10 Shocking Royal Rumble Plans WWE Originally Had
Forks in the road (to WrestleMania).
God bless the good name of Pat Patterson.
Without his spark of creativity, there wouldn't even be a Royal Rumble to enjoy each January. His late-80s genius feeds neatly into the ever-shifting creative face of what has become known as WWE's kick off on the 'Road To WrestleMania' for generations. Deciding exactly who will win each Rumble match, and how the show will be hyped as important to the coming springtime spectacular, has become an annual headache for the company.
It's perhaps no surprise then to learn that WWE change their minds often when it comes to the pay-per-view's biggest moments. Everyone knows what actually happened, but what about those plans that were originally penciled in before being consigned to the creative dustbin? They're often shocking, and they should send minds racing about what might've been had it not been for last-minute changes of heart, injuries and more.
Various Rumble cards from down throughout the years very nearly had stunning debuts, alternate winners, big 'Mania-affecting title switches, unique storylines and heel turns that would've changed everything. You won't believe how different things could've been...
10. Calling An Audible (2016)
Remember 2016's Rumble when then-Champ Roman Reigns entered? WWE don't want you to, because they'd like everyone to believe that Brock Lesnar's 2020 inclusion is original.
Speaking of original, what happened back at the end of 2K16's Rumble wasn't in the initial script. Triple H, who came out as #30 and eventually won the match, tossed Roman over the top rope before tangling with Dean Ambrose for the decision. That, according to reports at the time, wasn't WWE's plan at the start of the night.
Instead, Reigns and Trips were supposed to be the final two. As legend has it, officials backstage were left dismayed by cold reactions to Roman during the Rumble, and they called an audible to have him ousted and replaced by Ambrose when it came down to a straight, one-on-one shootout.
Maybe WWE were still reeling from the scorching boos Roman had received for winning the Rumble 12 months earlier in Philadelphia. Keep in mind that Reigns was being presented as a hero of the people and an underdog against The Authority. Ending the night with cheers for Triple H wouldn't have furthered that story.
9. The Perfect Winner (1990)
Hogan must pose.
That mantra, one furthered by Bruce Prichard's podcast and his impressions of Vince McMahon, has become familiar. It's surely what was running through McMahon's brain when he decided to scrap one writer's suggestion that someone other than Hulk win the 1990 Rumble.
Prichard has admitted that Mr. Perfect was in the running to win the thing. Back in '90, he was in the midst of an unbeaten streak that wouldn't technically end until he fell to Brutus Beefcake at WrestleMania VI. Buoyed by that winning run, he'd have been a fine heel choice to win the Rumble and keep such success in his back pocket for a summer run at soon-to-be WWF Champion The Ultimate Warrior's gold.
Vince said sod that and booked Hogan to win so he could grin, pose and celebrate along with the live crowd as the show went off the air; some have reasoned that Hulk winning made sense due to his upcoming 'Ultimate Challenge' match with Warrior. That's invalid, because the match could've happened without the Rumble result.
8. Braun Beats The Beast (2019)
Last year's Rumble was notable for a Seth Rollins' victory that set him on the path towards facing then-Universal Champion Brock Lesnar at 'Mania 35. According to WrestleVotes (reported via The Mix), that wasn't the first thing Vince McMahon and his writers thought of when sitting down to plan out the 2019 Rumble card.
They liked the sound of Braun Strowman toppling Brock.
Had that happened, then reports claim that Drew McIntyre was lined up to win the men's Rumble, not Rollins. Then, at WrestleMania, he would've been the one clashing with Strowman for the belt, and WWE would take things from there. Obviously, none of that happened, plans changed and McMahon went with the rather random pairing of Lesnar vs. Finn Bálor instead.
Braun's title glory (as it typically is) was put on ice yet again. On Raw, Vince himself appeared to cancel the planned bout after some "BRAUN SMASH" shenanigans and hastily arranged a Fatal-4-Way to establish a new challenger.
7. Scott Steiner's Solo Success (1993)
Consider this one 'Royal Rumble 1993: Rise Of The Genetic Mullet'.
It's another from WWE creative man Bruce Prichard. Back in the mid-90s, he was one of McMahon's closest confidants, and he was trusted to write most of the promotion's TV output with fellow wizard (and Rumble royalty) Pat Patterson. Together, they had quite the idea for the '93 event.
Bruce loved the thought of tag star Scott Steiner becoming a standout solo sensation during the match and somehow managing to upset the odds by going all the way. The plan was for Steiner to showcase himself by pulling off flashy suplexes before possibly becoming WWF Champion at WrestleMania IX.
It was a plan Vinnie Mac wasn't fond of, and that was that. He wanted towering heel Yokozuna to win the Rumble and become champion at 'Mania in Las Vegas, not anyone else. Any hopes Prichard and Patterson had of watching the super-athletic Steiner become an overnight smash hit went up in smoke.
6. The Free For All Rumble (1997)
The 1997 Rumble wasn't visually reflective of dwindling federation business when the WWF papered enough to fill just over 60,000 seats inside the huge Alamodome. Ratings and live attendance were struggling, and that's why the USA Network suggested airing the 30-man match for free after the fact on the 3 February episode of Raw.
