10 Ridiculous Wrestling Gimmicks Which Are Actually TRUE

Jimmy Hart versions of themselves.

Paul Bear Mortuary
WWE/William Moody

Did you know professional wrestling is fake? It has been said, and continues to be said, mostly in the intros to national newspaper puff-pieces begrudgingly ground out by put-upon reporters on assignment, as if they are revealing some earth-shattering scoop.

OK, yes: we know: it's not all fake. The bumps are real, the risks are real, and perhaps crucially, the pathos - although technically artificial - is real. But for the most part, wrestling really is as phony as hot dog meat. And, when we were once expected to buy into characters as outlandish as voodoo practitioners, evil employees of the Inland Revenue Service (is there another kind?) and anything Ed Leslie was doing, more often than not it was more fun when we didn't know how said sausage 'meat' was made.

Sometimes though, the sausage is made from actual, er, sausage. Despite all logical assumptions to the contrary, a number of wrestling's most ridiculous characters are, unlike this lot, ground from 100% reality. Did you know, for example, that Brock Lesnar was really an MMA fighter? And that Bret Hart, who played the best professional wrestler of all time, was in fact the best professional wrestler of all time?

You probably did. But perhaps you didn't realise these silly gimmicks were actually nothing but.

10. Thurman 'Sparky' Plugg

Bob Holly Racing driver
Twitter, @TheBobHolly

Bob Holly was a barroom boxer tougher than mutton - you'd have to be to pull off that bleached-blonde look - so obviously, WWE's instinct, when the Smoky Mountain alum re-joined the company outside a jobbing capacity in 1994, was to put him in a race car and call him Thurman 'Sparky' Plugg.

When Holly received paperwork from Titan Towers bearing the above appellation, he was somewhat taken aback, presuming it to be some elaborate rib on the part of old friend Paul Bearer. Nope: Vince wanted Bob to buckle up, owing to the newcomer's past life driving cars competitively.

The surly Californian knew full well that nice guys called Sparky finish last, and unsurprisingly, he asked if he could at least change his name to something a little less terrible. It wasn't all bad though: McMahon gifted Holly with a customised car to go with the gig. Just a shame the idea didn't have much gas in its tank.


9. Big Boss Man

The Big Boss Man
WWE.com

It's a fairly damning indictment on the state of the United States prison system that, when the Big Bossman debuted for WWE in the summer of 1988, fans were perfectly willing to buy into the concept of a corrupt corrections officer wholesale. Armed with his trusty government issue nightstick, the former prison guard would handcuff his beaten foes to the ring ropes, before laying them out with some rough corporal punishment.

What's arguably more alarming is that the man serving this brand of rough justice, Ray Traylor, actually worked as a warden in Cobb County, GA before swapping prison bars for arm bars. Many of the greatest wrestling personas are simply exaggerations of the real-life performer. Hopefully, for the sake of those poor inmates down south, that wasn't the case with the Bossman.


8. Paul Bearer

Percy Pringle Mortuary
William Moody

When Alabama mouthpiece William Moody walked into Vince McMahon's office about potential employment in 1990, he'd already been directing heels in the business for the better part of the past 16 years, save a brief hiatus following the birth of his son. It was that family sabbatical - and not his years of experience in the industry - which would inform his defining role.

Moody was recommended to WWE by his WCCW pal and former charge Rick Rude, though his usual moniker 'Percy Pringle III' wasn't an ideal match for McMahon's newest creation, the ghostly Undertaker. Luckily for the veteran manager, he told his prospective new boss that, during his time off, he'd became a qualified embalmer and mortician.

The deal was sealed; from that point, he'd trail the undead Mark Calaway as the ghoulish Paul Bearer - a pun oddly pitched by Road Warrior Hawk. It's hard to believe that, of all the outlandish gimmicks in early-'90s WWE, The Undertaker's was one at least partially dug up from reality.


7. General Adnan

General Adnan Saddam Hussein
Public Domain

Though it was patently ludicrous that US military hero Sergeant Slaughter and Iranian jingoist The Iron Sheik - tacitly repackaged as 'Colonel Mustafa' - would swap army fatigues as Saddam Hussein supporters during the former's ill-conceived and incredibly distasteful WrestleMania VII run in 1991, their Ba'athist buddy General Adnan's gimmick was arguably less realistic than the truth.

That Adnan was born in Baghdad, Iraq, already distinguished him from the vast majority of foreign wrestling menaces, in that he actually hailed from his supposed country of malevolence. But things went further. Though Slaughter's outranking Arabic mouthpiece wasn't quite a general in Saddam's army, he was an old school friend of the deceased dictator.

In fact, Hussein himself had asked his former classmate to bring wrestling to Iraq in the '70s; as the Iraqi leader's paranoia increased following his political ascension, he began to see the popular Adnan as a rival, and the latter fled the country of his birth for good. No wonder he was vocally flying the flag for his old pal years later.


6. The Maestro

Maestro Wcw
WWE.com

Although he was the grand-nephew (yes, that's a thing) of industry changer Gorgeous George, Robert Kellum was restricted from trading on his own legacy during his late-'90s WCW run, owing to Randy Savage's bizarre insistence his valet take the name of his wrestling idol. There was no arguing with the Macho Man - or, specifically, his creative control clause - and so the Smoky Mountain alumni brainstormed with Eric Bischoff to devise something else.

They landed on The Maestro, a gimmick which saw Kellum don a cape and wave a conductor's baton around, whilst his own valet Symphony (Alicia Webb, better known as Ryan Shamrock) hung off his arm. The idea was composed out of Kellum's legitimate musical theatre background; a trained pianist, he'd previously starred in Shakespearean productions including Macbeth and Hamlet, and reckoned the road to stardom lied in becoming an evil opera impresario.

