10 Surprise WWE Returns That Immediately Transformed Title Matches
Card Subject To Change
Keen to risk hearing the boos that echoed through Brooklyn's Barclays Center upon her mere presence backstage at SummerSlam, WWE elected to bring Bayley back in front of a San José crowd that last saw her shockingly dethroned by current Raw Women's Champion Alexa Bliss at April's Payback supercard.
Though the response was nothing in comparison to the rapturous celebrations her Battleground 2016 soft-launch generated (nor, for that matter, any of her appearances since departing NXT for the main roster) it was at least positive enough to ensure that the announcement of her inclusion in Sunday's multi-Woman championship clash was greeted by hollers of disdain.
Wrestling has always benefitted from the element of surprise, but it can be a difficult art to master when the stakes are high. Fans invest hugely in title matches and/or layered storylines, and the abrupt inclusion of a new character can dislodge that somewhat, even if the returnee is raucously popular or furiously despised.
A brave booking technique when done well, there has at least been a precedent for the concept having some success. Handled with care, certain late arrivals have contributed well to their newfound situation, acting more as a satisfying bolt out of the blue rather than a blundering bombshell.
10. Vince McMahon
Though it signified the end of Vince McMahon's 'lifetime' banishment less than three months after he'd agreed to stay off television forever, Triple H's grandstand challenge to the Chairman on the fourth ever episode of SmackDown crafted a memorable battle that saw McMahon presumably live out a lifelong dream he never thought possible.
Far from some of the many disgraceful ego trips from both his son and daughter, McMahon took an unabashed sh*t-kicking by his top guy and future son-in-law, only to escape as WWE Champion after Stone Cold Steve Austin planted 'The Game' with a Stone Cold Stunner.
Jaw-dropping enough to have Vince even challenge for the gold so early into Triple H's first ever reign, it was even more flabbergasting to see the company's owner hold the strap aloft as the show went off the air.
To his credit, McMahon relinquished the title at the first opportunity, vacating it on the following edition of Monday Night Raw to put it up for grabs in a Six-Pack Challenge at the following Sunday's Unforgiven pay-per-view. As if to peek into his subconscious first though, he revealed the title from within his suit jacket. Revelling in the fleeting moment, it was clearly a scene he'd played out in his head before.
9. Alberto Del Rio
Alberto Del Rio's answer to John Cena's Hell In A Cell 2015 US Open Challenge represented perhaps the most bewildering return in recent memory.
The former World Champion was fired from the company just over year earlier after losing his cool with an employee that he alleged had made a racist joke. Public opinion subsequently flocked to his side in the aftermath, aiding a prosperous period on the independent scene for World Wrestling Council, Ring Of Honor and Lucha Underground as Alberto El Patrón.
The acrimonious nature made his relatively quick return all the more bizarre. As did the presentation of his character and the match itself. Linking up with former bitter rival Zeb Colter to launch the ill-fated 'Mexamerica' gimmick that foreshadowed his League Of Nations unit with Sheamus, Wade Barrett and Rusev, Del Rio played a more serious version of his old self, underscored by a decisively clean victory over Cena in a match which triggered a two month hiatus for 'The Champ'.
It was the peak of a pitiful run. The Colter and League Of Nation relationships faltered fast, and after an August wellness policy violation, he took advantage of an opt-out clause in his contract that saw him gone again less than 12 months after his comeback.
8. Blue Pants
Sending a Brooklyn crowd into hysterics as Big Cass' DIY vocals played out over the Barclays Center PA system, Leva 'Blue Pants' Bates could and should have made much more of her time in NXT.
Trained by The Dudley Boyz and nearly a decade into her career as a wrestler, Bates was little more than a token opponent for the debuting Carmella in October 2014, but gained an enormous cult following and even a t-shirt as fans gravitated towards the bizarre simplicity of the Blue Pants persona.
On the losing end of matches against the bulk of the women's roster, she was all but gone from the developmental brand by the summer of 2015 having gained heat with colleagues and management alike for an apparent attitude problem, but was able to etch her place in NXT history by joining The Vaudevillains as an unannounced third for their last tag team title shot against Blake and Murphy.
