10 Secret Conversations That Changed Wrestling History Forever

Nothing was ever the same again.

Vince McMahon WrestleMania
WWE.com

Take a second to imagine how different pro wrestling could be.

WWE sit atop the wealth mountain right now, but that might not be the case had certain decisions been made and others not been made. In some far off parallel universe, WCW might be wrestling's top dog, ECW could be second, or Vince McMahon might be polishing boots for Tony Khan during Jacksonville Jaguars practices.

OK, that might be stretching things a bit far, but the possibilities are pretty endless. All it took for McMahon to reign supreme were a series of conversations that helped re-shape the industry forever, and it sounds so simple when worded that way. That's also true for various other major figures, promotions and wrestlers inside the wrasslin' sphere - things could be so very different.

Details from these convos didn't come out until after they happened and actions had been taken. That's what makes this so compelling; imagine being the proverbial fly on the wall for some of these chats. Eyes would widen, jaws would drop, and you'd probably become the go-to guru for wrestling prediction articles forever more.

Forever. Now there's a word...


10. Cody & The Bucks Discuss Dave Meltzer's Words

Cody Rhodes AEW
AEW

Wrestling Observer chief Dave Meltzer couldn't have known the flames he was fanning when he wrote in his newsletter that ROH would never shift 10,000 tickets for any of their shows. That, according to Cody Rhodes and The Young Bucks, got the friends (who all worked for the company) talking.

That led to the birth of AEW.

The threesome produced their own 'All In' event on 1 September 2018 first, of course, and the success of that made Meltzer eat his words. No, ROH hadn't shifted 10,000 briefs, but some of the group's top talents had, and that must've felt great. After that, Cody and The Bucks pondered more. That's when Tony Khan and family came into the picture.

Who knows if All Elite would even be a thing had Meltzer not fired out an accidental challenge to guys who were hungry to prove him wrong? There is a chance that Cody, The Bucks or a combo of indy workers might've tried running their own company, but shooting the sh*t about Dave's comments led to bigger things.


9. "We're Starting On Top Of The Cell"

Mankind The Undertaker Hell In A Cell
WWE.com

Bruce Prichard was appalled when he heard from Mick Foley that he and The Undertaker planned to start their Hell In A Cell stunt show on top of the cage. That was breaking new ground for the match type, and Prichard wondered if it'd ruin the entire point of having a roofed structure in the first place.

Foley didn't care. He had something huge in mind.

That passive conversation with one of the WWF's top creative minds changed the course of HIAC history for good. After Mick's huge bumps off and through (the latter of which was something he hadn't planned) the cage, fans expected massive stunts whenever the gimmick was scheduled.

When was the last truly great Cell match? It's an interesting question, because most today can't hope to live up to or top what 'Taker and Mankind achieved at King Of The Ring 1998. That may not be the case had they not agreed to start on top.


8. Bret Hart Talks To WCW (In 1992)

Bret Hart IC Champ
WWE.com

Bret Hart bagged his first WWF World Title from Ric Flair on 12 October 1992. Before that, he was secretly negotiating with WCW about jumping over to work there, but couldn't come to an agreement on money with then-senior management Jim Barnett.

Barnett actually told the 'Hitman' to stay put over the phone.

Although Hart was the reigning Intercontinental Champion at the time these talks took place, he wasn't sure how seriously Vince McMahon would take him as a headliner. In fact, Bret wasn't even sure Vince viewed him as someone deserving of a push at all. He was willing to take more money in WCW and try his luck there.

Barnett stepped in to dismiss what others in WCW were telling the Canadian; they couldn't pay him the cash he was looking for, and that changed Hart's mind. He decided to stay in the WWF - Vince told him he'd be champ later that year.


7. The Undertaker Tells Vince McMahon He's "Done"

The Undertaker Vince McMahon
WWE Network

On WWE's recent 'Last Ride' documentary series, The Undertaker was shown chatting with Vince McMahon after his tag-team match at Extreme Rules 2019. Despite being pleased with how the bout had gone, 'Taker suddenly told his gaffer that he was "done" and would probably be hanging up the tights.

McMahon told him, "I will follow your lead".

Extreme Rules didn't end up being The Undertaker's final match, but it was a sign that the icon was mentally prepared to call it a career almost 30 years deep. He'd wrestle one more time, in a cinematic 'Boneyard' brawl against AJ Styles at WrestleMania 36, before announcing on the doc's finale that he was retiring.

As The Usos and The Revival worked a tag match out in the ring, 'Taker told Vince behind the curtain at Gorilla that he was likely moving on from this chapter of his life. Nobody knew that conversation had taken place at the time aside from them and the camera crew.


6. Ted Turner Gives Eric Bischoff Monday Nights

Monday Nitro
WWE Best Of Monday Nitro DVD

In mid-1995, Eric Bischoff strolled nervously into Ted Turner's office and braced himself for a verbal volley of vitriol. He planned to pitch that WCW programming strike up a deal with China's Star Network. The problem? That network was owned and operated by sworn Turner enemy Rupert Murdoch.

Bisch didn't even get that far into the pitch. After a few minutes of setting the scene, Ted interrupted him and boldly asked, 'What do we need to do to compete with Vince McMahon?'. Stunned by the question, Eric blurted out that he needed to go head-to-head with him.