The Wrestling Observer claimed that USA wanted to ease the ratings plight by popping a massive rating during a period of uncertainty for the Monday night flagship. It had worked before when the 1988 Rumble earned a huge 8.2 score on TV, so why wouldn't it work again nine years later?
Pay-per-view providers who had paid for the rights to air the Rumble were aghast at the thought of this. They nixed the chances of it happening, and the WWF aired select matches from a Toronto house show on Raw instead of showing Steve Austin's sneaky victory and Bret Hart's tantrum free of charge.
Spoilsports, but understandable spoilsports.
5. John Cena Must Choose (2012)
Anyone who sat through Sheamus' first babyface run must've been sighing with relief when he clobbered Shorty G recently on SmackDown and re-established himself as a heel. It blatantly sucked when WWE sampled Sheamus as a face back in 2012-2013. Still, at least he got a Royal Rumble win out of it.
One that almost never happened.
Dave Meltzer reported in The Observer shortly after the 2012 Rumble that John Cena was originally supposed to win the match then choose between wrestling for the WWE Title or confronting The Rock at WrestleMania XXVIII. That, if nothing else, would've been a uniquely engaging story the promotion could've told on TV between the Rumble-'Mania.
Another plan called for Randy Orton to emerge as the Rumble winner in his hometown of St. Louis. In the end, WWE went with Sheamus (hey, points for originality count), put him over Daniel Bryan in 18 seconds and booked Cena vs. Rock without a title on the line.
4. Batista Gets The Edge (2010)
It's impossible to picture anyone other than Edge winning the 2010 Rumble. He'd been out with injuries since the prior summer and was the kind of comeback king Rumbles occasionally need to feel over-the-top and special. Here's the thing: Edge wouldn't have won it without Chris Jericho's influence.
Batista, meanwhile, would have.
Jericho pitched a story that'd see him and ex-(fleeting) tag partner Edge collide at WrestleMania XXVI, and he believed the story needed some extra juice. That's why he suggested having Edge win the Rumble, Jericho himself relieving The Undertaker of the World Heavyweight Title at Elimination Chamber and then putting both Canadians together at 'Mania.
Voilà, WWE would have a ready-made World Title showdown between old friends and the 'Taker vs. Shawn Michaels 'Streak vs. Career' stipulation wouldn't be bogged down by unnecessary championship implications on the side. Just like that, Batista was out and Edge was in.
3. It's Sabu (1996)
Unlike the logic of that previous entry, it is difficult to think back to the mid-90s and see ECW madman Sabu running riot over the Royal Rumble as that cartoonish WWF logo proudly trumpeted family friendly action in the bottom corner of the screen. Even so, he was going to be part of the 1996 event at one stage.
"At one stage".
Prichard (an absolute bastion of cancelled Rumble-related story gems) did say on his 'Something To Wrestle With' podcast once that talks were held between Sabu and the WWF about a Rumble berth. The battle-scarred extremist did agree to a one-off appearance, but only if he could eliminate himself to maintain his carefully-constructed aura.
Then, Paul Heyman got involved and talked Sabu out of the gig due to fears that the WWF's sickly-sweet presentation would harm any of the 'Homicidal, Suicidal, Genocidal' maniac's appeal in the much-more hardcore ECW going forwards.
No matter, 'cause Barry Horowitz was better anyway, right guys? Guys?
2. The Rock Wins (2019)
The 2019 Rumble has already been examined in this very article, and everyone knows that Seth Rollins won the thing. According to WrestleVotes on Twitter though, he wasn't even the second choice behind Drew McIntyre at first. The burly Scotsman sat snugly behind Hollywood's favourite son.
Yep, The Rock.
The tweet claimed that Rocky was set to win the Royal Rumble match and then set up a title confrontation with Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 35. Plans changed quickly when Reigns announced he was leaving to battle cancer in late-October 2018. That put all talks of Rock vs. Roman on hold until WWE knew for sure that Reigns' health (which came first) was sorted.
Over time, WWE apparently moved away from the thought of The Rock winning the Rumble and started firming up the aforementioned title situation between Braun Strowman and others instead. When that didn't suit, they moved towards Seth Rollins vs. Brock Lesnar for the Universal Title at 'Mania.
1. Heel Stone Cold (2000)
Triple H vs. Cactus Jack at the 2000 Rumble was a tour de force.
Their 'Street Fight' was blood-soaked, drama-filled and one of the best brawls of the era. It's somehow scary then to think that Mick Foley's title shot would've gone to Steve Austin had he not been benched by serious neck woes a few months earlier.
The Wrestling Observer printed news in late-1999 that tentative WrestleMania 2000 plans called for a heel Austin to drop the WWF Title to a babyface Rock. That, it was hoped, would've launched Rocky to the forefront of the promotion and made him 'the guy'. In order to get there, Austin had to best Triple H at the Rumble first.
None of this would come to pass due to Austin's neck surgery. He spent the bulk of 2000 on the shelf before returning as a babyface, and Foley got the nod to face mega-heel Trips at the Rumble; Triple H's upwards trajectory could've been seriously stymied had Austin been around to take the top villain slot that'd eventually belong to him.
What other shocking original plans do you know of from past Royal Rumbles? For more WWE, check out 10 Wrestling Matches That Led To Massive Lawsuits and 10 Things We Learned From Kane On Stone Cold's Broken Skull Sessions Podcast!