khan imagined when he brought it in early-2022.
Clearly a passion purchase - and, let's be honest, a vanity one, too - it's no secret that AEW's product hasn't been as hot since the added distraction of an entirely separate company. That acquisition has flooded AEW programming with multiple belts, stripping the other titles of their worth, and Khan has had to dedicate time on his flagship show to build for ROH events due to that promotion having yet to secure a TV deal.
It's all a bit of a mess, which is apt, because so is the act featured in this entry.
The Embassy started off as Tully Blanchard Enterprises, with the former Pinnacle manager taking a new role within ROH and seemingly aligning with the long-forgotten Brian Cage. Add in the Gates of Agony tag team, and you had a meaty stable for when the brand took off.
ROH hasn't, and neither did TBE, as Blanchard swiftly left the company and Prince Nana apparently 'bought' the group, reforming The Embassy and looking to dominate Ring of Honor.
Last week, Brian Cage had a shot at the TNT Title - despite not being on AEW TV for over a year - and he lost. At Battle of the Belts this past weekend, the Gates of Agony challenged FTR for the ROH Tag Team Titles. They lost.
So this group is made up of losers? Great. Next.
3. Maximum Male Models
Similar to Ezekiel, for a few weeks, this was over.
It was absolutely ridiculous, but it was a laugh riot and credit needs to go to ma.çé and mån.sôör̃ for how much effort they put into this. They threw themselves into the hilarious rebrand, and with the charismatic Max Dupri in charge, this did have some legs.
But as quickly as Vince McMahon loves a shiny new toy, he can just as quickly decide he hates it. Out of nowhere, Max Dupri was replaced by Maxxine Dupri and it looked like the former LA Knight would be repackaged once more. But then, he was back, and nobody really knew what was going on.
Enter The Game, who knew exactly what he wanted. He wanted his LA Knight back. Yeaaaah!
Since then, Maximum Male Models have done diddly squat, being embarrassed by Hit Row and have been berated, belittled and now beaten up by Max, who has officially returned to his LA Knight name. Without the former Eli Drake's raw charisma to help 'titillate our senses', there is no future for Maximum Male Models.
ma.çé and mån.sôör̃ are hardly big names or beloved talents, and surely Main Event awaits until they can find something else for them to do.
But hey, we will always have that Pure Life Water advert at SummerSlam. Chef's kiss.
2. Sammy Guevara & Tay Melo
Has any wrestler had a bigger fall from grace this year than Sammy Guevara?
The backlash against the real-life romance between Sammy and Tay Melo has been a little pathetic, because it's purely based on jealousy. Two very attractive, successful people are in a relationship and clearly having a lovely time. How dare they?
But there is a fine line between celebrating it and rubbing it in people's faces, and the way Tony Khan presented the duo in the first half of this year is one of his biggest mistakes as a booker. Let's make this clear: Sammy Guevara didn't turn heel.
The fans turned him heel.
At the backend of last year, during the in-fighting and eventual break up of the Inner Circle, the three-time TNT Champion was a beloved babyface. As one of the pillars of the company and the reigning champion, the fans loved Sammy. But his natural arrogance soon turned the tide, and he and Melo just didn't connect as a likable duo.
Since then, there have been multiple instances of Guevara's backstage behaviour that have come to light, such as his needless body shaming of Eddie Kingston (who got suspended for smacking Sammy) and the vitriol he spat at Andrade (who got sent home for smacking Sammy).
Having a punchable face is great for a heel - just ask Dominik Mysterio - but this act now has 'go away heat', and it's hard to see what the duo can do to get fans back onside.
1. Damage CTRL
For all the talk about how Triple H gets women's wrestling, he hasn't half messed things up with Damage CTRL.
A returning Bayley should have been an open goal, and bringing in the returning Dakota Kai and elevating IYO SKY to the main roster should have been just as easy. To be honest, Bayley should have returned as a babyface, but that's a different rant for a different list.
To establish a stable as a main event threat - which is what Damage CTRL are supposed to be - they should dominate. So why on earth, at the culmination of the WWE Women's Tag Team Championship tournament, Trips booked the random duo of Raquel Rodriguez and Aaliyah to win the belts is a mystery.
A swerve for swerve's sake? It was pointless, and having SKY and Kai lose such an important match, so early on, was damaging. Especially when they picked up the belts two weeks later. With their credibility shot, Triple H needed to course correct, and having Bayley defeat Bianca Belair for the Raw Women's Title and bring all the gold to the stable was the right move.
So, of course, despite the insurmountable odds, Belair successfully retained her title belt at Extreme Rules and now Bayley looks like a loser. Why should we take the stable seriously?
In all likelihood, the Role Model will get another shot and she may very well win that Raw Women's Championship. But seeing the three women lose such important matches within two months of their formation just pegs them as losers, and they seem damaged beyond anyone's control.