10 Signs That WrestleMania 36 Could Be A Crushing Disappointment

Pointing at the red flag.

Red Flag
WWE.com

WrestleMania season is upon us, and the Road has taken quite the turn.

The path was clear, the view rather grand. WWE put Drew McIntyre over big at the Royal Rumble; he eliminated Brock Lesnar and then tore up the rest of the field in a killer, committed spot of booking: a convincing, super talent the WWE system has not failed, or dumbly persisted with in spite of failure, emerged as the next top babyface of the company.

Edge returned that same night in a moment only the word "magic" can accurately describe. He looked thrilled and humbled, and performed very well as a gritty, wily babyface in eliminating Randy Orton, before Orton re-injured his neck in a shocking, disturbing scene so well-performed that it was thought WWE had restored its old, brilliant storytelling mechanisms. The vehicle entered a whacky fork in the Road when Shayna Baszler became a vampire for a week, but no matter: the follow-up promo exchange was excellent, promising real violence instead of delivering cartoonish gore.

And then WWE took that vehicle, GTA-style, and killed several innocent bystanders masquerading as pro wrestling stars, flattening Ricochet, AJ Styles and the Fiend in a five star police chase with minus five star squash matches...

10. A Bad Omen Informed By Recent History

Randy Orton Edge
WWE.com

A returning superstar returns from years-long hiatus in a white-hot angle that builds towards a marquee WrestleMania match.

Interest is high. This is classic WWE business when WWE most needs it.

The angle is furthered on television with very good promos.

A WWE Legend is destroyed to heat it up.

The issue is that the returning star's opponent is a very overfamiliar headliner with a penchant for working methodical, overlong slogs that don't generate a level of heat that makes up for how little he does or is capable of in his matches.

The above describes Triple H and Batista's WrestleMania 35 programme and match, but the dynamic is eerily similar to the ongoing Edge Vs. Randy Orton feud.

Randy Orton almost invariably disappoints at WrestleMania. He hasn't worked an over, very good match since 2015. Really, 2015 and 2014 were aberrations; Orton has mostly turned in quite good midcard performances (2012, 2013) or outright disasters (2009, 2013). His deliberate style fails to project to and ignite the upper bowl of the stadium-sized crowd. This storyline is hot, believable, and very well-performed. That doesn't matter much either; fans enjoyed his operatic but entertaining programmes with Triple H and Bray Wyatt.

And then the bell rang.

Basically, Randy Orton works 'Mania like a guy Bruce Prichard writes off on his podcast. He is Virgil in a stadium; good for memes, not so good for the semi-main.


9. Goldberg Is Thrashed

Fiend Goldberg
WWE.com

Goldberg's win over The Fiend at Super ShowDown was comically bad.

It was piss-funny, because people took to pitying a supernatural monster (!) and those people will cheer Vince McMahon the next time he does his next "We'll get better!" rah-rah speech on RAW when ratings tank.

The long-term principle behind the decision was disastrous, obviously, but Goldberg went over because he's a bigger draw in the short-term. This is even more myopic than that, because it's not as if him doing the job for Roman Reigns is going to make any difference. WWE has been trying to strap Roman Reigns as the tippy-top guy for five years now. It's not going to happen.

And it's definitely not going to happen with this vehicle because this match is going to suck sh*t.

Goldberg embraced the Fiend more than he Speared him. Perhaps he has an r/SquaredCircle burner account and this was his way of saying 'Can't believe it they've killed your push wanna run to u'.

Goldberg didn't have the snap nor the force to pull off an effective squash match, and the last time he wrestled for longer than three minutes, he endangered another man's life. The contrarians might come out to bury the whole thing, even if it's pretty good.

This is going to blow more than Goldberg blows out of his ass.


8. The Undertaker Did Not Look Good At Super ShowDown...

The Undertaker AJ Styles
WWE.com

The other relic WWE is depending on at WrestleMania 36 is the Undertaker, who also looked deep into his Heroes Of Wrestling phase.

The Undertaker hasn't worked an acceptable singles match since 2015. The Graveyard Dogs were spectacular because it was a parlour trick. Without such an exceptional, old-magic WWE layout, the Undertaker tends to endanger himself in sad affairs. AJ Styles is the ideal 'Mania opponent, because he can bump big and craft excellence, but the problem is that WWE has already dropped the ol' clanger. He lowered Styles very gently to the ground as if he actually were an Undertaker, and because Styles had absorbed zero danger, this felt less like the build to an epic WrestleMania match and more like one of those times Triple H used to come out and Pedigree Wade Barrett, or something.

