10 Shocks WWE Need To Book At Extreme Rules

The summer starts now.

WrestleMania 31 was, contrary to most expectation, a fantastic show. It featured a lot of great matches and legitimate surprises, as well as some truly memorable entrances and nostalgic moments that demonstrated that WWE does go all-out for the biggest show of the year. However, the general trend in WWE is that immediately afterwards, WWE tends to lose momentum and the quality of its shows drops off a bit. Only on rare occasions has the first PPV after WrestleMania been as good as, or better than the Grandest Show of them All. Therefore, in order to keep their positive momentum going, WWE need to make Extreme Rules 2015 as shocking as possible. With the exception of the main event match (which was still great) and a DX vs. NWO confrontation (also great), WrestleMania didn€™t have that many big surprises. Cena still won, Undertaker came out victorious, and most people were able to properly guess the outcomes of virtually every other match. Extreme Rules needs to be full of surprises, from changes in allegiances, to the separation and (re)formation of tag teams, to unexpected run-ins, to violent outbursts. The ten shocks presented in this article don€™t all have to take place at Extreme Rules, but having at least a few of these occurrences would make Extreme Rules that much more memorable of a show. These entries are based off of a combination of expected booking directions WWE will go in, and some wishful thinking on the part of the author. Either way, here€™s hoping for a fantastic Extreme Rules 2015, which should feature some truly shocking moments, such as€

10. Big Show Splits From The Authority

A rift in the Authority has been teased for quite some time, especially with how Kane has been treated in recent weeks. Seth Rollins basically presented Kane as €˜that big guy who doesn€™t really do much€™, and he was berated this past week on RAW to the point that he has teased leaving the Authority. However, if there€™s one person who should leave the Authority instead, it should be the Big Show. It makes sense to keep Kane as part of the Authority because WWE seems hell-bent on perpetuating some kind of authority figure in WWE, and Kane€™s role as €˜Director of Operations€™ (whatever that means) is the only one on the show while Triple H and Stephanie McMahon aren€™t on the show. For Big Show, however, the Authority hasn€™t yielded any particular successes for him. While some might point to his victory in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, that has nothing to do with his association with the powers that be. What he DID gain from allying with the Authority was a huge number of losses (including dozens to Roman Reigns alone), and has truly lost that €˜unstoppable giant€™ presentation he once had. As a sort of twist, Big Show should be the one to split from the Authority instead of Kane, by attacking both the Authority AND whomever they€™re victimizing at Extreme Rules. This doesn€™t necessarily mean turning Show face, because that happens way too often. Instead, Show should only look after himself, and enjoy one last hurrah before retiring. He has done it all in WWE, and finishing his career as a pro-Authority suck-up is not how hit stellar career should end.

9. Luke Harper & Eric Rowan Reunite As A Tag Team

Let€™s be honest here: ever since Eric Rowan and Luke Harper split up from Bray Wyatt, they€™ve floundered as singles competitors. Harper was a pseudo-member of the Authority and enjoyed a brief Intercontinental Championship reign, while Rowan was supposedly given a €˜genius€™ vintner gimmick, but the gimmick was never expanded upon. Since their separation they€™ve faced each other several times with little to no build, and have really lost steam as Superstars. Because of this, it would be shocking, and interesting, to see them reunite and enter the tag team title hunt. With the Usos out of commission for a while, the New Day sloooooowly building momentum, Los Matadores being so low on the card they€™re a comedy gimmick, and the Prime Time Players still a long way from being seen as credible challengers, the Wyatt Family, composed of Harper and Rowan, would be a nice addition to the Tag Team Division. This is especially important considering most of their initial time together was spent serving Bray Wyatt and teaming up against John Cena or Bray€™s other enemies. Harper and Rowan have main event experience; they have been very popular (as demonstrated by the Shield vs. Wyatt Family segments); and they have very good tag team chemistry when working together. On RAW, WWE could announce a multi-team Elimination match for the WWE Tag Team Championships, similar to WrestleMania (because WWE love to repeat match types), only they would leave one of the teams a mystery. Then at Extreme Rules, the final team would come down to the ring as Harper and Rowan, and all the participants would be shocked. In doing so, the tag team division would get two additional faces, and two otherwise floundering mid-carders would have something better to do than win and lose random, pointless matches.