Unfortunately, it didn't see him hit any high notes; he mostly exchanged victories with Ernest Miller before his contract expired in early 2000, after which the curtain fell on The Maestro. No encores.


5. Dean Douglas

Dean Douglas
WWE Network

In 1995, Troy Martin - better known by his ring alias Shane Douglas - had the wrestling world at his feet. The Pennsylvanian native had shirked off being a decidedly uncool WCW dude to effectively establish Paul Heyman's brazen, trend-setting vision of ECW, famously - or infamously, depending on your persuasion - denigrating the NWA belt and everything the historic organisation stood for. Duly, the nationals which had wasted him so badly before beckoned once more.

Superstardom didn't follow; The Franchise cashed-in on a WWE move, only to quickly find himself stuck in WWE detention, lumbered with the moribund 'Dean' Douglas gimmick - a wrestling teacher who would disparagingly assess his fellow performers.

Like many before him, Douglas made the crucial mistake of letting Vince in on his background. Knowing there were no guarantees in wrestling, Martin had obtained a teaching qualification from Geneva College, and it was this, not his apparently irrelevant wrestling acumen, that the WWE honcho immediately honed in on.

Although the 'Board of Education' - a paddle he'd spank opponents with - was inspired, the 'Dean' schtick unsurprisingly failed to make the grade. Still, Douglas theoretically had everything in his locker to make a terrible idea work. Unfortunately, how to gain the approval of a rival backstage faction, hellbent on your failure, was one thing that couldn't be taught.


4. Clarence Mason

clarence mason
WWE.com

At first glance, Jim Cornette's legal counsel Clarence Mason seems like a broad and obvious parody on Johnny Cochran, the attorney at the centre of the O.J. Simpson trial. That's because it was. The case was still ongoing at the time the character was introduced, WWE typically indelicate with their current affairs commentary.

Clarence Mason was clearly rendered in the broadest strokes possible then, but WWE put a surprising amount of work into such a seemingly one-note gimmick. His name was a semi-subtle play on lawyers both factual and fictional - Clarence Darrow and Perry Mason respectively - whilst he hailed from Sioux City. Even the man who played him, Florida hopeful Herman Stevens, was a one-time prospective attorney, who'd decided sports-entertainment suited him better than courts-entertainment. When veteran Ernie Ladd nabbed him a screening with Vince McMahon, Stevens earned the opportunity to combine both.

Mason was latterly associated with the Nation of Domination, though he left the company after growing uncomfortable with the racial tone of the faction's storylines. He wound up performing a similar role in WCW. After all that 'practice' in the wrestling industry, Mason now practices law for real.


3. T.L. Hopper

TL Hopper
WWE.com

WWE really plumbed the depths of desperation for something - anything - to get bored kids back onside with their outdated brand of sports entertainment in the mid-'90s, and they dredged up an absolute stinker in the form of wrestling plumber T.L. Hopper.

Another crap gimmick straight from the New Generation toilet, but believe it or not, unlike The Goon or Mantaur, this wasn't entirely one of Vince McMahon's whims. Dusty Rhodes famously fashioned himself into a working class hero based on his background as a 'son of a plumber', and Hopper's father also made U-bends meet to make ends meet. Except the man behind the plunger, Tony Anthony, thought The American Dream's story was "a bunch of garbage"; his father really was a plumber, and he too, could have been a blue-collar champion.

He wasn't. In fact, he wasn't even transformed into yet another Dusty Rhodes rib - some small wonder given his origin story. Instead, McMahon went as obvious as possible, and wrestling plumber it was.


2. Jimmy Hart

jimmy hart
WWE.com

When Honky Tonk Man turned his Elvis evil following a landslide fan vote in 1986, the in situ Jimmy Hart was immediately installed as his manager. There couldn't have been a more perfect fit to play the tribute 'King's Colonel Tom Parker; not only was the 'Mouth of the South' in the habit of decking himself out in musically-themed polyester, boasting loud note motifs and piano key lapels, but he was already billed from Memphis, Tennessee.

What's more, this sensible appointment wasn't simply superficial. The megaphone-wielding manager was no mega-phony; before entering the wrestling industry, Hart was the leading man in a rock 'n' roll troupe known as The Gentrys. Whilst Hart couldn't fire Rhythm and Blues' 'Hunka Hunka Hunka Honky Love' up the charts, his own band was a brief sensation, shake, rattling and rolling their way to over a million records sold with bopper Keep On Dancing.

The motormouth from Memphis (actually Mississippi) put his musical background to good use behind the scenes too, notably composing the themes of Shawn Michaels and Dusty Rhodes. Several years after Hart's time with Honky, WCW introduced their own Tom Parker knock-off in the form of Colonel. Robert Parker. Did they pair him with their own ersatz Elvis? Nope: he was bizarrely stuck with Steve Austin, of all people.


1. Dr. Britt Baker

Britt Baker Remix
Remix Pro Wrestling

When Jerry 'The King' Lawler drafted his personal dentist Isaac Yankem DDS - Kane in a smock - as foil for perpetual rival Bret Hart in 1995, many more discerning children quite rightly asked why a man who could reasonably expect to make upwards of $100,000 per year was diverting his attention to then less-than-glamorous climes of WWE. Presumably, he was in it to indulge the inner sadism inherent in all dental drillers.

A similarly logical question is why, given how crap the gimmick was, have supposedly game-changing AEW chosen to repeat it with their future superstar Dr. Britt Baker, dentist at arms? The answer to this one is much simpler: when she isn't pulling limbs, Baker is pulling teeth for real at her dental practice in Winter Park, FL. The question why she balances this lucrative career with wrestling remains. Tony Khan's sugar might be answer - even if she is professionally disapproving.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Paul Bearer
 
First Posted On: 
Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.