10 Risks That Could’ve KILLED WWE Careers

These WWE stars could've ruined EVERYTHING by risking it all, but they survived.

Becky Lynch Seth Rollins Risk
WWE

Every gimmick change, heel/babyface turn or new direction is a risk to WWE success. What if fans outright reject what they're being fed and it has a terminal impact on someone's career? What if the wrestler sprinting down this bold new path enters halfhearted performances because even they don't really believe in what they're doing?

There's a lot to think about here. Wrestling fans, bless 'em, are a fickle bunch who often take a lot of winning over when something new is plonked on their laps. That's not someone throwing stones - this writer is the same, and he was there bleating to friends about some of these risks when they happened.

At least everything worked out well in the end, eh?

Every worker here has carved a legacy for themselves in some form or fashion. Some are still smack bang in the middle of it, whilst others can put the slippers on, fetch a pipe and reminisce about days of yore. Oh yes, these were definitely risks worth taking, because they redefined careers.

Not everyone looked at things that way back when WWE took the plunge though. Some even thought careers were ruined forever...

10. Kofi Kingston Ties Himself Down

New Day Debut
WWE

This is a sneaky one for starters that you might not even think about.

By 2014, Kofi Kingston was already a made man in WWE's scene. No, he wasn't a World Title-winning top liner, but he was a stalwart of the midcard and that wasn't going to change. Yearning for something different, Kingston tied himself to younger stars like Big E and Xavier Woods, and New Day was born.

That was one hell of a risk for Kofi. Woods and E weren't exactly household names in the company, and there was a general feeling that Kingston was lowering himself somewhat to form a faction with them. Of course, as the history books show, Kofi was absolutely right to make this move and form the group he did.

The pressure was on Kingston - more than people might realise. Had New Day flopped hard (which was kinda expected at the time), then he would've shouldered the blame and probably been cut free alongside his new pals eventually. Kofi should be praised for going out of his comfort zone and elevating fresh names in the process.


9. LA Knight Agrees To Become Max Dupri

Max Dupri
WWE

You'd be forgiven for sitting there thinking, '...but what else was this guy gonna do?'. That's fair, 'cause NXT's LA Knight couldn't exactly look main roster management in the eye and say, 'Nah, I'm staying put' when they offered to call him up under a new gimmick. So, Max Dupri was born, but not for too long.

Knight clearly detested the new guise, but he was willing to suffer temporarily then show everyone what he was capable of down the line. His brief stay as head of Maximum Male Models convinced no-one, but it did enable LA to showcase his dynamic personality in front of the cameras here or there.

Once WWE's writers lost interest in MMM (say it out loud), Knight knew it was his time to strike. His risk had paid off when it easily could've wrecked his company dreams for good. Now, his LA Knight persona is so engaging that hardly anyone even brings up Dupri at all.

Good riddance, Max.


8. Bayley Changes…Everything!

Bayley 2019
WWE.com

Fans had turned on Bayley's 'girl next door' act long before she cut her hair, popped her inflatable tube men "buddies" and started acting ice cold. WWE had gone for the sympathy vote mid-injury, but Bayley's babyface promo was a painful (and harsh) lesson to her: She needed change.

That change was nonetheless risky.

There was always a chance crowds might've barked, 'We wanted change...but not like that!' at WWE creative and turned their backs on Bayley as a character forever. Instead, something remarkable happened. Her confidence grew, and she exhibited some of the same swagger Becky Lynch had when she went from smiling baby to nWo cool renegade the prior year.

Looking back, all WWE did was turn Bayley into a more generic women's wrestler than she'd been before. However, by cutting back on the add-ons like her side ponytail, the "Bayley buddies" and sickeningly sweet, almost apologetic promos, the promotion rescued Bayley from creative no-man's land.


7. Booker T Embraces “King Bookah”

King Booker T
WWE.com

Ask fans of a certain vintage if 'King' gimmicks work and they'll reply that they only grooved for Jerry Lawler and Randy Savage. 'King' Harley Race? Pah! 'King' Haku? Get out of here. 'King' Sheamus? Behave. 'King' Barrett? That was the pits. So, what made Booker T's run under the royal gimmick so great?

Him. Well, him and 'Queen' Sharmell.

Both embraced the goofiness of the royal persona so heartily that it was impossible to avoid being charmed. Think about this though; Booker was already a multi-time World Champion by the time he donned the crown and robe. This wasn't an introductory character, but instead a complete retooling of somebody who had worked as both heel and face.

It could've bombed spectacularly, and yet people still talk about "King Bookah" fondly in 2024. There's a reason for that. Booker and Sharmell were all in, and they played their roles with a knowing silliness. They didn't try to sell people on seriousness, which helped avert career suicide.


6. Kane Unmasks

Kane unmasked
WWE.com

Kane was only ever meant to be a short-lived rival for The Undertaker in 1997-1998. Incredibly, the character survived post-WrestleMania XIV loss and successfully carved a niche for itself on the roster. Big Glenn Jacobs kept Kane alive as full time concern until 2016-ish. That's when he became more of a part-timer and cameo attraction.

Who knew the 'Big Red Machine' would get that far once he unmasked for the first time in 2003? Look above to see how outright naff his "burns" and "scars" were. Also, this was the first time folks realised that hair was attached to the hood, not Glenn's head. There was so much about this reveal that could've gone south in a hurry.

