10 Strangest Ways Wrestlers Were Written Off TV

When simply getting 'injured' mid-match just won't do.

John Cena Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

Professional wrestling isn't a business famed for its compelling realism.

Though the majority of the manoeuvres we see go down in the squared circle are legitimate and involve stars frequently putting their bodies on the line for our entertainment, the storylines these wrestlers are part of are often about as far from authentic as you can get.

However, there have been times when wrestling companies have tried to trick audiences into believing an element of a programme was 'real' in order to get a wrestler off television for an extended spell. This is largely done by believably 'injuring' a star on screen who is coming towards the end of their contract, requires surgery on a genuine injury or just needs some time away from the ring.

But, as this is the insane world of pro wrestling, not every write-off gets the convincing kayfabe injury treatment.

Exploding vehicles, nightclub stabbings and literal burials have all been used to get various wrestlers off TV for multiple reasons and each of these moments have proven exactly why you should always expect the unexpected when it comes to this whacky (and sometimes quite disturbing) industry.

10. Rey Mysterio's Eye Injury

Rey Mysterio Eye
WWE.com

Jumping straight into the latest example of WWE going down the batsh*t route when it comes to writing off a legend, here we have Rey Mysterio and his eye situation.

After the 'Master of the 619' initially had his peeper injured by Seth Rollins on an episode of Monday Night Raw in May, fans were left wondering just where this programme would end up going. The image of Mysterio's eye being jammed into the steel steps was actually quite unsettling - minus Rollins' nutty eyes - so could this possibly turn into a genuinely dramatic storyline?

Well, things definitely got taken up a notch when Mysterio finally challenged the Monday Night Messiah to an Eye for an Eye match at The Horror Show at Extreme Rules. However, the surreal contest's conclusion left both the masked legend's and fans around the world's eyes rolling.

Mysterio was then sent to hospital to be treated for a potential globe luxation, but WWE later confirmed there was a chance he could maintain his vision. Dave Meltzer confirmed that WWE's decision to write him off television in this way was due to him not having re-signed with the company. So, Vince McMahon purposefully kept things open-ended just in case he decided to return.

We've definitely seen some odd stuff during this unprecedented crowd-less era, but a former World Champion rolling around on the floor with a prosthetic eye is definitely up there.


9. The Fiend Ends John Cena?

Bray Wyatt John Cena
WWE.com

Speaking of not seeing things (too soon?) John Cena was another legendary star written off television in 2020 and it's probably fair to say the word 'strange' doesn't cover his WrestleMania 36 conclusion.

After the current global situation completely shook up WWE's original plans, the 'Leader of the Cenation' and Bray Wyatt agreed to move their match into the eerie Firefly Funhouse.

Nobody knew what to expect going into this unique encounter, only that it was supposedly going to be a cinematic experience. That's one way of putting it.

Wyatt dragged 'Super Cena' through the important moments in his illustrious career and forced him to face up to the man he'd become inside and outside of the ring. This included mocking his debut, Doctor of Thuganomics gimmick and showing him what he could have become if he had given into his demons years ago.

Cena proclaimed going into the Funhouse match that this would be the 'end of the most overhyped, overvalued and overprivileged WWE Superstar in existence' and he wasn't wrong. Wyatt's 'The Fiend' finally took advantage of a beaten, vulnerable Cena and 'hurt' him to the point of no return.

Once the match had ended, we legitimately couldn't see him and perhaps we never will again... on WWE television that is...


8. The Undertaker Is Buried Alive

Undertaker McMahon Survivor Series 2003
WWE

Though The Undertaker had obviously been buried alive on a couple of occasions before 2003, he hadn't been written off television for that long a spell after those matches against Mankind and 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin.

However, 'Taker was a very different man coming into his Buried Alive match with Mr. McMahon at Survivor Series and this individual wouldn't be able to shake off all that dirt quite so easily.

After his brother Kane interfered in the contest, 'Big Evil' was laid to rest for good by the WWE Chairman and he wouldn't be seen again for four whole months.

This was clearly done to pump some new life back into the character of The Undertaker, but on the surface it was absolutely nuts. A human being had been literally covered in dirt and left for dead as part of a wrestling television show.

