10 Recent WWE Character Turns That Didn't Make Sense

Looking at 10 of the more egregiously bad flips in recent years...

Ryback John Cena Raw April 2013
WWE.com

It's often said that nice guys finish last. Just like life, in WWE, that sentiment is often true as very few characters go their entire professional wrestling career without making at least one change to their allegiances.

Good guys turn into bad guys, bad guys turn into good guys (and gals) and sometimes they do both. Currently, there's a huge deficit in the number of bad guys, or heels, on WWE's main roster and it's lead to some pretty questionable decisions.

With some recent character changes surrounding some of the top WWE superstars, it may be a good time to look at some of the more poorly handled character turns over the past few years.

From natural born heels being cast as heroes to unlikable "good guys" and everything in between, WWE has had no shortage of bungled character turns, be it heel-to-face or face-to-heel. For every successful Austin/Hart double-turn, there's at least five failed Dusty Rhodes heel turns, and recent developments in WWE has done little to improve that ratio.

More than they'd care to admit, WWE has made some head-scratching calls over the past several years in an attempt to "shake things up" but the following 10 character changes top the list.

10. Lana

Lana double denim
WWE.com

Last summer, WWE produced a storyline that became the most disastrous and bungled of the year.

The company had successfully built up the Rusev and Lana duo over the previous year, which included a lengthy run with the United States Championship and a victory over John Cena for the big Bulgarian. Admittedly, Rusev's heat suffered coming out of Spring 2015 (that tends to happen when you're booked to lose 3 PPV matches in a row), but the idea of going with a Rusev/Lana breakup and a Lana babyface turn at that juncture was completely the wrong call.

Over the weeks that followed the initial break-up, Lana went from being a strong, confident, independent leader to a meek, lost, love-scorned girl that needed to latch on to another man (Dolph Ziggler) to improve her self-esteem.

Where were all the characteristics from this bada*s chick that lead Rusev to the US title? Why did she suddenly go from being above the fans to caring about and wanting their adulation? Why did she drop the blazer for an acid-wash jean jacket?

All these questions were left unanswered and, sure enough, Lana would be reunited with Rusev before the year was through. Unfortunately, the damage had already been done.


9. Stardust

Goldust Stardust turn
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes' 2014 transition into Stardust marked the beginning of the end for his WWE run.

It's not so much that the Stardust character was such a terrible idea, it would've been fine for a period had it been presented in a more serious, more vicious manner. The reason why Cody makes this list is because WWE had a hot babyface on their hands in the Fall of 2013 that they should've pushed up the card.

Instead, they went the opposite way and it eventually lead to a WWE without Cody Rhodes. Clearly, that was a move that didn't make sense.

While taking on The Shield in the Fall of 2013, Cody was working as a babyface after years of successfully working heel. Fans were taking to Cody's in-ring style and move-set and were staunchly behind the younger Rhodes brother. The company should've recognised his talents, his improvements, his commitment and dedication to his craft, and given him a bigger opportunity heading into WrestleMania XXX. He certainly deserved one.

Instead, Cody's career took a turn for the worse by becoming Stardust, a character he could not get out of.


8. Erick Rowan

Erick Rowan Face
WWE.com

Erick Rowan, the tall, bearded, ugly, bald man from the backwoods-dwelling Wyatt Family would probably work better as a sympathy-garnering, awkwardly smiling, lovable "good guy". That's apparently what WWE was thinking in late 2014 when they inexplicably split up The Wyatt Family and decided to make Erick Rowan a babyface.

The Wyatt Family may not have been firing on all cylinders at this time, but it may have had more to do with the string of losses their leader had sustained over the past year. Add to that the fact that there never seemed to be any payoff to Bray's long and rambling interview segments in which he proclaimed to have the whole world in his hands. All bark and no bite.

The Wyatts definitely needed a boost, but splintering their core and turning the guy that wore the creepy lamb mask "good" was not it.

Needless to say, WWE realised their mistakes not long after pulling the trigger on this ill-conceived notion, and both Erick Rowan and Luke Harper were once again paired with Bray, reuniting as The Wyatt Family in 2015.