Instead, it added a fresh wrinkle to the character and prolonged Kane's shelf life.

Eventually, he stuck the mask back on in 2011 and rolled into more major matches from there. Taking the mask off in the first place was a monumental risk, and it might've ended Kane's initial run with a popcorn fart.


5. ‘The Man’ Shows Her Softer Side

Becky Lynch Seth Rollins
WWE.com

WWE did a p*ss poor job of presenting Seth Rollins as a likeable babyface in 2019. Worse, the then-Universal Champ threatened to derail what Becky Lynch was doing over in the women's division. Both started a real-life relationship, which is sweet and led to the birth of their beautiful baby daughter, but it didn't click on screen.

Becky had rocketed to the top of cards as 'The Man'. Fans adored her 'Stone Cold' style mannerisms and general badass behaviour, so it was a bit of a departure when she and Seth suddenly started acting like high school sweethearts during pay-per-view main events.

It didn't work for either of them. If anything, the romance stuff hindered their respective runs and unpicked progress WWE had made with Lynch. She didn't headline WrestleMania by smacking Seth on the arse, put it that way. Becks headlined because she was one of the most believably rebellious characters in years.

Thank God this was temporary and only existed to get WWE through a few PPVs.


4. Mankind Is Dude Love

Dude Love
www.wwe.com

It's easy to forget that Mick Foley introduced the world to Dude Love just one year after debuting as Mankind in the summer of 1996. Yes, one year. That isn't really enough time for somebody to cement themselves as a Teflon type who could withstand serious creative wobbles, is it?

Foley was a unique cat, to be fair. Viewers were immediately swept up in Dude fever, and everyone loved the way Mick was showing off his childlike love of wrestling on the biggest stage. It's perhaps only Mick's endearing qualities and his prior work as Mankind that made the Dude Love spin off tolerable.

This would not have flown as a first gimmick in the WWF, let's be real.

Foley was taking a colossal risk by temp-shelving the grittier Mankind guise in favour of a colourful 1970s-inspired hippie. Imagine WWE tried this today with someone like Kevin Owens. It seems impossible, but Mick somehow pulled off his outrageous alter ego.


3. The Rock Goes Heel Again Instantly!

the rock mankind survivor series 1998
WWE.com

Fire up WWE Network/Peacock (whilst you can!) and check out the oft-forgotten Breakdown pay-per-view from September 1998. There, fans boomed with cheers for everything The Rock did, and even popped harder for him than Mankind or Ken Shamrock. It was pretty clear the WWF had a hot babyface on their hands.

Or not.

People were firmly in Rocky's corner come Survivor Series '98 and a tournament to crown the new WWF Champ. Then, the company pulled a swerve and had Rock become Vince McMahon's "Corporate Champion". His fledgling babyface fire was doused with a bucket of freezing cold water, and The Rock was heel once more.

In retrospect, that could have screwed up his career trajectory. After all, crowds had only just started to come on board with him following another failed babyface attempt in 1997. In short, pulling the rug out from underneath fans right as they embraced Rocky was a risky move that could've backfired.


2. Dustin Rhodes Becomes Goldust

Goldust Debut
WWE.com

The world wasn't really ready for a wrestling gimmick like Goldust in 1995. His outlandish mix of vintage Hollywood and androgynous presentation was shocking at the time, but it's regrettable that the WWF quickly leaned into homophobia as a cheap heat-seeker rather than going another route with him.

Simply donning the gold paints/gold suit and shock blonde wig was a radical departure for one Dustin Rhodes anyway. If this was him trying to escape the shadow of his father Dusty and do his own thing, then he was certainly going extreme. Few gave Goldust a shot at lasting longer than a few months.

Fast forward to 2024 and Dustin would get a mega-pop if he returned to WWE as Goldie.

Back in '95, Rhodes was coming off a respectable run in WCW. Becoming Vince McMahon's latest cartoon gimmick (one more overtly cartoonish than his dad's polka dots run) was a big time risk, but it paid off in the end and sustained even through some serious personal strife.


1. The Undertaker Goes Biker

The Undertaker Bike
WWE

Older wrestling fans are still digesting the fact The f'n Undertaker is a YouTuber in 2024. Not many predicted that one, but 'Taker is having a quite smashing time lifting the lid on his iconic career and biggest moments. Via his channel, 'The Deadman' revealed just how much pressure he was under backstage at Judgment Day 2000.

A lot of his peers thought ditching the supernatural vibes of the character and turning into a tough guy biker was a massive mistake. 'Taker was about to re-debut as a more realistic version of his beloved gimmick, and his stomach was churning before riding that motorcycle to the ring during a main event 'Iron Man' classic between Triple H and The Rock.

What if this...wasn't what WWF fans wanted to see?

Had people rejected the 'American Badass' idea, then Undertaker would've had to disappear all over again and revert to type. He didn't want to do that, but nobody behind the curtain was filling him full of confidence that switching things up was the right course of action.

They were wrong. Dead(man) wrong.

What other huge risks could've ruined WWE careers? For more wrestling, check out 10 Amazing Wrestlers Who HUMILIATED Themselves At WWE WrestleMania and 10 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Terry Gordy! 


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.