It's WrestleMania. Even the most cynical of numbed hearts will pop for the Undertaker's majestic entrance and the manifested dream match graphic of the stare-down.

But then, the bell will have to ring, and in the case of so many Undertaker matches, it sounds rather like a toll.


7. No Announced/Rumoured Match Of The Year Contender

Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

How much does a great professional wrestling match matter?

The cult-like devotion to and arena-sized emergence of NXT, NJPW and AEW indicates that it very much does, but Lana and Bobby Lashley have drawn more eyes to their fake unfunny wedding than some of the most blistering wars fought on television in years and years.

It matters to an extent, and it certainly matters at WrestleMania. Great matches double as moments of ascendency. Great matches, like those the Undertaker unleashed in his streak-within-the-Streak, elevated and made commercially viable 'Mania's latter, stadium-sized aura.

Nothing on the rumoured WrestleMania 36 card has proper banger potential.

Drew McIntyre Vs. Brock Lesnar might be an electric, stiff-as-f*ck hoss fight, but elsewhere, we're looking at a slew of methodical melodramas that will feel even slower against the backdrop of that draining seven-hour runtime. The card doesn't highlight the most capable and dynamic of workers in the WWE system, but rather creaking Legends and the power-based big lads. There's not a single Match Of The Year Candidate, which isn't ideal.

WWE has built engrossing stories ahead of WrestleMania 36, which ultimately matters more, but...


6. Shayna Baszler Vs. Becky Lynch Part I Wasn't Great

Shayna Baszler Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Great professional wrestlers do not automatically produce great WrestleMania performances.

There is a different, advanced psychology to manipulating the vast reaches of a stadium crowd. Shawn Michaels grasped this brilliantly by intensifying and projecting the melodrama of his big matches. To become Mr. WrestleMania, he pulled anxiously at his hair in moments of doubt, and stamped the ground with exaggerated, burdened movement to extract from the crowd the most bittersweet of reactions. To tell an effective story at WrestleMania is a difficult balancing act; the big moments must be registered, but the pace can't dip for too long; the scope of everything is so bright and stunning that it's too easy for live fans to lose themselves in the mythology of it all just by looking, which is so much more grandiose than, for example, Randy Orton taking four days to complete the Garvin stomp.

Shayna Baszler Vs. Becky Lynch Vs. Bayley from Survivor Series wasn't over.

It was a strange, enervated match badly lacking in personality, and if the Triple Threat dynamic compromised the most interesting part about it, there's much to suggest WrestleMania isn't the venue for Baszler's superb, systematic joint work.


5. On That John Cena Vs. The Fiend Match...

The Fiend John Cena
WWE.com

This has enormous inadvertent comedy potential, which is fabulous, unless you want the Fiend to become the next Undertaker or anything.

The Fiend pointed to the WrestleMania sign as if he were just some innocent dreamer looking to make a name for himself, but the angle did get over because John Cena, in a remarkably restrained performance, actually - subtly! - sold the gravity of the challenge, even though a Jacksh*thammer had put the Fiend away just 24 hours earlier.

This subtlety cannot hold.

It's the Fiend.

It's the Fiend Vs. John Cena.

The Fiend is a farcical character, and f*ck knows how John Cena gurned his way into Hollywood because the man, from phrenology to acting skill, is the reincarnated soul of Jim Varney. He will, invariably, do one of two things, if not both:

1) Ridicule the Fiend character in his customary way, undermining the story before it's even told in the ring. "So Mr. Rogers ate a few pies, and I'm meant to be scared - hell naw, I'm John Cena!"

2) He will sell for the Fiend at 'Mania in a beyond exaggerated way, gulping like a complete cornball imbecile.


4. Charlotte Flair Vs. Rhea Ripley Doesn't Feel Hot

Charlotte Flair Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

The Charlotte Flair Vs. Rhea Ripley programme feels bigger written down.

