10 Short-Lived WWE Pushes You’ve Totally Forgotten

Blink and you'll miss it! These rapid WWE pushes just didn't work out as planned.

Johnny Nitro John Morrison Steve Austin Eric Bischoff 2004
WWE

Everyone loves a right good wrestling push.

Emphasis has to go on the word "good" there, but not every creative shove is guaranteed to work out or click with fans. Sometimes, audiences don't even get the chance to yay or nay a push - WWE themselves squash it before it really gets started.

It says a lot about the company's product over the years that this list includes everything from a dude playing the living embodiment of an entire WCW show to someone who has an imaginary friend/feels like there's some grand conspiracy to keep him from reaching the top of cards.

Yeah, this wrasslin' stuff is a bit...out there at times.

You've probably forgotten most (if not all) of these pushes too. They were real 'blink and you'll miss it' moments on WWE TV, and they were totally scrapped before long. Some did make it to the so-called promised land of a midcard title reign before being dumped though.

Brace yourselves for abandoned legend killers, tough-talking military men, body-proud babyfaces, workers willing to stand up against unfair persecution and more. How many of these do you remember?

10. Rob Conway (2005)

Rob Conway
WWE.com

Just look at him.

Rob Conway was physically gifted, and that had to earn him some credit at the bank of Vince behind the scenes. McMahon must've loved how muscular Conway was, but no amount of hard graft in the gym could help the wrestler lift a wobbly 'Con Man' gimmick up in 2005.

WWE transitioned Rob out of La Résistance in July that year - he re-debuted on Heat with some fresh threads and a character which looked for all the world like it had leapt out of the early-1990s. Conway's main objective was to target older legends like Doink The Clown, Greg Valentine, Koko B. Ware and more.

He even bagged an Intercontinental Title bout vs. Ric Flair on Raw, but WWE had given up on his push long before the end of the year. His own legend killer plan didn't pan out quite as well as Randy Orton's would, to put it mildly, and he ended up back in creative hell.


9. Billy Gunn (2000)

The One Billy Gunn
WWE.com

Alright, so everyone knows about Billy Gunn's King Of The Ring win in 1999 and an attempted skyward push at SummerSlam against The Rock. Most also know that the ex-New Age Outlaw's grand moment fell flat; so flat, in fact, that he was back in the tag-team ranks shortly afterwards.

WWE tried Gunn on for size again the next year.

The handsome devil returned in October 2000 as 'The One' Billy Gunn. His entrance tune was a total banger (just saying), but there was nothing to the character change beyond that. 'The One' was as generic a nickname as they come, and not even a brief IC Title reign could ignite Bill's solo career.

He tried his best though. Apparently, someone on the writing team believed that Gunn just didn't have it when flying solo, and he was dumped back in a temp tag with Big Show (Show-Gunns represent, baby) by mid-2001.

At least they gave him another crack at it.


8. Jaxson Ryker (2021)

Jaxson Ryker
WWE.com

Christ, this happened last year and it's already forgotten.

Former Forgotten (ha) Sons leader Jaxson Ryker became Elias' pal in late-2020. WWE didn't bother to flesh his role out with much context. Nah, it was preferable to have Jax stand around in the background like a bouncer as Eli strummed his guitar and encouraged fans to shut their mouths.

That was never going to last. The sort of/almost/kinda tag-team headed for Splitsville by May 2021 when Elias ran out on Ryker during a match against AJ Styles and Omos. After that, the promotion began playing up Jaxson's military background and rethought him as a proud ex-Marine who couldn't stomach his old pal's bullsh*t any longer.

This all boiled down to the most mini of mini-pushes. Ryker toppled his one-time musical chum in both a 'Strap Match' and a 'Symphony Of Destruction' bout between June-July on Raw, then...WWE threw the towel in on his ascension and mired Jax on Main Event until releasing him come November.


7. Ezekiel Jackson (2011)

Ezekiel Jackson Intercontinental Title
WWE.com

Here's a worker who almost melds both Jaxson Ryker and Elias into one man (the latter's new moniker, at least). That's fitting, because Ezekiel Jackson was bloody huge, and looked to be exactly the kind of physical beast that Vinnie Mac would fawn over for at least a few years.

Poor Zeke didn't even get that long.

WWE strapped a rocket to Jackson by splitting him from The Corre and having him beat ex-leader Wade Barrett to become Intercontinental Champion at Capitol Punishment in June 2011. Things were definitely looked up for the muscleman, but he only enjoyed a 51-day reign with the belt before dropping it to Cody Rhodes that August.

Injuries would blight the rest of Ezekiel's company career. There's a chance WWE would've tried another push for Jackson had he not been benched with so many problems, but there's no clear sign that a second attempt would've been any better than the first.


6. R-Truth (2011)

R-Truth 2011
WWE.com

Jackson wasn't the only guy getting pushed to the moon at Capitol Punishment.

R-Truth traded in his happy-go-lucky midcard babyface routine for a delusional conspiracy theorist gimmick in mid-2011. Suddenly, Truth appeared to lose his damn mind and claim that guys he used to look up to (John Cena, mainly) were holding him back from main event greatness.

