10 Superstars WWE Completely Wasted

Those times WWE totally missed the boat.

mvp wwe
WWE.com

WWE spokespeople love pointing out how WCW wasted the talents of Steve Austin, Mick Foley, The Undertaker, Triple H, Chris Jericho, and many more superstars. Those men toiled in the midcard for a promotion that never recognized their full talent, and it was only once they came to WWE that they were able to explore their true potential, making millions of dollars in the process.

To be fair, that's all true - but it's only half the story. WCW missed the boat with those men, but WWE's also been guilty of wasting talent. With only one major wrestling promotion in the United States, the results aren't as immediately noticeable as they were in the 1990s, but that doesn't change the fact that WWE's left a lot of money on the table a lot of times. Whether the issues involved personal grudges or bad booking, or remain a complete mystery to this day, WWE ended up making the wrong decision.

Here are the ten most egregious cases. These superstars could have been major players - instead, some were mishandled and released, some left the company to pursue other opportunities, and some still flounder there. One can only hope that the company is able to learn from its mistakes.


10. The Original Sin Cara

Sin Cara In Ring
WWE.com

Sin Cara's WWE tenure was dogged with problems from the start. Allegedly, the former CMLL World Welterweight Champion made no effort to learn English, refused to adapt to WCW style, and "carried himself like a star," which didn't endear him to WWE's brass or superstars. Before long, he was suspended for failing a drug test - and then the injuries started mounting up.

While Sin Cara's attitude problems may very well have been true, the company still burned millions by refusing to reach some middle ground with the most popular Mexican star in a generation. As Mistico, he captained a boom period for CMLL and lucha libre, and that's what drew WWE to him as early as 2007. If he carried himself like a star, it was because he was one.

Had WWE been willing to put its muscle behind a superstar who didn't cut promos in English and whose matches were a bit different than those on the rest of the card, the sky could have been the limit.


9. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

WWE has typically earmarked wrestlers for main event success very early in their careers, and with a few exceptions (Jeff Hardy, Daniel Bryan), superstars rarely work their way up the card and change minds in the process. Drew McIntyre was one of the lucky few supposed to be a future star, and in late 2009, Vince McMahon himself declared the Scot a future World Champion on TV. He won the Intercontinental Title in short order, but McIntyre's reaction and talent didn't match his push, and following a loss in WrestleMania XXVI's Money in the Bank match (McIntyre was schedule to win, but plans were changed for disciplinary reasons), his good fortunes soon faded.

McIntyre floundered in 2011 and 2012, but he quietly improved to the point of becoming a very good worker. In 2012, he joined the Three Man Band comedy stable, and continued to show greatness despite his position on the card.

In 2014 he was released, and since then, he's dominated the independent wrestling scene - he quickly captured the Dragon Gate USA and Evolve Championships, and later at promotions like ICW and WCPW showed fans in America and Europe what WWE failed to recognize. So much so they re-signed him in 2017 and is now firmly being pushed as NXT's next top guy.



8. Chris Kanyon

chris kanyon
WWE.com

As WWE decided against buying out the contracts of WCW's top stars prior to the Invasion angle, Chris Kanyon was one of the best-known names to make the jump. He soon became United States Champion and while his reign didn't last long, he was a prominent member of the Alliance until suffering a knee injury. Bad luck turned even worse, though, and before returning to TV, Kanyon hurt his shoulder. He nearly died after experiencing an allergic reaction to post-surgical medications, but eventually made a full recovery and reported back to OVW.

He stayed there for months until WWE finally brought him to Smackdown, where he dressed as Boy George and was attacked by The Undertaker in one of the show's more infamous angles. Despite working hard and showing his talent in every match, Kanyon floundered for another year before being released. It was the final major run of a career that never reached the heights it should have.

After coming out as gay in 2006, Kanyon said that the Boy George angle and his eventual firing were due to homophobia on WWE's part.



7. DH Smith

Harry Smith WWE
WWE.com

On paper, Harry "DH" Smith seemed to have it all - he was young, talented, tall, and the son of one of WWE's all-time most beloved superstars, The British Bulldog. He was signed to a contract at age 20, and the following year, he debuted on Raw. After failing a drug test, though, Smith was relegated to Heat, then sent back to development. Finally, in 2009, he joined longtime friend and partner Tyson Kidd on ECW, forming The Hart Dynasty with manager Natalya.

The Hart Dynasty captured the WWE Tag Team Championship in 2010, but when they lost the belts and split up, it was Smith who suffered. He ended up competing primarily on Superstars, and was released in 2011.

The next year, Smith arrived in New Japan Pro Wrestling, teaming with former WWE superstar Vance Archer as the Killer Elite Squad. The two have been a successful tandem, but it's still baffling that WWE did so little with the son of Davey Boy Smith and the scion of the Hart family.



6. Steve Williams

Dr Death Steve Williams
WWE.com

To be fair, when WWE signed former All Japan Triple Crown Champion "Dr. Death" Steve Williams in 1998, they had huge plans for him - he was intended to feud with Stone Cold Steve Austin, and whether or not he ended up as WWE Champion, a program with Austin during the height of the Attitude Era would make Williams a fortune. First, WWE needed to get him over to the fans who had never seen him before, and their idea was... a shootfighting tournament?!

The Brawl for All tournament over the summer of 1998 was designed to create a world-beater in real-life tough guy Williams prior to the Austin feud. Unfortunately, Williams was beaten (and badly injured) by Bart Gunn en route to Gunn's victory in the tournament. WWE saw Williams as damaged goods after that, and following a brief comeback, he was released.