It started well if blandly enough; Charlotte Flair teased who she was going to challenge on RAW a month or so back. After a week of mystery, NXT Champion Rhea Ripley decided to challenger her, in order to prove whether Charlotte still had what it took to hang with the newer generation/gradually siphon viewers away from AEW Dynamite to further monopolise pro wrestling as WWE strives forward into a global dystopia of chinlocks and "You see..." promos (delete as appropriate).

NXT's screen credit was far superior. On Wednesday nights, Bianca Belair was thrust into the story too effectively; many fans were dismayed when the teased Triple Threat did not materialise.

Things were less elegant on RAW. Ripley was going to say the word "a*se", and then Flair cut her off, a joke structure people found faintly amusing on milquetoast '80s three-camera sitcoms.

And then, last week, Ripley exposed her greenness by making sure to get her pose in as the woman she had defended two weeks prior was in the process of getting her ankle crushed.

The heavily-promoted show itself drew NXT's worst Nielsen in a long time - the sixth-lowest since the move to USA - which in parallel with Flair's post-2018 in-ring regression doesn't suggest a great, heated match is imminent.


3. What Is Daniel Bryan Even Doing?

Daniel Bryan TLC 2019
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan did not make the Wrestling Observer's projected match card last week, which, before some of you bother, has proven accurate for several years now, a fact not undermined by how much Dave Meltzer might praise a wrestling match you haven't seen.

He's pissing about with Drew Gulak and Heath Slater on Friday nights. It makes some kind of terrible sense for him to work King Corbin at 'Mania - they are the #3 pushed pair of acts on SmackDown following the arrivals of Goldberg and John Cena - and rumours persist that we'll see round three of Daniel Bryan Vs. Sheamus.

"This time, they'll actually wrestle!"

Bryan reportedly loves working with Sheamus, and they have awesome previous, but a 12-15 minute midcard match, a familiar one, is no reward for how great and productive his work is. The man has helped immortalise the mythology of the WrestleMania World Championship match as both the Guy and the Gatekeeper.

It's not good enough. WWE has too few stars. Daniel Bryan should be far more of a star than he is. Daniel Bryan can make new stars better than the machine can.

The outlook of WrestleMania 36 will not remedy that.


2. What Is Aleister Back Even Doing?

Carlito WWE
WWE.com

Also: where does Aleister Black fit in, and what does it say about the purpose of television that he doesn't?

What will his (actually committed) push mean, in the end, where it matters?

Black was pushed deep into 2019 in a very well-worked series with Buddy Murphy. In a sign of the State Of Things, that this push didn't end after three weeks framed him as an outsider to win the Royal Rumble, and indeed, only close scrutiny of RAW's quarter hours saw Drew McIntyre pushed in his place. Since then, Black has continued to work squash matches and twice defeated Rowan, who also received a push concurrently. He's been given interview time to flesh out his character. F*ck know what that character is - an angry, procrastinating motivational speaker? - but the point remains: he's an established rising star, a winner, and yet he won't do anything of note at WrestleMania. The biggest WWE audience will not receive him as a star, which paints WrestleMania as a crushing disappointment because it doesn't pay off the things you watched last month - just the things now, when the real stars come back.

This is a tale as old as time.

Why, again, are the best and often most profiled full-time workers missing from the matters of most importance?


1. We're In For Another Slog

Wrestling Fans GIF
WWE.com

Seven and a half hours is too long to endure any event, much less a wrestling show that by internal policy (as opposed to fan complaint) does not offer a plethora of unique styles.

Five hours is too long. The first, pre-Dynamite wave of All Elite Wrestling pay-per-views were plagued with timing issues to an extent that saw the main events performed to a straining arena crowd. Full Gear and Revolution effectively solved the issue, while in terms of sustained, raucous crowd reaction, the NXT TakeOver formula remains the benchmark.

WrestleMania 35 degenerated into a hush the very second Kofi Kingston reached his career pinnacle at, including the pre-show, the perfect four-hour mark. To the minute, that audience sent WWE a message: this new Network one-day festival thing is bullsh*t; the compact PPV run-time of old, enforced by providers, worked far better. Triple H Vs. Batista didn't get over, but that's probably because it was a Triple H match at WrestleMania. Roman Reigns' first singles match in a year didn't get over. Becky Lynch didn't receive a huge reaction, which is insane, given how hot she was.

At least WrestleMania won't feel like it's ten hours long, because Triple H isn't scheduled to work it, but it will still last seven and a half actual hours.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!