The champions had utilised Alexa Bliss' interference to remain a step ahead of the chasing pack on NXT, but Blue Pants' presence alongside Simon Gotch and Aiden English evened the sides enough for the vintage duo scoop their first and only tag straps.
7. Triple H
Flattening Seth Rollins with a Pedigree, Triple H binned off another relationship with a chiselled long-haired star in black leather to forge ahead with a fresh new project.
Having been A.W.O.L since Roman Reigns regained the WWE Title at his expense months earlier, 'The Game's return was destined to be monumental, but a turn on his most recent pet project was as big a shock as Kevin Owens' own ascension to the Universal Title picture.
'KO' hadn't managed to maintain the momentum he'd earned during his introductory feud with John Cena, and was an outside bet in Monday Night Raw's Fatal Four Way Universal Title main event that also included Reigns and Big Cass. With two Pedigrees, he'd gone from being a Rollins/Reigns afterthought to only the second ever holder of the brand new prize.
Even in being gifted the title from the Authority head honcho, Owens was given an on and off-screen acknowledgment by management that he was now their new star. Furthermore, he had within his arsenal the talent to look as if he always belonged in the role, even if the previous year of television had suggested otherwise.
6. Hulk Hogan
How dare he. How dare he.
Hulk Hogan had barely been back a month and had seemingly accepted a gentle transition down the card thanks to a newly-formed tag unit with Brutus Beefcake ahead of his WrestleMania 9 return. He'd kept his departure intentionally ambiguous in the run-up to WrestleMania 8, with the man and company believing it best he disappeared until the heat from his 1990 steroid lies and various other scandals engulfing WWE in general had died down.
Returning just in time to claim a Caeser's Palace payday, Hogan's night was supposed to be over after the failed attempt alongside Beefcake to dethrone Money Inc of their doubles straps. Little did fans know how shrewd an operator Hogan was.
Planting a seed shortly before the main event by challenging the winner and referring to Yokozuna as 'the J*p', 'The Hulkster' had managed to place himself back in the conversation before the evening's closing controversy. Running out ostensibly to fight Bret's corner after Mr Fuji had thrown powder and rendered him defenceless to the challenger's almighty leg drop, Hulk got bored of fighting someone else's fight and instead commandeered a title shot there and then.
With Bret literally out of the picture, Hulk won his fifth title just like that, then didn't wrestle once on television with the title before shipping it back to the sumo star at June's King Of The Ring.
5. The Rock
Wrapped up in the emotion of the moment, The Rock perhaps regretted his tacit gesture for Stone Cold Steve Austin to 'get the F out', having returned to whip up a storm on the first edition of Monday Night Raw following 'The Rattlesnake's sensational June 2002 walkout.
He didn't channel his words directly down the lens at his career rival, but in suggesting that any roster members having Austin's doubts should head for the exit was more than just a neat way to tie in the company's latest marketing slogan.
The company Stone Cold walked away from after months of unrest and the continued eroding of his physical and mental wellbeing was a very different place to the version that exists today. Losing his biggest star almost overnight, McMahon's efforts to bring in The Rock at short notice highlighted the panic that had clearly set in for the Chairman. It was perhaps more astonishing that 'The Great One' even said yes, but his rabble rousing monologue ended on a surprisingly pointed note as he announced his intentions to be present for the upcoming pay-per-view WWE Title match between The Undertaker and Triple H.
Interfering in the contest itself, the entire segment foreshadowed his return and then-historic sixth title reign. Having physically asserted himself earlier than planned, Rock took back the strap at July's Vengeance supercard just in time to admirably put over Brock Lesnar at that year's SummerSlam.
4. Bayley
It may prove to be unnecessary to include 'The Hugger' in the Raw Women's Title Match at such late notice, but if nothing else, a fourth body to figuratively and literally carry Nia Jax can only assist Alexa Bliss, Emma and Sasha Banks in making the contest broadly enjoyable.
Bayley's character has been obliterated by main roster micromanagement, to the point that less than a year removed from her Monday Night Raw debut, Brooklyn SummerSlam fans vociferously booed a wordless shot of her bonding with Sasha Banks ahead of her contest with Alexa Bliss. It was a staggering reversal for both women, having presented one of the greatest matches in company history to the very same crowd just two years prior.