8. A New Paul Heyman Guy

With Brock Lesnar €˜suspended€™ until further notice for his devastating attack on RAW a few weeks ago, Paul Heyman lost his most important client. This makes Paul Heyman essentially useless in terms of storyline development, which is unfortunate when you consider how much of a promo master he really is. So what better way to keep Paul Heyman relevant and on TV than by introducing a new Paul Heyman guy? Last year, Cesaro became a Paul Heyman guy, but tragically, nothing came of it, possibly due to creative indecision. This year would be different, as whomever Heyman offers his services to this time around would benefit from them many times over. This year, Heyman should recruit someone who€™s a heel and Heyman€™s expertise on the microphone would help elevate that person by a significant degree. One option would be for him to pair with the Ascension, a heel tag team that has found little success since leaving NXT. Pairing them with Heyman would give them more legitimacy and Heyman would be able to sell them as more of a threat than they could€™ve done themselves. Another possibility could be Big Show, who, if he splits from the Authority, would need a mouthpiece to talk for him. Plus, he and Heyman have history, which could lead to some good chemistry together. A third option would be either Luke Harper or Eric Rowan, or both of them together as a tag team. Neither one of them is particularly good with promos, despite their intimidating appearances. Once again, with Paul Heyman, he could do all the talking for either one of them or the team, and he would be more than capable of presenting them as a dangerous threat once again. So the general point of this entry is that WWE needs to keep Paul Heyman on screen as much as possible. He€™s the best talker in WWE today, and not using his talents with a microphone to help build more stars for the future would be a simply terrible idea.

7. A Dean Ambrose Heel Turn

Even though he€™s popular as a face, Ambrose€™s career since the break-up of the Shield has hit a wall. Of the three members of that group, he€™s the least successful, and has fallen from arguably the top babyface in the fall of 2014 to that terrible place known as mid-card purgatory. He has lost virtually every major PPV match since the Shield€™s dissolution, he has been without a serious creative direction, and his moniker as €˜the Lunatic Fringe€™ hasn€™t yielded any serious character development or memorable moments, save for a terrible segment involving a Seth Rollins mannequin. Therefore, the best way to save Dean Ambrose would be for him to turn heel. His character definitely works better when he lacks a moral compass, and nothing says €˜Lunatic Fringe€™ like a madman attacking whomever he wants and brutally assaulting whoever gets in his way. One possible direction for him to go in would be to turn heel and attack new U.S. Champion John Cena mercilessly, since Cena defeated him for the title on the RAW after WrestleMania. Ambrose could show a darker side that emphasizes brutality, and attacking Cena would re-elevate him after months of losing and falling down the card, while emphasizing Cena as the €˜fighting champion€™ and adding more value to the title itself. Whatever direction WWE takes Ambrose in going forward, he can€™t stay as a face because he has floundered as one. If he wants to keep his nickname as the €˜Lunatic Fringe€™, he needs to live up to that insinuation and just go crazy and attack people with uncontrollable brutality. It€™s a much better direction than being a stale, smiling babyface with slight lunatic tendencies.

6. A Brock Lesnar Revenge Run-In

Brock Lesnar was suspended, and so he€™s not expected to be seen in WWE for a long time. One could make an educated guess and assume that he€™ll be seen again sometime around SummerSlam, because his new contract is similar to his old one and allows him to work limited dates, which pretty much means only the most important of shows during the calendar year. What WWE should do to keep Lesnar relevant until his next big match, is to have him make a surprise appearance at Extreme Rules and do a revenge run-in, attacking whomever he wants. What would make this run-in more memorable would be that Lesnar would disregard Stephanie€™s authority and would break through any army of security officials. We€™ve seen many fights and unsanctioned brawls where they get ruined by referees, agents and other personnel, which takes away from the magic of the moment. As such, Lesnar€™s beat down on, for example, Seth Rollins and Randy Orton, would also have him push aside referees and agents trying to restrain him. This would perpetuate Lesnar€™s image as this freakishly-strong monster, while continuing his disregard for the authority and doing what he wants. It would also keep fan interest in him while he€™s away from the ring, and would provide viewers with a memorable moment at Extreme Rules. In the end, Lesnar needs to show up at Extreme Rules and bring the pain to someone on the roster. He€™s too popular and too much of a badass to let something as trivial as a €˜suspension€™ keep him away from WWE programming.