7. Ryback

Ryback ambulance 2013
WWE.com

Do you remember when Ryback was considered the next major superstar and fans debated whether he could replace John Cena as the face of WWE? No, it's not a joke, that actually happened and WWE definitely had something with Ryback in late 2012.

The Big Guy debuted to a series of "Goldberg" chants due to his look, size, and move-set, but it wasn't look before those jeers turned to cheers. Many fans soon rooted for the newcomer to dethrone long reigning WWE Champion CM Punk in the Fall of 2012. The company had a chance to anoint a new champion in Ryback as he seemed to be on the verge of something big as a babyface.

While the title win didn't happen, WWE did go to lengths to protect The Big Guy as they still had major plans for him. Those plans came in the form of a sudden heel turn and a post-WrestleMania program against John Cena. While that's a position most superstars would kill to be in, it was only a temporary boost and, in 2013, was all but guaranteed to follow with a significant slide down the card.

Indeed, Ryback's value sank faster than Yokozuna in quicksand and the bygone days of fans considering Ryback as next face of the company seemed light years away.


6. Cesaro

Andre the Giant Trophy Cesaro
WWE.com

In this current age of sports-entertainment, legit babyface superstars are in short supply. Finding and developing characters that connect with the majority of today's fan base is a difficult task. It's been discussed how WWE had several superstars with breakout babyface potential in Cody Rhodes and Ryback, but they also had it with Cesaro in 2014.

Gaining fan support heading into WrestleMania XXX, Cesaro had the most memorable moment of his career when he body-slammed The Big Show over the top rope to win the inaugural Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal. At the time, it wasn't clear what that victory would mean.

Was it going to be the next Money In The Bank or would it simply be forgotten weeks later like most outcomes on WWE television? Unfortunately, it was more the latter than the former.

Coming out of WrestleMania XXX, WWE decided to turn Cesaro heel and pair him with Paul Heyman. This resulted in a massive losing streak which evaporated all the momentum Cesaro had previously built.

Along with being told to refrain from using the Big Swing in fear of the dreaded fan support, WWE separated Cesaro from Heyman after only a few months together and he's yet to reach the heights he seemed so ready to scale back in early 2014.


5. The Bellas

Brie Nikki Bella Promo Feud
WWE.com

With the emergence of female WWE superstars like Charlotte, Sasha Banks, and Bayley, it may be difficult to remember that it wasn't that long ago Brie Bella was headlining the women's division, taking on Stephanie McMahon at SummerSlam 2014.

This match was supposed to be the culmination of the Brie/Stephanie storyline that saw Brie gain her revenge for The Authority's treatment of her family during the previous year. Instead, Nikki Bella turned on her sister, costing her the match and fans were expecting to find out who the superior Bella Twin was.

Only that payoff never came.

Sure, we got the infamous "died in the womb" promo from Nikki and a Jerry Springer segment, but this whole angle was dropped without any explanation after the 2014 Hell In A Cell Pay-Per-View. Inexplicably, Brie was willingly back at her sister's side after being physically and verbally abused since SummerSlam.

Clearly, WWE did not like the angle they had created and did their best vanishing act to try and make the fans forget. After a massive betrayal at the second biggest show of the year, Nikki and Brie were right back to where they were before SummerSlam.


4. The Miz

The Miz 2012
WWE.com

There's no shortage of heel qualities in the characterization of The Miz. He's arrogant, sarcastic, annoying, cowardly, talks trash, has a hot wife, and the list goes on and on. So why then did WWE think that in late 2012 fans would rather support him than root against him?

Perhaps it was simply another poor decision on the part of the writers or Vince McMahon or whomever's idea it was to flip The Miz, but it just didn't work. The failure that was The Miz: WWE Good Guy was seen coming a mile a way, yet WWE did nothing but drive straight into it.

The company wisely reversed course not long after their decision but, once again, the damage had been done.

Notice a theme developing? The WWE guide to character arching seems to be: make obvious bad decision, try and undo said decision, end up back where you started, only much further behind. Repeat.

A radical idea would be for the decision makers to learn from their previous mistakes of turning the wrong guys so that they don't happen so often in the future. Instead, WWE seems perfectly content with throwing everything against the wall, hoping that something doesn't immediately fly right back at them, and keeping the status quo.