Originally more beloved than Banks, it's subsequently been Bayley that's absorbed more boos than 'The Boss'. Her title reign was littered with booking missteps that managed to bodge a satisfying WrestleMania build by virtue of obliterating Charlotte's pay-per-view winning streak just one month before the 'Show Of Shows'.
Unquestionably a favourite to unseat Bliss (if indeed anybody will), Bayley's sudden return and victory could perhaps atone for her miserable first experience with the strap, but she may be better served finally entering into an NXT re-write with Sasha in an effort to salvage them both.
3. Triple H
As evidenced in this very list, the element of surprise has suited 'The Game' over the years, but nothing quite matched his dream draw in the 2016's rigged Royal Rumble.
Fresh off obliterating Hunter at December's TLC pay-per-view, new WWE Champion Roman Reigns had raised the ire of Vince McMahon enough that the boss insisted he defend his new prize in the Rumble match itself. It would mark the first time the title had been up for grabs in the 30-man war since Ric Flair's historic 1992 win, but Triple H wouldn't ape his idol's heroic victory.
Forced to enter as #1, 'The Big Dog' survived the first third of the battle royal until Vince and his League Of Nation goons marched out to try and physically remove him from the theatre of conflict. Missing a substantial portion of the match as a result, Reigns returned late on, but The Authority still had their ace to play.
Entering last having not been seen on television since December nor wrestled since the prior year's WrestleMania, Triple H coasted to victory over the knackered champion and his former Shield bretheren Dean Ambrose.
2. The Hardy Boyz
TNA. Impact Wrestling. GFW. Impact Wrestling again. When a company struggles even to make a coherent name for itself, it's incredibly tough for a wrestler to attempt to do so too.
However, that's what Matt Hardy finally did after years of failed experiments attempting to reimagine the dated Hardy persona he emotionally detached himself from following a 2010 WWE departure.
The #BROKEN universe he crafted in 2016 not only clicked with the last remaining TNA devotees, but also drew in the wrestling audience at large and even a section of the mainstream that looked on curiously as he engaged in end-of-the-world wars with his brother Jeff from his fabled 'Compound'.
Starting as a feud after a particularly aggressive Hardy vs Hardy match sent him off the deep end, the two's maniacal battles eventually resulted in them forming a union as the Broken Hardyz after Jeff's defeat in the 'Final Deletion' rendered him 'obsolete'.
The duo astonishingly became the most relevant act in wrestling over 15 years after getting their big break at 1999's No Mercy supershow. A WWE comeback seemed inevitable, but their incredible redebut at WrestleMania 33 just 24 hours after losing the Ring Of Honour Tag Team Titles to The Young Bucks left even hardened observers awestruck.
Inserted into the Raw Tag Team Title match, the pair scooped the straps, completing a monumental WWE comeback and even concluding their storyline 'Expedition Of Gold' that had began whilst still employed by TNA.
1. Andre The Giant
Having not actually wrestled as 'Andre The Giant' since April 1986's WrestleMania 2, the return to television of the company's largest athlete and arguably wrestling's most famous star outside of Hulk Hogan himself in January 1987 marked the start of a last great run for one of the McMahon family's most vital historic draws.
It was an unusually auspicious reappearance of the legendary figure. Hogan had been presented with a mammoth trophy on Piper's Pit to celebrate three years as WWE Champion. 'Rowdy' Roddy and WWE President Jack Tunney paid tribute to the iconic run before Andre himself emerged to eerily declare that 'three years (was) a long time' before shaking 'The Hulkster's hand with some force and exiting as quickly as he'd arrived.
Of all people, Bobby 'The Brain' Heenan spoke out about how insulting it was for the Giant to have been a guest in Hogan's celebrations rather than earning a trophy for his own (mythical) undefeated streak.
WWE acted upon the consternation, presenting Andre with a noticeably smaller trophy the following week. As Hulk and Piper heaped praise upon him, Andre simply stormed off. All would eventually be revealed
Mediated again by Piper following an agreed-upon meeting with Jesse Ventura, Hogan and Andre faced off again. Only this time, Heenan flanked the towering monster. The pair callously issued a challenge to Hulk's title, severing an on-screen friendship and setting up the most historic main event in company history.