That's when Turner told his executives to give WCW two prime time hours every Monday night.

Boom! Nitro was born, and it'd eventually debut that September. Bischoff didn't divulge details on this face-to-face with Ted until years later, but he recognises how pivotal it was in changing the wrestling landscape forever. The 'Monday Night Wars' had begun.


5. Eric Bischoff Convinces Hulk Hogan To Turn Heel

Hulk Hogan Heel Nwo
WWE.com

1995 was notable for another reason too.

Towards the end of the year, Bischoff started talking to Hulk Hogan about the possibility of freshening up his act and trying something different. By 1996, polite talks had switched into full-blown pitches for Hogan to turn heel. Eric had the perfect gig for him: Hulk would be the leader of the new heel faction known as the New World Order.

Whilst all this was going on behind the scenes, Hogan continued playing his classic babyface character in front of fans. Few knew what the real plan was, or that Hulk was pacing around his house wondering if going rogue might destroy everything he had built since the mid-'80s. This was the hardest decision he had ever been asked to make.

Bischoff got his way at the 11th hour when Hogan finally made up his mind and agreed to become the nWo's focal point. His heel turn shook the foundations of WCW (as well as the entire wrestling industry), prolonged Hulk's career and helped the company become number one.


4. Jamie Kellner Cancels WCW Programming

Vince McMahon WCW Nitro
WWE

It wasn't Hulk Hogan, Eric Bischoff or even Ted Turner who made the biggest call in WCW's history though - it was a television executive nobody had even heard of. Jamie Kellner was the one who decided that company programming would no longer air on Turner's own networks in 2001.

Without TV, the company was effectively defunct.

Kellner's move opened the door for Vince McMahon to purchase the remnants of a promotion that had once kicked his ass all over the United States. For the paltry sum of $2.5 million, McMahon received WCW's tape library, numerous trademarks and over 20 talent contracts he could use to bolster the ranks on his own shows.

A random board meeting amongst Turner top brass altered the course of wrestling history for good. WCW didn't mean much to Kellner or his associates (it arguably never did), and they were sick and tired of the money pit it had become. So, they put a pen through it and moved on.


3. Howard Finkel Names WrestleMania

Wrestlemania 1
WWE

The brand name WrestleMania has become synonymous with pomp, circumstance, an endless explosion of fireworks and excitement. It's by far the biggest show on WWE's calendar every single year, and it still commands attention even when recent real-world events meant running stadiums would be impossible.

It's hard to see it still being around as a respected thriller had original plans to call the show 'The Colossal Tussle' prevailed. That, believe it or not, was the first name proposed for 'Mania, and it didn't change until someone said something to the effect of, 'Erm... that sucks. How about calling it WrestleMania instead?'.

That 'someone' was Howard Finkel.

Bruce Prichard once revealed on his podcast that the 'Fink' was the one who named WWE's iconic annual masterpiece. Without his intervention and willingness to speak up one day, Vince McMahon might've went with 'The Colossal Tussle', and yours truly wouldn't be writing about wrestling.


2. The Plan To Screw Bret Hart

Bret Hart Montreal Screwjob
WWE.com

This one wouldn't have happened had Bret bolted to WCW back in 1992.

He didn't though, and instead went on to become a linchpin of the WWF's main event mix. Hart's influence would grow to the extent that he was one of Vince McMahon's most trusted lieutenants. Then, Vince reneged on a bumper new deal with Bret, said he couldn't afford it, and that p*ssed Hart off to the point that he decided WCW's money should be his.

At that point, things turned ugly. Bret, who had a fractured relationship with Shawn Michaels, told Vince he wouldn't drop the WWF Title to him in Canada. That worried McMahon, because it meant Hart could theoretically appear on WCW TV with his top title. He couldn't let that happen, so he called a meeting.

Vince, Michaels, Triple H and possibly a few others conspired to screw Hart out of the belt at Survivor Series 1997. Yes, the 'Screwjob' has been chronicled endlessly, but it deserves a spot on this list. The secret conversations Vince had with HBK and others pushed Hart out, birthed the Mr. McMahon character and had a huge knock on effect generally.


1. Vince McMahon Sr Sells To His Son

Vince McMahon Hulk Hogan
WWE.com

Vince McMahon Jr (he reportedly hates the junior tag, but it's necessary here) founded Titan Sports in 1980. Two years later, he acquired the World Wrestling Federation from his father and set about ruthlessly expanding throughout the US, and eventually globally, over the next decade.

There had to be that first conversation between father and son about Vince Jr assuming control of the entire company, and that had to be a proud day for the man known today as wrestling's single most powerful figure. Vince Sr could not have known back in 1982 that his boy would ignore traditions, break new ground and revolutionise the pro wrestling industry.

There's a chance Sr might not have given Jr complete power had he known the extent of his plans. Vince the younger wanted to monopolise, and he didn't care who he had to trample over to get there. That was the way it was - he smelled opportunity, and he was going to grasp it regardless of what anyone said.

Who knows how different things would be had Sr said, 'No chance in hell, son' and sold up to someone else.

-

What other private conversations changed wrestling history forever? For more like this, check out 10 Mistakes That Actually Enhanced WWE Matches and 10 Most Disappointing WWE Moments Of 2020 (So Far)!


Watch Next


 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.