Miz as a babyface? Really? Really?


3. AJ Styles

aj styles
WWE.com

Almost every single thing about the AJ Styles character screams "babyface".

The moves, the backstory, the workrate, the colours, the gloves; this guy is the prototypical good guy, yet after only 4 short months with WWE, he was turned heel. This is to say nothing about the boost in merchandise sales that Styles supposedly experienced in his first quarter with WWE, but that's a whole other issue.

To be fair, WWE is in somewhat of a crisis right now in terms of the heel:face ratio on the main roster and they could certainly do with some credible villains. But WWE had numerous talents to choose from to flip (e.g. Ambrose, Ziggler, Crews, etc.). Why those chose their best worker that was being heavily cheered by the majority of audiences and selling more merch than 80% of the roster after merely 17 weeks working for WWE does not make any sense.

Too many athletes with breakout babyface potential have had their legs cut out from under them because of a bad WWE decision. Time will tell if this turn will negatively affect AJ the way it has so many others, but WWE's track record says it absolutely will.


2. Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan The Wyatts
WWE.com

Speaking of organic good guys, Daniel Bryan is known as one of the most genuinely kind and caring wrestlers in the entire sports-entertainment industry.

This, in addition to his incredible talents inside the squared circle, allowed Bryan to become the most popular WWE superstar in 2013 and 2014. The trend would've likely continued for the next several years had Bryan been able to continue his in-ring career, but he was forced to retire last February due to concussion-related issues.

As much as it was a disappointing and heartbreaking story, it made sense. Years of working a ferocious style, going all out all the time had caught up to Bryan.

What didn't make sense was WWE's mindboggling decision to make Daniel Bryan a heel in 2013, aligning him with The Wyatt Family, smack dab in the middle of his white hot babyface run.

Bryan had been feuding with the Wyatts throughout the Fall of 2013 so when he decided to join forces with them, it made little sense storyline-wise and even less sense in reality. Why would WWE take its hottest superstar, the Leader Of The Yes Nation, a "movement" that had received mainstream media attention, and try to kill that?

It's one of the many enigmas that is WWE booking and it's good enough for #2 on the list.


1. Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins WWE Title
WWE.com

The stage was set so wonderfully for Seth Rollins to become one of the company's biggest babyface superstars upon his return from injury that the decision to make him heel could be the worst call WWE has made in 2016.

Everything WWE had done since Rollins went down with a torn ACL, MCL, and medial meniscus had prepared the audience to root for this guy when he returned. The coverage of his surgery in Alabama, the WWE 24 special that had been produced for the WWE Network, the Redesign/Rebuild/Reclaim strategy, and his surprise return in the main event of WWE Extreme Rules were straight out of "How To Make A Babyface 101".

While not necessarily a turn per se, Rollins returned on the RAW after Extreme Rules and instantly buried the fans.

Now again, it is clear that WWE has been in dire need of top heels to balance their roster, but that's a problem that A) is of WWE's own doing and could've been resolved by now and B) not a reason to extinguish the flame of potentially WWE's hottest babyface since Daniel Bryan.

God knows they're not getting what they want out of the crowd's reaction to Roman Reigns, why not give Seth that opportunity, especially considering how many fans were vehemently behind him?

Maybe Vince doesn't want another Bret Hart to Roman Reigns' Lex Luger, but that doesn't prevent it from being a terrible decision. In fact, it cements it as the #1 most recent character allegiance decision that did not make any sense.


Contributor
Contributor

A former stuntman for Paramount Pictures, Matt enjoys sports, water skiing, driving fast, the beach, professional wrestling, technology, and scotch. At the same time, whenever possible. Having attended many famous (and infamous) shows including WrestleMania XV, In Your House: Mind Games, and the 1995 King of the Ring, Matt has been a lifelong professional sports and wrestling fan. Matt's been mentioned in numerous wrestling podcasts including the Steve Austin Show: Unleashed, Talk Is Jericho, and Something To Wrestle With Bruce Prichard. As a former countywide performer, Matt has been referred to as Mr. 300 for his amazing accomplishments in the world of amateur bowling. He is also the only man on record to have pitched back-to-back no hitters in the Veterans Stadium Wiffle Ball League of 2003.