To summarize: WWE tried to create a star by hoping he would win real fights - which everyone watching assumed were fake, anyway. Hopefully somebody learned a lesson.



5. MVP

Mvp Smackdown
WWE.com

MVP debuted on Smackdown with a ton of fanfare, and he quickly entered into a high-profile feud with Kane. While Kane got the better of the program, MVP's next opponent was Chris Benoit, and he defeated Benoit at Judgment Day 2007 for the United States Championship. MVP would hold the title for almost a year - and reign as Tag Team Champion with Matt Hardy during that time - becoming one of the cornerstones of the Smackdown brand.

MVP lost the title to Hardy at Backlash, and things started to change for him. WWE saddled him with a losing streak gimmick, and from summer of 2008 to early 2009, MVP didn't pick up a single win. Finally, he defeated The Big Show and turned babyface, but the losing streak storyline worked as well as it did every other time WWE tried it. He won the United States Championship again, but quickly lost it, then floundered for the rest of 2009 and 2010 before being leaving the company.

Throughout it all, he remained an amazing worker who should have been in the main event, but wasn't given the opportunity. After leaving WWE, he joined New Japan and became the promotion's inaugural Intercontinental Champion, but still never reached the heights he deserved.


4. Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

Dolph Ziggler is currently a prominent member of the WWE roster - some would argue that he's one of the most featured players in the company. Still, it's hard to have watched his career in WWE progress and wonder why the hell he's not a multiple-time WWE Champion. The man's performances have been uniformly excellent, he's among the most popular wrestlers in the world, and he's been responsible for some of the most dramatic moments in recent WWE memory. Still, something unseen is holding him back.

It may be foolish to compare wrestlers to one another, but there's been nobody who smacks more of being the current era's Shawn Michaels than Dolph - he's ultra-athletic, he works his hardest, and he has no problem getting the fans behind him. At this point, it's likely the company has decided he'll never be a major player. If so, it's their loss just as much as Dolph's.


3. Shelton Benjamin

Shelton Benjamin
WWE.com

Shelton Benjamin and Charlie Haas formed a great tag team in the early 2000s, but when the team was split up in the 2004 draft lottery, Benjamin became a star almost overnight - just days after Triple H headlined WrestleMania XX, Benjamin took him on in a singles match and scored an upset win that seemed to have cemented his status as the future of WWE. Benjamin would go on to defeat Ric Flair, and finally he would wrest the Intercontinental Championship from Chris Jericho.

Benjamin would surprisingly lose the belt to Carlito following an eight-month reign, and soon after, he began a losing streak. After being saddled with a ridiculously offensive gimmick involving his "mother," Benjamin turned heel. He would win the Intercontinental Title twice more during a time when he should have been defending the WWE Championship, and he was voted "Most Underrated" in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter Awards in 2005, 2006, and 2007.

Benjamin continued to wow viewers with his performances - especially during Money in the Bank matches - but he was released in 2010. Since then, he's competed for New Japan and Ring of Honor and looked sett for a WWE return in 2016 before an unfortunate injury put his comeback on the shelf.


2. Ricky Steamboat

ricky steamboat entrance
WWE.com

Former World Heavyweight Champion Ricky Steamboat is heralded as one of the most talented wrestlers of all time and is recognized as a Hall of Famer by every reputable organization in wrestling. Had he spent more time in WWE, though, that might not be the case.

Steamboat first made a name for himself in the NWA, but he joined WWE in 1985 and was given a head-shakingly ignorant martial arts makeover with the nickname "The Dragon." Nevertheless, Steamboat's talent made him a huge babyface, and a feud with Randy Savage culminated in one of the company's most legendary matches ever, when Steamboat defeated his adversary for the Intercontinental Title at WrestleMania III. WWE planned on giving Steamboat a lengthy reign, but he requested a sabbatical to be with his wife, who was expecting their first child. WWE decision-makers were mad that their plans had to change, and Steamboat was persona non grata upon his return. He was eliminated in the first round of the WrestleMania IV WWE Title tournament, and he retired from the company shortly thereafter.

Steamboat returned to competition in the NWA the following year and defeated Ric Flair for the company's world championship, taking on "The Nature Boy" in some of the best matches in wrestling history and becoming a legend. Even then, he would return to WWE in 1991 for a brief run that wasted his potential once again.


1. Zack Ryder

Zack Ryder Rusev Battleground
WWE.com

Few things in wrestling are difficult as creating a super-hot babyface - just ask Roman Reigns. Not only can it be hard to gauge what fans want to see, but in today's wrestling environment, knowledgeable audiences are quick to vent their anger on wrestlers they feel are being manufactured by corporate interests. With all that in mind, it stands to reason that if a babyface is getting really, really over on his own, the best thing to do is run with it.

Zack Ryder created his own YouTube show in 2011 and before WWE knew it, he was one of the most popular wrestlers on the roster. His merchandise sold out, fans chanted "We Want Ryder" on nights he wasn't even in the building, and eventually, WWE decided to capitalize on his success. Ryder defeated Dolph Ziggler for the United States Championship, and it looked like WWE had a new star on its hands.

They didn't - at least, not if they could help it. Fans were enraged as Ryder soon lost the belt, was put in a wheelchair by Kane, and lost crush Eve Torres to best friend John Cena. The company seemed to be picking on Ryder, treating the ultra-plucky babyface like an ostracized high school student. Before long, Ryder was back where he started, and his brief success seemed like a memory.

Still, Ryder is popular - even today, he gets huge reactions on live shows. Why WWE intentionally decided not to strike while the iron was hot (or ever) is a mystery. Ryder did their work for them, and all of his potential was completely wasted.


In this post: 
MVP
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013