He would finally make a triumphant return as a modern version of his original 'Deadman' persona and battled his despicable brother at WrestleMania XX, but before this WWE were repeatedly telling fans that one of their favourite stars had been legitimately murdered by his brother and his boss.

Don't you just love Sports Entertainment?


7. Paul Bearer Buried In Cement

Bearer Suffocated In Cement
WWE Network

When The Undertaker made his aforementioned 2004 return, he did so with his old manager Paul Bearer by his side.

The sight of the old 'Deadman' methodically walking towards the ring with Bearer was one fans had grown used to throughout the '90s and it definitely helped re-establish the character all these years later.

However, this alliance wouldn't last as long as some may have hoped.

After Paul Heyman ordered The Dudley Boyz to kidnap Bearer so that he could take control of 'Taker's urn, the 'Phenom' would eventually find himself in a handicap match against the tag team at The Great American Bash. The stipulation being that, if he lost, Bearer would be buried in cement. Yep.

'Taker eventually won the match and stopped Heyman from pouring cement on his long-time manager, but he then shockingly buried Bearer himself.

Sure, Bearer wasn't an in-ring performer like the majority of the other names on this list, but this was still a crazy way of writing a recognisable face off WWE TV. Bearer would be used as a booker for a while after leaving 'Taker to go solo, until he was eventually let go in 2005. He would then finally return to WWE television in 2010 as part of another Undertaker vs. Kane storyline before sadly passing away in 2013..


6. Elias Is Involved In A Hit-And-Run Accident

Elias Jeff Hardy Renee Young
WWE.com

2020 hasn't been a pleasant year for many, but it's been particularly troublesome for SmackDown's Elias.

After being launched off a balcony and having a guitar broken over his back by 'King' Baron Corbin, it looked like things were looking up for 'The Drifter' during the Intercontinental Championship tournament. Beating Corbin in the first round, a semi-final against the eventual winner AJ Styles was next up for the instrument wielding wrestler.

That was until he found himself caught in the middle of one of the most controversial WWE angles in recent history.

In reality, Elias had genuinely suffered a torn pectoral muscle which required surgery and a lengthy spell on the sidelines. Yet, instead of simply revealing he'd picked the injury up in a match, WWE made it look like his pain was the result of a hit-and-run accident involving Jeff Hardy. This would then kickstart a fairly uncomfortable programme with Sheamus which centred around Hardy's past issues with drugs and alcohol.

With Elias stretchered away in dramatic fashion, he now looks set to miss the rest of the year due to his legitimate injury.

Though any normal human being would likely press charges against another person for attempting to kill them with a vehicle, expect Elias to return in 2021 and challenge his attacker to a parking lot brawl.


5. Vince McMahon Explodes In A Limo

Vince McMahon Limo
WWE.com

Admittedly, WWE Chairman Vince McMahon was not a consistent in-ring performer when he was suddenly written off television in June 2007, but he had just been involved in an odd ECW World title feud with Bobby Lashley.

However, after eventually losing the belt he'd won from 'The All Mighty', McMahon decided it was time for a break from the spotlight and used this as a chance to get more eyes on his product.

Killing the 'Mr. McMahon' character in a freak limousine accident, it looked like this storyline was set to dominate Monday Night Raw for the foreseeable future. Fans all around the world were also deeply invested in the event, with Donald Trump even calling up Titan Towers to check if his WrestleMania 23 rival was OK.

Yet, when Chris Benoit and his family were tragically found dead in their home a few weeks later, those plans to continue the story were immediately scrapped and McMahon acknowledged that his death was merely part of a programme.

McMahon would then disappear for a few weeks after the Benoit incident and upon returning revealed that he faked his death to see what people really thought of him.

Needless to say, we haven't seen many fake death angles used to write stars off WWE programming since and it'd probably be wise to stay clear of them for the foreseeable future.


4. The Spirit Squad Are Sent Back To OVW... In A Box

DX Spirit Squad OVW HI LARIOUS
WWE.com

The mid-2000s saw its fair share of characters being written off television in peculiar ways.