The whole exercise was riotously entertaining, to be fair, but Truth's headline run was never destined to last too long. He started sliding back down the card following that June pay-per-view, and it became obvious that WWE just needed to plug a gap in Cena's schedule for the one-off show.

In fairness, the rapper did find some doubles success alongside The Miz later that same year. Their 'Awesome Truth' tag also earned Truth the distinction of working opposite The Rock for big Dwayne's first WWE match in over seven years.

Still, Truth's main event-sized push was fleeting at best.


5. Humberto Carrillo (2019)

Humberto Carrillo
WWE.com

Hey, remember when Jerry Lawler randomly alleged that Humberto Carrillo was WWE's own version of Justin Bieber on commentary? That was never going to endear the Mexican flyer to fans. Being fair to Lawler though, those same folks were barely interested in what Carrillo was selling anyway.

This was creative bashing their heads against ye olde brick wall for sure.

Humberto bounded onto the main roster in late-2019, and he was immediately programmed against top stars like Seth Rollins and AJ Styles. Both of them were instructed to hype Carrillo up as something special, but he...had the same amount of charisma as your average dish drying rack.

Although a later feud opposite Andrade did show signs of improvement, WWE viewers had long-since made their minds up about this forced push. Announcers could wax lyrical about how impressive Carrillo was all they wanted - fans didn't see it, so WWE's writers quickly dumped him on the failure pile and moved focus elsewhere.


4. Otis (2020)

Otis Money In The Bank
WWE.com

OK, so this one is cheating slightly, but WWE's current version of Otis is almost an entirely different wrestler to 2020's ham-loving funster. Alpha Academy's Otis is described as a wrecking ball who's all business when the bell rings. Two years ago though, the guy just wanted Mandy Rose.

Man, 2020 was a fever dream.

Otis did so well as a socially-awkward, body-proud babyface that he started outgrowing his Heavy Machinery partner Tucker and motored up the cards. WWE noticed how much traction he was gaining, and they decided to back Otis by booking him to win Money In The Bank.

That's when the fun stopped.

Like many other lovable faces before him, Otis struggled once he had everything he'd craved. He nabbed the briefcase, and he even scored Mandy as his unlikely girlfriend. WWE lost interest from there, scripted him to lose his MITB privileges and generally started phoning it in on the dude's career.


3. Nidia (2004)

Nidia WWE 2004
WWE.com

If the Otis entry had you screaming, 'Who wouldn't remember that push, you fool?!', then here's one to make up for it. Tough Enough's Nidia earned plaudits for her work as "trailer trash" alongside Jamie Noble on SmackDown between 2002-2004. Together, the pair were often comedy gold.

Nothing good lasts forever in wrestling.

Nidia and Noble parted ways following a match at No Way Out '04 (which Noble cheated to win), and it became clear that the Diva needed something fresh. She couldn't continue with the trailer park gimmick, so WWE moved her sideways to Raw and tried to lean on Nidia's Hispanic heritage in promos.

She actually defeated Molly Holly during her debut on the brand in March, and then entered the Women's Title scene for a short spell. Nidia worked matches against everyone from Trish Stratus and Jazz to Gail Kim before quietly being released in November 2004.

Her repackage job and push didn't work.


2. Buddy Murphy (2019)

Roman Reigns Buddy Murphy
WWE.com

'10 SmackDown Storylines You've Totally Forgotten' could be an entirely separate list. If it was, then the fact that some scaffolding fell on Roman Reigns back in July 2019 would definitely be on there. Poor Buddy Murphy just so happened to be in the background on camera when that happened, so he became a suspect.

Reigns confronted Buddy backstage and found out that Daniel Bryan's heavy Rowan was responsible for the potential murder plot. This eventually led to a pretty f*cking hot match between Roman and Murphy on the 13 August SmackDown; Buddy was so impressive there that WWE started to view him in a new light.

What was that about nothing being built to last?

Despite excelling every single he entered the ring, Buddy was a mere pawn in the simmering issues between top stars. He'd get some more shine as part of Seth Rollins' next gimmick, but the short-lived babyface push WWE nearly gave Murphy in 2019 sticks in this fan's craw.


1. Johnny Nitro (2004)

Johnny Nitro John Morrison Eric Bischoff 2004
WWE

Yes, that is future parkour and "Drip Stick"-lover John Morrison alongside then-Raw GM Eric Bischoff back in 2004. No, Morrison wasn't quite the rockstar-inspired character he'd later become at that stage. Instead, he was actually the walking, talking, living, breathing human embodiment of WCW's Monday Nitro.

WWE actually introduced the guy as Johnny Blaze on the 1 March '04 Raw. Then, they changed his name to Johnny Spade before settling on the Nitro surname. This was all pre-MNM too. Think Val Venis when he morphed into Chief Morley to become Bisch's apprentice/assistant in 2002.

The presentation and role was very similar.

Nitro's first big break only lasted until June. WWE sent him back to developmental after that, he formed a tag-team with Joey Mercury and the rest is history. Before that though, he was in a pretty featured spot on the flagship every week, and most fans probs don't even recall it.

What other short-lived pushes did WWE give up on? For more wrestling, check out WWE WrestleMania Backlash 2022: 10 Things That Must Happen and WWE WrestleMania Backlash 2022: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.