5. Charlotte's Full-Time Main Show Debut

With AJ Lee€™s sudden and unexpected retirement from WWE, the Divas Division is once again lacking in the skilled worker€™s department. While they do have the likes of Natalya and Paige, and to a lesser extent Naomi, as reliable workers, a big part of AJ Lee€™s popularity was her emphasis on actual wrestling over appearance. In order for someone to fill the void caused by her retirement, WWE needs to bring in someone who has a reputation for hard work and excellent wrestling, while still doing well in the looks department. Enter Charlotte. Ric Flair€™s daughter is one of the most praised women in WWE right now. Many of the WWE€™s higher-ups, including Vince himself, are said to be really happy with her work, and many observers think that it€™s only a matter of time before Charlotte makes her full-time debut on WWE€™s flagship shows. While she wouldn€™t be having the same kind of wrestling matches on RAW or SmackDown that she would in NXT, due to the main shows€™ ridiculous time constraints and rigid nature, her skill would make her an ideal candidate for the main show, and would attract a lot of regular NXT viewers to the main shows. In terms of Extreme Rules, WWE could continue with the current Battle Royal storyline, where one of the Divas faces Nicki Bella at Extreme Rules for the WWE Divas Championship. After Nicki were to retain (because, Total Divas), Charlotte would come down the aisle and attack both Bellas, signaling her intent on capturing the Divas Championship. It would make a nice surprise, especially considering that Charlotte€™s an amazing wrestler whose skills are desperately needed in an otherwise limited division with few other great female wrestlers.

4. Sheamus Does A 'Brock Lesnar-Style' Beat Down

What€™s the best way to counter the €˜You Look Stupid€™ chants that have been directed at Sheamus since his return on the RAW after WrestleMania? By having him decimate someone or something so badly that it becomes the new talking point when Sheamus€™ name is brought up. Instead of having him cut any promos, what WWE should do is something similar to his RAW debut in 2009, when he decimated Jamie Noble so badly that he was €˜forced into retirement€™. That established Sheamus as a dangerous force on RAW, and elevated him very quickly. He wasn€™t cutting promos; he was attacking people left, right, and centre without provocation or reason. The idea behind this would be to really elevate Sheamus as a credible threat to the Champions in the company. People need to stop thinking of Sheamus as €˜that guy who only gets pushed because he€™s buddies with Triple H€™, and instead of thinking of him as €˜that merciless guy that people want to see kick other people€™s asses/that guy people want to see get what he has coming to him.€™ The current rumors suggest that Sheamus is scheduled to face Dolph Ziggler in singles competition at Extreme Rules. To achieve this goal of elevating Sheamus, WWE should book him to destroy Ziggler so badly that Ziggler has to be stretchered out of the arena and (in storyline) put on the shelf. This would garner him some serious heat, especially since the crowd simply loves Ziggler, and switch the fan€™s focus from his appearance to his actions.

3. The New Day's Heel Turn

On the April 6 edition of RAW, it appeared that all three members of the New Day were criticizing their own gimmick and seemed to embrace the boos that were coming their way, which was repeated on that week€™s episode of SmackDown. Most people agree: their heel turn is coming, but it would be truly memorable if they were to go full heel at Extreme Rules. In doing so, they would abandon their Gospel-inspired gimmick and adopt what should have been their gimmick in the first place: a 21st century version of the Nation of Domination. While it€™s true that WWE might be afraid to pull the trigger on this kind of gimmick, especially given the continuing controversy surrounding the deaths of African Americans and the serious race issues in parts of the country, this gimmick wouldn€™t be a pseudo-Black Power stable that defined the old Nation. This would be the kind of €˜we€™re fighting for our right to be treated fairly€™, and would be based on how they€™ve been relegated to the undercard undeservedly. Long-term, the idea behind this gimmick would present a story around these three men trying to break a glass ceiling, and could later include them capturing the Tag Team and/or US/IC championships. But for Extreme Rules, the New Day should be booked in a multi-team match for the Tag titles. In it, they would be eliminated, but afterwards, once all the other teams are exhausted from competition, the New Day would attack all of them in brutal fashion, and would stand tall afterwards holding the titles.