A year before WWE Chairman Vince McMahon had attempted to escape programming via limo explosion, his former allies The Spirit Squad were also set to leave Monday Night Raw for an extended spell.

Kenny, Mikey, Nicky, Mitch and Johnny had all been feuding with the likes of D-Generation X, Ric Flair and other WWE legends. However, by November 2006 they'd lost their World Tag Team Championships to the team of Flair and 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper and it was clear the company had ran out of ideas for them as a unit.

So, it was decided that the majority of the squad would be sent back down to OVW and repackaged as different characters (apart from Kenny Dykstra who would remain on Raw). Yet, instead of simply having them lose a 'losers leave town' match, WWE chose to hammer home the team's demotion by having Triple H and Shawn Michaels throw them into a box with the letters OVW stamped on the front of it.

They were then literally shipped back to OVW, with only Nicky (Dolph Ziggler) surviving in the company after this humiliating conclusion.


3. Mickey James Is Thrown Onto A Train Track

Kane Survivor Series buried alive
WWE.com

Controversial and insane writing isn't exclusive to WWE in the world of professional wrestling. That much was proved during Mickie James' 2015 run with Impact when the Knockouts Champion found herself involved in a programme with James Storm.

After Storm successfully convinced James to return from her recent retirement for one more match, he then offered the star a chance to join The Revolution. James would decline this offer, but it's what came next which really caught everyone off-guard.

Clearly annoyed by her decision, Storm pushed James onto a train track and left her for dead. This moment led to a negative response from some, with Jim Ross even admitting the situation "had (him) feeling embarrassed for two, very good talents."

This unusual act was used to write James off Impact television as she simply hadn't signed on for any more dates with the promotion at that moment in time.

In the end, she'd return a month later - after it was revealed she'd suffered a concussion from the fall - and challenged Storm to an intergender tag team match. After winning the bout, James would finally get revenge by delivering a jumping DDT to her attacker.


2. Mr. Kennedy Impersonates A McMahon

Vince McMahon Mr. Kennedy
WWE.com

After returning to WWE programming post-fake death, Vince McMahon felt his product needed a fresh injection of nutty soap opera drama. So, it wasn't long before it was revealed the WWE Chairman had an illegitimate son he wasn't aware of, who just so happened to be a WWE Superstar.

What are the chances?!

It later came to light that the illegitimate son twist would have come into play during the original 'death of Mr. McMahon' storyline, but due to the sudden change in circumstances WWE were forced to make this the main focus of the programme.

What didn't change, however, was the idea that Mr. Kennedy would be revealed as McMahon's bastard son. Well, that was until the star was suspended for 30 days after being revealed as one of the names involved in the infamous 2007 steroid scandal.

Kennedy had tried to convince McMahon that he was in fact his long lost son on the 3 September episode of Raw, but this was proved not to be the case before the end of the show. Then, in order to completely write Kennedy out of the picture, the WWE Chairman announced the following week that Kennedy had been suspended for "impersonating a McMahon".

Good thing the boss doesn't watch the Firefly Funhouse then...


1. John Cena Is Stabbed In A Club

John Cena US Champion 2004
WWE.com

Long before he was starring in movies like Bumblebee and Fast and Furious 9, John Cena was taking his first steps into the world of filmmaking with a WWE produced feature known as The Marine in 2004.

However, in order to find the time to shoot this heart-stopping action flick, Cena would need to be written off WWE television for a while. So, during his feud with debuting star Carlito, Cena lost his U.S. title to the newcomer and was abruptly 'injured'. This kept him out of action for a month.

Yet, his faux-injury didn't come during a bout with the performer who spat in the face of people who didn't want to be cool. Instead, Cena was cut down (quite literally) after being allegedly stabbed by Carlito's bodyguard Jesus in a Boston nightclub.

The storyline wound to his kidney would keep him off WWE TV until Survivor Series, where Cena returned as part of Team Guerrero to beat Team Angle on the night.

He'd then win back his belt from Carlito on the next episode of SmackDown and instead of pressing charges against Jesus, he just beat him in a street fight at Armageddon. Each to their own.


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!