2. Sting & The Undertaker Make Their WrestleMania 32 Match Official

It was initially rumored that Sting and The Undertaker would appear on the RAW after WrestleMania to tease their inevitable match at WrestleMania 32. That never happened, and the most anticipated match in modern WWE history is still speculated, at best. That is why WWE should have both of them appear at Extreme Rules 2015 for a short confrontation and signal their intentions to face off. This could be done in a similar way as Undertaker€™s match with Triple H at WrestleMania XXVII, where both men gestured to the WrestleMania logo and did their signature taunts. While that won€™t be possible now, with the €˜Mania logo gone, it would be very easy for one of them, ideally Undertaker, to say the words, €œYou, me, WrestleMania€ Not only would this garner huge interest in WWE€™s flagship show for next year almost immediately, but it would also add more importance to Extreme Rules itself. Instead of having the biggest stars appear exclusively on the €˜Big 4€™ Pay-Per-Views, putting such an historic declaration on a €˜lesser€™ PPV would amplify its importance, and would give fans a lot more to look forward to. After all, WWE succeeded with booking John Cena vs. The Rock a year ahead, and they can certainly garner that kind of interest in Undertaker vs. Sting in a real €˜one-in-a-lifetime€™ match. Since they missed out on doing so on the RAW after €˜Mania, Extreme Rules 2015 would be the best time and place to do it.

1. Samoa Joe Debuts With WWE, Representing NXT

Samoa Joe Wallpaper If recent rumors are to be believed, not only has Samoa Joe filled all of his contractual obligations with Ring of Honor, but Triple H is said to be very high on him, and if signed, he would bring in a considerable viewership to WWE, especially towards NXT. However, the best way to create a shocking moment at Extreme Rules 2015 would be for Joe to skip NXT altogether and debut at the Extreme Rules PPV€by attacking Randy Orton or Seth Rollins€or both. In doing so, he would decimate whoever€™s in the ring, and once he€™d be done, Triple H€™s music would play and HHH would walk down to the ring and shake Joe€™s hand, indicating cooperation between the two. The justification for this move would be that, in a WWE.com exclusive not too long ago, Triple H said that his goal is for NXT to be a rival brand to the main shows, RAW and SmackDown. Over the past two years or so, NXT has been hands down the most popular WWE program, with some fans going as far as sending HHH a €˜thank you fruit basket€™ (courtesy of /r/SquaredCircle) and chanting €˜Thank you, Hunter€™ during NXT shows. With NXT€™s popularity at an all-time high and still rising, this is the ideal time for Triple H to make his move and introduce NXT as the de-facto new WCW, in the sense that it rivals the popularity of both main shows, and offers a different product than what Vince does. With Triple H wanting to sign big names from the independent scene, Samoa Joe would be the perfect fit. Despite his age and less-than-chiseled physique, Joe is one of the most popular €˜indies€™ wrestlers, and his addition to NXT would being a surge in WWE Network followers, and having Joe attack WWE€™s top stars would be an ideal way for Triple H to start a war between NXT and Vince€™s product. Furthermore, with HHH off WWE TV for a few weeks, this would be an ideal time for his on-screen character to change from pro-Authority shill to the mastermind behind NXT. This is the perfect time for Triple H to prove to his father-in-law that his product, his darling NXT, is better than the main shows. And if things are done the way they€™ve been described here, HHH would have the respect, fan interest, and revenue to prove it.

Contributor

Alexander Podgorski is a writer for WhatCulture that has been a fan of professional wrestling since he was 8 years old. He loves all kinds of wrestling, from WWE and sports entertainment, to puroresu in Japan. He holds a Bachelor of Arts degree from Queen's University in Political Studies and French, and a Master's Degree in Public Administration. He speaks English, French, Polish, a bit of German, and knows some odd words and phrases in half a dozen other languages.